16 ms·
This demonstrates that the tech is near to being usable at scale. The thing that doesn't add up is the price... While coal is still usable as an energy sour
by londons_explore 4y ago
This demonstrates that the tech is near to being usable at scale.
The thing that doesn't add up is the price... While coal is still usable as an energy source for making steel, it doesn't make sense to use electricity.
And if one country outlaws using coal for steelmaking, then steelmakers will just move to another country - steelmaking is ferociously competitive, and lots of countries subsidise steelmaking because it is strategically important.
This tech will remain on the sidelines for 'green' projects only until there is some kind of worldwide carbon tax/cap/quota system.
- awestroke 4y agoThere is massive investment happening in green steel production. There is a high demand for green steel from car manufacturers among others. It's easy to dismiss anything out of ignorance, but it only amounts to misinformation
- londons_explore 4y agoCar manufacturers at the moment are happy with "100% recycled with carbon free processes" for their steel. That means you take scrap steel, put it in an electric arc furnace, and power that furnace with matching wind/solar contracts. So far, carmaking uses less steel than comes into recycling plants, so it hasn't really caused any change in the market.
- Danieru 4y agoAre you basing this on real knowledge or a guess? My understanding, from when I lightly researched Japan Steel as a stock, was that car makers want fresh steel with higher guaranteed performance. Thus they can use less steel and reduce weight. Since vehicles are mobile the reduced weight will have a much bigger carbon reduction than from using recycled steel.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- _trampeltier 4y agoWe make welded steel tubes primary for car industry, and as far I know, we also use just "new" steel. Still, since 2 years or so, in all our mail signatures is something about an green steel award we won. But they just anounced, our factory will be closed by end of 2023.
- hectormalot 4y agoCorrect. This is a place where regulation could play a role if the market is large enough. For example: If the Netherlands would prohibit coal for steelmaking, it would just bankrupt the 1 steel mill they have. If however, the EU would prohibit coal for steelmaking, _and_ introduce a carbon tariff/tax on imported steel that was made with coal, it would be a significant enough market for companies to still compete for. It would likely kill the export market for basic steel from the EU, as well as raise steel prices across the continent. Long term benefit might be that the EU could position itself as a technological leader on coal-free steel. No easy options I suppose.
- ben_w 4y agoThis is probably a dumb question but: Given how cheap steel appears to be, would it cause any significant damage to the rest of the economy if steel prices went up because of this?
- londons_explore 4y agoThe price of steel feeds into the price of lots of other things. Cars, buildings, bridges, etc. If steel is more expensive, then the quality of life of most people will go down, even if people don't walk into walmart and think "today I'll buy some steel".
- ben_w 4y agoFeeds in yes, but how significant is it as an input cost? Would doubling the price of steel increase general inflation 0.1% or 10%? (Even as a vague number; economics is never going to be my job).
- roenxi 4y agoIn theory, either the price will go up so much that people use less steel or other goods will stop being produced to free up more energy for steel production so that it stays level. Possibly some combination. If governments make steel production harder there aren't a lot of other ways the story would end. It is impossible for the process to be less efficient without prices moving enough to change behaviour. Something has to give.
- mschuster91 4y ago> This tech will remain on the sidelines for 'green' projects only until there is some kind of worldwide carbon tax/cap/quota system. Doesn't need to be worldwide. The EU and US are large enough markets that can put up import tariffs on carbon. In any case, the production of coal is going to go down rather sooner than later... steelmaking should prepare for this.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoActually cost is why companies are doing research into things like this. Carbon emissions are a problem for heavy industries in the sense that it will raise their cost and this is something they have to address mid to long term. Meanwhile electricity prices are not a constant and trending down. It might be too expensive now but at some point it might actually become the cheaper option if cost continues to drop. Also, large energy users, like steel plants, would probably end up investing in their own energy generation. Wind, solar, maybe even nuclear. That turns electricity from a variable cost into a fixed cost for them. So, it's not as clear cut that electrifying their processes is long term more expensive. It might actually turn around and become the cheaper option. Carbon taxes of course might make this attractive sooner. But even if it were more expensive, another reason for investing in de-carbonizing steel would be that there is actually a growing demand for companies to source their materials from companies that have lower carbon emissions. Steel is used by a lot of companies and those companies too are looking to clean up their supply lines. And of course because some companies are researching and trying different options here, other companies now need to worry about having a plan when their competitors start producing cleaner and cheaper steel. All good reasons for companies to be investing in this now rather than in 30 years.
- ethbr0 4y agoMy naive impression is that heavy industry is (and has been) doing a lot of research into aligning their processes with more intermittent future energy characteristics. I.e. moving from a "we want to run the plant at optimal efficiency, damn the load pattern" to "we want to be able to optimize by following energy costs, even if that means we need to idle sometimes" Processes were very well optimized for the former, hence the greenfield for research into the latter.
- fbdab103 4y ago>even if that means we need to idle sometimes Is that even possible? For a huge industrial process like a steel mill, I think the capital and operational costs are so massive you want to run them continuously. Even "turning the plant on" could take many hours to get everything to temperature and stable.