4 ms·
Top 27 highest-earning substacks generate over $22M a year
- vfclists 4y ago[flagged]
- zug_zug 4y agoI'm downvoting how you're expressing this rather than what you believe
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI think the only one biased is you. It's a factual article, and it describes a wide variety of authors, most of them more mainstream, yet you chose to quote this paragraph and only this paragraph. The worst insult in the paragraph you quoted is "fringe", which is a label most of the quoted writers would probably be proud to wear, being the antonym for "mainstream".
- cidergal 4y ago[flagged]
- motoxpro 4y agoAn end of the world newsletter seems pretty fringe to me. Or maybe I’m just out of touch with politics.
- harvey9 4y agoSky News runs a YouTube Livestream with what amounts to a doomsday countdown, a modeled global average temperature shown to about 10dp so they can have the drama of watching the number go up about once per second. This is both fringe in the sense that the stream has a miniscule number of viewers, and mainstream in that it is run by a licensed broadcaster.
- tr3ntg 4y agoIt’s unfortunate how harshly this comment is worded - the video linked provides a level-headed and informative speech given at a UK Parliament meeting that is a good summary of vaccination outcomes based on government data. I’ve struggled to find unbiased summaries such as this, so it’s an appreciated link.
- notahacker 4y agoI'm not sure I'd apply the adjectives "level headed and informative" to Andrew Bridgen MP, the crank most recently found tweeting that COVID was invented by the US DoD in Fort Detrick and an unnamed facility in Canada"...
- vfclists 4y agoAd hominems, the mark of the dogdy debater without counterarguments and facts who who appeals to the intellectually challenged. The speech said nothing about the DoD, Fort Detrick or Canada. He quoted statistics from the UK Government about the efficacy or lack of efficacy of the vaccine. It is also a matter of public record that the US DoD and the NIH funded the EcoHealth Alliance who channelled funds to the Wuhan Institute of Virology for Gain of Function research on the coronavirus. A lot of the coronavirus GoF research was also done by Dr Ralph Baric at Chapel Hill University and guess who funded that as well? Irregardless of how the Covid outbreak occurred if you have some points to make about the content of Andrew Bridgen's speech lets hear them. They are about the efficacy or lack thereof of the vaccines and their side effects and are not about the origin of the Sars Cov 2 virus. For anyone reading this comment, I would advise you to listen to the speech rather than wasting time on snide HN commenters who have no meaningful facts to contribute.
- notahacker 4y ago> Ad hominems, the mark of the dogdy debater without counterarguments and facts who who appeals to the intellectually challenged. QED. HNers are of course, free to make up their own minds whether someone who suggests that Fort Detrick and a facility in Canada created COVID and refers to it as a "viral bioweapon" is a "level headed" commentator on the issue likely to be offering accurate interpretations of government statistics well worth taking the time to listen to. And indeed on the subject of your original claim about whether politicians feared the implications of hearing a fearless utterer of such irrefutable truths or just didn't want to dignify someone who has rapidly descended into the political equivalent of Alex Jones with an audience.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> peeved at the fact that the so called alt-right writers shunned by his MSM masters have an audience willing to pay Where do you see peeving? I see a call to action. This content makes money. That doesn't mean you have to write that, but there's clearly–as you observe–an audience willing to pay for a different perspective.
- paulpauper 4y agoMy belief has been if you are decently talented at writing and can set aside a few hours to write at least 2 articles/week, you should be writing on Substack. The upside is huge--thousands of dollars or even a six-figure income--with almost no downside besides time spent writing and maybe some promotion, but with any talent the content should go viral (on both the Substack app/network but also Twitter) without too much work. Unlike Medium, Substack seems to care much more about its writers and less inclined to censor. Writers have much more control. Many journalists are making way more with Substack than with their prior publications/employers, but with full autonomy and control of the platform, so they have both more income and also the platform, which is also worth a lot and can be monetized in other ways, like affiliate links. It shows how much money they were leaving on the table.
- scarface74 4y agoThat’s like saying if you are a decent singer you can make money. Once you have so many people producing content, you’ll get the same power law like every other form of media.
- dataangel 4y ago> but with any talent the content should go viral (on both the Substack app/network but also Twitter) A lack of ethics also helps. Fringe views are more likely to gather attention. If you optimize for attention (revenue) then you basically end up getting paid to spread lies. Way more clicks for well written conspiracy bait than debunking conspiracies.
- the_shivers 4y agoThis is also true of mainstream media publications.
- asdff 4y agoI have often thought about how easy it must be to be one of these crazy conservative talking heads. All you have to do is be loud, angry, and say the obvious bigoted talking points they have, and people will flock to you because you are doing it with no shame. Then once you have a bit of a base you are a player in that game for life with a career of conservative podcasting to always fall back on. Maybe you even have a shot for higher office. Of course, this all requires selling your soul, so there is some cost.
- mellosouls 4y agoAs a reader of several Substack writers, I find the individualist approach frustrating, and - I feel - ultimately counter-democratic in a way. By the latter I mean that with legacy media - despite the political slant (either way) of the publication as a whole, you generally have access to a multitude of voices. With the Substack model that isn't the case - unless you limit yourself to the free options, or are wealthy enough to subscribe to as many writers as you like. I suppose there are Substack amalgamations out there, grouping writers on a common outlet, but those who have managed to gather enough of a living striking out on their own are probably not going to worry too much about whether they are also available as part of a more economically accessible and diverse collection of voices using a different subscription model that collates multiple writers for a single cost. Ultimately that means that access to a truly wide range of authoritative voices is potentially limited to the wealthy.
- aiappreciator 4y ago"access to a multitude of voices" You mean a multitude of groupthinked, editor supervised voices? More people != better opinions unless there is a constant debate. And the modern subscription driven model for large newspapers means appealing to the base, and neutrality is bad for revenue. Substackers also have to appeal to their base. But individual idiosyncrasies and strong opinions are much better preserved when its just one person, instead of a n editor enforcing a hivemind.
- mrangle 4y agoYou must have a huge "democratic" beef with books. Those being the dominant largely solitary-voiced format that people pay for. Before now, I've read anything that correlated them to being counter to democracy.
- codyb 4y agoThere's libraries, at least in the USA, in a lot of places.
- nradov 4y agoAfter 30+ years of web publishing we still have no viable system for content micropayments. There's just no way I will sign up for any more monthly subscriptions; those build up and eat you alive. But I would be happy to pay a small amount to read an individual article if it was a frictionless one-click process. There have been many attempts to crack that problem but so far all have failed. https://www.nngroup.com/articles/the-case-for-micropayments/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/the-case-for-micropayments/
- a-robinson 4y agoMisleading title -- it isn't claiming that there are any newsletters generating $22M a year individually. It's just saying that the top 27 (why 27?) newsletters in aggregate make at least that much.
- dang 4y agoOur software screwed that one up. Sorry - fixed - thanks!
- ghiculescu 4y agoI started Substacking recently. I’m not bothering with a paywall - I’m doing it to get better at writing and because writing helps me think and reflect. If people find what I’m writing interesting or helpful, that’s a bonus. I thought the only people who’d read my posts were people I have on LinkedIn so I’ve been really pleasantly surprised how many people I’ve never heard of have been subscribing. I’m not sure what Substack are doing but they seem to do something right to spread your writing beyond your direct network. I appreciate that, and I’m not surprised they’ve enabled some very large subscriber bases as a result. ps. If you want to make my day: https://ghiculescu.substack.com https://ghiculescu.substack.com
- aiappreciator 4y agoYou are literally demonstrating how substack "does something right to spread your writing beyond your direct network" On substacks, writers own their brands. Their own brand is plastered everywhere on their website. Compare that to medium, where the medium brand takes precedence. Since writers own their brands, they are highly incentivised to market it themselves, and keep a distinct personal voice, both easily drawing in paying customers.
- miklosme 4y agoThey talked about this article on the Blocked and Reported podcast (13th on the list). They said the numbers in this article are inflated.
- jwsteigerwalt 4y agoWowzers, “The Fifth Column”!
- agentwiggles 4y agoGood for them! I love their podcast.