11 ms·
The risks of cleaning with bleach and other disinfectants
- tyronehed 4y ago[dead]
- LinuxBender 4y agoI agree with the risks stated in the article but I would add that people on well water should still use bleach and other strong chemicals in their bathroom from time to time. Well water does not contain Chlorine bleach and there are a number of bacteria that can grow out of control in a bathroom when Chlorine is not present in the water. Some feed off the fats in soap scum, commonly on the bottom of the shower curtain. A home I bought came with this little gift and I've had to cycle through bleach, Lysol and high powered UVC lamps to get rid of it. And UVC lamps come with the risk of converting O2 to O3 Ozone which requires good ventilation.
- vuln 4y agoLiquid Chlorine worked the best in my use case. Bought a house in Florida with no bathroom exhaust fan. Fought tooth and nail to keep it at bay. Squeegeeing the walls, apply after shower mildew/mold inhibitor. Nothing worked. Liquid Chlorine did. Open bathroom window, placed a fan in front of it and sprayed down the entire shower heavily. Yes the smell I was powerful, I wore a respirator. It's been over a year and we haven't had it come back at all. We still squeegee and apply mildew/mold inhibitor and we now have a very high powered exhaust vent in the master bathroom.
- kube-system 4y agoI try not to spray bleach when I can avoid it -- wiping or pouring keeps more of the bleach on the surface instead of floating around in the air.
- vuln 4y agoMakes complete sense. Less to breathe also. Can't believe I didn't think of that. Thanks!
- nilram 4y agoSimilar situation, I have a bathroom with an exhaust fan but no openable windows. Besides the squeegee religion, I have a circulation fan on a timer that I let run for a couple hours to dry things out.
- vuln 4y agoThat is the one thing I wish it had was a timer. Was thinking about replacing the flip switch with a turn knob style timer.
- sclarisse 4y agoConsider cleaning with Pine-Sol too. It’s a mold/mildew inhibitor by its nature.
- vuln 4y agoNever thought of that. We'll definitely try it. Thanks!
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoI added a chlorine injection pump to my well that adds a little bit whenever the main pump runs. Water quality very much improved.
- hinkley 4y agoLast time I was in a thread with homesteaders doing sketchy things with water, one of the voices of reason invoked Legionaire's Disease. Legionaire's disease being a rather nasty bacterial pneumonia, grows in water and needs to be aerosolized to get into the lungs. Like might happen when using a low-flow showerhead.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI've heard some horror stories as well. There are lab tests one can send off their water to test for literally hundreds of metals, toxins, pathogens and more. Most towns will also do limited testing. There are also bacteria test kits on Amazon but they only test for a few things. My well tested clean but I still intend to shock it with chlorine. The bummer is that this is such an old well they did not make it easy to shock it without pulling the pump but I am going to replace the pump anyway because I think it was installed in the 80's.
- hinkley 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but don't you also want to retest after a flooding event (even if your well head is never submerged)?
- LinuxBender 4y agoAbsolutely. AFAIK there have been no floods here. I get snow but the underground well room is covered with a heavy concrete cover. My home is much higher than the fields around me. That said I have no idea if there are any volcanic passages that would allow unfiltered ground water to reach the well. The mineral and bacterial tests would suggest that is not occurring.
- neonate 4y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20230323080410/https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/21/well/live/cleaning-disinfectant-bleach-risks.html http://web.archive.org/web/20230323080410/https://www.nytime... https://archive.ph/7PjyQ https://archive.ph/7PjyQ
- dogma1138 4y agoBleach wasn’t commonly used for bathroom cleaning in the US ore-covid? It’s quite common in Europe and much of the rest of the world…
- pixl97 4y agoEither bleach or some other powerful cleaner was. Quite often you hear about some some younger adult working at a low paying job using bleach to clean, and they decide to mix some other cleaner in because it's not working well enough, and there is a reaction that hospitalized them or kills them.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoBleach + ammonia? Chloramine. Bad. Bleach + peroxide? Exothermic reaction that produces oxygen. Bad. Bleach + an acid like vinegar? Chlorine gas. Bad. Bleach + alcohol? Chloroform. Bad.
- cratermoon 4y agoIn short, that chlorine atom really wants to be somewhere else, and nearly anything, even water, will break the bond. So now there's chlorine ions floating around, and chlorine has the 2nd highest electronegativity after fluorine. It's so reactive it will even form compounds with many of the noble gases.
- 123pie123 4y agoI've worked in a few cleaning jobs as a student in the UK and I've always had to a have a mini induction on how to use cleaning fluids, which is v basic - don't mix certain types of cleaning fluids
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm in the US, and myself and most people I know well enough to know this about them have been using bleach for bathroom cleaning for my entire life.
- ben7799 4y agoI thought bleach and alcohol were thought to not create pressure for resistance because of their nature. It is interesting they talk about benzalkonium chloride, that stuff absolutely destroys my hands. When the FDA shut down triclosan all the soaps for paranoid people switched to Benzalklonium Chloride. That stuff absolutely destroy my skin. No matter what anyone complains about they won't stop putting it in all the bathroom soap dispensers in our office. I can go in with my skin fine, if I wash my hands 3x in a day they are almost bleeding by the end of the day. Also interesting Benzalkloium Chloride last time I looked was in limbo with the FDA, they couldn't decide whether to officially approve it or ban it. They know it causes contact dermatitis. It is currently in a state where the manufacturers are preparing evidence to get it approved but yet it is allowed to be on the market.
- MengerSponge 4y agoI've been known to carry a small bottle of Dr Bronner's for this reason. Also, the bleaching agents in a lot of commercial paper towels also chew up my hands. I'll carry a few handkerchiefs in the winter too.
- cma 4y ago> Also, the bleaching agents in a lot of commercial paper towels also chew up my hands. Are you saying if you wet a commercial paper towel with plain water and drop it on some cloth it will bleach the fabric? Why would the bleaching agents still be active any more than with printer paper or toilet paper? Wouldn't these be a hazard if someone wiped ammonia with them?
- crazygringo 4y agoYeah I'm confused about that too. Not to mention most commercial paper towels are the brown unbleached kind. Meanwhile toilet paper I've never seen unbleached... But there is something I've also always found very mildly irritating specifically about unbleached brown paper towels, as well as uncoated corrugated cardboard. Just kind of like a micro-scratchiness.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ReaderView 4y ago[dead]
- KaiserPro 4y agoSorry, but saying hydrogen peroxide is safer than bleach and therefore you should swap them is leaving out a massive caveat. It is still corrosive and an irritant. Yes, the decomposition products are much less of a problem, but thats kinda less of the point.
- photochemsyn 4y agoIf you ever have to move into a cabin in the American Southwest that's been a mouse and rodent playground, saturating it with a solution of 10% chlorine bleach in water is not a bad idea (hantavirus is the general issue in that case). You will want to rinse with a lot of water to get residue out, though. However, such scorched-earth tactics are a bad idea on a regular basis, just use simple non-toxic cleaning agents like sodium percarbonate aka 'chlorine-free oxygen bleach', sodium citrate (basically citric acid + sodium bicarbonate cooked together in solution), and simple soap (vegetable oil + lye). The latter two are not hard to make yourself if you want to, just find a reliable recipe and instruction set online (gloves and eye protection recommended).
- giantg2 4y agoDo you mean .5% chlorine bleach? The stuff they sell in the store is 5-7%.
- jollyllama 4y agoI've heard a one-time ozone generator cleaning is also good for this
- JohnFen 4y ago> and simple soap People really underestimate the antimicrobial properties of just plain old soap. Soap is bad news to a lot of common microbes, and kills them dead.
- LinuxBender 4y agoSome bacteria live, feed and thrive off the fats in soap if your water does not already contain chlorine. I had to fight that in a home I bought with bleach, Lysol and powerful UVC lights. This applies to people with well water as there is no added chlorine.
- insaneirish 4y agoFrom the article: "The chemicals in bleach “are persistent in the environment, and they’re also very corrosive,” she added." This seems incomplete at best and disingenuous at worst. It's my understanding that chlorine bleach breaks down into oxygen, NaCl, and water. So, sure, you can argue that salt water is persistent in our environment and also corrosive, but that statement strikes me the same way as how people have long warned about the dangers of ever present dihydrogen monoxide in almost everything we consume these days.
- giantg2 4y agoDoesn't most bleach contain stabilizers? Perhaps that part of it. The other possibility is that when bleach reacts with stuff it can form other, more stable compounds. Either way, I generally agree with your position. Bleach tends to break down pretty quickly compared to many other things.
- insaneirish 4y ago> Doesn't most bleach contain stabilizers? Not sure. SDS for Clorox Regular Bleach: https://www.thecloroxcompany.com/wp-content/uploads/cloroxregular-bleach12015-06-12.pdf https://www.thecloroxcompany.com/wp-content/uploads/cloroxre... It lists a single ingredient: sodium hypochlorite.
- giantg2 4y agoAh, I might have been thinking about pool chlorine and some outdoor cleaners.
- jaywalk 4y agoPool chlorine is just slightly more concentrated bleach.
- rootusrootus 4y agoYou might be thinking of certain types of pool chlorine tablets that include cyanuric acid. Really a terrible way to treat a pool, honestly, it builds up CYA in the water and eventually you can't get enough active chlorine to safely disinfect. And the only realistic way to reduce CYA is drain the pool partly or completely and refill. Properly maintained pool water only needs basic chemicals, and pure sodium hypochlorite (unless you're going to use a chlorine generator, in which case you'll end up buying a few hundred pounds of salt when you fill the pool).
- AlbertCory 4y ago.. since I just used some dilute bleach to de-stink a kitchen sponge (yes, I will buy some more sponges next time I think of it): You do have to be careful. I soaked the sponge in several changes of water, soapy and clean. But come on! Bleach is a mainstay. Just don't overuse it.
- giantg2 4y agoWhat about iodine based sanitizers? I see those were missing from the list. Obviously those aren't great on things that can stain. I understand the risk with those is that some people are sensitive to iodine.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI've purchased a little water electrolyzer from Amazon to use as a bleach alternative, and it seems to work quite well. I wonder why this isn't more popular. A little less convenient (takes a little time to make, shelf life of days) and more upfront cost perhaps?
- cobbal 4y agoAs I understand it, that's just a way to create bleach, and bleach itself isn't particularly expensive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrochlorination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrochlorination
- micromacrofoot 4y agoit does seem significantly less noxious that the typical bleach I’ve used, but maybe it’s just about the dilution level
- denton-scratch 4y ago> Calls to poison control centers about cleaning chemicals also increased during the pandemic, primarily for accidental or intentional ingestion. I seem to recall a prominent American recommending the ingestion of bleach as a treatment for Coronavirus.
- cratermoon 4y agoMan Dies, Woman Hospitalized After Taking Form Of Chloroquine To Prevent COVID-19 https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/03/24/820512107/man-dies-woman-hospitalized-after-taking-form-of-chloroquine-to-prevent-covid-19 https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0... In this case, chloroquine phosphate, a common antimalarial, but also found in tablet form to treat fish tanks. The FDA even put out a statement about it. https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/product-safety-information/fda-letter-stakeholders-do-not-use-chloroquine-phosphate-intended-fish-treatment-covid-19-humans https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/product-safety-informa...
- misssocrates 4y agoIs there a transcript of that? The exact sentence please.
- yamtaddle 4y agohttps://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-president-trump-vice-president-pence-members-coronavirus-task-force-press-briefing-31/ https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefings-statements/re... He doesn't literally say "inject bleach" [EDIT: and also doesn't say: "ingest bleach"]. What transpires is this— Acting DHS undersecretary Bryan: > We’re also testing disinfectants readily available. We’ve tested bleach, we’ve tested isopropyl alcohol on the virus, specifically in saliva or in respiratory fluids. And I can tell you that bleach will kill the virus in five minutes; isopropyl alcohol will kill the virus in 30 seconds, and that’s with no manipulation, no rubbing — just spraying it on and letting it go. You rub it and it goes away even faster. We’re also looking at other disinfectants, specifically looking at the COVID-19 virus in saliva. (and also some stuff about UV light killing Covid) Then, slightly later: > THE PRESIDENT: Thank you very much. So I asked Bill [Undersecretary Bryan] a question that probably some of you are thinking of, if you’re totally into that world, which I find to be very interesting. So, supposing we hit the body with a tremendous — whether it’s ultraviolet or just very powerful light — and I think you said that that hasn’t been checked, but you’re going to test it. And then I said, supposing you brought the light inside the body, which you can do either through the skin or in some other way, and I think you said you’re going to test that too. It sounds interesting. > ACTING UNDER SECRETARY BRYAN: We’ll get to the right folks who could. > THE PRESIDENT: Right. And then I see the disinfectant, where it knocks it out in a minute. One minute. And is there a way we can do something like that, by injection inside or almost a cleaning. Because you see it gets in the lungs and it does a tremendous number on the lungs. So it would be interesting to check that. So, that, you’re going to have to use medical doctors with. But it sounds — it sounds interesting to me. Then a question about it: > Q But I — just, can I ask about — the President mentioned the idea of cleaners, like bleach and isopropyl alcohol you mentioned. There’s no scenario that that could be injected into a person, is there? I mean — > ACTING UNDER SECRETARY BRYAN: No, I’m here to talk about the findings that we had in the study. We won’t do that within that lab and our lab. So — > THE PRESIDENT: It wouldn’t be through injection. We’re talking about through almost a cleaning, sterilization of an area. Maybe it works, maybe it doesn’t work. But it certainly has a big effect if it’s on a stationary object. So, I mean... he kinda does, in a completely dumbshit way, suggest we should explore injecting bleach (or maybe isopropyl alcohol? It's always hard to tell WTF the guy's talking about) but then walks it back when actually questioned on it, but then finished by leaving open the idea of exploring... something? "Maybe it works, maybe it doesn't"—maybe fucking what works? Impossible to know. "We're talking about through almost a cleaning" well, yeah, we know that works for, you know, not the inside of people, so... did you or did you not mean trying to get bleach or isopropyl alcohol inside people? Because the first statement clearly meant that, but then you said, not, but now "maybe it works", but what maybe works? And now my head hurts. "Or almost a cleaning". I mean. What? Anywho, IIRC from watching this when it happened, he does not seem to be making a joke with the initial comment about using tanning beds or household cleaning product injections to fight covid, or whatever the shit he had in mind when he said that craziness. [EDIT] Though, to be clear, he does not say people ought to go inject or drink bleach. He just suggests he's going to have government scientists look into the idea, which is hilariously stupid but also not as bad as it's sometimes made out to be.
- jrootabega 4y agoYes, bleach is great when you dilute it properly, ventilate, wear gloves, and don't mix it with other chemicals, thanks article!
- webnrrd2k 4y agoThis strikes me as more of a scare piece than useful. Certainly overuse of cleaning agents is a problem. But that sounds like more of a problem with education or a mental issue than a problem with the cleaning agents, per se. I used to swim all the time in chlorinated pools as a kid. The only consequences were hair getting bleached to an greenish tint, and irritated eyes. Sodium and chloride are the constituents of plain 'ol salt. You body deals with it well. Your stomach acid of hydrochloric acid, and it doesn't seem to be an issue, either. I'm not worried about bleach at all, as long as it's used with common sense. So don't go overboard. Dont drink it. Don't take a both in concented bleach. I'm sure you'll be fine. I'm sure that there are exceptions, like maybe the fumes are too much for someone with asthma or whatever. There used to be problems with dioxins that were the redult of bleaching agents. But, again, if people exercise common sense, then I'm sure that society will muddle along.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> Sodium and chloride are the constituents of plain 'ol salt. You body deals with it well. Sure, you can make any substance sound innocuous or harmful by reducing it to its elemental constituents and then comparing them to other substances. The structure and form make the poison (along with the dose). I could tell you that benzene is "just" carbon and hydrogen, and your body deals with those well. Except benzene is extremely carcinogenic. Unlike, for contrast, toluene, which has a very similar chemical formula but is not carcinogenic, due to a different structure. Heck, your body "deals with" oxygen well. If you're referring to diatomic oxygen, that is - O₂. Your body does not like O₃, even though that's also "just" oxygen. Furthermore, you're conflating chloride with chlorine. Chloride is a single chlorine anion joined in an ionic bond (or dissociated aqueous, more commonly). Bleach contains a chlorite anion - the entire anion is negative, but chlorine is itself covalently bonded to another nonmetal (oxygen). The properties of specific nonmetals as part of a larger compound are completely different from the properties of those nonmetals in isolated ions. Both have elemental chlorine in them, but they're quite different chemically.
- webnrrd2k 4y agoThe tone of your response is, like the original article, more of a scare piece. And I'm not trying to make bleach "sound innocuous". Bleach, when used with common sense and whatever guidelines that apply, is actually innocuous. It's just a fact that some substances are actually innocuous. Bleach has been used for cleaning and disinfecting for a very long time... people have used it daily for years on end in their jobs as dishwashers or whatever. If it was such a problem then people would have noticed the higher cancer rates, or whatever bleach-related diseases that actually occurr. The fact is that people in the US have had small amounts of bleach in their drinking water and it hasn't been an issue. People clean with bleach every day. It's used in laundry and all sorts of other things. As a kid I swam in some over-bleached pools and it didn't hurt me or any of my friends. The same thing happened in swimming pools across the nation. I'm sure that we swallowed some of it as we swam, too. It wasn't a big deal then. It's not a big deal now. I'm not a member of a multinational bleach consortium trying to trick you into using bleach against your better interests. If you don't want to use it then go ahead and stop. The article talks about problems with bleach if you're a "professional cleaner". Ok, fine. Maybe pro-cleaners should have better ventillation sometimes, or respirators, or something else. Maybe they are using a very strong bleach and that's the problem. Maybe it depends on what they are cleaning and there is some reaction that causes problems. All are worth taking precautions against. But a regular person who occasionally uses bleach to sanitize dishes or clean a bathroom or whiten laundry? I just don't believe there is any hazard worth worrying about.
- exabrial 4y agoLow quality, low science article.
- ericbarrett 4y agoWhat the New York Times thinks will happen: Enhanced labeling and regulation of dangerous chemicals in household cleaners leads to a safer world for all. What will actually happen: Common chemicals like bleach, borax, vinegar, and ammonia will be banned from direct sale to consumers; you'll be forced to buy whatever brand name from one of two major manufacturers, with as little insight into its composition and dangers as you have today. A decade from now they'll run an exposé about the multi-generational environmental impact of some exotic chemical these products used. Lawyers get paid $millions in a class action. You get lung cancer and a coupon for $5.95. Cleaning products still cost $10 per quart.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> What the New York Times thinks will happen: Enhanced labeling and regulation of dangerous chemicals in household cleaners leads to a safer world for all. > What will actually happen: Common chemicals like bleach, borax, vinegar, and ammonia will be banned from direct sale to consumers; This is a lifestyle piece providing basic safety information for common household goods. It's quite a stretch to imply any intention of a regulatory outcome for that, let alone one that somehow bans common cooking ingredients. Not to mention that the only mention of vinegar is as an aside, a (correct) warning that two common cleaning materials should not be used simultaneously.
- Eumenes 4y agoGlad I'm not the only one who deciphers similar takes from these latent articles
- 57FkMytWjyFu 4y ago"10 a quart? Those are rookie numbers! " - Ecolab
- grammers 4y agoI don't use disinfectants - not because I fear the chemicals - but because I believe that your immune system needs to be exposed to germs. It's necessary to keep it fit IMO.
- Fomite 4y agoIn such a vague sense, "exposed to germs", it doesn't matter if you use disinfectants or not - you'll encounter plenty in your daily life. The purpose of disinfectants is to target surfaces that harbor massive populations of them.
- crazygringo 4y agoEveryday respiratory and doorknob germs? Sure, maybe. But salmonella from raw chicken? Or diseases spread via feces? I don't think so. That's not keeping you fit, it's just a risk of making you seriously sick for no good reason. People don't generally wipe down their whole house. But disinfecting kitchen prep surfaces and your toilet bowl, is basic hygiene/safety. Don't worry, you'll still be getting more than enough germs from the rest of the world.
- syntaxing 4y agoSerious question, what do people clean their bathroom with then…I used to never use bleach but it’s the most effective thing to clean bath and toilets.
- pazimzadeh 4y agoI like this article because it seems to be like a lot of people in the US equate the smell of bleach or lysol with cleanliness, which is far from the case and we now know, could be harmful. You should not let the floor dry with cleaning product, you should first rinse it with water. Plus, there is increasing recognition that our mucosal surfaces are covered by 'helpful bacteria' and when you get rid of them the pathogenic bacteria are in more direct contact with your epithelium. I don't see why a similar mechanism would not exist for inanimate surfaces - maybe having a thin coating of 'good dust' is better than letting a pathogen stick directly to the tiles? In a few years maybe cleaning products will come with a post-cleaning/pre-biotic solution which includes 'good bacteria' or 'good fungi' to form a new barrier on your clean home surfaces.
- Animats 4y agoAfter all the clickbait, here's the EPA's Safer Ingredients List for antibacterials.[1] * Chitosan * Citric acid, anhydrous * Ethanol * Hydrogen peroxide * Isopropanol * L-Lactic acid * Peracetic acid * Sodium bisulfate Citric acid cleaners are widely available and cheap. They work as as degreasers, and they are not flammable. [1] https://www.epa.gov/saferchoice/safer-ingredients#searchList https://www.epa.gov/saferchoice/safer-ingredients#searchList
- LinuxBender 4y agoHydrogen peroxide has another bacterial related use. If one is unsure of the existence of pathogens they can spray peroxide on all the surfaces and just listen. The bacteria will bubble up making almost a hissing sound. Bacteria free surfaces will make no sound. I also found that peroxide will change the color of some bacteria making it easier to see with the bare human eye.
- assimpleaspossi 4y agoI see this time and again and people need to know that bleach is not a cleaner. It is a disinfectant at most and an oxidizer that can turn some things white but, no, it does no cleaning of its own.
- StrangeATractor 4y agoAny reason to not just give things a quick wipe down with isopropyl alcohol, besides flammability?
- Forestessential 4y agoauthor gives worse-than-real arguments for bleach causing COPD while grouping it with actual disinfectants that leave nasty residue which grows resistant bacteria.