4 ms·
The Odd Story of Factory-Downgraded 486s (2020)
- wolpoli 4y agoIn case anyone is wondering - the second Intel CPU is stamped "A80486SX-25" near the middle but SX-33 at the bottom.
- hulitu 4y agoThe practice continued with AMD Athlon X3.
- snvzz 4y agoThat one had some reasoning to it. They were able to use CPUs that they would otherwise have to discard, due to defects, by disabling the faulty core.
- Idiot_in_Vain 4y agoOn most Athlon X3s the user could enable in the BIOS the forth core and usually get a fully functional quad core.
- consp 4y agoMine did, also did the pencil trick with the Duron in the past (bridge the 4 L1 links) to unlock it and those overclocked easily so you'd have more bang for your buck.
- nicolaslem 4y agoTo be clear, this is how most chips work today. Intel, Nvidia and AMD make entire lineups of CPUs and GPUs with only a handful of different chips, the only difference being features fused off (either because the silicon doesn't handle them well or because they need market segmentation).
- rplst8 4y agoIsn't this how all binning works? If some part of the chip doesn't work, cache, core, fpu, they cut the traces and sell it at a cheaper price point.
- Macha 4y agoI mean, the most recent case was the 1600AF, which was not a new stepping of the Zen 1 based 1600, but an underclocked 2600 (including the instruction set efficiency improvements, cache changes, etc.)
- perbu 4y agoI've got a similar story. In 1998 a had a summer job, as a programmer, in a little shop that built computers. At the time there was a short of Pentium II 300Mhz chips. One day the logistics guy mentioned they had gotten a batch of Pentium II 300Mhz marked with an operating voltage of 2.0V, instead of the usual 2.8V. Hmm. Intel had taken a bunch of their most expensive CPUs, PII-450Mhz, using the brand new 250nm process and rebranded them as the cheapest CPUs which were at the time built with a 350nm process. You could just take this, stick in a motherboard an change the base frequency and you'd have the best CPU Intel could make. We never sold any of those CPU to customers. We all bought ourselves new CPUs that day.
- krylon 4y agoSomething similar might have happened with Celeron 300 CPUs, I recall they could be overclocked to 450MHz as well without trouble. I think they didn't have as much cache as the Pentium II, but the increased clock rate meant you could get a pretty fast CPU for cheap.
- smcl 4y agoYep, the Celeron 300A: https://www.anandtech.com/show/174/3 https://www.anandtech.com/show/174/3
- vasac 4y agoEspecially those manufactured in Malaysia, as they could be overclocked more successfully than the 300As made in Costa Rica. Fun times.
- ableal 4y agoI seem to remember that the 300A overclock was first published by Tom's Hardware - a site started by a German medical doctor, as implausible as that sounds. I was trying to confirm this, but he didn't claim credit for that in this interview: https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/20-year-anniversary,4552-7.html https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/20-year-anniversary,455... P.S. Also, some twenty years ago another MD rewrote the Linux scheduler, because he wanted better interactive performance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Con_Kolivas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Con_Kolivas
- brk 4y agoIt wasn’t just CPUs, at the time it was also common to pay a premium for faster RAM chips. In many cases a chip marked as a 70ns speed could be reconfigured to support 50ns easily by adding or removing a surface mount resister or cutting a solder pad.
- MBCook 4y agoThe old pencil trick on early Athlons! http://www.ocmelbourne.com/tutorials/PencilTrick/ http://www.ocmelbourne.com/tutorials/PencilTrick/
- FartyMcFarter 4y ago> the double-sigma (ΣΣ) sign added on early 386s after they had been tested bug-free from the infamous 32-bit multiplier bug I hadn't heard about this, I think this is what's being discussed here: https://groups.google.com/g/comp.arch/c/qm7FVR_YV4A/m/P97XlCVS_IsJ https://groups.google.com/g/comp.arch/c/qm7FVR_YV4A/m/P97XlC... > Contrary to industry speculation, the 80386 multiplier errors result from a layout problem, not from an error in logic design. "We didn't allow enough margin to catch the worst-case pattern in the multiplier at the corners of our process," explains Dana Krelle, Intel's 80386 marketing manager. "As a result, some chips, at some temperature/ voltage/frequency points, will produce errors from particular combinations of 32-bit operands." The error, apparently due to unintentional coupling between adjacent cells in the multiplier, escaped Intel's simulation and chip verification process until it was spotted in a subsequent stress-testing program.'
- cubefox 4y agoSimilar story: ATI Radeon 9500/9700.
- anthk 4y agoVBIOS related, right? Or custom drivers.
- tyingq 4y agoLots of quirky stuff in the same time period. Like the 487. Marketed as a math coprocessor for the 486sx, meaning it was supposedly the same idea as the 387, 287, etc. But it wasn't that. It was a full on 486DX that disabled your installed 486SX and took over.
- xen2xen1 4y agoI had an IBM motherboard that had an odd enameled wire on it that stuck out like a sore thumb. It was a 486/33 that someone had hotwired to be more like a 486/100. Local computer shop showed it to an IBM rep that said he'd never seen anything similar. It was not as fast as a real /100, but was quite fast for the money.
- titzer 4y agoI have a weird nostalgia for all things 486 because the PC my father had while I was growing up was a 386, and the 486 was "one better", running all the games silky smooth...and EVEN WINDOWS! Other people seem to share this weird nostalgia because the prices of crappy, broken old laptops and desktops from this era are surprisingly high, and working ones are actually expensive!
- knodi123 4y ago> broken old laptops and desktops from this era are surprisingly high, and working ones are actually expensive! What do you think, could it be factories or corporations that have critical processes running on ancient software that requires very specific hardware to run, and which nobody wants to pay to rewrite for modern hardware? Young me would have said "don't be silly", but I've seen some crazy things, man.
- titzer 4y agoThe draw of laptops is easy to understand. I have a cardboard box full of old motherboards and things, but without all the requisite drives and video cards, they are junk. I'm not going to buy a bulky 486 desktop for nostalgia. A laptop is a pretty compact, fully self-contained item; just needs an AC power adapter. Easy to have a box full of them. All of my old laptops still work, especially that 12" aluminum G4 Macbook.
- tracker1 4y agoI think part of it comes down to emulation being less than great for some use cases. I'm fine with emulation, but some want the real experience. The difference with CRT displays vs modern displays is particularly noticeable... I seem to recall a video running a Control, maxed out on a 22" Flat CRT at 1280x1024 that looked better than a 4k display sitting next to it, let alone the performance differences. I know I held on to my pro grade CRTs until I had to move them 3x one summer... man they were heavy. Had a permanent bow in my desk.
- formerly_proven 4y ago
- Brian_K_White 4y agoForget merely binning, labelling, & marketing. Didn't Intel physically burn out perfectly functional fpus to make SX's?
- elsurudo 4y agoMy first (childhood) computer was a 486 (DX I think?). Pentiums were already out, even PIIs maybe. The LEDs on the front (remember those?) said "100", but I was always suspicious of these, because my computer seemed a _lot_ slower (at playing games – what else) than my friend's 133MHz... But his was a Pentium(!), so I never got to the bottom of it. For the record I needed to downscale Doom to about a 1/2 window (running in DOS) to have it run at a decent framerate. Can't have been 100MHz, right? Does anyone here have a comparable benchmark of a "true" 100MHz 486 I can compare with? Thus began my fascination with computers. Booting up DOS in some low-memory mode in order to squeeze every CPU cycle out of that thing. Working within constraints taught me a lot. I didn't have internet at the time, but this thing had a 14.4k modem that I tried to get running. When the modem was in use, the mouse froze (and vice-versa). They were on the same IRQ interrupt jumper I think. I ended up frying the motherboard trying to fix this issue. I didn't have a computer for a while, but after lots of pleading and my parents seeing that I was serious about this, they eventually got me a Pentium 2 (450MHz or so!). But alas, it had a Voodoo Banshee video card (which had notoriously-bad drivers which often simply hard crashed). Alas, working within another constraint...
- Narishma 4y ago> My first (childhood) computer was a 486 (DX I think?). Pentiums were already out, even PIIs maybe. The LEDs on the front (remember those?) said "100", but I was always suspicious of these, because my computer seemed a _lot_ slower (at playing games – what else) than my friend's 133MHz... But his was a Pentium(!), so I never got to the bottom of it. A Pentium is much faster than a 486 at the same clock speed, so that shouldn't be surprising.
- whoopdedo 4y agoI only have my unreliable memory to say, but on a 486DX/33 I recall play Doom 2 at least on the second-from-top view size without noticeable lag. But what sound card did you have? In the late 90s hardware manufacturers made budget cards with processing being done in software rather than dedicated chips. If you had one of those it may have been too much for a 486 to handle. Also probably the cause of your modem problems, as "soft modems" were notorious for being unreliable. Obviously these cards were meant for use in Pentiums with their extra processing power. But some stingy integrators coughPackardBellcough would slap together the lowest cost components without regard to if it'd actually work properly.
- nubinetwork 4y agoHow does one get one of these analyzers?
- rasz 4y agoYeah, article shows socket3 daughterboard while even 286 is not available.
- thewileyone 4y agoCheaper to sell downgraded or mislabeled CPUs than maintain separate manufacturing lines.