16 ms·
When did New York start building slowly?
- bobrown010 4y agoI wonder how much of this is regulations and process related? It would be curious to see lines overlayed when new regulation was passed that might affect things. Not sure anyone would ever be able to prove causation, but it would definitely be interesting to look at. For all I know maybe it’s not a factor at all?
- adam_arthur 4y agoIt’s pretty obvious from first principles that added cost to the builder necessitates higher housing costs to justify building something. Alternative is lower margins, but they aren’t that big in typical development projects anyway (in normal times)
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoI encourage everyone to go attempt to build a house for themselves. It takes away the armchair quarterbacking once you add up the Home Depot receipts.
- gedy 4y agoI did this actually, and the pluses were: - Dollar cost was 1/4 to 1/3 what a builder estimated. (Labor savings) - I saw continuous progress with no surprise delays. - It was easier and cheaper to do custom solutions or adjustments as unforseen issues came up. - Was fun and I learned a lot. Minuses: - Material costs were higher than if contractors bought due to retail purchasing. - It took over a year, versus 5-6 month estimate from builders. - Was a lot of personal time and learning.
- MiddleEndian 4y ago>It took over a year, versus 5-6 month estimate from builders. Depending on how they actually worked in practice, it may have taken them a year too.
- iamthepieman 4y agoI have the trade skills to do this. Worked as a cabinet builder in my early career and started a short lived construction business with my brother in my 20s. But if I take my total compensation for the year it would take me to build, the cost of the subcontracting I wouldn't do myself (plumbing and electrical) and the materials cost it would probably be about the same as getting it built by someone else. There's also the very subjective tradeoff between opportunity cost of taking time off from my career vs the benefits of doing more manual labor and learning a lot building a house.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThe Stud Pack channel on YT is now essentially a father-son general contracting duo who recently relocated to Houston from somewhere in Louisiana, and are building a new house (and demolishing an old one). They have excellent general contractor skills, but no experience in whole house construction. It has already been an interesting ride (as of now, they have dealt with soil conditions and dug grade beam trenches for the garage foundation), and there's still 98% of it left to play out over time.
- ibn_khaldun 4y agoThere’s no Power Broker in the city to keep the irons hot.
- Animats 4y agoShort version: "New York skyscrapers are built at around 50-70% the speed of Chicago skyscrapers. This seems partially due to New York constructing many more skinny skyscrapers with very small floor plates than Chicago does, which take proportionately longer to build." Ones like this:[1] [1] https://www.cnn.com/style/article/steinway-tower-intl-scli/index.html https://www.cnn.com/style/article/steinway-tower-intl-scli/i...
- chrisco255 4y agoWhy is NYC building skinnier skyscrapers? Is it air rights? Or is it easier to get approval to build such things on the few remaining smaller parcels and shorter buildings (which have to be knocked down first).
- twelvechairs 4y agoIts also, as briefly mentioned in the article, residential use over office use. IMO the two shouldn't be compared theres a big difference in complexity. Residential is much more complicated.
- mgbmtl 4y agoBoth. In order to encourage existing building owners to keep their existing height, they were able to sell their air rights, which then made it possible to build tall skinny buildings. https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/feb/05/super-tall-super-skinny-super-expensive-the-pencil-towers-of-new-yorks-super-rich https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/feb/05/super-tall-su...
- tehwebguy 4y agoI thought this meant they were building weird tetris shapes but I guess building height is like carbon credits?
- the_mar 4y agoNo the land is expensive
- 4y ago
- Arainach 4y agoSpeed is affected by process, and process evolves in reaction to abuse. In the beginning, it's quick to do everything, but as people take advantage - routing contracts to friends, taking safety shortcuts - rules get put into place and those rules affect the time to complete. For New York specifically there's another factor that it's strange the article omitted: Robert Moses. Prior to the mid-1960s, it was fairly simple: if Robert Moses wanted something built, it was built. If he wanted it blocked, it was blocked. This made the process of getting approvals a known factor. Moses chaired a wide variety of authorities including NYC Planning Commission, the Parks Department, and more. He was the sole authority to negotiate with the Federal government for NYC projects. This kind of central oversight allows certain projects to be completed much faster than it would be in other setups, but it also allows for a number of bad outcomes - corruption, ignoring the public good, environmental destruction, and more. As such, over time more process gets added. It's easy to criticize process, but many of the rules were written in blood with the best of intentions.
- chitowneats 4y agoThis is a simplistic take. European and East Asian democracies build infrastructure far faster and cheaper than the U.S. Often with even more stringent safety regulations and higher standards of quality. The question we are tasked with answering is: why?
- soperj 4y agocorruption.
- rootusrootus 4y agoOn which side? The faster side, I'm guessing?
- sixo 4y agoboth. corruption favors the powerful. in established cities the powerful own land and don't want it changed, in new ones it's the developers and govt.
- rr808 4y agoI was surprised to see most construction sites only have one shift working. Sites work around 8->4, 5 days a week. Not sure if that is city regulation or union workforce.
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoNoise ordinances. Waiting on city inspectors. Working capital. Labor doesn’t care to work overnight and those that do get paid a lot more. With interest rates low, easier to just hold construction note for another year.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThat’s when most people want to work. Do you want to work 4-midnight or midnight-8? Even if you do, many other people don’t want the noise of a working construction site at those hours.
- rr808 4y agoI regularly work until midnight. I'd think lots of construction people are young and/or immigrants without families here. If you offered them a night shift with overtime pay is a good choice.
- m0llusk 4y agoEveryone who wants to find fault with modern constructions trots out the Second Avenue Subway as an example. This subway is an obvious route for convenience and as such was first proposed more than a hundred years ago. At that time analysis of the geology and hydrology along the route as well as the very large amount of infrastructure including other subways already in place resulted in the conclusion that a subway along Second Avenue would be unreasonably expensive to construct. The idea kept being proposed every couple of decades or so and the conclusion was always the same: Far too much complication and expense to reasonably construct. Then in the 90s politicians decided that miraculous new tunnel boring technology would solve all problems and make a subway along Second Avenue easy and cheap to construct. This new technology turned out to have some complications and as a result all the nearly hundred years of cost estimates stating that a subway along Second Avenue would be unreasonably complicated and expensive to construct turned out to be true. It is to the credit of our modernity that the project was completed at all. The real lesson here is not one of generalized slowing, but of a lack of rational analysis, particularly when a wealth of information is available.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt is worth noting that the second phase costs even more per mile to build, despite the fact that pretty much all the tunnels already exist from an earlier attempt, are structurally intact, and will be reused.
- steveBK123 4y agoYup. $8B for .. 2-3 stations, 1.5 miles of track and 0.75 mile of new tunnel. Incredible.
- darkerside 4y agoThis reminds me of political discourse. We solve all the easy problems (murder is wrong, we all agree), and then we're left with the tough questions like abortion and civil rights. It's not that we can't agree, it's that we solved everything that is solvable (without great difficulty). Maybe we've now built everything that's easy to build, and all that's left is the hard stuff.
- baseline-shift 4y agoPermitting time is far longer. Not addressed in this story.
- Daz1 4y agoWhy? Unions. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-...
- bumby 4y agoIt's interesting that the Times identified three culprits (unions, construction companies, and consulting firms) but you only focused on one.
- ryan93 4y agoIf you read the article you would see that the unions are the ones demanding a much larger than necessary number of employees. The unions are the political road block to change.
- bumby 4y agoYou mean the same article that said this: >Construction companies, which have given millions of dollars in campaign donations in recent years, have increased their projected costs by up to 50 percent when bidding for work from the M.T.A., contractors say. ... Consulting firms, which have hired away scores of M.T.A. employees, have persuaded the authority to spend an unusual amount on design and management, statistics indicate. or this: >"Worker wages and labor conditions are determined through negotiations between the unions and the companies, none of whom have any incentive to control costs." All they say is that the reason starts with the number of people employed. If you continued reading past that point, they talk about other non-union incentives that drive up costs, like: >Critics pointed out that construction companies actually have an incentive to maximize costs — they earn a percentage of the project’s costs as profit, so the higher the cost, the bigger their profit. They also talk about the "soft costs" of NYC construction, like: >The project plan called for the hiring of 500 consultants from a dozen different companies And of course bureaucracy: >Officials have added to the soft costs by struggling to coordinate between vendors, taking a long time to approve plans, insisting on extravagant station designs and changing their minds midway through projects. So while we can probably agree that unions are part of the problem, it's disingenuous to act like they are the whole problem.
- Awelton 4y agoI work for a place that designs and manufactures parts for a lot of these NYC projects. There are several factors that slow them down, and every step of the process is horribly inefficient. We start the bid and design process years before groundbreaking because it takes so long to get reviews and approvals. Permitting, planning, and impact studies that should take a few months drag on for years. The land prices are so high and putting lots together so difficult that they build tall skinny buildings. Tall skinny buildings take longer to build than shorter, wider buildings. Everything is so hush hush in the preconstruction phase that we don't even know who exactly is building it or where it's at until a few months before they start demo on the existing structure. Shipping and delivery is a logistics nightmare downtown and crane time is always at a premium. Imagine how hard it is to get around NYC anyway, and then imagine how many hundreds of tons of material have to be delivered 24 hours a day by big trucks that aren't as quick and maneuverable as a car. The whole process is just years of waiting followed by half a decade of absolute madness trying to get it all crammed into a city block.
- tuatoru 4y agoThis is interesting stuff, but the article was focused on the actual construction phase, not the pre-construction planning and approvals. The duration of those is a related problem but not the one Brian was looking at.
- Awelton 4y agoThat's the delivery part. There is no room to stage anything on the site, so the mad 24/7 logistics nightmare has to happen during the entire construction process. There are 2 million more people in NYC now than there was in the old highrise heyday and that doesn't count commuters. That's a lot more traffic to have to negotiate. Not being able to physically deliver enough materials during the construction phase is an enormous slowdown. Coupled with the new smaller footprint/higher elevation slowdown it winds up being a slog. You can only fit so many workers in a given area. There are other differences that add time and complexity that the old buildings didn't have to deal with as much as well, like the thousands of miles of additional cabling that goes in now for higher electric loads and data. I would also imagine that inspections weren't near as thorough and time consuming in the past. It's death by a thousand cuts. Hundreds of little things add a little time and complexity and it all adds up.
- cyberax 4y agoSigh. This is the fate of ALL systems. Once something gets complicated, it gets progressively more complicated to change anything. NYC is an example of a runaway complexity. So now 1 mile of Manhattan subway costs about the same as 1000 miles of 6-lane freeway. The correct way to fix it is: don't. Stop encouraging density, instead make sure that other cities can thrive by providing incentives for companies to build in sparse areas.
- dnissley 4y agoAre you advocating for sprawl?
- cyberax 4y agoAbsolutely. Sprawl (with some small adjustments) is the best way to structure cities. It's also the only workable way to provide affordable housing.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoSprawl leads to cheaper housing at the cost of more expensive infrastructure costs (mainly roads, but water, sewer, schools becomes more difficult to support without density). It also leads to places that are not very nice to live at.
- cyberax 4y ago> Sprawl leads to cheaper housing at the cost of more expensive infrastructure costs Nope. Sprawl's infrastructure cost is about the same as urban cost over time. This is because maintenance of city infrastructure is way more expensive. "Expensive roads" are also a myth. As I said, one mile of NYC subway can cost as much as 1000 miles of 6-lane freeway. Or another point, Seattle is building subway expansion at the cost of $60B. It's projected to increase rideship by about ~100k daily passengers. For that $60B we could have instead built a city, gave 100k people houses for free, and still have enough money left to allow them to live on investment income from that. Sure, we'll need to do some small adjustments: switch from giant SUVs to medium-sized and small-sized EVs. Improve pedestrian and bicycle accessibility within suburban villages, etc. But these are all relatively minor changes that can be done gradually. > It also leads to places that are not very nice to live at. Most people surveyed (80+%) would prefer to live in suburbs if they could. Yep, very unpleasant places.
- Scubabear68 4y agoI agree with the premise, but keep in mind we weren’t always so concerned about injuries and deaths on the job. Many of our greatest works were built on pools of blood that would not be tolerated today.
- bluGill 4y agoToday we have a lot of tools and automation that we didn't in the past. Those tools should speed things up by far more than tighter safety standards slow things down.
- pzone 4y agoFrom the same Substack: "Homebuilders don’t seem to think the burdens of OSHA and other safety regulations are all that high. Complying with OSHA is the second lowest category of perceived jobsite regulatory costs." https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/how-much-safer-has-construction-gotten https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/how-much-safer-ha...
- robertwt7 4y agoThis goes the same with tech company right? When you're a startup, you build features fast, you're not afraid of breaking things. Big features are scoped out within days, development starts, and everything is done within a couple of weeks or months. It is so different when you start working for big tech companies, in FAANG for instance some of the small features will take developers months to build given all of the process required to do (RFCs, collaborations with other teams for different services etc)
- 29athrowaway 4y agoI don't understand why someone would like to live in New York.
- pzone 4y agoBecause it’s the best city in the United States
- 29athrowaway 4y agoIn terms of what? traffic? air quality? schools? crime rates? housing? Exactly how is it a good place to live? Probably when Frank Sinatra was alive but certainly not now. What can you get in New York that you cannot get somewhere else?
- drchickensalad 4y agoThere is the widest variety of deep cultural experiences, events, and food next door to you than anywhere else in the world. You never have a reason to drive, but are still in the US; no traffic jam, instead reading hacker news on a relaxing subway ride or walk into work. Retail businesses are no bullshit fast and efficient. Every type of job opportunity surrounds you. It's the safest comparable city in the US.
- pzone 4y agoIt’s one of the safest places to live in the US, period. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new-york-city-more-dangerous-than-rural-america https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new...
- HNDen21 4y agoI used to live in NYC, here are a few that come to mind... Art/museums... top notch collections Restaurants... you can find any type of food here Sports.. I used to go to the US Open tennis every year... then there is football, baseball, MLS soccer.. all of these are within 1 hour Sit down at a restaurant table on a sidewalk and just people watch Broadway shows Concerts Beaches are close by Hunter mountain for skiing is not too far 3 airports that have flight going everywhere Those are just a few........
- Spooky23 4y agoIt all depends on the goalposts. Seems like a weird set of metrics whose relevance isn’t clear. Of course approved construction projects are going to take longer - demolishing a 19th century 6 story building is trivial compared to a mid century high rise. Construction is a cutthroat business, so I’m sure that if velocity was the gating factor, the companies would find a way. I’ve been involved in construction projects as a stakeholder, and NYC isn’t slower to navigate if you have a team that knows how to navigate NYC. I can think of a couple of projects in random suburbia, CA that took longer to permit than the total duration of a NYC project. Government contracting is totally different, as New York law is knowingly designed to maximize employment. Most government projects do not allow a single general contractor and require separate bids for different components of the building, for example. You also cannot design and build a project in most cases.
- ar9av 4y agothere is less space now. if you walked around NYC in the 1980's there were still a bunch of empty lots. these have been built over and so each new project is more expensive as the current building must be purchased, demolished and then rebuilt
- coding123 4y agoFor small things, like 10-unit apartment complexes, the number of people available to run such projects in the 70s was probably pretty massive. Since then many people left the trades (presumably to mash their fat fingers at keyboards instead). Now projects like that are likely harder as the companies that can do it are 1) busy, 2) expensive, 3) not in your area.
- dclowd9901 4y agoIsn’t this always just a result of existing architecture and kludge? Doesn’t this same thing afflict us here in software engineering? You can’t build fast on a city that’s been around for a while. There’s too much shit already there. And not just infra, but also simply people, and culture and everything else that comes with human beings occupying a space. You could probably build the entirety of Manhattan out in the middle of Wyoming somewhere in 10 or 20 years from scratch with a reasonably sized set of resources because there’s nothing around and so little to deal with. It’s just the nature of a place with a lot of people.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoMission vs resignation If there is a mission, a shared common goal and a belief that the benefits of the mission will be as fairly shared as the effort then you get the "magic". Corruption is looked down upon, stupidities are challenged. But if there is no mission, no expectation that the benefits will accrue to "society", then "getting paid" is the most obvious and sensible response - one is resigned to the stupidities of the project and just accepts them. Basically, a society with a safety net people trust will find it easier to have a mission that everyone believes.
- NickM 4y agoReminds me of the situation with intercity rail in New York state. It was faster to take a train between Buffalo and NYC in 1890 than it is today. In 2009, NY started working on a high-speed rail study, which finally completed last month after 14 years. Now, the completed version of the study recommends a 25-year project that will increase train speed from 80MPH to...wait for it...90MPH. Insanity.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoIt seems like so much of society is affected by mutual trust. Without mutual trust, inevitably that gap is made up with contracts, and processes, and laws, and rules, because that's the only way people can coordinate on the same page. As the US becomes more and more divided on every level: ideologically, religiously, ethnically, culturally, etc this is only going to continue.