3 ms·
Well, I can tell you that the first time I see some sufficiently advanced AI walking in the streets between the public, I will grab my baseball bat and smash it
by amelius 4y ago
Well, I can tell you that the first time I see some sufficiently advanced AI walking in the streets between the public, I will grab my baseball bat and smash it to pieces.
- number6 4y agoAIs should have human rights, if we are able to upload our us into computer we need a precedence that post humans are humans too.
- ben_w 4y agoMaybe, but a pre-requisite to doing that right, is that we must first understand what this mysterious "consciousness" thing even is. I can play word games like saying "consciousness" is the opposite of "unconsciousness" (or alternatively and IMO not entirely compatibility that it is the opposite of "subconsciousness"), but every time I've looked at this, it's either ended with (1) circular definitions, (2) definitions that accidentally include VHS players connected to TV set, or (3) things that humans regularly fail at. None of that actually helps figure out whether or not a machine does or doesn't have that which makes us have the experience of being. Getting it wrong, in either direction, is a Bad Ending. https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/06/18/lamda-turing-test-sentience/ https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/06/18/lamda-turin...
- boplicity 4y agoYeah, but what if it's just a little canister scrubbing public toilets,trash cans, or something similar. Do you really want to destroy that? Will you even realize what you're seeing?
- ben_w 4y agoI find it curious that even here there are people who conflate a robot body with an artificial mind. Sure, you can put the computer running the mind that controls the body into the body itself, and there might even be good reasons to given spotty wifi or mobile data, but you don't have to. Also: why embody them in human form at all? https://www.tesla.com/drive https://www.tesla.com/drive https://www.bostondynamics.com/products/spot https://www.bostondynamics.com/products/spot https://www.parrot.com/us/partner-ecosystem https://www.parrot.com/us/partner-ecosystem (FWIW I've never heard of these before, I just searched for AI drones…)
- amelius 4y ago> I find it curious that even here there are people who conflate a robot body with an artificial mind. You are trying to read things in my comment that are not there. It's _not_ about destroying the actual machine. It's about drawing a line.
- ben_w 4y ago> Well, I can tell you that the first time I see some sufficiently advanced AI walking in the streets between the public, I will grab my baseball bat and smash it to pieces. Describing an AI walking the streets, or smashing it to pieces, necessarily carries with it the implication that the AI is located within a physical body that moves on legs. And those words you used are very explicitly about destroying an actual machine. But if you wish to claim that was merely a linguistic turn of phrase not meant to be taken as an implied literal belief of the location of thought? Ok, but it remains the case that what you propose against a "sufficiently advanced" AI, is somewhere between petty vandalism and a pogrom, depending on questions of if "sufficiently advanced" comes as a package deal with "sentience". Which is a totally different, and in the latter case much more severe, problem.
- amelius 4y agoHuh? Of course I understand that they have a backup somewhere. Whether I destroy the CPU or the actuators or some other hardware is not relevant as long as my statement is clear.
- codpiece 4y agoYou won't be able to. The aerial drones will take you out long before you reach for the bat.
- elforce002 4y agoYou know what's interesting: Your take is somewhat similar to a part of animatrix and even crazier is that I'll vouch for you just because of the sense of tribalism within me, hehe.