5 ms·
Our small Maine city recently replaced an entire bridge in a couple days, https://verandaplan.org/ https://verandaplan.org/ It worked great. They shut down the
by mrguyorama 4y ago
Our small Maine city recently replaced an entire bridge in a couple days, https://verandaplan.org/ https://verandaplan.org/
It worked great. They shut down the road for a couple hours, literally moved the newly built bridge from beside the road into place, and then were ready for rush hour in a couple days. I had a friend who worked the project.
America can build great things if we were willing, but the past 70 years has seen strong anti-government rhetoric (weirdly after the most successful big government projects seen probably in our history) has helped hollow out local governments and remove any chance they had to cultivate internal talent that could get more efficient at doing things.
Imagine having the pay of a local grocer, the turnover of Amazon warehousing, and the public animosity of Google and Facebook combined, with an entire TV channel watched by 60 million daily screaming that your very existence hurts the country, and plenty of grandmas taking that to heart. Government is overtly attacked every single day. Is it any wonder it often struggles?
- sokoloff 4y agoDo you think the complaints about government come unfairly out of the blue while it busily provides efficient and timely service with a friendly smile to its constituents?
- rconti 4y agoI guess the better question is, are the complaints limited to those that provide a poor service? Or are they fairly evenly distributed regardless of how good or bad the government in question performs?
- analog31 4y agoIt could be that the two things -- complaints and actual service delivered -- are unrelated.
- vanattab 4y agoMeanwhile in the the real world complaints about service and the quality of said service do tend to correlate.
- bsder 4y agoAnd sometimes it's intentional: Take the DMV in Texas. Texas specifically shut down DMV offices in some of the most populated areas. Yeah, that's going to make the DMV suck in those areas. Of course, they left open then ones in the more rural areas, and those DMVs are going to be quite pleasant.
- analog31 4y agowas that to make it harder to register to vote?
- jacobr1 4y agoThe point isn't the government services are currently high quality. The point is that the current environment foster low quality service. In some cases voting in politicians that drove top-down management changes would help. And that would require the populace to value such changes. We might need to structure the incentives for government employees, contractors, or the regulatory environment to better align with delivering good service. That might mean more pay, which means either higher taxes or strong prioritization of efforts. We can't do that intelligently if nobody cares, or is skilled enough to drive these large institutions. Because it is hard. We almost certainly are using the wrong tradeoffs: some things privatized and outsourced should be done by government agencies. Some functions should be privatized or just regulated on the open market. Some things are better handled at regional levels that today are handled at local or national levels. The mix of tradeoffs is wrong. Incremental work to fix this requires a society-wide agreement to make progress. Not necessarily agreement on any particular (and even when there is agreement, we are going to get it wrong a bunch) but agreement on the project of bettering our society and social collaboration. That seems like it is missing and thus progress is made only in fits in starts, in a hostile environment. A hard-one deregulation here, a new bill to fund a project there, contested on ll sides, and undermined before the initiatives get started.
- rjbwork 4y agoNo. However, consider that since the 40's there has been a concerted effort by a variety of actors, such as Rothbard and other people backed by institutes such as the Volker fund, the AEI, Federalist Society, Murdochs, etc. to sap both the perceived effectiveness of government and the actual effectiveness of government. "Government doesn't work - elect me and I'll prove it!"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notch898a 4y agoNo criticism of the ineffectiveness of government is complete until we've blamed Rothbard.
- rjbwork 4y agoWell hey, he's the only person I know of to have argued professionally that a government shouldn't even be powerful enough to prevent people from selling their children on the open market to the highest bidder. He's kind of the most extreme example one can pluck, and quite an influential one, at that.
- notch898a 4y agoIsn't that an argument against Rothbard being successful? You can't meaningfully auction off a child in the US. Although I guess some may argue he's been successful to the extent that in some parts of the US you can electively terminate your unborn offspring, which is a firmly Rothbardian viewpoint.
- rjbwork 4y agoIf my goal is murder, but I only render you completely brain dead, or maybe only paralyzed from the neck down, have I failed? Yeah, in some sense. But in terms of the grievous harm rendered, I've succeeded to a pretty serious degree.
- lmm 4y agoI think there's a self-reinforcing downward spiral where reduced funding and poore reputation begets poorer service and vice versa.
- mym1990 4y agoThe time it took to place the bridge has almost no indication of whether this project was on time or on budget. This bridge project started December 2017! So 5+ years of work for a weekend of final execution. On top of this, while the bridge may be in a small city in Maine, the initiative is run by the Maine DOT, which is likely substantially larger as an organization.
- geenew 4y agoIt has a bearing on the cost associated with road closures, which can't be insignificant. Anyway, some quick looking found: > Gov. Janet Mills toured the Veranda Street site of the new bridge being installed along Interstate 295 in Portland on Saturday afternoon and said she was pleased with the rapid progress of the project. > “I’m thrilled with the technology, thrilled that it’s going on time and on budget,” Mills said. “Three days’ time, and this bridge will be done. It’s amazing. It’s like giant Legos going together.” https://www.pressherald.com/2022/04/23/i-295-bridge-replacement-is-on-track-dot-says/ https://www.pressherald.com/2022/04/23/i-295-bridge-replacem... which seems like enough to go on to presume it's at least close to being on budget.
- mym1990 4y agoYou can always say you are on time and on budget as long as extensions come your way. My point was not saying that this project was not on time or on budget, it was mainly to illustrate that the 3 days of work that locals saw was based on 5 years of research and preparation. I recently read 'Built: The Hidden Stories Behind our Structures' by Roma Agrawal and it would be fairly rudimentary for a structural engineer, but for the average passerby it was a very interesting read on some of the structures that we use every day! (and how some of them are miserable failures haha)
- echelon 4y agoThe best construction hustle I've ever seen is Georgia's relatively recent repair of a bridge over I-85. I-85 is an interstate highway serving a central economic corridor through Atlanta. A portion of the bridge collapsed when a homeless person lit a fire next to highly flammable plastics stored under the bridge, which later grew into a bridge-melting inferno. The state of Georgia provided incentives for contractors to finish the project early due to the incredible economic damage it was causing. The loss of the bridge took out all travel on I-85 - it was a devastating and crippling loss that gave many Atlanta area knowledge workers their first taste of "work from home" (or five hour commutes). The incentives provided absolutely made the contractors hustle. There was work ongoing 24/7 for the entire period, and they completed ahead of time and budget. I don't think I've ever witnessed something happen so fast. It was a marvelous feat, and it's too bad we don't see more like it. It's what happens when the correct incentives and pressures are put in place. https://transportationops.org/case-studies/i-85-bridge-collapse-and-rebuild https://transportationops.org/case-studies/i-85-bridge-colla...
- lr4444lr 4y agoAnti-government rhetoric? In New York State, construction projects have been notoriously delayed and gone over budget ever since the days of Boss Tweed, which historians have generally linked to corruption and graft.
- nonethewiser 4y agoCareful, you’re getting dangerously close to domestic terrorism rhetoric.
- lr4444lr 4y agoDon't be extreme: that only happens if you talk sharply at a school district board meeting out of concern for your child.
- kneebonian 4y agoAt least with major projects this is 100% the case. Had a buddy involved in a state legislature said one of the reasons there is so much road work and construction going on all the time is because it is one of the easiest ways to disguise corruption and embezzlement. As an example in a 5 year project for a new overpass you can have literally 1000s of different contractors involved in the work and it becomes very difficult to notice and prove that Joe's Cement company never showed up to pour the liminal substrate pylons like they were paid $10k to do.
- buildsjets 4y agoMy favorite New York "Joe's Cement" story is that when they were expanding Islip airport, a mob-owned cement company that was giving kickbacks to the local county government poured the ramp pad WAY under the specified thickness using unreinforced concrete, so of course the first Southwest plane to arrive damaged it. Don't hire a mob-owned cement company, you say? Tough noogies, In NY, at least at that time, they were all mob-owned. https://www.aviationpros.com/home/news/10393303/southwests-concrete-apron-at-islip-must-be-removed https://www.aviationpros.com/home/news/10393303/southwests-c... https://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=401393 https://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=401393 https://www.nytimes.com/1994/09/23/nyregion/mob-allegation-clouds-new-york-concrete-deal.html https://www.nytimes.com/1994/09/23/nyregion/mob-allegation-c... https://www.gothamcenter.org/blog/material-politics-of-new-york-from-the-mafias-concrete-club-to-isis https://www.gothamcenter.org/blog/material-politics-of-new-y...
- panny 4y ago>TV channel watched by 60 million daily screaming that your very existence hurts the country Yet the TV channel is controlled by the council on foreign relations, like all tv channels, and says exactly what the government directs them to. https://mronline.org/2017/07/23/the-american-empire-and-its-media/ https://mronline.org/2017/07/23/the-american-empire-and-its-...
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. What exactly are people supposed to do in response to public services that are over budget and don’t serve their needs? Surely the solution to criticism of government inefficiency is for government to operate well. If visiting San Francisco was like going to Tokyo or Copenhagen—clean, efficient, convenient—Fox News would lose credibility. At some point, people in Missouri would point to San Francisco and be like “that’s great, why don’t we do that here?”
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> It’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. This is precisely the conservative game plan though: starve the government of funds, force it to outsource as much as possible to the private sector, then when projects end up delayed and overbudget (or failing), point to lack of government efficiency and competence to justify further funding cuts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast This has been happening since basically the Reagan era. >> Surely the solution to criticism of government inefficiency is for government to operate well. No organization can operate well if it doesn't have necessary levels of funding, and the government is no exception. Said lack of funding is the primary cause of the inefficiencies, which often times manifest as lack of inhouse expertise that can provide strict analysis of and oversight for projects outsourced to the private sector.
- surement 4y ago> Said lack of funding is the primary cause of the inefficiencies No, the primary cause is politicians promising things that sound good so that they'll get reelected, because that's the number one thing they care about, not efficiency. On the other hand a private company will only build something that makes economical sense.
- Ozzie_osman 4y ago> On the other hand a private company will only build something that makes economical sense. Yes, economical sense to the company. But not all things that are good for society make economic sense for companies.
- notjoemama 4y agoSigh... > with an entire TV channel watched by 60 million daily screaming that your very existence hurts the country, and plenty of grandmas taking that to heart Just say the name next time, I think it's obvious whom you are referring to. It's also obvious replies to your assertions are off topic in part because of this part of your reply. So here's my list of what the article suggests cause large construction projects to go over budget. > SUMMARY: > It’s a tale as old as civil engineering: A megaproject is sold to the public as a grand solution to a serious problem. Planning and design get underway, permits issued, budgets allocated (that took a lot longer than we expect), construction starts, and then there are more problems! Work is delayed, expenses balloon, and when all the dust settles, it’s a lot less clear whether the project’s benefits were really worth the costs. > REASONS: > underestimation > limit in design prevents accurate overall estimation > subcontracting availability > subcontracting sufficiency > subcontracting estimation (bids) > missed pre-construction costs > inflation of labor and materials > course correcting takes longer on big projects > stakeholder compromises > not taking exploratory work into account > opportunistic greed > ...but that's not nearly as common as: "just too darned optimistic and short-sighted" The suggested solution from the source, as the author points out, is to spend more time in design and planning. ref: https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/megaprojects-and-risk/78B4E0A8FDBEC72919B832D33BECF083 https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/megaprojects-and-risk/7... As far as software, that suggests waterfall like planning could give you a better estimation on total project expenditure. But delivery has won that battle, I think. Maybe as our industry contracts (layoffs and svb) we'll see a push towards that kind of project estimation too?
- tormeh 4y agoMore time in design and planning? That phase can already often take a decade. I realize most of that is probably political horsetrading around which backyard is going to be torn up and which budget the money will come from, but long planning phases are already a problem.
- nonethewiser 4y agoSounds like he’s talking about CNN. Or MSNBC.
- daveslash 4y agoRe >> Our small Maine city [This is good natured ribbing] Small? Small Maine City? I clicked this expecting to see Machias or Limestone, but I get your biggest city? Sure, it's small by comparison to other cities, but it is your biggest! Tone is difficult to convey online, so please understand this is all in jest. :-) I grew up in DownEast Maine (Machias was my local 'small city') - so I actually was expecting some small city I'd never heard of. Jokes aside, that is very cool about the bridge, and you make good points in your last 2 paragraphs.
- ilyt 4y ago> Imagine having the pay of a local grocer, the turnover of Amazon warehousing, and the public animosity of Google and Facebook combined, with an entire TV channel watched by 60 million daily screaming that your very existence hurts the country, and plenty of grandmas taking that to heart. Government is overtly attacked every single day. Is it any wonder it often struggles? Right. Completely nothing to do with underdelivering while bending the knee to whoever corporation brib... I mean lobbied more.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThere are MILLIONS of people who work in government that aren't politicians and are just trying to do the best with the purposeful obstruction that is handed to them.
- hammock 4y agoThat’s a pretty standard method for installing small bridges/overpasses. They did a dozen of them in Chicago during the construction of the 606