4 ms·
However warm & fuzzy the current pop culture image of octopi might be - the reality is that they are very short-lived, and even in a (theoretical) completely hu
by bell-cot 4y ago
However warm & fuzzy the current pop culture image of octopi might be - the reality is that they are very short-lived, and even in a (theoretical) completely human-free natural world, 99.9+% of young octopi will be eaten (by natural predators) before they reach adulthood.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Lifecycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Lifecycle
Orthogonal to that - the article makes a huge deal of "plunge them alive into freezing water". Octopi are cold-blooded, and cold water is the natural habitat of many species. Does anyone know if cold is actually painful for octopi?
- the_gipsy 4y agoI heard that freezing is the most humane way to kill fish etc.
- jjgreen 4y agoOctopuses, or if you want the Greek plural: octopodes. "Octopi" is the Latin pluralisation of a Greek word.
- bell-cot 4y agoThere are times when I feel smarter because I knew enough to be able to make the error... From https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/octopus#Usage_notes https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/octopus#Usage_notes - > Usage notes > The plural octopi is hypercorrect, coming from the mistaken notion that the -us in octōpūs is a Latin second declension ending. The word is actually treated as a third declension noun in Latin. The plural octopodes (Latin: octōpodēs) follows the Ancient Greek plural, ὀκτώποδες (oktṓpodes). The plural octopii is based on an incorrect attempt to pluralise the word based on an incorrect assumption of its origin, and is rare and widely considered to be nonstandard. > Sources differ on which plurals are acceptable: Fowler's Modern English Usage asserts that “the only acceptable plural in English is octopuses”, while Merriam-Webster and other dictionaries accept octopi as a plural form. The Oxford English Dictionary lists octopuses, octopi, and octopodes (the order reflecting decreasing frequency of use), stating that the last form is rare. The online Oxford dictionary states that the standard plural is octopuses, that octopodes is still occasionally used, and that octopi is incorrect. > The term octopod (both octopods and octopodes can be found as the plural) is taken from the taxonomic order Octopoda but has no classical equivalent, and is not necessarily synonymous (it can encompass any member of that order). The uncountable use of octopus is usually reserved for octopus flesh consumed for food ("He ate too much octopus last night.").
- maneesh 4y agoThis was my one piece of knowledge for the day! Thanks for this!
- fatjokes 4y agoMust feel good to be able to cite that you weren't just correct, but hypercorrect.
- bell-cot 4y ago"I know enough to be dangerous" has some humorous bragging rights. But hypercorrect is actually not a favorable adjective - https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hypercorrect https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hypercorrect
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- casenmgreen 4y agoIf the young human death rate was 99.9%, would that make killing adult humans okay? If a human has cancer, and is going to die in a month, would that make killing that human okay? I am sure the humans in the above examples would wish to live, and if we killed them, against their wishes, it would be murder. I think those octopi - including the young who die - all wish to live; and that all creatures either behave to live (plants and bacteria, for exmaple) or, and the more so as their brains become more capable, have a specific and individual wish to live, be it purely instinctive, emotional, or with higher creatures such as elephants, dolphins and gorillas, an actual personal self-conscious wish to live.
- bell-cot 4y agoHeartfelt...but the less like humans a creature is, the more that anthropomorphism starts to read like allegory, irony, sarcasm, or farce. (Admitting that vegans likely feel otherwise.) Philosophically, you sound eager to campaign against octopi being eaten by humans. Do you similarly oppose octopi being eaten by the many non-human predators which currently do so? Those octopi also wish to live, do they not? Are humans somehow morally inferior to every fish in the seas (which freely partake of octopus), so that even 0.1% is forbidden to us?
- throwuxiytayq 4y agoI get your point, but I’m still not sold on the idea that this line of thinking justifies farming octopi in factory conditions by the millions.
- bell-cot 4y agoMorally, I figure that the octopus factory will be roughly as horrible as the current generation of pig factory. Certainly no field of daisies. But not an Evil Demonic Nazi Temple of Genocide, either.
- DangitBobby 4y agoProbably closer to the latter than the former.