34 ms·
Intimidation is what these copyright monopolists are all about. > We knew recording was useful, but the app’s ability to apply audio effects anywhere on the Ma
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
Intimidation is what these copyright monopolists are all about.
> We knew recording was useful, but the app’s ability to apply audio effects anywhere on the Mac carried much less legal peril.
Look at this. Innocent software developers, intimidated by these nebulous "legal perils" of copyright infringement to the point they felt afraid of marketing a perfectly reasonable and legal feature.
I can't possibly be the only person deeply offended by this. We don't need their blessing to record anything. We should be free from their tyranny but it binds us to this day.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoThis is why open source software and non-walled garden systems are so vital. With open source software and hardware where you can install your own software, all it takes is one developer somewhere in Russia or China who is not afraid of the RIAA's intimidation, and all of us will have access to the recording in a way that cannot be taken away. We must defend open source software and fight against walled garden promoters (like Apple) to secure our right to general purpose, freedom-respecting computing.
- deafpolygon 4y agoSettle down, Richard. You really think Open Source is going to solve the problem? I love the FOSS as much as the next man, but it's not some holy panacea for all of our freedom-loving woes. RIAA doesn't have to sue the developer in Russia, they can just take the legal fight to the consumers (and they HAVE done so).
- alwayslikethis 4y agoHow would they tell? RIAA has no right to check your computers. I doubt it would be possible to outright ban the software from existing or being installed since it has totally legal uses too.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoI think open source is more important and relevant than ever, especially in an era when LLMs are controlled by a select few. But we can both say “Nu uh” and “yes huh” at each other and it won’t really advance the discussion. Do you have specific examples?
- deafpolygon 4y agoEvery time the doomsday of AI is heralded by some folks here , they go "but-but, Open Source is the solution!" No, regulation is the solution. Learn about politics, learn the local and federal laws and get on the horn with people if you're so concerned.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoI didn’t say anything about the doomsday scenario, nor that open source is a solution.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> No, regulation is the solution. Learn about politics, learn the local and federal laws and get on the horn with people if you’re so concerned. I have a degree in political science, completed about half of law school before deciding I didn’t want to leave technology, have worked in and around government for most of the last 25 year. Transparency—and open source plays a big part in this—in the answer. Regulation can be important to, but if there isn’t transparency in the field (even if not for all models, though that will be important) and particularly for anything adopted for important use in administering policy and pressure from the open source community on proprietary vendors, the dangers of AI are magnified. Yes, I know people tied to the big vendors are selling the idea that opacity and regulatory restrictions are the answer, and I’m telling you read Adam Smith: The interest of the dealers, however, in any particular branch of trade or manufactures, is always in some respects different from, and even opposite to, that of the public. To widen the market and to narrow the competition, is always the interest of the dealers. That’s why you hear that story.
- bharathyes 4y agodidnt they try that with youtube-dl ? though they were able to partially take down the repo it was brought back after the legality ot their claim was analyzed.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoThat's the perils of using a proprietary service beholden to the law of the US. Ideally you would want redundant services in different jurisdictions to circumvent takedown requests like this. It is crucial to have control of your infrastructure, even if it may be mirrored elsewhere.
- nico 4y ago> This is why open source software and non-walled garden systems are so vital. Are there people organizing to develop, deploy, run and provide “AI on demand” for free to people? Like Wikipedia but for AI. How much money would be needed? How many volunteers? Who wants to build this?
- alwayslikethis 4y agoDon't we have LLaMA? The quantized version is runnable on top end consumer hardware, which is within reach for many people if a bit expensive. You can also use it on a rental GPU unit from something like vast.ai or another commercial vendor. AI on demand for free is not a viable economic proposition for now, lest you create a way to vouch for legitimate users and purposes, but at that point most people would rather pay a bit. Maybe in a few years it will become economical.
- zirgs 4y agoIt's not legal to use LLaMA for commecial purposes. We need an open source alternative. Not something that was leaked.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Are there people organizing to develop, deploy, run and provide “AI on demand” for free to people? Stable Horde, though its p2p rather than centralized nonprofit https://stablehorde.net/ https://stablehorde.net/
- nico 4y agoEven better! Is there a marketing team?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoVery few open source projects have a marketing team.
- 4y ago
- unyttigfjelltol 4y ago> somewhere in Russia or China who is not afraid of the RIAA's intimidation I can't be the only one that sees the irony in developed western democracies relying on Russia and China to protect liberty and freedom.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 4y agothe enemy of my enemy is my friend, right?
- i80and 4y agothe enemy of my enemy is my enemy's enemy: no less, no more.
- tracker1 4y agoNot always... a single issue "friend" isn't generally enough to stay that way and bigger issues can prevail. While I appreciate a lot of the hardware and hard work that comes from China, I think their government makes them adversarial to the point where the US should seriously work on shoring up domestic production and alternative supply chains. China has been working hard to make the US unnecessary for their own. Not many countries can really exist without at least their neighbors, but it's very concerning. Similarly with alignments with Russia going through. Not that I advocate for the military interventions going on right now for the most part... I just think the US govt and industry have become so short sighted to the point that long term harm is inevitable.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYes, and that's why they're trying to own our computers before they even leave the factory. They want a world where only the programs they approve can be executed. That's literally the only way that copyright can be enforced in the 21st century. In other words, they are the antithesis of everything hackers stand for. Computers are too powerful and subversive for them, they need to control it. Governments have similar aspirations. They want to contol access to cryptography software.
- 0dayz 4y agoWhile I do agree: "keep your hands off my computer", There's a huge difference in wanting to close down a computer and wanting cryptography software banned. Government don't care if you use open or closed source software, in fact it probably welcomes hackable (as in easy to tinker with, more moving parts that they could easily extract data from) open computers more.
- neilv 4y agoRampant MP3 copyright violation motivated and enabled some awful owner&user-hostile design, from which we're still suffering. I don't like anything about the RIAA, but a lot of computer users don't have the high ground either.
- klabb3 4y ago> Rampant MP3 copyright violation motivated […] There was a singular reason for this: UX. The IP mob absolutely despised anything different to their existing business model, and were too boneheaded to recognize the opportunity to make something good. Most of all, they hated that they needed to change. It took decades, but now only niche enthusiasts download music, even though it’s as easy now as it was then. The same thing could be said about TV streaming, of course, although they’ve done a worse job on the technical side.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThis is classic victim blaming. RIAA not liking what users do caused RIAA to do user-hostile design, from which we're still suffering. Bad users, bad!
- zirgs 4y agoThankfully Spotify came out and it reduced music piracy far more than all the RIAA lawsuits combined by simply offering better service than both RIAA (who wanted to sell albums only) and pirate sites (that didn't offer discovery features and there was no quality control). As GabeN said - piracy is a service problem.
- skhr0680 4y ago> that didn't offer discovery features and there was no quality control Pirate sites generally had better quality than iTunes (which was 128kbps for way too long), and were often ripped from a better sounding source or master because the people uploading albums were dedicated fans of the material. One great example is the soniclovenoize uncensored stereo version of "We're Only In It For The Money".
- noirscape 4y agoThe problem is that it's extremely risky as a platform operator to stand up for blatant abuse of copyright infringement tools under the current model, especially when you do anything at scale. Basically if you operate any website, as long as the DMCA request you get is reasonably properly filed, you are required to process it or else you risk legal liability. It's a goddamn mess and when you're operating on the scale of say, Google, you don't have the option to risk that liability and hire people who can examine those claims. No, what you do is blindly process all claims and just hope that people counterclaim the bad ones. It's why for example GitHub sticking it's neck out for 1201-related violations (where they manually investigate any anti-circumvention related takedown) is such a big deal. They are running a risk by doing that where if they tell the RIAA (who usually files these requests) to go fuck themselves, that they could be forced to eat crow in court, but they're doing it because well... the RIAA abused that part of the DMCA to file a dodgy claim against youtube-dl[0]. Improper DMCA claims are technically punishable as perjury but the actual process is so draining that it's super rare to see someone convicted for it. [0]: The RIAA assumes that youtube uses actual encryption to protect people from downloading them. They're wrong - YouTube doesn't use widevine or anything like that for regular uploads (movies are a different case, they do use widevine), they have their own rolling cipher which is just a plaintext javascript file that your browser fetches when loading YouTube. Youtube-dl contains a python reimplementation of that cipher. Fully legal insofar as section 1201 is concerned, but the RIAA filed it under that anyway (because they'd have no actual standing to file a regular DMCA claim for basically blatantly reusing Google code, since the RIAA isn't Goole).
- makeitdouble 4y agoIn my eyes the main issue is political standing, which we had very few. When in France the RIAA equivalent came up with a plan to add a tax to all digital storage media, because it could be used for piracy, the tax was applied an we all ponied up. Why ? because they make money, deal with politicians everyday and make sure the wheels are well lubrificated when they need them to turn. For a very long time the computer industry had none that, and/or wanted contents right holders on their side, with not enough negociation power. Now I feel we're on the other side with Apple straight telling legislators to turn a blind eye because they need their semi-monopoly to keep printing money.
- tzs 4y ago> When in France the RIAA equivalent came up with a plan to add a tax to all digital storage media, because it could be used for piracy, the tax was applied an we all ponied up. Why ? because they make money, deal with politicians everyday and make sure the wheels are well lubrificated when they need them to turn. RMS has suggested a similar tax on internet users in exchange for legalizing file sharing [1]. The idea of taxing something associated with the consumption of creative works in order to fund the creators instead of the direct sale of copies model is one of the more popular ideas among those who try to actually figure out how creators should be funded in an age where anyone can make unlimited copies for essentially no cost. [1] https://stallman.org/articles/internet-sharing-license.en.html https://stallman.org/articles/internet-sharing-license.en.ht...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The idea of taxing something associated with the consumption of creative works in order to fund the creators ... usually ends up as a barrier to creators, because the funding goes to established creators or industry cartels, reinforcing their existing advantage over upstarts and independents.
- tzs 4y agoIndeed, the big problem with the tax approach is deciding how to distribute the money. The government could do it via grants to creators, but then you've got the government playing a major role in determining what art gets created, which would not doubt in the US end up a partisan thing. Yuck! Another approach would be to track downloads and distribute the money based on popularity. That at least gets away from having the government decide what gets funded.