4 ms·
>“Since the Hayabusa2 spacecraft collected two samples directly from asteroid Ryugu and delivered them to Earth in sealed capsules, contamination can be ruled o
by coldtea 4y ago
>“Since the Hayabusa2 spacecraft collected two samples directly from asteroid Ryugu and delivered them to Earth in sealed capsules, contamination can be ruled out.”
I seriously doubt that it could be "ruled out" just like that.
For one, the spacecraft (or the empty capsules) could have been pre-contaminated before their launch.
Second, the capsules could have been contaminated after arrival even if they were "sealed" (perhaps the seal had issues, or maybe it happened when they opened them, since one assumes they couldn't test still sealed capsules, they'd have to open them).
- Aachen 4y agoI wonder if there's a "control group": a tiny but identical container that goes through all the same steps. Nothing can ever be proof that it wasn't contaminated or a seal was broken on the real but not the control container, like, nothing will convince an Internet conspiracy theorist, but a control vessel and a handful such missions ought to prove beyond reasonable doubt that it wasn't contaminated from earth. I'm personally already willing to trust that they thought of (and controlled for) these things and more, since it's their job and we're just thinking out loud here.
- gehwartzen 4y agoI don't know how they do it but I always thought the best way would be to have the probe place them in glass ampules and seal them while still in space.
- aa-jv 4y ago[flagged]
- coldtea 4y ago>You better alert the scientists that they missed something, then! That's some serious business, they must be alerted to their failings immediately! Yes, unimaginable that scientists could have made a mistake that a layman could spot, or just said something to create good PR to their mission, even when it's inaccurate. They also never unwittingly or intentionally BS in their research papers, right? And only a colleague (or a higher level intellect than theirs) could spot a mistake... /s >Seriously though, do you really think these scientists are making claims, being widely reported, without having made the same conclusions and analysed the situation with all the data, not just that reported through a story on the Internet .. ? Seriously, similar blunders have happened time and again. In 1996, scientists at NASA declared that a 6.3-ounce rock, broken off from a Mars meteorite discovered in Antarctica in 1984, contained flecks of chemical compounds — polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, magnetite, and iron sulfide — that suggested the existence of bacteria on the Red Planet 3.6 billion years ago. "August 7, 1996, could go down as one of the most important dates in human history," intoned one newspaper report. But within two years the theory began to crack. Traces of amino acids found in the rock, crucial to life, were also found in the surrounding Antarctic ice. More damning, other non-Martian rocks — rocks from the moon, where it is clear life does not exist — showed the same "evidence" of life. By November 1998 an article in Science declared "most researchers agree that the case for life on Mars is shakier than ever." >Because it seems you're smarter than rocket scientists. Are you a brain surgeon, then? This particular case aside, you appear to believe that you need to be smarter than X person to be able to spot an error they made. It doesn't take a very high IQ however to see the error in the above idea. In any case, based on the insults, did you just wanted to lash out on someone to feel better for yourself?
- aa-jv 4y ago[flagged]
- permo-w 4y agoif you want people to engage with you seriously, perhaps avoid such a condescending tone. ditching the sarcastic italics could be a good place to start the way it currently reads is less like curiosity and more like “how dare you question the judgment of scientists”, as if questioning results isn’t the absolute bedrock of science in the first place
- lumb63 4y agoNowadays, to a lot of folks, questioning isn’t the bedrock of science. “Trusting the experts/science” is. That’s the root behind a lot of issues we’ve seen socially, especially over the last few years.
- craftsman 4y agoDisagree. It's trivial to question. It's non-trivial to do the work required to show evidence for or against some proposition. What is at "the root behind a lot of issues we've seen socially" is the easy path of questioning something without actually being able to do the work required to back up one's claims or counterclaims. So I believe the reaction which you think of as "trust the experts / science" is actually "do the work and show the evidence". If a paper is published which claims that such-and-such drug shows effectiveness against shingles, it's easy and trivial to say, "Not so fast my friend" followed by any number of statements about Big Pharma, citing previous situations in which a claim was later shown to be false, etc. But while all of those things may, in fact, be true, they don't bring to bear any actual evidence that this particular drug study is flawed and exactly how.
- coldtea 4y ago>It's trivial to question. It's also trivial to accept though. And in a world where you can't (for time and effort constrains) check every announcement personally, and where expert proclamations aren't always correct so thay you can just take them as granted, there are still reasons to have an estimation (as a layman but even as a scientist) of something being true or not summarily.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoReading this comment I couldn't help but remember the research showing extremophiles replacing phosphorous with arsenic in their DNA backbone. NASA held a big press conference and made a huge deal out of its potential implications for extraterrestrial life. It was later found that the data was inherently flawed(possibly even doctored? My memory fails me) due to arsenic contamination of samples. Retracted. Things like this do happen, and more frequently than one might expect.
- ianai 4y agoNonetheless, the goal post to pass is the scientific process and journal article review. It’s not “someone made a mistake in a study once before so all science is ruled out” as this would tend toward. We’re not doing ourselves any good carrying around old bad behavior.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoIf you read my comment as implying all science is ruled out due to one example, that's very much a you problem. I said or implied no such thing. I also didn't take a stance on this research. I've yet to read the paper, and I don't read "science journalism" like TFA. But it's not like the findings are earth shattering given previous research. Therefore I lean towards optimism. I am simply saying that scepticism is warranted even if a paper is peer-reviewed and published in Nature. The "scientific process" doesn't magically end at peer review. The process goes on, and it pretty much never ends.
- craftsman 4y agoIf your post was simply to say, "This paper could have flaws and its conclusions could be incorrect," then yes, almost all of us will agree with you. I'm not sure it's big news, however. I would guess most of us understand that scientific findings are contingent on future experiments and results. If your post was to point out a specific flaw, e.g., that the sample could have been pre- or post-contaminated, then it falls short of anything substantive and actionable. Nobody can do anything with it. Yes, you are correct. But no, there is not anything anyone can do with the critique. If you're going to point out a flaw, it needs to be something that you, the authors, or other PIs can check, perform, etc.
- chatmasta 4y agoIt's worth noting that there are plenty of rocket scientists and brain surgeons on HN, although I don't know the professional background of the commenter to whom you're replying.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoWhile we are probably really good programmers, surprisingly enough these “scientists” seem to know how to do their job without our guidance: https://earth-planets-space.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40623-022-01628-z https://earth-planets-space.springeropen.com/articles/10.118...
- eggy 4y agoWell played. I do find HN to be full of "expert" commentators on any subject matter even if they aren't ;) Remember David Levinson (Jeff Goldblum in Independence Day) figured out how to defeat the alien invaders by uploading a virus to the alien ship. He used MacOS 8! Wasn't it a modem parity issue (8N1) or some other such nonsense for a space-traveling, gravity-defying spaceship?
- coldtea 4y agoThey can also always be too confident in having done their job perfectly - and they can be that with or without our guidance.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoIt’s pretty clear if you read the paper they are not confident they did their job perfectly, and have erected guard rails around everything to cap the maximal contamination and established tests for assessing the extent of contamination exploiting assuming there is going to be contamination.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI'd ask why techbro culture makes people like you so confident in areas outside your expertise, but I just answered my own question.
- roywiggins 4y agoIt would be a little weird for it to be contaminated with only uracil. Sure, if they found full RNA strands you'd start to think contamination was more likely, but what are the odds it was contaminated but with only uracil, especially considering how far they've gone to prevent contamination?
- Cardinal7167 4y ago> For one, the spacecraft (or the empty capsules) could have been pre-contaminated before their launch. I had a really interesting discussion with someone who oversaw decontamination protocols and preparations for various satellites, including the JWST. The protocols they use to prep satellites for these types of missions are beyond stringent, and the chemicals they use are exotic as all hell. All this to say, contamination is absolutely possible, but there is so much insane behind the scenes work to control for it that it shouldn’t be thought of as something they might “just forget” or casually missed.
- stonemetal12 4y agoRemember the faster than light neutrinos that turned out to be a loose cable? I doubt they "just forgot", but being perfect is more difficult than making a mistake somewhere in the process. Before they publish I would hope they Quadruple checked for every source of possible contamination. Instead of saying we did it right so obviously nothing went wrong.
- craftsman 4y agoI think you're reading too much into the phrase "can be ruled out." I suspect that the leader author was saying "Contamination is possible, but based on our procedures, test methods, etc, the overwhelmingly larger probability is that we did detect <...> in the samples, and that the detection was not from pre- or post-contamination." Could the paper's conclusions be incorrect? Yes, I think everyone--the authors included--will agree that "something could have gone wrong." But pointing out that "something could have gone wrong" is probably not a new idea to most readers.
- dekhn 4y agoI've talked to a few scientists in this area and I found out the Viking project life detection experiments generated a lot of controversey. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/04/science/space/gilbert-v-levin-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/04/science/space/gilbert-v-l...
- b1c1jones 4y agoGoogle [or search engine of your choice] is your friend. https://earth-planets-space.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40623-022-01628-z https://earth-planets-space.springeropen.com/articles/10.118...