5 ms·
> NPR was clearly on the left before, and went hard left after that. It's essentially propaganda now. Do you understand that actual leftists consider NPR to b
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> NPR was clearly on the left before, and went hard left after that. It's
essentially propaganda now.
Do you understand that actual leftists consider NPR to be a voice of the corporate right-center?
Anyway, the correct analysis of NPR, like most "mainstream" media outlets, is that they are biased but not consistently left or right (or any other direction in whatever N-dimensional political space is now fashionable); their bias is pro status quo. That is, their bias is always towards the idea that we live in something roughly approximating the best of all possible worlds, that it requires a bit of tinkering, some careful tweaks to get it dialed in even closer to justice and desirability, but that's about it.
The concept that we live in something that is basically, fundamentally broken on the deepest levels is very difficult for mainstream media to tackle, and even though some occasionally do try, it is quickly put back in the box so that we continue to consider how best to tweak and tinker with what we already have.
- timr 4y ago> Do you understand that actual leftists consider NPR to be a voice of the corporate right-center? Google: "No True Scotsman". Just because you think that they're not left enough to be "really left" is not responsive to my point.
- Sai_ 4y ago> Google: “No True Scotsman” Another recent front page HN story talks about ChatGPT and other advances in AI. So, defining “no true Scotsman” would be within AI’s wheelhouse. I think Openai needs to verbify the act of using GPTx to summarise ideas.
- chris_wot 4y agoIt’s hilarious to me that you and the OP keep bandying about terms like “left” and “right” but don’t ever give any instances to support what you mean. It’s basically just hand waving - in other words, pretty meaningless other than “I don’t like their viewpoint”.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoNot really. I don't have much interest in such labelling and consider it lazy. However, the OP chose to label an organization "leftist", when I'm fairly sure that the people he would identify as "leftist" would not share the feeling that NPR represents their perspective. Whether or not NPR represents my viewpoint is not of much concern to me. I don't expect it, if it happens it happens, it probably won't. That's fine.
- fwungy 4y agoThe hard left is not a place, it's a movement that exists to move further to the left, to the point of insanity. The hard left is offended with the definition of a woman as someone born with female reproductive organs. As a feminist liberal man I do find it amazing that we fought for women's rights for over 100 years only to make the term "woman" meaningless. I still enjoy some NPR shows, but they've gone way past what I'm comfortable with ideologically.
- malermeister 4y agoThe left has nothing to do with the definition of women. That's identity politics and those are a liberal thing. Liberalism is a right wing movement. The left is concerned with public ownership of the means of production.
- arghnoname 4y agoThe problem is these terms are basically undefined and current 'left' and 'right' trends don't match historic left and right trends. Actual communists (e.g., Stalinist USSR) have had periods that were socially traditional in many ways, up to and including prosecuting homosexuality. The truth is what we call 'the left' and 'the right' is some kind of attempt to cluster a bunch of orthogonal belief systems that in our contemporary time tend to cluster. You then also have things like post-modernist ideas that in some sense reject the idea of an objective reality and are idealist, whereas orthodox Marxism is solidly materialist and modern. People don't know what the hell any of these terms mean. Even Marx himself, in comparison to some self-proclaimed Marxists, said something like, "if they are marxists then surely I am not a marxist." Most orthodox Marxists I know do not consider themselves liberals by the way and many wouldn't call themselves feminists because they may disagree with a bunch of baggage there, while being stridently in favor of equality between the sexes. A common struggle among "the left" (e.g., the "new left" in the 60s) is whether or not it is an intra-liberal struggle and whether or not class is the primary or even only determinate and other 'identities' should be subsumed. It's complicated. Personally I try to not take on a label that defines for me a set of beliefs that are orthogonal. Someone can disbelieve in the trans movement you identified entirely and also want a workers revolution. It's not actually uncommon.
- 4y ago
- pessimizer 4y ago> Do you understand that actual leftists consider NPR to be a voice of the corporate right-center? We have to give up on arguing about what "leftism" is. It doesn't mean anything, and Glenn Beck stirred the American brain so thoroughly that there's no way to even give them a general idea of what it used to mean. Just let liberals have it. We have to just talk about our specific political positions on their merits and leave the taxonomies in the history books. NPR is exactly what you would think its sponsors, which are managed funds, massive health care insurers, huge agribusinesses, silicon valley and chemical companies want it to be. Arguing about whether it's "leftist" with people who think the most "leftist" things are massive banks, Hillary Clinton, and fundamentalist Islam is a waste of your life. As a person who identified as a leftist and hung with other people like that for 30 years (and continuing), we were calling NPR National Petroleum Radio 25 years ago when it was gutted at the end of the Clinton administration. It no longer has any serious intention to inform; like most media it's staffed by the children of the wealthy, generating content to support current political initiatives.