3 ms·
Wait, because it goes through a computer it has to be retained? Then why wouldn’t that apply to voice as well as text, so all phone conversations (which definit
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
Wait, because it goes through a computer it has to be retained? Then why wouldn’t that apply to voice as well as text, so all phone conversations (which definitely go through computers these days) have to be retained as well? Or is text some sort of sacred thing that has to be recorded and stored forever, while voice and video calls are somehow exempt from that requirement? Where does American law point out special status for text and not for other signals?
- otterley 4y agoThe law hasn't completely caught up with technology here, but in general, "records" refer to written documents since that's how businesses have traditionally communicated when it comes to decisionmaking. In the eyes of many judges, text chat is viewed as merely a less formal, more spontaneous, and append-only version of writings, and therefore records. Also, for chat to work, it has to persist beyond when it was written for some amount of time so that people can see it. Voice and video, on the other hand, don't share that property: once said or viewed, you either heard the message, or you didn't. It is not ordinarily recorded or stored for any length of time. Of course, if a court ordered you to create voice or video recordings of video or audioconferences, you might be forced to comply. (I'm not sure what the law is here, but in a civil case, if the opposing party paid for the storage, the court might be more inclined to issue such an order, as long as it's not unduly burdensome.)