4 ms·
> The cities that allow for lots of sprawl (eg Houston) are not very nice places to live in many people’s viewpoints. "Many peoples' viewpoints" is a cop-out.
by cyberax 4y ago
> The cities that allow for lots of sprawl (eg Houston) are not very nice places to live in many people’s viewpoints.
"Many peoples' viewpoints" is a cop-out. You can apply it to ANY phrase: "In many people's viewpoints we should drop a nuke on Manhattan and rebuild it from scratch".
If you look at objective data, Houston beats NYC handily in pretty much any important metric.
Houston commute is 26 minutes vs 33 minutes for NYC. Per-capita income after taxes is similar, and housing costs in Houston are not even in the same league ($3000 average rent vs $1300). Houston also has less income inequality (Gini coefficient of 0.51 vs 0.55 for NYC).
> People aren’t clamoring to live in Houston
This is rich, because Houston is one of the fastest-growing cities in the US: https://www.click2houston.com/news/2016/03/24/census-data-shows-houston-leads-in-population-growth-across-us/ https://www.click2houston.com/news/2016/03/24/census-data-sh... - it's THE fastest growing city in some measures.
Apparently, nobody goes there - it's too crowded.
> Roads are a bad value for what you get. Not only is the throughput not great, they are expensive to maintain.
You're making factually false statement after factually false statement.
I really find it curious how people swallow the urbanist propaganda without ever bothering to check if it makes sense.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoYou accuse others of 'swallowing urbanist propaganda' but that's both highly uncharitable and also grossly ignorant given the extremely high demand for pre-war and denser areas.
- cyberax 4y ago"pre-war"? WTF? > the extremely high demand for pre-war and denser areas. Of course there is a high demand for urban areas. It's an effect of runaway density. Companies have competitive advantage if they locate their offices in The Downtown of a large city. This in turn makes the area around it more expensive, as people try to move closer to avoid longer commutes. This is a vicious circle, leading to a sort of "density pollution". And it should be solved in exactly the same way we dealt with other forms of pollution: via regulation and gradual tightening of rules.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoTightening of the rules to what, precisely ? "Nope, sorry, your company's locating here would push downtown density past the limit, you should find a greenfield site on the edge of town and build something new there" ???
- cyberax 4y agoYup. Exactly that. A hard limit on the amount of office space per square mile. You simply can not build any more offices. The market forces then will take care of distributing the office space accordingly. If you absolutely NEED to have an office in The Downtown, then you will just have to pay $$$$$$$$$. Otherwise you'll have to rent an office in a nearby suburbian village center. Kind of like we did cap-and-trade for sulfur emissions.
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 4y agoWhy would a city do that? To make you personally feel better?
- telotortium 4y agoMaybe to ensure that the country is evenly developed, which would make housing more affordable across the entire country. The US is not even that bad - unlike many other countries, it doesn't have a true primate city[1] on a national level. I'm thinking of places like England, where the privileged areas of London (and the Home Counties), Oxford, and Cambridge are the only place to earn a decent salary, but have extortionate housing costs, while the rest of the country has much lower housing costs but such lower wages that people are pushed to migrate into the privileged areas, pushing housing costs there even higher. Densifying the cities would help to some extent, but construction tends to cost a lot more in these cities, and not entirely due to zoning, planning permissions, etc. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primate_city https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primate_city
- Tade0 4y agoI've been observing the discussion on sprawl vs high density in the US from the safety of my commie block and my conclusion is that sprawl is silly, but cities the density of New York are dystopian. It appears that the same induced demand that makes traffic eventually occupy all lanes, no matter how many you build, works to make dense cities unaffordable and impossible to maintain. There's a middle ground to be achieved here, really, and it's better than both the extreme views I've been hearing over and over again.
- ryan_lane 4y agoTexas has one of the highest drunk driving scores, and New York has one of the lowest: https://zutobi.com/us/driver-guides/the-us-dui-report https://zutobi.com/us/driver-guides/the-us-dui-report. That's just one of the things that makes living in cities with public transportation and less sprawl so much nicer. > Houston commute is 26 minutes vs 33 minutes for NYC. I'd take a 33 minute train commute over a 26 minute car commute any day. I'd take a 1 hour train commute over a 26 minute car commute even. When you commute by car you have to be paying attention the entire time. On a train, I can read a book, use my phone, etc. The experience of commuting by car absolutely sucks, and is considerably more expensive. > Per-capita income after taxes is similar, and housing costs in Houston are not even in the same league ($3000 average rent vs $1300). You need to also include the cost of transportation, which brings this figure a lot closer ($3100/m vs $2200; see: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/total-cost-owning-car https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/total-co...). Also, using average here is misleading. You can live in the outer boroughs and pay a lot less than that, and some areas in manhattan drive the average up a lot. You also have to take into consideration the fact that sprawl forces you into that car pretty often. You need to use the car to go grocery shopping, whereas you can walk to a grocery store in a dense city. I live in Tokyo and used the train once so far this week. I'll be using it again today. On a normal basis, I have everything I need within a 5-10 minute walk. >> Roads are a bad value for what you get. Not only is the throughput not great, they are expensive to maintain. > You're making factually false statement after factually false statement. On a total usage basis, public transportation is considerably cheaper than roads, because as a whole, public transportation tends to be very highly used, when it's ubiquitous enough to be used as a primary method. You can increase throughput by increasing train frequency, which improves commute times. When roads are heavily used, the throughput decreases, commute times increase, and expanding roads doesn't help that situation.
- cyberax 4y ago> Texas has one of the highest drunk driving scores, and New York has one of the lowest And so? > When you commute by car you have to be paying attention the entire time. Self-driving software will fix this within a decade. It's technically already legal to read books and watch TV in a car, if you own one particular high-end car model. > You need to also include the cost of transportation, which brings this figure a lot closer Cost of transportation is a whole another issue. Because then you need to include the local taxes that are used to build and maintain transportation infrastructure. > You also have to take into consideration the fact that sprawl forces you into that car pretty often. You need to use the car to go grocery shopping, whereas you can walk to a grocery store in a dense city. Yes, and? Car also allows me to just do 2 trips a week to the store to get groceries for 4 people for several days. I had to do a grocery run every day when I lived in a dense city. That's easily another 30-40 minutes wasted every day. > On a total usage basis, public transportation is considerably cheaper than roads, because as a whole, public transportation tends to be very highly used That's not true. The average bus load in the US is 16 people. This makes it close to the car cost, only just a bit more efficient. It also does not consider the cost of wasted personal time. > When roads are heavily used, the throughput decreases, commute times increase, and expanding roads doesn't help that situation. It does, actually. More roads/lanes almost always increase throughput. They don't necessarily increase the average _speed_. But guess what, the transit speed is _slower_ than cars pretty much everywhere. Have you personally lived in Houston or another car-oriented city in the US? Or are you just reading the horror stories about "car hells"? Try it yourself to see the drawbacks and advantages. I personally had lived in Europe and used transit and biking a lot. Including the bike hell of Amsterdam. I got my driving license at the age of 30 and my first car at 32.
- troad 4y agoJust wanted to chime in and agree with cyberax. I’m living in a dense, beautiful European city, in a heritage listed building near the historic centre. If I got a US visa tomorrow I’d be on the first flight to the Houston or Dallas suburbs. Judging by the growth rates of Texas cities - compared to the growth rates of old European ones - lots of people agree. Pretty =/= functional. There are costs to density that aren’t immediately apparent, and advantages to having space that people who are used to it may not appreciate.
- xen2xen1 4y agoI want a yard. Well, I want to live someplace with a yard, and I have one. A place with a pool, and room for my dogs to run. I live "in town" but I have a yard. I don't want to live in a dense urban area. Some do, but I'll bet they tend to be younger and don't have kids or have younger ones. People want space. How about we make roads and cars cheaper instead of demonizing owning actual land? That's why suburbs are popular, why they'll stay popular, no matter how much strongtowns.com tries to push something else.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoHouston is actually losing people, it’s growth occurring in the suburbs: https://kinder.rice.edu/urbanedge/houston-dallas-led-metro-area-growth-2021-even-their-urban-cores-lost-population https://kinder.rice.edu/urbanedge/houston-dallas-led-metro-a...
- cyberax 4y agoI'm sorry, I should have specified that I meant "Greater Houston Area", not the Houston proper. It's what people mean by saying "Houston" anyway.