5 ms·
AI could replace equivalent of 300M jobs – report
- otoolep 4y agoSuitably dramatic image headlines the piece. :-)
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoThey missed a chance to have it generated by AI. The eight fingered hand pointing would have been the cherry on top.
- postalrat 4y agoAll jobs
- garbagecoder 4y ago“Kill all the lawyers” —Shakespeare “Kill all the poets” —Plato Gg will bro, not gonna lie you had me there in the first Millenium.
- nopinsight 4y agoRelated: Check out a petition for a moratorium to pause training of AI models more powerful than GPT-4 signed by Yoshua Bengio (Turing Award winner based on his deep learning research), Stuart Russell (AAAI fellow and author of the most widely used AI textbook), Elon Musk, Steve Wozniak, Yuval Noah Harari, and many others. https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experiments/ https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experime... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35348353 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35348353
- pixelpoet 4y agoSame as with human cloning or genetic tweaking etc, once knowledge of how to do it escapes there's no putting the genie back in the bottle, it's just a matter of time until the worst comes true from some less regulated place.
- nopinsight 4y agoHow many human clones exist? How many would exist in an alternative scenario without regulations?
- friend_and_foe 4y agoThe answer to both questions is "probably more than you think." Which is kind of the point; a moratorium won't solve anything. Even wity successful regulation, governments do whatever they want.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AJRF 4y agoAnyone got a link to the report? I've Google'd it and all I can find is new articles, but none of them link to the report.
- achow 4y agoGPTs are GPTs: An Early Look at the Labor Market Impact - Potential of Large Language Models Tyna Eloundou1, Sam Manning, Pamela Mishkin, and Daniel Rock OpenAI, OpenResearch, University of Pennsylvania March 27, 2023 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10130.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10130.pdf
- edgyquant 4y agoAre there any not made by the people currently marketing this?
- noobermin 4y agoThis wouldn't be an issue if we actually recognized the theft of intellectual property that underlies training of these LLMs. I don't know if OpenAI would consider it okay if someone took a NN and trained it on their private IP and the net's weights, then generated their own GPT-4 based on it. I don't think they'd say it's "fair use" then, otherwise, every person at OpenAI who has access to the internals is a fool not to do that and open up their own start up. The fair-use argument holds no water, and if we didn't have a broken government in the US, it certainly would doom these tools to being trained only on data they've generated themselves, which is how it should be.
- drstewart 4y ago>This wouldn't be an issue if we actually recognized the theft of intellectual property that underlies training of these LLMs Suddenly people think copying things on the internet is theft again. What happened to "its just a copyright violation and nobody loses anything anyway, it's not theft!" when you're torrenting movies and video games? >The fair-use argument holds no water, and if we didn't have a broken government in the US, it certainly would doom these tools to being trained only on data they've generated themselves, which is how it should be. Well surely the "fixed" and "working" governments of Canada and the EU will take action against this promptly! Can you share the bills they've already passed that will doom these tools?
- agentultra 4y agoIANAL but these seem like two different accusations. Copying a movie and watching it in your own home and sharing it with your neighbour is different from redistributing a new film you claim is your own but is derived directly from the movie you downloaded; sure your changed the character names and dubbed over a few lines but you didn’t create the assets used and you didn’t attribute the sources of the ones didn’t alter or produce on your own. I think the argument is that It’d be like those knock-off studios using someone else’s footage in parts of their films without permission.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoBut, but, but all those smart people in TED talks 10-15 years ago told us that AI won't kill jobs, it will be alright. Do not be afraid, embrace the change they said.
- LinuxBender 4y agoFWIW not everyone was saying this. some things in this video did not age well [1] I've also seen a lot of fringe science on TED that HN would be very skeptical of. I am not sure what the bar to entry is for TED. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU [video][15 mins]
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoOh it's getting stranger every year, I mean most of the presenters are like from an entirely different universe when they start to talk about trivial things.
- paxys 4y agoTechnological progress automating away work to the extent that we don't have to all slog for 40-80 hours a week just to be able to afford food and shelter is a wonderful thing. So don't blame AI, but instead the social and economic systems we have created that cannot accept this reality.
- jleyank 4y agoUnless there’s something like UBI, where’s that food coming from if you’re not working the hours?
- paxys 4y agoThe AI is working the hours. That's the entire point.
- webdood90 4y agowhat a wonderful bubble you must live in where you actually envision the decision makers allowing this to happen without significant turmoil first
- paxys 4y agoThe turmoil is usually necessary before real change can happen.
- wolpoli 4y agoA human will unfortunately need do it, because Agricultural Equipment Operators have no exposed tasks to LLMs [0]. We'll need other AI advancements. [0]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10130v4.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10130v4.pdf
- symlinkk 4y agoYou’re relying on the hope that the people with money and power would be willing to share that with everyone else. They wouldn’t. Our entire economic system is based on the principle that people are inherently selfish.
- maxwoj 4y agoIt’s middle of the night and I cannot sleep because of what I expect will happen with almost all jobs in the next decade. 2023 is the down of new era. Almost everyone will be out of job. Even the jobs requiring what we call “unskilled labor” involve things replaceable by AI - object recognition, spacial awareness, reacting to unexpected situations, decision making. I see all these gurus on Twitter saying we just need to be “ahead of curve” and I think they miss the point so badly. There won’t be staying “ahead of curve” In the long run, AI will do better whatever it may be invented or done
- kranke155 4y agoEliminate current-form capitalism and you eliminate the dystopian outcome. Enforce UBI and you have utopia. If an economic system does not provide utopian outcomes for emerging technology, then the economic system is wrong. Economic systems that provide dystopian outcomes with emerging technology are meant to be replaced. Your worries are about an economic system, not AI. Economic systems are tools, means to an end. If you accept that we live in post scarcity and begin from that principle, everything is not only fine, but we could be entering an amazing age. If you say - only those who provide value will get value - then you will enforce dystopia.
- porknubbins 4y agoI used to think it was just an econ problem that could be solved with UBI but lately I am not sure we are psychologically ready for UBI. Looking at the stats, young men who drop out of the labor force tend to spend their time on things like videogames, porn and marijuana rather than building a meaningful life.
- kranke155 4y agoPeople working in factories could be described as “not having a meaningful life”. Living a meaningful life is a choice left up to the individual. What are most people going to do when we automate everything ?
- examplary_cable 4y agoPrompt engineers: huh?
- supernova87a 4y agoNot that long ago there used to be people who would add up columns of numbers to calculate the books at companies, and every time they wanted to run a different scenario a whole room full of them would have to get back to their pencils and redo the calculation for a day, and they no longer exist because of spreadsheets. We used to have admins whose entire job it was to find out when people could meet, and they no longer exist (or only in much smaller numbers) because you use your online calendar tool. We used to have people who would physically fly bank checks from one city to another each night, and in a single day they ceased to exist when you were instead able to transmit just the numbers back and forth. People who used to sell encyclopedias are out of work. People who used to develop rolls of film are no longer around. We're missing a whole generation of telephone operators. But people will deal. Because these developments come from every single one of us using tools and adopting things that we choose to, not because it's some decision handed down and enforced by some government against our will. You and I, using Excel, scheduling our own meetings, using direct deposit or even our phones. I don't even believe yet that these latest models are going to be that transformational, but even if so, people will deal. And new things will take the place of old.
- credit_guy 4y agoIndeed. When I was a kid there were people who were fixing TV sets. There were people who were fixing watches. There were travel agencies, where you'd go and buy plane tickets, or vacations. All these things disappeared more or less overnight.
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> Not that long ago there used to be people who would add up columns of numbers to calculate the books at companies Sure. If you go back a few centuries before that (much less in some regions of the world), you had maybe 90% of the population consisting of unfree agricultural laborers (serfs or slaves), with say 10% as soldiers to keep the serfs in line and defend the land against invaders, and a very, very thin veneer of lords and priests at the top. > But people will deal. I agree. They will. No one worries about all the unemployed serfs, because there aren't any. They're all doing other stuff.
- sinuhe69 4y agoFrom “could affect” (in OpenAI own assessment) to “replace” is a stark difference, BBC!
- sottol 4y agoTaking the title literally... that's more than 5% of the world-wide working age population -- I'd be surprised if that wouldn't cause luddite riots. But there are a lot of weasel words in the article and even the headline has a "could", I guess the gist is that they really expect generative AI to lower wages. Wish I could my hands on the actual report and not just this article which seems to summarize the reports abstract at best.
- sfc32 4y agoIs there a link available to the Goldman Sacs report?
- glyphy177 4y ago[dead]