4 ms·
I guess one of my own issues with AI, is seeing how the tools we already have, have been twisted by greedy, ruthless people (many of whom are on this very venue
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I guess one of my own issues with AI, is seeing how the tools we already have, have been twisted by greedy, ruthless people (many of whom are on this very venue).
I was one of the people that started off in tech with dreams of a digital Nirvana. I ignored the "negative naysayers," and sallied forth, with an open heart, and hope for the future.
I'm really quite disappointed in what we've done with these marvelous tools. As I've gotten older, wiser, and a lot more cynical, I can tell you that, if I had known, then, about human nature, what I know now, it would have been entirely predictable.
I think we'll be seeing AI-driven scammers, calling and messaging us, almost incessantly, I think we'll be seeing AI-generated political manipulation, like fake videos and audio, of politicians and public figures, I think we'll be seeing AI-driven promotional campaigns, and almost undetectably subtle media manipulation, like corporations seeding news stories with their talking points. I also think that we'll be seeing AI-driven workplaces, where it will be hard to be simply human, and AI-driven surveillance, by authoritarian regimes (and people right here, will happily sell it to them).
I want to believe that we'll do good, but bad pays so well, and there's outright scorn for doing stuff for any reason other than pure, personal profit.
- bovermyer 4y agoI wonder if humans would behave better - or at least, be more reigned-in - if we could only interact with people we are physically close to.
- paxys 4y agoYou have thousands of years of human history to look back on to figure out whether that is true or not. I'm going to go ahead and say that the answer is a pretty clear "no".
- bovermyer 4y agoI'm not so sure about that. We have more information at our fingertips than ever before, and we can talk to people on the other side of the planet in real time. However, all it takes is a couple minutes of browsing social media or playing an online game to see that humanity has some pretty poor ideas of what constitutes acceptable social behavior. I don't think we've advanced socially all that much. I've read a fair number of history books (my degree is in history), and while our data on daily social behavior of the common person is woefully incomplete, I haven't seen much evidence that we're all that much more polite than our ancient Babylonian cousins.
- asdff 4y agoThat works well actually, until you get some other group that moves into the community, then they are blamed for all ills and targeted with violence that is only possible due to physical proximity.
- le-mark 4y agoI’ve adopted a similarly pessimistic view, that even if I’m one of the ones who gets to keep my job, “it’s” all going to shit from here. I’m surprised and confused to say the least.
- joenot443 4y agoSame boat. I think in the ways gen-x’ers talk about the “pre-internet” days spent offline, we’ll talk about the “pre-AI” days spent online. I can imagine a flood of content so gargantuan and vast that by 2030, finding new real words online written by real breathing people will be like finding a teacup in a junkyard. I’ll stress that this view is strictly my own and not my employers, but I personally wish this box had remained closed. The benefit we’re seeing now just isn’t worth what’s to come, I fear.
- tenpies 4y ago> we’ll talk about the “pre-AI” days spent online. I like the pre-social media days we spent online. When making a web site took some non-trivial effort so just having something up and hosted meant that you were either interested in the technology, or felt that whatever you were publishing was important enough to warrant the effort. When there were no "normies" online, or if they were, they were confined to e-mail. I'm sure if you go far back enough, you'll find someone centuries ago expressing the same thing. Oh how the printing press has cheapened writing. Back when people had to put quill on paper, they really had something to say . . .
- t0bia_s 4y agoSame with films. On analog, you have really think what story you want to say. Mistakes was expensive. Nowadays cheap mistakes let you experiment more, but again... Without thinking about purpose of those experiment, nothing valuable is made.
- 0xf00ff00f 4y agoYeah, I've been a technophile all my life but this is probably the first development I don't see as a net positive. All the use cases I've seen so far lead to a shittier world, and we probably won't even get sci-fi AGI in return.
- trekkie1024 4y agoPersonally I think there’s a distinction to be made between generative AI and that of say, self driving cars. I’d definitely consider the latter a net positive for safety.
- sli 4y agoMassive net negative for anyone who can't afford a new car once those become required. Without expansion of public transportation basically everywhere, self-driving cars are a money making method that will lock out millions of people, not a real solution.
- trekkie1024 4y agoAgree that better public transport is the ideal solution. When do you see self driving cars becoming required?
- Nevermark 4y agoTime sharing of self-driving cars will be very inexpensive. Biggest cost now is drivers. Think about how little time utilization most cars get. That blurs the line between public and private, in a good way. In tandem to self-driving, electric car hardware keeps getting cheaper. Projected lifetimes keep getting longer. So the economics are going to trend better for quite a while.
- bitwize 4y agoIt's like how William Gibson moved away from cyberpunk, because all the shitty aspects of cyberpunk are in today's world with few, if any, of the cool bits.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trekkie1024 4y agoDon’t forget AI driven relationships, ala what happened with Replika
- flashgordon 4y agoThis was exactly what I was commenting the other day. I am still a technophile. It is not tech that worries me but the rich who will exploit and monopolize it to rule us more and that too more unscrupulously. May be it is time to actually find ways to not provide more data to train ai? Sure the worlds knowledge until 2022 got ai so far, that doesn't mean we cannot starve it going further if we act collectively?
- asdff 4y ago>I think we'll be seeing AI-driven scammers, calling and messaging us, almost incessantly, I think we'll be seeing AI-generated political manipulation, like fake videos and audio, of politicians and public figures, I think we'll be seeing AI-driven promotional campaigns, and almost undetectably subtle media manipulation, like corporations seeding news stories with their talking points. I also think that we'll be seeing AI-driven workplaces, where it will be hard to be simply human, and AI-driven surveillance, by authoritarian regimes (and people right here, will happily sell it to them). I've been having similar concerns, however, I just wanted to note in this paragraph there is not a damn thing you've listed here that isn't already being done right now without ai. We already get scammed incessantly. Every political message we receive is meant for manipulation versus actual understanding. Corporations have been seeding news stories since there was ever news stories. We have corporate cultures that routinely dehumanize us, forcing us to be sedentary indoors, when we ought to be foraging during the daylight if we actually lived according to our biology. we surveille eachother, and have no need of any advanced technology to oppress ourselves by the millions with brutal effectiveness. If you are concerned now, then you must not have been paying much attention. If you have issues with these things, then ai is not what you need to be going after, this is how the world is incentivized to run.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoMany of these scams are older than dirt. I remember, in the 1980s, companies getting actual snail mail 419 scams, then, in the 1990s, faxes. But AI will be giving the same sharks, new tools. Soon, you will actually be hearing your granddaughter on the phone, screaming, as they rip out her fingernails. The "IRS agent" will no longer have a dodgy Indian accent. Those "I caught you masturbating" emails will now have actual deepfakes of your face. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if a new racket appears, of extortion, using wholly-fabricated nude/embarrassing photos. I suspect that influencers will be targeted, as they put out so much material, and many have means. I just know exactly how bad people can get; better than most, hereabouts. I have few illusions. But we'll also be getting some good. This is the real deal. It isn't Claptrap's BECHOWafers.
- asdff 4y ago
- solarmist 4y agoThe problem is that humanity is not just capable of the best and worst outcomes, but that we constantly act to realize both the best and worst we can achieve.
- musicale 4y agoRuthlessness and greed tend to be signature qualities of successful companies and their executives.
- tjchear 4y agoWe're just trapped in the present day tech zeitgeist. Taking a step back and looking at things on a longer time scale, you'll see there has always been good people to keep things in balance, and the general state of things improves over time. There are great people working on tools to identify AI generated content, and even regular people will eventually catch up to the impact generative AI brings and adapt accordingly, like most other technologies / developments. I'm optimistic we'll pull through.
- antibasilisk 4y ago>you'll see there has always been good people to keep things in balance yes but technology has enabled good people to be shut down much more effectively
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoUnfortunately the last time we had a publishing revolution we had two world wars before we got the press properly regulated. We’re now having two publishing revolutions within 30 years and are only in early stage fascism
- f0ld 4y agoHey, don’t forget the thirty years war after the invention of printing press
- joshspankit 4y agoWe are at a unique inflection point: one where manipulation is basically transparent if you can see all the information at once. This has never been true in the past (except for small communities where everyone knew everyone else’s business) and it basically annihilates the very thing that manipulation needs: shadow. Personally, I’m looking forward to an AI that can immediately answer the questions “is this a scam?” and “what are the facts underpinning this?”.
- rblion 4y agoI know what you mean, my life has unfolded in a similar way. What I have realized is that until we evolve our hearts and minds, no amount of technology will solve our collective existential crisis. With that said, I am still young (33), live in Maui, and am still hungry and foolish to try new and bold things. :)