6 ms·
One interesting thing is that properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashi
by yieldcrv 4y ago
One interesting thing is that properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashion. Many people in the crypto space could attest to that from various crowdfunds that distributed everything fine, or exchanges that told people to withdraw, or wound down.
In comparison, every bank in existence would have trouble with this.
Its strange that the high profile mismanaged companies that happened to be dealing in crypto are influencing this kind of exclusion from Federal agencies now. But its also validating that these accounts that are moving will be handled with care, and whatever crypto service those deposits are supporting will most likely be able to function fine. Assuming these were predominantly US-based stablecoins. (Circle’s USDC used to bank there)
Leveraged illiquid organizations with losses cannot withstand a collateral call. Whether that's a bank or a crypto exchange. Alternatives that remove or prohibit the leverage would be great.
- kasey_junk 4y agoYou are comparing apples to oranges. Many banks offer custody services which are off balance sheet for them. That is they don’t count as assets or liabilities because there is no use of the custodial securities by the bank. The big difference is that you pay for the privilege of using a banks custody services. That’s why most people don’t use them for cash, it’s equivalent to putting cash in a safe deposit box, it depreciates even in deflationary times. Signatures crypto clients were not doing that. They were loaning money to the bank in order to achieve yield. No matter who it is you loan money to, you have counterparty risk, banks just happen to be one of the most regulated debtors in the world and depositors have unprecedented creditor rights. No crypto firms have that same level of security.
- chollida1 4y ago> One interesting thing is that properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashion. Many people in the crypto space could attest to that from various crowdfunds that distributed everything fine, or exchanges that told people to withdraw, or wound down. This is no different than any hedge funds prime brokerage, which is the more appropriate comparison. Both can lend out the securities that they hold but both should be able to call back and make their depositors whole. Crypto has nothing to do with this as far as I can tell.
- anonporridge 4y ago> Alternatives that remove or prohibit the leverage would be great. Fun fact, the Fed just denied chartering a new crypto focused bank, Custodia, that was planning to keep not just 100%, but 108% of customer cash on hand, thereby foregoing insurance, and make money from fees instead of lending customer money like a typical bank. > The Fed’s eviscerating explanation for its denial of Custodia cites the crypto bank’s decision not to insure its deposits – instead, the bank proposed to be fully capitalized, holding $1.08 in cash for every dollar deposited by customers – which the FRB said could increase Custodia’s risk of runs and contagion. https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2023/03/24/federal-reserve-says-custodias-crypto-focused-business-model-is-inconsistent-with-approval/ https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2023/03/24/federal-reserve-s... I suspect they aren't talking about runs and contagions on Custodia, but runs and contagions on all other banks if Custodia were allowed to exist. You can't have one bank totally safe from bank runs in an environment where every other bank keeps less than 10% of your cash on reserve. This breaks the system. Either everyone has to be fractional reserve, or no one can be.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoFractional reserve allows banks to return some of their gains to the customer via interest. Does Custodia do that? If not, it's clear that they can both exist in the same market as they both offer different levels of risk and return. If Custodia were to pay interest with no risk (which is impossible), then yes, that would change the market.
- Lazare 4y agoCustodia would not have paid interest, and indeed, that's impossible. Functionally, Custodia was offering a "we'll park your cash in a safety deposit box in exchange for a fee" service, except offered by a dodgy outfit with a lot of crypto links. Now narrow banks - as proposed by, among others, TNB USA - would be effectively entirely safe and could pay interest. Efforts to set one up were shut down by the Fed because they would, in fact, be too attractive compared to traditional banks. See, eg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-03-08/the-fed-versus-the-narrow-bank https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-03-08/the-fe...
- rippercushions 4y ago> One interesting thing is that properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashion. Ah, the mythical "properly run crypto custodian". Does such a fantastic beast actually exist?
- mhluongo 4y agoBitGo seems to have done fine after all these years.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoI cashed out back in 2021 but back before that I used to hold some crypto assets on Nexo. I don't have any inside knowledge of their operations, but they always seemed to take compliance and overcollateralisation more seriously than others, and they have certainly weathered the storms. I'm purely in tradfi investments now because, well, look at crypto.. Honestly I would expect the market to be won by an exchange that plays by the rules. The dodgy ones will outcompete in the short term, but they are prone to instant and complete destruction in a way that the well run ones aren't. Additionally, it's clear as day that regulation is coming, so those exchanges who are already compliant will have an advantage.
- paxys 4y agoNexo settles federal and state regulatory lawsuits for $45M (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-19/crypto-lender-nexo-pays-45-million-to-settle-with-sec-states#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-19/crypto-le...) Nexo pulls out of US market (https://financefeeds.com/nexo-cease-its-business-operations-in-the-united-states/ https://financefeeds.com/nexo-cease-its-business-operations-...) So yeah...
- mhluongo 4y agoHm, none of this is about fractional reserve, right? So the OP's point stands?
- 4y ago
- stefan_ 4y agoOh! I know this one! You see, because in crypto you can just keep billions in a flash stick, the properly run crypto custodians 100% collateralized are just.. all of us! Keeping the crypto with us, because putting it with some kind of "custodian" utterly defeats the original purpose.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashion This is all properly-run custodians. They don’t make the news because they shouldn’t. Institutions demanded custody for crypto because they wanted the safety traditional custodians provide. In the old days, CFOs were trained on sweeping cash across FDIC-insured accounts and custodying Treasuries and the like. Apparently, that is now obsolete.
- bmitc 4y ago> One interesting thing is that properly run crypto custodians don't make the news, are 100% collateralized and can withstand 100% withdrawals in an orderly fashion. Which crypto custodians are those? > In comparison, every bank in existence would have trouble with this. That isn't true. Schwab just announced that they can cover 100% of bank deposits without selling a single security. https://www.financialadvisoriq.com/c/3995094/511764/schwab_lose_bank_deposits_stay_open https://www.financialadvisoriq.com/c/3995094/511764/schwab_l...
- medellin 4y agoSo the one cool thing with crypto is that you can actually verify it. Hopefully proof of reserve will become a requirement in the future to operate an exchange
- bmitc 4y agoSchwab is a brokerage in addition to a bank. They are scrutinized infinitely more than any crypto exchange I known of. Most crypto statements can be suffixed with "in theory". > Hopefully proof of reserve will become a requirement in the future to operate an exchange That's an interesting idea. Do any have this now?
- medellin 4y agoKraken is the only that I currently know of but i think the process for it could be improved still https://www.kraken.com/proof-of-reserves https://www.kraken.com/proof-of-reserves
- panarky 4y ago> without selling a single security Why sell a security that's only worth 74 cents on the dollar when you can use it as collateral to borrow 100 cents on the dollar, and if you can't pay back the loan then the public will bail your ass out?
- legulere 4y agoCrypto coins are securities. If you hold securities at your bank, they are not loaning them out and they have zero problems transferring all of them away.