4 ms·
Sigh. This is the fate of ALL systems. Once something gets complicated, it gets progressively more complicated to change anything. NYC is an example of a runaw
by cyberax 4y ago
Sigh. This is the fate of ALL systems. Once something gets complicated, it gets progressively more complicated to change anything.
NYC is an example of a runaway complexity. So now 1 mile of Manhattan subway costs about the same as 1000 miles of 6-lane freeway.
The correct way to fix it is: don't. Stop encouraging density, instead make sure that other cities can thrive by providing incentives for companies to build in sparse areas.
- dnissley 4y agoAre you advocating for sprawl?
- cyberax 4y agoAbsolutely. Sprawl (with some small adjustments) is the best way to structure cities. It's also the only workable way to provide affordable housing.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoSprawl leads to cheaper housing at the cost of more expensive infrastructure costs (mainly roads, but water, sewer, schools becomes more difficult to support without density). It also leads to places that are not very nice to live at.
- cyberax 4y ago> Sprawl leads to cheaper housing at the cost of more expensive infrastructure costs Nope. Sprawl's infrastructure cost is about the same as urban cost over time. This is because maintenance of city infrastructure is way more expensive. "Expensive roads" are also a myth. As I said, one mile of NYC subway can cost as much as 1000 miles of 6-lane freeway. Or another point, Seattle is building subway expansion at the cost of $60B. It's projected to increase rideship by about ~100k daily passengers. For that $60B we could have instead built a city, gave 100k people houses for free, and still have enough money left to allow them to live on investment income from that. Sure, we'll need to do some small adjustments: switch from giant SUVs to medium-sized and small-sized EVs. Improve pedestrian and bicycle accessibility within suburban villages, etc. But these are all relatively minor changes that can be done gradually. > It also leads to places that are not very nice to live at. Most people surveyed (80+%) would prefer to live in suburbs if they could. Yep, very unpleasant places.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe cities that allow for lots of sprawl (eg Houston) are not very nice places to live in many people’s viewpoints. They definitely never make the list of nicest cities. People aren’t clamoring to live in Houston, they are trying to live in Seattle. Turning Seattle in Houston would probably just make less people want to live there (well, that’s one way to solve Seattle’s housing crisis). Roads are a bad value for what you get. Not only is the throughput not great, they are expensive to maintain. Switching to EVs only really solves pollution and energy usage problems, it doesn’t make traffic somehow more streamlined.
- cyberax 4y ago> The cities that allow for lots of sprawl (eg Houston) are not very nice places to live in many people’s viewpoints. "Many peoples' viewpoints" is a cop-out. You can apply it to ANY phrase: "In many people's viewpoints we should drop a nuke on Manhattan and rebuild it from scratch". If you look at objective data, Houston beats NYC handily in pretty much any important metric. Houston commute is 26 minutes vs 33 minutes for NYC. Per-capita income after taxes is similar, and housing costs in Houston are not even in the same league ($3000 average rent vs $1300). Houston also has less income inequality (Gini coefficient of 0.51 vs 0.55 for NYC). > People aren’t clamoring to live in Houston This is rich, because Houston is one of the fastest-growing cities in the US: https://www.click2houston.com/news/2016/03/24/census-data-shows-houston-leads-in-population-growth-across-us/ https://www.click2houston.com/news/2016/03/24/census-data-sh... - it's THE fastest growing city in some measures. Apparently, nobody goes there - it's too crowded. > Roads are a bad value for what you get. Not only is the throughput not great, they are expensive to maintain. You're making factually false statement after factually false statement. I really find it curious how people swallow the urbanist propaganda without ever bothering to check if it makes sense.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoYou accuse others of 'swallowing urbanist propaganda' but that's both highly uncharitable and also grossly ignorant given the extremely high demand for pre-war and denser areas.
- quickthrower2 4y agoSprawl with competing “centres” I think is fine. Sprawl where everyone is trying to get to the centre for work and play not so much. London has good sprawl IMO. I doubt it affects affordable housing. Although it may make houses more affordable vs. appartments.
- shadowofneptune 4y ago...except the article found that Chicago did not have nearly as much of a problem.
- cyberax 4y agoChicago is about 2 times less dense than NYC: 12000 vs 26000 people per square mile. If we look at Manhattan, it's a complete runaway disaster: 73000 people per square mile.