3 ms·
Matt Levine has talked a few times about the wild scope increase of records retention in finance over the past century or so in Money Stuff. Not exactly the sa
by loeg 4y ago
Matt Levine has talked a few times about the wild scope increase of records retention in finance over the past century or so in Money Stuff. Not exactly the same as a legal hold, but analogous for similar reasons (recording everything has become cheaper).
> We have talked before about the SEC’s probe into how the employees of big banks discussed their work in text messages and chat apps like WhatsApp on their personal cell phones. The SEC has collected big fines from the biggest banks because, it has said, these chats violated the SEC’s recordkeeping requirements.
...
> From the perspective of the banks, I have argued, this is a novel expansion of the SEC’s authority. When the SEC created its rules on recordkeeping, it required banks to retain copies of their “inter-office memoranda,” but it was 1948 and those memoranda were produced with carbon paper; they were formal business records memorializing serious policies. In the 2020s, WhatsApp chats are, in large part, substitutes not for formal memoranda but for talking to someone in person. When I was a banker, I have written, “There were some mornings when I sent more than 100 inter-office memoranda, though like 20 of them would be ‘lol’ or ‘fml.’” In 1948, the SEC would not have dreamed of demanding a searchable archive of all of the informal chats held at a brokerage: That was not technologically feasible, and also did not seem to be the point of its rules. In 2022, it was feasible, and the SEC did demand it, and when the brokers were missing some chats they paid a billion dollars in fines.
> ...
> It really is wild that the SEC’s official position is now that it is illegal to “use unofficial communications to do things like cut deals, win clients or make trades.” “Conduct their communications about business matters within only official channels”! Imagine if that was really the rule! You can’t have lunch with a client and talk about business, or have beers with your colleagues and gripe about work, because that does not create a searchable archive for the SEC to review.
> Of course the SEC does not entirely mean this. Yet. But in like five years, technology — and the SEC’s interpretation of the rules — will have advanced to the point that banks will get fined if their bankers talk about business with clients on the golf course.
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-02-02/the-sec-wants-to-see-more-phones https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-02-02/the-se...
- lovich 4y ago>> It really is wild that the SEC’s official position is now that it is illegal to “use unofficial communications to do things like cut deals, win clients or make trades.” “Conduct their communications about business matters within only official channels”! Imagine if that was really the rule! You can’t have lunch with a client and talk about business, or have beers with your colleagues and gripe about work, because that does not create a searchable archive for the SEC to review. The alternative interpretation is that now that it has become technologically feasible to record and search such the breadth of these conversations, it’s now illegal to try and conduct business via a channel that is opaque to the regulators. Does having informal conversations have any downside for the companies other than knowing that regulators can pull the conversations information when analyzing if the banks broke regulations? This data isn’t available to their competitors or anything, right? If that’s the case then as a citizen I’m totally behind the SEC enforcing these kinds of decisions. I’d like to make it a formal rule if it’s not already.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThey don’t apply it to voice communication, and it’s very feasible to store them. Ever since the Nixon tapes in the 70s, the government has shied away from applying this requirement to audio for some reason, maybe because it would come back to bite them as it did for Nixon.
- lucb1e 4y agoMakes me very curious what the judge had to say about that opinion because this all makes sense, and I can't imagine that "a billion dollars in fines" was not fought over in court regardless of what they thought the odds of winning were (almost a no-brainer to blow ¼ million on lawyers for a chance of reducing or striking a 1000 million fine).
- ohgodplsno 4y ago>It really is wild that the SEC’s official position is now that it is illegal to “use unofficial communications to do things like cut deals, win clients or make trades.” “Conduct their communications about business matters within only official channels”! Imagine if that was really the rule! You can’t have lunch with a client and talk about business, or have beers with your colleagues and gripe about work, because that does not create a searchable archive for the SEC to review. If we were talking about pretty much almost any other sector, that would indeed be wild, but considering how often and how much the banking sector has shown that they are willing to break every rule imaginable, they can't really complain when the hammer falls down on them, can they ? Act like a mafia, get treated like a mafia.
- loeg 4y ago> the banking sector has shown that they are willing to break every rule imaginable I think the visible outcome of the banking sector being subject to lots of fines for technical rule violations is less a symptom of the banking sector being uniquely bad and a more a symptom of (a) just having more rules and (b) being under more scrutiny than other sectors.
- dan-robertson 4y agoIf you apply it to any other sector, I think there aren’t rules and regulators that issue large fines to enforce them. Eg if there were a ‘big tech regulator’ that had rules on record keeping like in finance, this google thing would be resulting in some regulatory action and big fine. I think it’s interesting to wonder what other industries might look like with regulators that are more like financial regulators.
- hnbear 4y agoFor anyone interested in the language, it’s called Rule 17a4, and you can see it here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/17/240.17a-4 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/17/240.17a-4 It’s got a long list of things to keep, some specific and some very general. It’s pretty detailed in terms of what and how you need to retain records, which is useful to implement, but includes enough language like “or analogous..” to make it flexible to enforce.