6 ms·
>Meanwhile, Taiwan’s value to the Chinese diaspora can’t be understated—it’s a bastion of a mandarin-speaking democracy. A bastion of democracy which has been
by coldtea 4y ago
>Meanwhile, Taiwan’s value to the Chinese diaspora can’t be understated—it’s a bastion of a mandarin-speaking democracy.
A bastion of democracy which has been a right wing dictatorship from its inception until the 90s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Terror_(Taiwan) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Terror_(Taiwan)
- daemoens 4y agoSo it's still a bastion of democracy?
- coldtea 4y agoNo, it's just an ex-dictatorship with a progress towards a democracy and skeletons in its closet...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fortuna86 4y agoYou aren't refuting what he's saying you're just trying to change the subject.
- coupdejarnac 4y agoThis guy pops up in many China threads to regurgitate CCP talking points.
- coldtea 4y agoYeah, god forbid somebody doesn't have the US viewpoint on foreign policy and other countries, especially given its excellent track record and how it has fucked up one country after another for a century! Anybody having different opinions must be burned to the stake!
- fortuna86 4y agoI don't believe anyone is saying that. Reasonable objection is fine. However the reductio ad absurdum tactic you employ to dismiss pointing out actual problematic behavior is typical of trolling itself. My opinion? I don't think that's an accident.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> A bastion of democracy which has been a right wing dictatorship from its inception until the 90s. The 1990s being, well, not now, the correct conjugation is either “was” or “had been”, not “has been”. Which relates directly to why its irrelevant.
- coldtea 4y ago"That was then and this is now" is not how it works in such transitions (and after such wide-ranging power and influence of the far right, and such bad blood from the murders and torture). Not any more than it worked for the blacks after 1865 (or 1964 for that matter), to give an example from US history. Hell, it took decades even for post-WWII Germany to shake the ex-Nazi-high-ranking influence in its politics, media, finances, and so on, and the Nazi rule was just 12 years, and they had far more horribleness and more shame as a motive to stomp out those elements after 1945... The same has been true in post-Franco Spain, and any other place with such history.
- def_true_false 4y agoKeep in mind Germany had to deal with the Soviet threat at the same time. Sadly, the communist influence there will take a few more decades to stomp out. Things seem to have worked out fine for Central and Eastern European post-communist countries. Also Portugal, Greece.
- seszett 4y agoThe 90s are now thirty years ago, and Taiwan has undisputably been a functioning democracy since then.
- ninjin 4y agoIt is difficult to get distances in time into my own mind. But for those other than me reading this and having trouble with this mentally. The first democratically elected president in Taiwan in 1996, which was arguably a high point in the democratisation process, is now in 2023 temporally equidistant to the moon landing in 1969 and us in the present.
- coldtea 4y agoIt's also difficult for societies with populations absorbed deep into their private sphere, with very little feeling for history, how developments 30, 50, or even 100 and 200 years still leave all kinds of traces and influences, materialized in attitudes, political affiliations, laws, and so on. History is not a "that was back in the day, doesn't matter anymore" affair.
- ninjin 4y agoYour response feels largely tangential to the point I was making: That the 90s feel closer in history than they really are (especially to those of us that “were there”). It also feels like a borderline attack, implying that I and others are somehow “absorbed deep into their private sphere, with very little feeling for history”. Pretty odd to make a statement like that in response to someone who you know next to nothing about, no? If you want to contribute to a good debate and hope to bring me around to your point of view, I would ask that you try harder.
- coldtea 4y ago>Your response feels largely tangential to the point I was making: That the 90s feel closer in history than they really are (especially to those of us that “were there”). Well, either the point you were making was even more tangential to what was in this thread - a general observation unrelated to what we were discussing, or (as I read it), aside from the literal point, there was a deeper implicit point pertinent to what was discussed. In this case, I wrote something along the line of "as close as year X, Y was the case", so your response can be read as: "you might think this date is close and thus events from that era still matter, but we tend to overlook how close a period in living memory is, so they matter less than you think". >Pretty odd to make a statement like that in response to someone who you know next to nothing about, no It wasn't writing about you, it even explicitly writes "it's difficult for societies with populations (...)". I was writing about a cultural difference. Certain cultures got it lucky and didn't have much history of the sort to concern with, and so don't have much of a historical perspective (and how history affects the present). It's easier to have that perspective when you have had huge events like wars, dictatorships, and so on in your local livable history, than when you just read about those in the media (if many even do much of that).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hayst4ck 4y agoI watched a Taiwanese election in Taiwan. I observed their polling stations. A Taiwanese citizen started a conversation and educated me, an American, on democracy and elections. This Taiwanese person told me that elections are for the loser. If the loser does not believe in the validity of the election, it serves no purpose. That's why electronic voting machines are anti-thetical to the purpose of an election. Electronic voting machines exchange trust for a more efficient election. That is why Taiwan does not use electronic voting machines. That is a pretty impressive insight that was absent from my American civic education. I was very impressed with the civic education in Taiwan, and I was impressed with the average level of education in Taipei. My subjective experience as an American was that Democracy is more healthy in Taiwan than it is in America.
- scrubs 4y agoFor the loser? That's like the mob's take on what practical operational control means. >My subjective experience as an American was that Democracy is more healthy in Taiwan than it is in America. Cause why?
- plaguuuuuu 4y agoI don't live in Taiwan but my impressions - people are a lot more engaged with politics, general political knowledge and awareness is higher, voter turnout is higher - all of these may be as a result of the ever-looming threat of being subsumed by the mainland, but also maybe an enthusiasm for democracy since it's relatively new to the country! Taiwan has its issues with first past the post voting, quality of news media and control of media (eg by sketchy foreign corporations) and conga line of infotainment propaganda outlets. There's a big economic incentive in reunificiation for some actors which perverts politics and discourse to an extent. But to be honest.. America is currently a really low bar for democracy in the first place (speaking as someone living outside USA as well)
- scrubs 4y agoThanks for the feedback. For example, the US Congress really could use some of the technical bureaucratic competence I hear Taiwan has. US institutions are in post-WWII lows right now, which is like a moist, dark, sugary place for attracting larger-than-life-personalities to no ultimate good. As one smart guy wrote, there's three kinds of power: tradition, institutions, and personality. My coralary: weak institutions attract strong personality. See the other conversation re: China & Taiwan below. It'd be a shame to see a good thing go away.
- Timpy 4y agoI'm not sure how that's relevant, a quick look on Wikipedia and they are number 1 in Asia in terms of democracy index, number 10 worldwide. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index
- JCharante 4y agoIs self improvement not something to be applauded?
- timeon 4y ago> until the 90s. So was Czechoslovakia. What is your point?