3 ms·
I'm sure all those 300-byte images have the 37signals servers at melting point. I don't think this is the horse you want to ride.
by vacri 15y ago
I'm sure all those 300-byte images have the 37signals servers at melting point.
I don't think this is the horse you want to ride.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI'll take that pony ride. Someone who's happy to steal from someone else just because that person is richer than them and they're only stealing little things still, IMO, lacks morally. With proviso's which aren't I don't think pertinent to this current situation (eg immediate life-preservation). Your argument is basically the shoplifter's manifesto - the store is rich, I only took some of their stuff, it's barely a drop compared to their profits, etc..
- vacri 15y agoNo, my argument is that of all the things wrong with this situation, stealing 300-byte bandwidth is so far down the list it's unimportant. That's what I meant by this is not the horse - there are far better horses to ride in this race. It's nice of you to tell me what my argument is, but you have it utterly wrong.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>nice of you to tell me what my argument is How you've reiterated it here appears to match my interpretation of what you said. So perhaps you can say what your argument actually is - FWIW my comment had several upvotes so it doesn't appear to be just me being a dullard. >stealing 300-byte bandwidth is so far down the list it's unimportant So you're saying this is nothing like the argument 'stealing a snickers from Walmart is such a small amount, it's not important'?
- dustyleary 15y agoNo, he's saying that when a guy walks out of Walmart with a pallet full of flatscreen TVs, nobody cares about the snickers bar he also grabbed on the way out, and talking about the snickers bar is a waste of time.
- vacri 15y agoSo you're saying this is nothing like the argument 'stealing a snickers from Walmart is such a small amount, it's not important'? Will you stop trying to paint me as only talking about one issue? That's where you get my argument utterly wrong. It's akin to saying "Mao Zedong's China was bad because the dog-catchers weren't licensed properly". Like it or not, the legal system regularly drops small, less important charges when bigger ones are present. The murderer who exceeding the speed limit trying to escape from police doesn't get a speeding ticket. That doesn't mean that speeding tickets themselves are unimportant or never get pursued.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoWe're discussing this issue which you raised. It's fallacious to consider that one is only concerned with a single facet of a situation because that is all that is being addressed. Others have addressed the other points in the thread. So, going back to my initial comment (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3523870 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3523870) you're saying that it's wrong of me to characterize your argument this way because I've failed to mention that it's a corrupt tycoon that is shoplifting. Because they've also committed greater crimes we have to ignore the shoplifting? Or to recapitulate you'd nab a shoplifter but only if they'd not done something worse as well? Got to say I still don't follow the reasoning and still consider image hotlinking to be bad; and that, for a company, it indicates some sort of corruption.
- vacri 15y ago"this issue which you raised"!? What the hell are you on? eropple was the one that raised bandwidth stealing, not me. Or to recapitulate you'd nab a shoplifter but only if they'd not done something worse as well? The legal system already does this - if someone sets fire to the shop but takes a Snickers on the way out, no-one really cares about the shoplifting. The legal system doesn't prosecute it, and the media doesn't report "the arsonist and shoplifter was in court today". People reading glossy magazines don't gossip "oo, that arsonist - did you know he also took a candy bar? the nerve!". Anyway, absolutely nowhere have I said that hotlinking is okay. If that's what you think I've said, then you have grossly misunderstood me.