6 ms·
TikTok is a threat. So is the rest of Big Tech
- colechristensen 4y agoI’m very skeptical of any attempt to quash tiktok and ignores the mechanisms that allow them to collect and abuse data. Most of us have more more to worry about from FAANGlikes and who they enable than China.
- barrysteve 4y agoWhat is FAANG going to do that they haven't been doing already? American culture depends on the humble hiding away and the upper classes overseeing everything. That hasn't changed since the 1800s. The over-seers just have more data now. China is a foreign government that can cause negative consequences, it's apples to oranges to compare Chinese foreign data collection to American domestic data collection.
- genmud 4y agoSo you don’t believe a country, who in the year 2023, systematically suppresses free speech, reporters, it’s own citizens, disregards it’s neighbors borders in violation of international norms and continually sides with Russia in its war of aggression against Ukraine… who also has demonstrated the ability as well as the willingness in the last 2-3 years to exert both overt and covert controls over social media platforms within its sphere of influence… Is effectively the same or less of a threat than Facebook, Snapchat or Instagram? You really don’t see any strategic or geopolitical concerns and think that FAANGs are more dangerous? I’m genuinely curious.
- colechristensen 4y agoData is for sale for nearly every public interaction you have, every dollar you spend, every medical appointment, your location from your phone, really just everything, with at best laughable attempts to anonymize it. Everyone is collecting data about everything they can and figuring out how to monetize it. Facebook and google in particular are worst offenders here but there are plenty of others. I am much more concerned with the effects and consumers of this data which have much more to benefit from it and have. Unless you’re an individual of particular interest to China (people in politics and defense should avoid tiktok) there’s much less to fear than domestic sources and sinks of data.
- jmpman 4y agoI strongly disagree. The anti-Ukraine messaging recently adopted by the right didn’t come from the individuals thoughtful consideration of geopolitics, but a careful influence campaign by Russia. China will do the same in their attempt to retake Taiwan, and TikTok will be their mechanism. Anyone speaking up against Chinese aggression will be silenced and any pro-Chinese voices will be amplified. This isn’t about silencing Charli DAmelio’s first amendment rights to wiggle, but China’s attempt to sway foreign policy while they crush yet another democracy.
- colechristensen 4y ago>a careful influence campaign by Russia Which helped Trump get elected, which was enabled by a former-KGB-led Cambridge Analytica which was sold data en masse by Facebook who after the fact put on a show about how it was not used as intended. BS, they didn't care, they just wanted to make money. Everybody is doing it and you only know about the ones who got caught. Again, much more worried about FAANG+ than TikTok.
- jmpman 4y agoDo you think TikTok isn’t the next Cambridge Analytica? Are they benign? No, they are fully controlled by the CCP and will be used to crush Taiwan.
- genmud 4y agoTell me you don’t understand the issue, without telling me you don’t understand the issue. First off, raw data is not for sale from FAANGs, it is their most jealously guarded golden goose. Second, the entire point isn’t that you as an individual have something to fear from the CCP, the point is they have/can/will use their platform to push specific viewpoints, amplify messages with the goal of influencing public opinion. AKA propaganda. Say what you want about big tech, but continuing to allow the CCP a direct conduit into 140 million Americans is pants on head stupid. Bytedance have known about the issues and have yet to actually meaningfully address these concerns. In fact they have done thing which make things worse, they have actively obfuscated things and used their platform to go after reporters. Anyone who says this is protectionism is either naive or not making a genuine argument.
- dayjaby 4y agoAny source for China siding with Russia? The impression that I've got over the last 400 days is that China tries to take up the role as a mediator.
- chronophylos 4y agoChina is supporting Russia with drones and other equipment such as radios. https://www.bbc.com/news/60571253 https://www.bbc.com/news/60571253
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timeon 4y agoMediator should communicate with both sides. Xi already met with Putin more then once, while he was not in Kiev.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoIn the first sentence you're basically describing the united states can you see that? The iraq occupation is on everyone's minds recently and that was basically the ukraine invasion of the 2000s. We have protestors facing life in prison on terrorism charges for putting paint on a road, we have an inward focused civil surveillance program rivaled only by, yes, china. We're no better!
- genmud 4y agoBeing blunt, the mere fact that you can talk about that in public shows me you don’t truly understand the difference between US or European values and CCP values. You can and should have policy discussions about how the US isn’t perfect and can do better, since in many ways this isn’t possible in many parts of the world. If you live in the west and can’t see that CCP interests are not aligned with the wests interests, you are a fool.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoNo I clearly see that. I also see that the US's interests aren't aligned with the world's interests. They're only partially aligned with my own interests. A mismatch of interests doesn't make an entity evil. Their other actions may make them so and I think there's a compelling argument that they do. But so do our actions. And I'm not even arguing that we're "as bad" or anything like that. But we are certainly bad enough and if you can condemn a chinese tech product because of the actions of china you can certainly condemn an american tech product because of the actions of the US.
- genmud 4y agoI think something you should consider is the heirarchical nature and the tight integration of business, politics and social policy in the CCP vs the US. In the US, it’s more like a loose federation of aligned interests vs a top down, integrated system. If Facebook is doing bad things and being used to facilitate propaganda, it’s largely a failure of Facebook and the lack of appropriate legislation or oversight. Whereas TikTok has been accused of promoting pro-China viewpoints, and the reality is the way business is operated there, the lines are blurred between what TikTok the company does and what TikTok the CCP controlled entity does.
- genmud 4y agoIMHO if someone is a privacy advocate and they aren’t cheering this on and trying to push for more regulation or control of our data, I don’t know what to say. It probably has the most likelihood of making meaningful changes to the way we approach big tech.
- bakuninsbart 4y agoAs a non-American, I'd be cheering on legislation for stronger data protection, but this isn't really it. Banning TikTok is first and foremost a protectionist policy lobbied for by Facebook and the others. I think it is also short-sighted at that. If the national security concerns are valid, then they are also valid regarding Meta and Google in other countries. US legislation will serve as a shining beacon for privacy advocates in the EU to ban or heavily regulate these data kraken as well. Even China had better reasons to ban Facebook, and can rightfully claim hypocrisy on the USs part once again. Banning your competitors could also fracture the internet. For many young people, TikTok, Youtube and Instagram are the internet. It is an incredible means of soft power for the US currently, but they risk isolating themselves as TikTok might succeed without the American market as well. The big problem is the asymmetry though. If you only go after specific companies on dubious grounds instead of crafting clear legislation applying to all companies in the sector, that's not in the spirit of constitutional democracy. It allows government and media to decide the winners and losers of the economy, which gives them power far beyond what is chaste.
- lwansbrough 4y agoHere’s how you fix the web, protect the children and ruin the economy at the same time: make online advertising to children illegal, full stop. This does (at least) three things: 1.) Drives down the value of minors’ attention to zero, 2.) Forces all websites to do an age check if they want to advertise, 3.) Obliterates the influencer scheme because they can’t verify the age of their followers This would significantly diminish the value of operating platforms that derive value from the attention of minors. It also allows websites to continue to operate for adults, who we should all agree are obligated to make their own choices about what (legal) content they’re allowed to consume.
- DeathArrow 4y ago> Here’s how you fix the web, protect the children and ruin unhealthy parts of the economy at the same time: make online advertising to children illegal, full stop. Here, I fixed it for you.
- euroderf 4y agoFor privacy, you'll want to decouple the identity that is being age-checked from the destination address & content.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sph 4y agoWhy would it ruin the economy? It would in theory kill any company that makes money from advertising to and exploiting children attention, and that is a good thing. The rest of the world will be fine.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y agoParent poster and many in their peer group would lose their jobs. It would ruin their economy. The rest of the world will be better off.
- _heimdall 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoTech companys are paid to hack the customers brains in one way or another. The add buisness is nothing but a plausibel veneer for the "free services to exist" that allow to manipulate, observe and destroy. The reason for the whole thing to be is obvious. Governments and companys are scared shitless of the multi-crisis coming up and want levers to pull that dont break and contain dissent. And they want to come out of the crisis, sitting on top of the ash heap. This is the actual buisness model and purpose to exist, not the friendly colorful sweets shop upfront. Panopticon. Social egineering. Leviathancybernetics. Because solving problems for politicians is not a worthy endavour. They want to solve the "meta"-problem that is the enraged citizen, the protesting org, the social unravelling forces that could uproot them. Solution: Let them fight, blue vs greens, instead of discussing and forcing actual problem solutions. Big Tech is now a integral part of the big problem in democracy.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoWe need to update Marx. "Social media is opium for the masses". All hail the techno priests.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Governments and companys are scared shitless of the multi-crisis coming up and want levers to pull that dont break and contain dissent. That suggests foresight and planning on their part — something we've hitherto seen a scarcity of. I am not sure I buy that.
- prohobo 4y agoEvidence of "foresight and planning": - WEF's The Great Reset: https://www.amazon.com/COVID-19-Great-Reset-Klaus-Schwab/dp/2940631123/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=the+great+reset https://www.amazon.com/COVID-19-Great-Reset-Klaus-Schwab/dp/... - UN's 2030 Agenda: https://sdgs.un.org/2030agenda https://sdgs.un.org/2030agenda - WEF and UN create strategic partnership for 2030 Agenda: https://www.weforum.org/press/2019/06/world-economic-forum-and-un-sign-strategic-partnership-framework/ https://www.weforum.org/press/2019/06/world-economic-forum-a... - Central bank digital currencies: https://cbdctracker.org/ https://cbdctracker.org/ - The Russian invasion of Ukraine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine - The BRICS alliance: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-15/brics-debates-expansion-as-iran-saudi-arabia-seek-entry?leadSource=uverify%20wall https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-15/brics-deb... - Russia and China stop attending WEF conference in 2023: https://tass.com/economy/1562563 https://tass.com/economy/1562563
- hcks 4y agoI read ´great’ and though to myself: that might be an original piece for once
- DeathArrow 4y agoNot wasting my time reading/watching useless stuff on the Internet is great.
- endisneigh 4y agoIronic you say that here
- blackpill0w 4y agoHacker News is definitely better than scrolling in tiktok for countless hours, or watching the perfect life of an "influencer" on Instagram.
- endisneigh 4y agoit's really not. there are very smart people posting things on both tiktok and instagram - and there are plenty of dumb takes on here. go on "new", for instance. you can also scroll for hours on here.
- DeathArrow 4y agoTrue, but the percentages are different. Signal to noise ratio is way better here.
- blackpill0w 4y agoIt is. As far as I can tell, Hacker News is not designed to be addictive, the site doesn't push 10 seconds clips to keep you scrolling, if you find something interesting you stay otherwise you leave, there is no algorithm to recommend the best article for you. There are no groups/pages to subscribe to, the threads get pushed by the users. I believe this is infinitely better than the way Instagram or Tiktok work, sure you can find interesting people there too but you'd have to put up with an uncomfortable amount of nonsense and I don't know if you're really willing to make that sacrifice when better alternatives exist.
- wkat4242 4y ago
- Mizoguchi 4y agoThe recent debate about the threat of TikTok has nothing to do with harming children. We are taking about an app owned by a corporation controlled by the CCP which is running on half of the phones in the US. In that context, comparing Bytedance to Apple, Google, Amazon and Meta is beyond ridiculous.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd from outside USA it really makes one wonder. If they fear single app so much. Should we for example in Europe fear any app from outside, specially from USA?
- spookie 4y agoThe EU has tackled the big players in this question in order to come to agreements that respect Europeans rights. This has worked to some capacity because we're able to communicate issues with one another and trust eachother's judicial systems. I'm not sure if the same can be done with authoritative governments. I think that's where the problem lies.
- unclenoriega 4y agoIs data on European citizens held by US companies subject to national security letters?
- WeylandYutani 4y agoThe US actually has to lie about the real reason to ban TikTok because if they told the truth the WTO would be on their ass. It's naked unabashed protectionism.
- CogitoCogito 4y agoEven if it is protectionism, given that China engages in the same protectionism on their end, this seems like pretty reasonable policy. Edit: Changed "It definitely is protectionism, but" to "Even if it is protectionism," since I can't say I truly know the truth of that statement.
- afpx 4y agoI thought TikTok was a threat because it's used to broadcast pro-China and anti-American propaganda. As far as I know, none of the other US tech giants are doing that.
- bitlax 4y agoReddit certainly used to but I haven't used it in years.
- nickthegreek 4y agoit isn't used to do that, they fear that it could be used to do that.
- jmpman 4y agoI have plenty of Chinese propaganda in my TikTok feeds right now.
- nickthegreek 4y agoInteresting. Please link one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BigCryo 4y agoI trust China and tiktok more than I trust Facebook and Washington DC