3 ms·
> (3) Heading for a recession (equivalently, “in an economic expansion”, if you are more a “glass currently full” than a “glass will sometime in the future be e
by lmm 4y ago
> (3) Heading for a recession (equivalently, “in an economic expansion”, if you are more a “glass currently full” than a “glass will sometime in the future be empty” type).
> There are literally no other options.
When growth is increasing or steady you're heading away from a recession; it's only when growth is declining that you're heading for a recession.
- Rury 4y ago>steady you're heading away from a recession Not quite, but there is certainly only 3 scenarios, just as shown by a graph. It can go up (growth), it can go down (recession), or it can be flat (stagnation).
- dragonwriter 4y agoThere might be a sense where that would necessarily be true, if potentially only evident at finer resolution than economic statistics are normally gathered, if the “aggregate economy” curve whose peak marks the beginning of a recession (GDP to a first approximation, but recession is not assessed on a single indicator or simple function) were constrained to being a function that is differentiable (and whose derivative also is) everywhere, but…it’s not. There’s no reason it has to, from expansion, smoothly turn around through a level point to start going down, so that you could assess “heading toward a recession” as where the second derivative as where the second derivative is negative. (In fact, there isn’t even an actual function, just declared peaks and troughs; between peak and trough is “recession”, between trough and peak is “expansion”, and if you are in one – unless it goes on forever – you are heading for the other. The only nontrivial prediction regarding “heading for” is how soon, not are we.)
- Dylan16807 4y agoTake a running average and it will easily be differentiable. And you can set up a test for how aggressively and consistently it's turning toward the negative to say we're "heading for" a recession. But also I don't like your definition of "heading for" at all. When I leave my house to go to work, I am not "heading for" my house, despite the fact that I will inevitably return.