7 ms·
The rise and rise of e-sports
- fatnoah 4y agoA few years ago, I took my son to the CS:GO Major Championship in my city. It was held in a university's arena, and my son was excited to go. Even though I'm a gamer myself, I was very "meh" about being up to my armpits in e-sports fanatics, and was expecting something like LAN party writ large. I was completely unprepared for the spectacle I beheld when we walked into the arena. It was an atmosphere to rival any professional sports events, complete with over-the-top lights, announcers, and a boisterous crowd. It was completely awesome, with crowd oohing, aahing, and cheering to amazing plays.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoWhat an out of touch writer. Apparently the West is purely the USA, and we need to quote "Minecraft", the biggest game in history.
- charcircuit 4y ago>Broadcasting gameplay has become a big business Most of esports is not profitable. Events are usually run for the love of the game as opposed to trying to make money. Or there is VC money which they are unlikely to find a return on.
- jackgolding 4y agoYep, one game I follow Hearthstone Battlegrounds has had a majority of funding for events slashed by Activision Blizzard. Very unfortunate for the professional players who are incentivised more to be successful streamers rather than competitive gamers and us fans.
- dewey 4y agoIf you are disputing the whole point of the article directly like that, you'll have to provide a source. There's a lot of sponsor money involved, big organizations with multiple teams for different games traveling to large events. Doesn't sound like they are all doing it for the love of the game. There's single teams that are valued > $500m: https://www.insiderintelligence.com/insights/esports-ecosystem-market-report/ https://www.insiderintelligence.com/insights/esports-ecosyst...
- unmole 4y agoPrivate valuations are nonsense. FaZe went public via a SPAC and is now down by ~95%.
- CaveTech 4y ago10x Revenue multiple is insane on those valuations. Most of those teams are barely 10 years old, and mostly unprofitable through their tenure. I think we're starting to see a rational market take over with FaZe going from 750m+ market cap to ~30m.
- charcircuit 4y ago>There's a lot of sponsor money involved, big organizations with multiple teams for different games traveling to large events. Just because there is a lot of money moving around it doesn't mean it's profitable in general. >Doesn't sound like they are all doing it for the love of the game. Doing it in hopes of making a return on investment doesn't guarantee you will be profitable. >There's single teams that are valued > $500m A lot of those numbers are inflated. As the sister comments mention look at what happened to faze.
- sdwr 4y agoMost esports is marketing by the game developer, produced at a loss to retain player interest and sell the dream. Having pros to watch makes the game more fun and feel legitimate. There's a reason casters hype player skill non-stop. Ex. Valorant, Overwatch, WoW, LoL (maybe actually profitable?), DotA. Scenes actually run for the love of the game are Melee + anything tiny The only independent esport that is kinda self-sustaining is Korean Brood War, been divorced from blizzard for a long time and still going strong w sponsorships and ad revenue.
- duskwuff 4y agoDotA has a healthy number of tournaments that aren't hosted by Valve, but a concerning number of those are heavily sponsored by esports betting companies. When (not "if") regulation closes in on that industry, the scene may look very different.
- Claude_Shannon 4y agoMelee scene is getting killed by both Nintendo and the biggest organizators too :( But yeah, fighting games scenes are actually quite durable and rising up from grassroots in general
- pharmakom 4y agoCS:GO is self sustaining.
- bleazoman 4y agoRocket league for one receives sponsorship from car companies, nike, movie studios, and even football clubs regularly. Their nike paint finishes were selling like hot cakes.
- charcircuit 4y agoNotice how the game company is the one making the money. Tournament organizers, server admins, production, casters, players, managers, etc do not have a sustainable source of money. Often people volunteer their services and communities fundraise money to fly teams in to compete because that's the only way they can afford it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rypskar 4y ago>Most of esports is not profitable. Events are usually run for the love of the game as opposed to trying to make money That can be said about any sport. Broadcasting football is big business but most teams are not profitable and the players play for the love of the sport as opposed to trying to make money
- atdrummond 4y agoHow does this thesis contrast with the absolute collapse of industry leader FaZe to $0.67? https://www.google.com/finance/quote/FAZE:NASDAQ?sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiRr4qypPv9AhVUcGwGHRgLDF8Q3ecFegQIDRAc https://www.google.com/finance/quote/FAZE:NASDAQ?sa=X&ved=2a...
- oidar 4y agohttps://archive.is/D27fN https://archive.is/D27fN
- crop_rotation 4y agoI find watching RTS e-sports tournaments of games that I love much more entertaining than Netflix/Sports. The commentators just love what they are casting and you can sense it in their voice. You get to see real players doing so many things at the same time, constantly adapting. All the while the viewer sees everything and knows everything while the players only see a small subset. It makes it all so unpredictable and entertaining.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoI miss the gomtv era of StarCraft 2 with tasteless and artosis, I still have fond memories of being glued to the screen.
- cwillu 4y agoDid you watch the ESL last month?
- Fuzzwah 4y agoI concur. I wonder if the fact that the game was also "less solved" back then made it more enjoyable to spectate too. Add in the balance patch changes that were still happening, broodwar players making the cross over, new players showing up, foreigners sort of having a few GSL showings... It really was excellent entertainment.
- ajuc 4y agoI think what makes RTS great to watch is the same thing that made soccer the most watched sport in the world. The game is free-flowing, it's not repetative, decision-making on the spot matters and comebacks aren't very rare. One bad fight in RTS might lose you the game. 2 minutes of bad defending might lose you a game you were 100% winning in soccer. Same in fighting sports (because of knock-out) and in chess (because of check-mate). Meanwhile in basketball, volleyball, baseball, MOBA, FPS - if you're winning by 20% your chances of comeback are very low. If you're winning by 50% it's over. TL; DR: games that are good to watch aren't linear.
- 4y ago
- djrobstep 4y agoThis seems like a very unhealthy development. Why not get off the computer and get some real exercise?
- Zetice 4y agoPor que no los dos? Exercise is not a long activity, plenty of time for both.
- loveparade 4y agoHow many people watching professional football do you believe regularly get off the couch to get some real exercise? I don't see the difference.
- operatingthetan 4y agoAt least you can say that the regular sports inspire people to be active or get involved in sports. I'm not really on the esports being a negative thing though.
- crop_rotation 4y agoThey mostly inspire people to sit on the couch and eat unhealthy food and drinks with friends while watching on the TV. The amount of people watching is so so much higher than the people who get involved in any particular sport.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- operatingthetan 4y ago>The amount of people watching is so so much higher than the people who get involved in any particular sport. I didn't say anything about whether more people who watched sports were active versus passive. This doesn't invalidate my point that professional sports serve as a source of inspiration for people to be active. Esports inspire exactly zero people to be physically active.
- oidar 4y agoI've watched a few esports games, like Overwatch and Fortnite, and I have to say, they didn't quite grab my attention. The problem is, unless you really understand the ins and outs of the game, it's hard to tell if a player is doing something truly remarkable. I mean, how can we even be sure that the people we're watching are actually playing the game? They might just be pretending to hit keys and move their mouse, and we wouldn't know the difference! Compare this to traditional sports like basketball, baseball, or hockey. When someone does something truly impressive, even someone who's not an expert in the sport can still appreciate it. There's no special knowledge needed to recognize an amazing shot, a great catch, or a stunning goal. It's just obvious. So, until esports can make that same kind of connection with a broader audience, I don't think it's going to be a huge draw for a lot of people. Fans need to be able to clearly see and appreciate the skill and talent on display, without feeling like they're missing something or being left out. Once that happens, I think esports could really take off and become a major force in the world of sports and entertainment.
- 12345hn6789 4y ago< I don't watch overwatch or Fortnite> Isn't it pretty obvious when someone gets multiple frags? Saves their team? This isn't any different then the running back going through the other team. It's pretty obvious
- jjtheblunt 4y agoI think the parent comment means it would have been hard to see if it was the person performing or if it was an algorithm
- NhanH 4y agoThat was one of starcraft 2's game and graphic design criteria: it should be obvious to the viewer even if they don't have the game knowledge. Unfortunately the game flopped fairly hard in term of esport (relatively to expectation) along with the decline of RTS. Early league of legends's character designs somewhat aims to achieve this as well, it only lasted for a couple of years though. Basically the issue is that when you keep adding content (characters, maps), the complexity just grew too much. Not quite exponentially, but definitely some kind of super-linear. I think this is one advantage of traditional board games (chess, go) and sports in comparison to Esports. If I spend a couple years of my life learning the basics of Go, 10 years from now on, I will still be able to appreciate the game all the same. Can't say the same for any kind of esports -- and I did spend thousand of hours in a couple of them.
- RajT88 4y agoPerhaps in the west we can connect the rise of e-Sports with a near future of them as the Next Big Thing. I have nieces and nephews who loves videogames, but are often not invested enough in one to really master it. These kids spend more time watching youtube videos of other people playing games than actually playing them themselves. I hear it all the time, how mystified parents and grandparents are. Fast forward 10-15 years. Those kids are adults with a love of the games, with a habit of spectating. It's no different than football or tennis or hockey. (Well - it's different than golf, which sucks...)
- stocknoob 4y agoYep. And funny enough, when someone over 22 says they like football, they mean they like watching people play football.
- dieselgate 4y agoAssume we’re talking American football here - it’s a unique sport because you can really only play it legitimately on a team with a lot of equipment and time/resources. So basically if you’re 18 and under (or very talented at playing football). I played 5 seasons in my life, 4 in high school and it was without a doubt the most fun athletic experience of my entire life. I’ve never really been able to get interested much watching football otherwise because it just isn’t the same. There were a few women on my teams throughout the years (some of the most feminine and badass women I’ve ever met) but it’s unfortunate American football is such a male dominant sport. It almost seems when people say they like watching football now they mean they like drinking alcohol or playing fantasy. Idk, always thought it was kind of strange how basically every sport can also be a “pastime” activity but football just turns into a spectator activity after a while. Edit: not a football quote but makes me think of “people don’t think it be like it is but it do” Edit2: not a fan of footy/soccer much but really the greatest thing about the sport imo is the simplicity and ability for anyone to play basically whenever wherever and at whatever age. It’s so much more the game of the People as such Edit3: just rambling here but remember towards the end of last season senior year the coaches said something like “hope you have a lot more better things to look forward to in your life after this, but keep in mind these will be some of the best times of your life”. think about that a lot, and it was never lost on me at the time, but now I’m actually feeling my body age and chit it’s just so true and real. This feels somewhat pathetic to write out haha but really do miss playing football unlike anything else. Last edit: this is literally the last thing I’d ever of thought to be writing about as a comment on HN
- keithalewis 4y agoBusiness people fund projects and figure out there are only a small number of people living in their parent's basement that find it interesting.
- laserbeam 4y ago> E-sports have yet to engage Western audiences quite as much. About 20% of Americans take an interest, according to a poll by Morning Consult—slightly less than follow horse-racing. Huh. That's neat trivia. More westerners are interested in horse racing that e-sports. Thank you article.
- rl3 4y ago>At Seoul Game Academy, a chain of schools in South Korea’s capital, 3,000 students aged nine and up (roughly 99% of them boys) hone their skills at nine games in hopes of becoming full time “e-sports” athletes. That's just sad. The level of grind it takes to become pro is nuts. For every one professional player or streamer there's a countless number of people that have wasted their lives on this stuff. The scale is such that to be good it's very often a case of mastering a zero-sum game. Rote repetition until it becomes [hand] muscle memory. The same shit, over and over, until your eyes bleed. Aged nine and up? Just let the kids have fun. High-level e-Sports should be considered child abuse at that age.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoYou could replaced esports with piano, violin, ballet or gymnastics and the comment would be equally applicable.
- dual_dingo 4y ago> High-level e-Sports should be considered child abuse at that age. There is money to be made. That clearly is more important, don't you think? /s Also, this is not new - in music, real sports, chess and other fields, young children have been abused in that way for ages, all over the world.
- lelanthran 4y agoIsn't that true of traditional sports too?
- rl3 4y agoYes and no. Sports with young kids typically don't get too intense outside of the occasional psycho coach or parent. American football in particular of course does have a nasty CTE/TBI hazard by nature—which IMHO should render it off-limits to minors. For collegiate sports—which is a meat grinder of hopes and dreams unto itself—most athletes figure out pretty quick whether they're making it in the big leagues or not. There's an expiry there just by virtue of the way the human body works. I suppose it's still possible to ruin your life trying, but least you come out of it with excellent physical fitness (brain injuries aside), and having not stared at a screen the entire time.
- pyrolistical 4y agoI think we are just at the start. Battle royals like apex legends tend to be more watchable by non players
- nathants 4y agoclix fans rise.