3 ms·
>Everything I've used ChatGPT for so far I could, more-or-less, have written or searched for myself in the time it took to get it out of chatgpt correctly. Tha
by coldtea 4y ago
>Everything I've used ChatGPT for so far I could, more-or-less, have written or searched for myself in the time it took to get it out of chatgpt correctly.
That's not even true. For one, it can stub a whole new function or coding project, intelligently, in a few seconds after the prompt, whether it's RoR or DSP code or whatever. For one unfamiliar with the domain, this can take hours or a full day, even with examples found on Google. Heck, even looking up and understanding how to use some command line flags in a shell pipeline can need lots of looking around, even if you have been using Linux/Unix for ages.
For a domain expert? They could do such things very fast. But several times slower still than GPT. Think minutes or half hour instead of seconds. Even the row typing and file creation would be some minutes.
It's also very premature when people judge a service we've had for like 5 years and has already changed by leaps and bounds, as if it's the peak stage, without considering what it could be in 5 or 10, or with different variants tuned for specific tasks.
- mjburgess 4y ago> For one unfamiliar with the domain, this can take hours or a full day Yes, I did say expert. > But several times slower still than GPT. Almost all the output needs to be re-read, modified and integrated in the project. This often takes longer than just typing it out, even from docs -- because you're still forced to think through the solution -- which is most of the time. Typing is quick
- coldtea 4y ago>Almost all the output needs to be re-read, modified and integrated in the project. This often takes longer than just typing it out You'd be very suprised. Try measuring it.
- mjburgess 4y agoYes, I have. That's largely why I've stopped using it. The time it's taken to rewrite has been larger than not; and worse, it deprives me of understanding the problem i'm solving. So I end up not having thought through the problem and basically having to press delete and type from scratch.
- quonn 4y agoI found it useful for writing unit tests, which really is a stupid brain dead code monkey task.
- maaanu 4y agoReally? For me it could not generate meaning full tests, even for the simplest react-components. E.g. it tried to test the display of an error-message in a field in a form. The error message was basically "this is field is required and can't be empty.". It tried to test that, by inserting valid data into the field...
- deeviant 4y agoTo be fair, many human software engineers can't generate meaningful tests.
- ChatGTP 4y agoPeople don't have to love using it you know? If the guy doesn't like it, why force it down his neck? I use plenty of code completion tools already, so I feel similar to them. Sometimes it saves me time, sometimes it doesn't. For me personally, language servers have been the best thing, you can explore libraries, auto-complete nicely, without as the other poster said, worrying about verifying the correctness.
- coldtea 4y ago>People don't have to love using it you know? If the guy doesn't like it, why force it down his neck? It's not about feelings. It's about there being a thing, in objective reality, with some specific merit, and we're trying to evaluate what it is with some accuracy. Whether someone enjoys it or not is beside the point.