6 ms·
JPMorgan advising First Republic on alternatives, including a capital raise
- newaccount2023 4y agothey have $30 bln in new deposits its the same bank they were two weeks ago, but with a $30 bln buffer why do anything? so what, the stock collapsed...if the business is still basically sound (and I have yet to see material evidence to the contrary), then it will move back up maybe there is evidence not brought to light...but otherwise, we're talking about a mid-size bank on good terms with regulators that has a P/E under 2 (!!!) this almost feels manipulated to the downside... and please don't respond with "bank run blah blah" every bank in the world is subject to that risk FRB seems actually better off in that its depositors don't need to empty their accounts to pay off the lease on a used minivan
- bmmayer1 4y agoWhy are you trying to yada yada a bank run? If First Republic bleeds depositors (especially HNW depositors where they're concentrated) then it is going to go out of business. It doesn't matter if the bank run is "justified" or not -- the perception of fear is enough to scare depositors away, which would make it a self fulfilling prophecy. That said, there are good fundamental reasons to be bullish, which is why (full disclosure) I am still long $FRC. But I'm feeling increasingly unhappy about it.
- zamnos 4y agoFRC is now down to $15/share from a high of $170 so it's no surprise that anyone that's holding FRC is running scared. If it fails, however likely/unlikely as it may be, what we've seen is that shareholders will be zeroed out by the FDIC (at least in the immediate term, there's at least one lawsuit pending, and we'll have to see how much can be recovered), or in a purchase by, say, JPM, then it's likele not even worth that much. A bank in recievership after a bank run is worth about as much as a Snickers bar, as Matt Levine opined, and a Snickers bar split a million ways is not worth the digital bits the certificate is printed on.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoThere are so many people who are long FRC because they like the service or want the bank to survive, but the only thing that matters for valuing a bank stock is the deposits and the revenue they can make off of them. Based on the news from the last several weeks, it's clear that the uninsured deposits have fled First Republic. The hole is being plugged temporarily by the consortium of banks but that will only be temporary. The next disclosure date will make it clear that FRC is not worth anything close to what it was previously. Buying the common stock is a huge bet that First Republic can bounce back to what it was prior to this crisis, but that's looking extremely unlikely.
- newaccount2023 4y ago> it's clear that the uninsured deposits have fled First Republic their customers are high-net-worth so this would basically means almost all customers have left FRB, which is obviously not the case at this point the stock is so cheap you don't even need it to get back to previous levels to make a killing...even if it ends up at a 50% discount from its peak, thats 4x from the current price...which gives you an indication of how irrational the panic selling has become
- nostrademons 4y agoAssuming that it doesn't go bankrupt or get fire-sold - both of which are very possible outcomes at this point. #1 on Peter Lynch's list of mistakes an invester can make : "It can't go any lower." Any stock - including stocks of high-flying blue-chips - can go to zero. https://www.flowbank.com/en/research/10-sayings-that-will-punish-your-investments-by-peter-lynch https://www.flowbank.com/en/research/10-sayings-that-will-pu...
- newaccount2023 4y agoStocks do not go to 0 on the open market, and delisting does not imply 0 value List a stock whose trade price was $0.00, I'll wait
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hbarka 4y agoI like First Republic. They don’t charge ATM withdrawal fees when using it internationally. I hope their services will not degrade. Carry on FRC.
- RC_ITR 4y ago>a P/E under 2 FWIW, banks are priced on Book Value (that's literally what the stock in a bank represents, whether it's public or private - banks aren't like normal operating companies), since earnings are volatile and dependent on outside factors. FRB's book value is anyone's guess ATM, but it's probably quickly becoming negative given the bank run blah blah Also, for companies that are priced on earnings, they're priced on forward earnings, which is assumed to be extremely negative for FRC.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the stock collapsed Bank equity is weird because it directly feeds into the funding cost for the bank’s massively-levered balance sheet. That said, I agree something is off here. First Republic (and Credit Suisse) may be (and have been) better off as private companies.
- nerdponx 4y ago> The alternatives may include a capital raise, the sources said, which could dilute current shareholders. A sale of the bank is also a possibility. This is why we need to stay very very strong on the "no help for shareholders" policy when banks fail. The potential for moral hazard is extreme otherwise.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe moral hazard is already in place. See SVB's stock price in the last few years. The signal is clear to banking execs: take on risk, show growth metrics, and the stock market will reward you. If your salary is tied to stock price, and whatever risky behavior you adopt won't show up for years, you have no real incentive to play nice. Banking execs are not going to stick around at the same bank forever. Do a 3 year tenure, pump up the stock, get paid, and gtfo with someone else left holding the bag.
- encoderer 4y agoEverybody in charge lived through 2008. Now we all get a live fire test of the question: did anybody learn anything useful from that crisis.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- user3939382 4y agoYes: the government doesn't regulate the banks, the banks regulate the government. Actually I knew that before 2008...
- weinzierl 4y agoThe useful thing we learned from the 2008 crisis is that the state will actually save big institutions because it is not willing to risk civil unrest. This was not sure before 2008, many assumed big banks can go under. Now with that knowledge there is little incentive for banks to play it safe and a bailout every couple of years is to the benefit of everyone except the taxpayer and a few unlucky scapegoats. Of course this is not sustainable either and maybe this time or next time what we learned 2008 will prove untrue...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> a few unlucky scapegoats By which you mean the shareholders and lenders. Out of all possible evils, this is probably the best.
- weinzierl 4y agoDid the shareholders really suffer in 2008? Honest question, no snark. Sure, the SVB shareholders will suffer but this is different from the 2008 bailouts.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Did the shareholders really suffer in 2008 Some did, most didn’t. That was the gripe. That’s why we’re doing it differently this time.
- vagab0nd 4y agoI find it funny that people take money out of First Republic and deposit into the big banks. The big banks then proceeds to return the money to First Republic. They call it a bank run but ultimately there's really no place to run.
- nickff 4y agoPeople are taking money out of banks which may be permitted to fail, and putting it into banks that are "too big to fail".
- TheBlight 4y agoRight and they're in turn depositing it back into the small banks. See: https://www.wsj.com/articles/jpmorgan-morgan-stanley-and-others-in-talks-to-bolster-first-republic-4f9eeb76 https://www.wsj.com/articles/jpmorgan-morgan-stanley-and-oth...
- codyb 4y agoYea, they're depositing capital so that the small banks can meet depositor demand. It's a liquidity infusion. A lot of times the big banks don't want more small depositors anyways.
- twblalock 4y agoYes but as an individual depositor, if you moved money this would not impact your decision. You got the safety you wanted.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoSVB is (was?) 16 and First Republic is 14th "largest commercial banks" based on this report (not sure what it is measuring? assets at the Fed?) as per this December 2022 (probably outdated) report: https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/lbr/current/ https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/lbr/current/
- 4y ago
- woeirua 4y agoIf FRC goes under it will be because Janet Yellen put her foot in her mouth by saying that banks that are not too big to fail will not get a depositor guarantee.
- roundandround 4y agoSeems like fair warning to me. If you have a few million in a bank you may lose it. That's the law. Pretending you are going to break the law by issuing fire insurance on houses that are on fire and then not doing it wouldn't really be more ethical would it?
- woeirua 4y agoBut that's what she just did with SVB...
- roundandround 4y agoShe did what she was ordered to do which is not something she could claim she was going to do as the powers of her office are not wildly out of control.
- credit_guy 4y agoIt's true, but it's possible (quite likely actually) that the Fed and the FDIC looked at SVB's balance sheet, and concluded that they can make good on all the deposits given the FDIC insurance (of $250k per depositor) plus the new funding facility that allows banks to borrow against high quality collateral valued at par, rather than fair value. It does not follow that the math will work out with every single bank that's underwater out there.
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]