5 ms·
I think you misunderstand how the law works here, and how a judge will view Pichai's actions. The mere fact of having a text-based chat is itself a written rec
by kelnos 4y ago
I think you misunderstand how the law works here, and how a judge will view Pichai's actions.
The mere fact of having a text-based chat is itself a written record. Turning history off when you are under a retention order is likely to be equivalent to destroying records, in the eyes of a judge.
If they wanted to be truly off the record, they should have met in person or made a phone call.
- yallpendantools 4y ago> Turning history off when you are under a retention order is likely to be equivalent to destroying records, in the eyes of a judge. > "routinely opted to move from history-on rooms to history-off Chats to hold sensitive conversations, even though they knew they were subject to legal holds" Nah, I think that's too far. There are simply too many legitimate reasons for Google to turn history off. What if they are switching to a topic irrelevant to the case and, therefore, not covered by discovery? You can only prove they had a sensitive conversation they wanted no record of, but you can't prove that that sensitive conversation is under the "legal hold" they were in. Even if all the context of the on-record chat seem to imply a crucial bit is coming up, you can't really prove the crucial bit did come up. It's all based on speculation. > If they wanted to be truly off the record, they should have met in person or made a phone call. So... `spichai: let's take this to an ephemeral chat` will be viewed negatively but `spichai: let's discuss this in person` is completely normal? I'm not buying it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- woodruffw 4y ago> What if they are switching to a topic irrelevant to the case and, therefore, not covered by discovery? That's a matter for a court, or a court-appointed expert, to decide. You don't get to opt-out of discovery procedures by intuiting that the other party simply wouldn't be interested in what you have to say. (This raises all kinds of legitimate corporate IP concerns, which the courts have extensive experience handling.)
- yallpendantools 4y agoBut in this case, an "irrelevant topic" can range from something exclusively Google's business (like details of a new product) to something uber-mundane or even personal. So, really, unless the legal hold on Google is a blanket, encompassing order to preserve all internal comms, I find it difficult to be objectively certain they are at fault here.
- woodruffw 4y agoI think you're extending this too far, beyond the facts available: it sounds like a few companies have identified a specific policy within Google, one that seems to exist primarily to render discovery impossible. They're not asking a court to impose onerous or abnormal preservation mechanisms, as evidenced by no other company of Google's size or scope deleting all messages every 24 hours.
- yallpendantools 4y agoCaveat: I did not read the embedded pdfs but I did read the article, and nothing there even alludes to anything like a retention policy. Even the wording of the accusation does not even imply a policy: > Like Mr. Pichai, other key Google employees, including those in leadership roles, routinely opted to move from history-on rooms to history-off Chats to hold sensitive conversations, even though they knew they were subject to legal holds Routinely opted is not a policy. A policy is formal, not an option you routinely take. I'll wager even the best lawyers will be hard-pressed to prove this routine is primarily to render discovery impossible. In fact, on face value alone it will be hard to objectively prove any purpose to this, unless more info/evidence/data/witnesses come up. The text that follows my quote > they did so even when discussing topics they knew were covered by the litigation holds in order to avoid leaving a record that could be produced in litigation. makes assumptions that you can only speculate on, not prove. Sure, they were discussing topics covered by the litigation and then pivoted to private chat within nine seconds. Does it follow that the part of the conversation they moved off-record (and hence we are not privy to) is also definitely covered by litigation and could affect the outcome of the trial? Not necessarily (although likely, alas courts don't settle for likely).
- rhaway84773 4y agoWe are not talking about an ordinary situation. We’re talking about a situation where Google has been placed under a retention order because of a lawsuit. This is not gonna work out well for Google at all because this kind of BS really pisses judges off and also looks really bad to juries if it makes it that far.
- DannyBee 4y agoIf you are under a retention order, yes, you can get in trouble. Epic has some reasonable arguments there when i read it. I thought actually some of this was already resolved in Epic's favor, and some in Google's, and they were only trying to figure out sanctions or something. It's a complex case (well set of cases, really) so i don't remember all of the state. I think it's that their is one in DC where they are trying to decide on the motion, and one in California where they are trying to decide on the penalty. The DOJ's argument, meanwhile, or at least part of it, was not about retention but about reasonable anticipation of litigation and coverage. They basically were arguing (again, in part), that since they started investigation in 2019, Google should have saved all chats from all employees since then. That particular argument seems unlikely to fly. A more targeted argument might stand a better chance, but when they argue crazy things, it doesn't help convince a judge that the rest of your argument has merit. These sorts of arguments always get thrown around anyway. In litigation this large, everyone claims everyone should have disclosed something more, or saved something, or ... Sometimes they win, sometimes they lose. That doesn't mean if someone did something wrong they shouldn't get sanctioned, but like I said, it's not uncommon. It actually used to be worse. Before some rule changes about 2 decades ago, people used to end up spending more time arguing about sanctioning each other than the actual case took, and trying to get money for it. It's more reasonable now, but yeah.
- RHSeeger 4y ago> The mere fact of having a text-based chat is itself a written record. But it doesn't mean it was a "recorded" record, in the same way that having a conversation over the phone necessarily means it was recorded. Sure, in both cases there is "a recording" because the communication needs to be recorded in order to send it. But there's not a "recording" in the sense that it was saved somewhere to be available later. In what way is an unrecorded text conversation different than in unrecorded voice conversation?
- otterley 4y agoThere's no such thing as an "unrecorded" text conversation, since it has to persist for some time on some media for longer than an ephemeral period in order for its intended recipients to receive the communication. The same is not true for voice or video.
- justahuman74 4y agoNo, the same is true. There are various buffers holding voice and video frames that are stored, and then erased/overwritten many times over the course of the conversation.
- otterley 4y ago> for longer than an ephemeral period Reading comprehension is an essential skill in litigation and in legal practice in general.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoWait, because it goes through a computer it has to be retained? Then why wouldn’t that apply to voice as well as text, so all phone conversations (which definitely go through computers these days) have to be retained as well? Or is text some sort of sacred thing that has to be recorded and stored forever, while voice and video calls are somehow exempt from that requirement? Where does American law point out special status for text and not for other signals?
- otterley 4y agoThe law hasn't completely caught up with technology here, but in general, "records" refer to written documents since that's how businesses have traditionally communicated when it comes to decisionmaking. In the eyes of many judges, text chat is viewed as merely a less formal, more spontaneous, and append-only version of writings, and therefore records. Also, for chat to work, it has to persist beyond when it was written for some amount of time so that people can see it. Voice and video, on the other hand, don't share that property: once said or viewed, you either heard the message, or you didn't. It is not ordinarily recorded or stored for any length of time. Of course, if a court ordered you to create voice or video recordings of video or audioconferences, you might be forced to comply. (I'm not sure what the law is here, but in a civil case, if the opposing party paid for the storage, the court might be more inclined to issue such an order, as long as it's not unduly burdensome.)