5 ms·
Most Americans Doubt Their Children Will Be Better Off
- JohnFen 4y agoI seriously doubt my children will be better off, if you're measuring "better off" in terms of material wealth. Short of some amazing fluke, I don't see a path for that. Instead, I'm just hoping for a more realistic "happy & healthy".
- ThorsBane 4y agoThe next generations will be far healthier than previous generations if they want to be. If they practice just a little bit of discipline. That is wealth. That guarantees wealth over time if basic mathematical principles pertaining to living on less than you make and investing into compounding streams are adhered to over time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CrackerNews 4y agoWhat is better than having health is a wealth that is ownership of capital. Capital exchange goes through the conversion of money into commodity into money of altered value. This can help provide the means of attaining great health. Another way to look at it is home ownership becoming more of a pipe dream for newer generations. More investment will be needed in order to participate and reap from the housing market. This is over a basic human need of shelter.
- ThorsBane 4y agoHealth comes first. Without health, you cannot work to produce that wealth. Very few people inherit meaningful amounts of wealth. The next generations will have capabilities for boosting their health that nobody else has had before. Home ownership is an easy problem to solve. We need to build more property and develop and redevelop existing properties. We need more investors, more builders, more construction, more new shopping malls, more infrastructure spending, larger infrastructure products. We can print fiat to fuel this because it's tied to real economic gains and the increased movement of all commodities. It is not a choice between treating real estate as investment vs a basic human need of shelter. When you properly allow supply to meet demand by getting out of the way of construction and investment and business to build the products (the houses), the supply will rise to meet the demand. Some places have artificial blockers on the ability of supply to rise to meet demand. Most of the United States does not have this problem because of how giant a landmass it is and how much open space there is to continually develop, redevelop, and reforst over the coming thousand years.
- JohnFen 4y ago> If they practice just a little bit of discipline. Discipline is essential, yes, but equally as essential is just plain getting lucky.
- ThorsBane 4y agoIncorrect. The majority of human beings choose stagnation and comfort over discipline and future-thinking even when they could do more with what they already have. This will become much more apparent and visible with ChatGPT fueling everyone and boosting those who are diligent, disciplined, focused, and in love with their craft(s). There won't be any more of these excuses around luck for long.
- JohnFen 4y agoHard work and future-thinking has never been sufficient for success. Critical, yes, but not sufficient. Success also requires a good dose of luck. I don't see how the likes of ChatGPT can possibly change that reality. But I suppose that we will see!
- ThorsBane 4y agoIf you don't see how ChatGPT is already changing that, your vision is not good. Do you want me to write more to drive the point home? If you cannot see the results ChatGPT will bring to the human species, then you are not able to see clearly at all, let alone to render judgment on the nature of the United States and how hard work and future-thinking play into success and how luck does and what luck is. Luck is just when preparation meets (endlessly abounding) opportunities. America is the Land of Opportunity. You can come at me with the luck talk when opportunities dwindle and when the majority of the species is not stagnating by not making the most of what it already has.
- JohnFen 4y agoWhat a shame. We were having an interesting exchange, but then you decided to start engaging in personal insults.
- appleiigs 4y agoThere was news that life expectancy has dropped. Obesity and suicide.
- mrandish 4y agoI'm not sure how it's possible to "not see a path" when every long-term global trend shows material wealth has been increasing for centuries. By every measure from standard of living to health and happiness the positive trend data is overwhelming. I suggest you go look at the objective long-term data and stop letting negative spin from click-driven media and politicians trying to drive their various agendas rob you of reality.
- CrackerNews 4y agoThe keyword is global. For example, China is reducing extreme poverty (again the keyword is extreme).
- the_only_law 4y agoI find it difficult to believe GP didn’t know this.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThe fact that people of similar belief spam facts about global poverty reduction on stories of pessimistic Americans seems to indicate that they do not, in fact, understand this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 4y ago> I'm not sure how it's possible to "not see a path" when every long-term global trend shows material wealth has been increasing for centuries. It's because I'm thinking about my children's well-being. That's near-term, local stuff. That the long-term global trend is going up doesn't mean the short-term local trend is also going up. Also, I'm comparing my children's standard of living to my own. I'm not comparing my children's standard of living to that of past eras. > stop letting negative spin from click-driven media and politicians You're assuming quite a lot about about me here.
- ThorsBane 4y agoThis is because people are internalizing too much negative clickbait and letting it become their worldview. American optimism is a trademark feature of being American and being in America. We must retain and encourage relentless optimism in American innovation and American capabilities and the American spirit. It is this spirit that emboldens NATO and all nations and peoples loving free exchange, free education, free upwards momentum for the motivated, and freedom for the brave and the bold. And we try to lift up all boats as the tide rises higher for us, and we demonstrate this over a very long track record now. Don't fall victim to authoritarian bullshit or fear mongering or gas lighting or astro turfing or internet psyops from abroad. The United States is poised for significant continued growth and innovation.
- CrackerNews 4y agoEach generation has less share of the overall wealth than the previous generation. When does the hopeful idealism convert into positive material change?
- infamouscow 4y agoHistory books are quite clear about this. When all other options are exhausted, violence has a way of presenting new ones.
- ThorsBane 4y agoViolence is almost never a rational choice because it is the last choice. It is a final choice. There are thousands of possible branches still remaining to individuals even if GPTs were to accelerate to GPT-5 and beyond within some months from now. Even if the majority of work as we know it now becomes automated, that will unlock a universal basic income that elevates all people to the status of being a diligent researcher, scientist, engineer, or college student in training towards one of these directions as everyone gets massively boosted because of ChatGPT and other tools and friends like that coming online. The end result of this boosting is a generous universal basic income that makes ancient the concept of needing to work for a "living." Instead people will work to continue the next wave of innovation in products and services across all industries, and in commodity extraction and acquisition even from celestial bodies. Mining operations are already being spun up. 3d printed rockets are being tested in flight. What this means is that momentarily human beings will have entirely new classes of work opportunity that are more badass and interesting than anything before it. Expect astronaut openings by the millons.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoI'm definitely a lot better off than my parents were, but as a Millennial, I feel like I'm in the minority. I don't (and won't) have kids, but if I did, I think they'd definitely be worse off. Between stagnant wages, corporations buying all the housing stock and constantly rising rents, yeah...they're basically fucked. The threshold for being able to buy a house has gotten ridiculous. The 638 sq ft 1-bedroom apartment I lived in in 2011 for $650/month is now $1,600/month. The 900 sq ft 2-bedroom I lived in in 2015 for $900/month is now a whopping $2,200/month. That's absolutely bonkers.
- carlosjobim 4y agoIf you won't have kids you are by definition worse off than your parents and all your ancestors since the beginning of time, because reproduction is the definite measure of success.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> reproduction is the definite measure of success. For a species, sure. For an individual, absolutely not. Personally, I'd just say "happiness" is the measure of success, with "happiness" having a definition that varies from individual to individual.
- carlosjobim 4y agoEspecially for an individual. In the end that is the only measure at all of success, if you have a living heritage.
- teachrdan 4y agoThat's kind of a reductive definition of success. I have one biological child. Am I less successful than a sperm donor who has "fathered" multiple children? Is this the lifehack childless millennials have been waiting for?
- 4y ago
- chung8123 4y agoDoes it make sense for them to be better off? We have been living on oil which takes a crazy amount of years to produce and clean up. This is like living on debt for a number of years and you cannot continue to live with a negative balance. At some point you have to take the foot off the accelerator and when you do that it lowers the quality of life.
- kevviiinn 4y agoQuality of life would be improved by not polluting the air we breathe, water we drink, and food we eat
- carlosjobim 4y agoEfficiency of energy and all production and services has increased extremely much in the past decades. All that surplus is being sucked away somewhere and wasted. If you look, it's not hard to find: Millions and millions of people not working for a living or working pretend jobs. And most of them get very well compensated for that. The only reason for a general decrease in quality of life is because the rulers have determined that the population is more easily controlled the less freedom they have. There is no investment that pays better than investing in the poverty of others.
- gamechangr 4y agoI see the divide in my friends groups. There are no easy answers. I think for me, one insight is that of my friends making over $100,000 lack the real awareness of what it means for my friends who make just enough to pay rent and food, while struggling to provide the life they want for their kids. We ( I have been guilty of it) sometimes reduce the conversation to some version of "just re-tool" as if they are 10 weeks away from a different life. There are so many steps that I used to take for granted. Mindset is one of them. Different priorities is another major issue. I have a friend that could have worked on a cutting edge robotics team that stayed home and took a help desk job so he could live with his mom that is 88 years old and struggles to walk. The hopelessness of many hard working and smart people is not very appreciated. They are not dumb or lacking discipline or some variation of that. There is a real economic issue. Take school teachers or nurses (my wife's a nurse) that truly aren't paid adequately for their contribution. is there fault they chose wrong at 18? That just seems too simple of an answer to me.
- KerrAvon 4y ago"Fault" is a tricky word here. Anyone going into teaching minors as a profession cannot be doing it for the money, because at no point in recent history have US teachers been adequately paid, so they knew to some extent what they were getting into. But that certainly doesn't mean they're adequately paid or respected or that we shouldn't fix that. > have a friend that could have worked on a cutting edge robotics team that stayed home and took a help desk job so he could live with his mom that is 88 years old and struggles to walk. This is also pretty common. The US healthcare system could help here if it weren't an arbitrarily cruel profit center for billionaires. We need a real social safety net in this country.
- acuozzo 4y ago> Anyone going into teaching minors as a profession cannot be doing it for the money, because at no point in recent history have US teachers been adequately paid, so they knew to some extent what they were getting into. Indeed, but the economy is considerably worse now than it was and how observant one is does not seem to be determined by nurture. The teachers I had in elementary school in central NJ in the 1990s could all afford to lead pretty normal middle class lifestyles. I wouldn't say that they were thriving, but they certainly weren't just barely making ends meet. I wouldn't think less of a classmate of mine from that time if they went into teaching as a profession thinking it would now provide what it provided then.
- MPlus88 4y ago[dead]
- adversaryIdiot 4y agoI don't want to sound naive, but I am at the point where I consider it unethical and inhumane to have children.
- helen___keller 4y agoFrom what perspective? It’s unethical to knowingly inflict suffering, but even if (economy/climate/etc) has a poor outlook, that doesn’t equate to suffering for your children (it’s possible to be happy while the economy sucks and the world is heating).
- carlosjobim 4y agoThen your rulers have successfully put you in the exact spot they wanted. Now stop wasting time on HackerNews and go be productive for your lords! There are profits, taxes and interest to be paid!
- tenacious_tuna 4y ago> in the exact spot they wanted I know this is a joke, but that can't be right: the rulers will continue to need a working class to support their lifestyle. If birth rates collapse and the music stops, a whole lotta everyone is gonna be without chairs, not just the working folk.
- carlosjobim 4y agoThey don't need that many people, and there are already plenty. Birth rates have collapsed completely, and the people left will be those who are grateful for being allowed to even live - now that's much more comfortable than having an annoying populace talking about their rights and thinking they are equal to the lords.
- helen___keller 4y ago30 and thinking of having kids. I did very well for myself, as did my wife. We are both doing better than our parents at our age. But we also recognize we basically won the career lottery (tech, biotech). I highly doubt my kids will be better off financially. But finances are just one aspect of life and I hope I can set them up to be happy, healthy, and enriched.
- squokko 4y agoI believe that my kids will be materially OK but I think that the world will be a worse place for them than the one that I grew up in. Geopolitics, sociopolitics, loneliness, dating, fertility, etc...
- jstarfish 4y ago[dead]