4 ms·
The Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest Mistakes Biggest ever? more than nuclear weapons? A bit of a stretch to say ever. I think this is disp
by paulpauper 4y ago
The Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest Mistakes
Biggest ever? more than nuclear weapons? A bit of a stretch to say ever. I think this is disputable.
- nradov 4y agoNuclear weapons were not a mistake.
- renewiltord 4y agoNeither is leaded gasoline. As the FAA is eager to point out, it's not safe to do anything else. Can you imagine? Most aviation would never have happened if this guy hadn't invented leaded gasoline.
- jabl 4y ago> Most aviation would never have happened if this guy hadn't invented leaded gasoline. Duh, of course it would. Aviation gasoline would have used other methods of increasing octane, and/or then we'd have made do with slightly lower octane avgas. And engines would have been designed accordingly. The only reason why getting rid of leaded avgas has been a 40 year saga is that they have been chasing the dream of a 1:1 replacement that would require no changes to 100% of existing aircraft. Now it seems they finally have such a fuel in G100UL, we'll see if and how quickly usage of it expands to replace leaded avgas.
- Zak 4y agoThere are a substantial number of existing aircraft that are safe to operate on a subset of automotive gasoline (93 octane, ethanol-free). The FAA says to do so legally requires the purchase of a supplemental type certificate for thousands of dollars. There's no inspection or modification of the aircraft. It's just a piece of paper. The FAA could fix the problem for those aircraft with the stroke of a pen.
- Ekaros 4y agoMistake was anti-proliferation. If every country had nukes wold would be much more peaceful place. Would Iraq or Afganistan got involved if they had capability to deliver nuke to fight enemy combatants in NYC or DC?
- sofixa 4y agoWhat would the Iran - Iraq war look like with nukes? What would a falling dictator à la last days Saddam or Ghadaffi or the Shah do with nukes? That's a very stupid idea if you think about it for more than 5 seconds.
- ElfinTrousers 4y ago> That's a very stupid idea if you think about it for more than 5 seconds. Which you can use as a reply to like 90% of comments on this benighted site.
- kergonath 4y ago> If every country had nukes wold would be much more peaceful place. It does not work. Countries would still fight conventional wars, because not everything is worth escalating. Even in your example. They are being invaded and are at risk of losing their country (well, they were at some point anyway). Do you reckon they’d throw a nuke at the US and so be absolutely certain to lose everything they have rather than fight a conventional war and having a chance at taking their country back? On the other hand, proliferation has real risks in terms of radionuclides ending up in things like terrorist groups. Overall, it makes as much sense as the “if teachers had guns schools would be safer” talking points.
- Ekaros 4y agoQuestion is would USA risk direct conflict with a country if they could actually suffer some actual losses of combatants on their own soil? They might, but I think it would substantially lower the risk. Same applies to most current conflicts. And about non traditional fights, maybe there would be less of those as big countries would be more careful about their actions. Also I believe that if every school kid had a gun there would be lot less bullying. As they would be able to instantly produce credible self-defence when the society entirely fails to protect them. And they would be fully in moral right to answer with reasonable force to such actions.
- kergonath 4y ago[flagged]
- gmac 4y ago> Nuclear weapons really have not killed that many people. ... so far. https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/public-awareness-of-nuclear-winter-too-low-given-current-risks-argues-expert https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/public-awareness-of-nucl...
- yesenadam 4y agoI'm not sure how to respond to that comment, which I find profoundly shocking and depressing. I've read some HN comments before which for some reason suggest a large-scale nuclear "war" wouldn't be so bad, but..this one seems even much worse, for some reason. I don't get it. I don't get how anyone could believe or write that. Anything I could write seems so obvious. I can't think. I think I need a break from HN for a while. You don't seem to have been downvoted in 5 hours.
- kergonath 4y ago> I find profoundly shocking and depressing Indeed, it is. There is nothing more depressing than what we are doing to ourselves and to our own world. > I've read some HN comments before which for some reason suggest a large-scale nuclear "war" wouldn't be so bad No mistake, it would be absolutely terrible, country- if not civilisation-ending. None of this is any good. It is just that nuclear weapons and our current way of life are on two opposite sides of a risk spectrum: nuclear apocalypse is a very improbable event with huge consequences; our industry is a fact of life that has been more or less silently killing indiscriminately, almost innocent because we don’t see its effects as huge, memorable events. A nuclear winter might kill hundreds of millions if it happens; we’ve already killed much more than that with non-nuclear means. So yeah, nuclear weapons are terrible, and I completely disagree with the other poster who said everyone should have them. I just wish we would see the harm we do every day as clearly as the harm we could do in exceptional circumstances. > You don't seem to have been downvoted in 5 hours. I think the post has been downvoted. I don’t have all the detail but I think the score has fluctuated a bit. If it can be of comfort to you.