6 ms·
That’s a terrible ruling. The first sale doctrine says the copy of the book you bought is yours. Lending the book is clearly not copying it. So, I guess you
by hedora 4y ago
That’s a terrible ruling. The first sale doctrine says the copy of the book you bought is yours. Lending the book is clearly not copying it.
So, I guess you just don’t own anything you buy anymore? Like what if I want to lend a tool to someone, and the tool manufacturer wants to rent their tools out? Is that also illegal?
What if the tool contains software?
What if reasonable use of the tool requires accessing a print manual? A pdf manual?
Edit: Reading the ruling, IA should have argued they are simply format shifting a single copy that they own. I wonder if they did make this argument, and then the judge conveniently ignored it (then lied in the summary ruling, when they say IA made no other arguments in their defense), or if IA’s lawyers screwed up.
- jkdufair 4y agoI don’t disagree with the ruling. IA is not lending their copy that they purchased. They are lending a copy of their copy. While that copy is lent out, they are still free to, I.e. read the copy in their possession.
- benatkin 4y agoUnsurprising that not all of HN is pro-fair use. That's how you digitally send a copy of a book. You're saying something similar to "you wouldn't download a car".
- endisneigh 4y agoI don’t see how you’re refuting their point
- benatkin 4y ago> You're saying something similar to "you wouldn't download a car". It's applying without considering it. The digital book isn't being kept at the old location because there is no digital book in the physical book. It's the only way to transfer a single copy of a book without destroying the physical copy. Judges should consider stuff like this and it's a disappointing ruling. But go on...
- endisneigh 4y agoExactly. And there lies the issue. Internet archive has the book and lends the book simultaneously. Hence why they lost.
- benatkin 4y ago[dead]
- hackernewds 4y agoThis makes logical sense. Pay for one, lend one.
- jrmg 4y agoThe ruling discusses this (at length!) and concludes that even a buy-one-physical-lend-one-digital scheme would not be acceptable under current law.
- criddell 4y agoDo you think it would have made a difference if they bought three copies of the book and then shredded two of them? That way they would have the original they scanned, their digital version they copy to lend, and the loaned digital copy.
- endisneigh 4y agoNo, because they still wouldn’t be lending out what was bought.
- dahart 4y agoNo, that’s not why they lost. The reason is because they effectively lend it to many people simultaneously, and implement no controls on getting it “returned” (deleted) by the people they lent it to, while even being aware that some of them don’t “return” it. The technicality that they keep a copy of the book while it’s being lent isn’t really at issue here at all. It’s not because there are two copies, it’s because there are three or more copies, given to two or more parties at the same time. It has become “distribution” in the eyes of copyright law, beyond the lending analogy.
- hker999 4y agoYet, we should proscute GPL violations when the original GPL code is untouched.
- benatkin 4y agoYou're comparing apples and oranges. In the case of a physical object needing to temporarily go digital, it needs to be sent digitally and the records kept, and of course the physical copy has to be kept. In the case of the GPL there's no physical copy and thus there's no need to consider how to move from one form to the other. To require that a physical object never be used digitally is bad for society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yencabulator 4y agoPeople rarely buy copies GPL'ed source code, they obtain a license to the software. Buying something is very different from licensing it.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> Unsurprising that not all of HN is pro-fair use. Isn't "fair use" restricted to (a) short portions of a work, (b) used for specific purposes, such as education or criticism?
- derkades 4y agoThe entire article is about fair use and how what IA is doing is not fair use. I would like the IA to exist, but I agree with the ruling that their fair use argument is nonsense. It's not a derivative work.
- nighthawk454 4y agoThat’s technically true. But frankly it seems like such people have a giant stick up their ass. The digital version would be infinitely more accessible, while still maintaining effectively 1-1 access restrictions. I’m not even sure if they’re _is_ a physical IA library one could go to. For all I know they’re in a vault somewhere. Even the USD isn’t backed 1-1 with physical tokens. It seems patently ridiculous that books be held to this standard in this day and age.
- benatkin 4y agoIt's based on refusing to adapt to a society with digital objects.
- gaganyaan 4y ago[flagged]
- IshKebab 4y agoAnd also it's a lot easier to copy a digitally borrowed book than it is to copy a physically borrowed book. There are practical differences between the two, which mean that the law probably should treat them differently. I expect a lot of HN have difficulty dealing with that because they think "but they both contain the same information". It reminds me of people trying to encode books into prime numbers or the digits or pi or whatnot to "get around" copyright. Fundamentally missing the point.
- yencabulator 4y agoYou cannot even read an ebook without copying it from storage to RAM, to CPU cache, to video RAM, and so on; by your thinking, all owners of ebooks commit multiple instances of copyright infringement every time they read an ebook.
- jkdufair 4y agoMaking a copy in RAM, cache etc does not involve distributing it to other people.
- yencabulator 4y agoYou cannot lend someone a digital instance of the item without copying it. The problem is the sharing of supposedly-one-instance, not the copying.
- jrmg 4y agoReplying to your edit: The format shifting argument and first sale doctrine are discussed in the ruling. Notably in the section headed ‘3’ starting on page 28 - but also in other places.
- bradrn 4y agoThis is interesting, from that section: Nor does IA’s promise not to lend simultaneously its lawfully acquired print copies and its unauthorized reproductions help its case. As an initial matter, IA has not kept its promise. Although the Open Library’s print copies of the Works in Suit are non-circulating, IA concedes that it has no way of verifying whether Partner Libraries remove their physical copies from circulation after partnering with IA. Pls.’ 56.1 ¶¶ 495-496. To the contrary, IA knows that some Partner Libraries do not remove the physical books from their shelves, and even if a Partner Library puts a physical book into a non-circulating reference collection, it could be read in the library while the ebook equivalent is checked out. Id. ¶¶ 494, 497. IA also does not inform Partner Libraries when an ebook in its collection is checked out, and Partner Libraries do not tell IA when their physical copies are circulating. Id. ¶ 498. IA admits it has never taken action against a Partner Library that did not suppress circulation properly. Id. ¶ 499. I do want IA to win, but this certainly doesn’t help their case, to say the least…
- klabb3 4y agoThis is such an “ackchully” argument from the ruling. It’s not the spirit of the law and the principles behind the idea of free access to information. Instead it’s narrowing in on the specifics of physical lending of books, grasping for analogies to the 20th century, in a world which has transformed and moved on decades ago. But even if all those things weren’t true, or important, it’s profound that there’s enough collective incentive to go after IA, instead of say corporations violating GPL, or the hedgies who created “temporary” artificial supply of stocks (which shares a similar “overprovisioning” aspect, except they’re fraudulent at massive scale).
- alwayslikethis 4y ago
- alwayslikethis 4y agoNow that I think about it, not being able to own anything is a good reason to start stealing. Think about it, why is stealing bad? Usually, this is an application of the Golden Rule. If you don't want people to steal the stuff you own, you shouldn't steal their stuff either. However, if you are no longer allowed to own anything (just like under communism), then the argument falls apart. Realistically, information wants to be free, and spreading it is much easier than controlling its spread. I expect the current copyright wars will come into an end in a decade or two, ending in the loss of the copyright mafia as society reconsiders the concession that is the copyright system.
- 0x72 4y agoCome on, this was explained like milion times: you cannot own private property (factory, land, buildings, means of production), but you can own your personal property just fine. Why do leftist use such confusing terminology? I don't know. We should ask Free Software Foundation. Most importantly here, information falls under "means of production", so under communism it should be free. Freedom of information under capitalism is (as everything) a discussion about money. I admire your optimism, regarding the copyrights future. Fingers crossed.
- detrites 4y ago"Alpaca III, can you write an accurate page-by-page summary of every page of Book-I-Want-To-Read, where each summary's one page long and as faithful to the original pages content and length as possible, fully quoting each page permitted?" My point being: as technology marches on the ageing concept of "owning" entirely fungible digital material becomes less and less valid. It is already at a stage meaninglessness is flirting with it in a new way daily and that will continue. Really, we need to let it go.
- jkdufair 4y agoWhether or not someone is allowed to distribute creative works without the permission of the author, the point of copyright, is and will contribute to be independent of the technology used to do the distribution.