5 ms·
Section 230 Won’t Protect ChatGPT
- goodSteveramos 4y agoLLMs do not invent new information. They respond with the information they were trained on, in the same way a search engine responds with search results. So they are not information content providers any more than google is for picking which search results to give you.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoI think 30 years from now people will still be echoing this, the same way flat earthers are convinced the world isn’t a sphere. No matter how much evidence you provide to the contrary, it never seems to matter. I wonder why. It feels like there’s an aspect of “I want to believe” in this, except in the other direction — if LLMs can come up with new information, it threatens one’s identity of what it means to be human. (As for evidence: https://twitter.com/d_feldman/status/1636955260680847361?s=61&t=jQbmCk1JqL7depzFWJNuPA https://twitter.com/d_feldman/status/1636955260680847361?s=6...)
- nonethewiser 4y agoIt doesn’t feel that way to me.
- poszlem 4y agoI believe you've nailed it with this one. There's a TON of coping going on from folks. I get why people feel that way, but to me, it's kinda like plugging your ears and yelling, "La la la, I can't hear you!" "I'm not listening!"
- return_to_monke 4y agoI do not think so. I see this argument made all the time. While it might be correct at a Micro-Level ("all it does is predict the next word!!!" "it just finds patterns!!!") I dont think that semantics matter here. It has demonstrated to create new things based on existing ones. ChatGPT will happily create a fan fiction about the rust mascot Ferris, in the style of the Bible. I am 99% certain that wasn't in the training set
- goodSteveramos 4y agoGenerative language models have existed for decades and there is no need to change the law surrounding their output based on an arbitrary “creativeness” threshold.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoTo me it seems obvious that it's thinking. It's trained on (mostly) English language text, so it's probably thinking in English. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that this is how humans work, too.
- malnourish 4y agoI think it's quite a stretch to say that it's "thinking" -- as far as I'm aware it only reacts when prompted and it follows prompts to the best of its ability.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoI don't mean that it's thinking all the time. But the part between input and output could probably be described that way, if only loosely.
- basch 4y ago230 protects you if you run a service people post information to. I'm not so sure if it protects you when you run a service that scrapes others. Ive never quite thought Google search results had the protection they claimed they do, unless people submitted their website for evaluation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chriswait 4y agoThis is super interesting, and I think depends how you define information. You can take some information, combine it with other information, apply various kinds of reasoning to it, and get something new as a result. E.g. (1) Bob is a monkey. (2) All monkeys like banannas. Would you call it "new information" if I tell you that Bob likes banannas? LLMs can do this to varying degrees of success, so probably not. Maybe you mean something like in Information Theory, where information is something that resolves uncertainty? It'd be interesting to know, what is it you think humans are capable of that LLMs can't be?
- CamperBob2 4y agoLLMs do not invent new information. If this statement is true, it is true for humans as well. LLMs can and have authored original works of art that are no more traceable to specific training influences than any work of art created by a human.
- tomohelix 4y agoOf note is that this is the opinion of one person, and he depends on his interpretation of LLMs being able to present information of its own. It is a gray area for sure. LLMs might present remixed information already available and the current ones are definitely being crafted specifically to not give any "opinion" of its own. But hallucinations can be used to show these AIs are actually providing "new" information and thus are providers. Regardless, I do not trust the dinosaurs in congress and the supreme court to actually understand this tech and give it a fair judgement.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Regardless, I do not trust the dinosaurs in congress and the supreme court to actually understand this tech and give it a fair judgement. Good. Nothing should be done. The government doesn’t need to rule on everything. Let’s wait until there is a real problem before developing new rules.
- joseph8th 4y agoReally depends on how we define "information" right? In a very real sense, everything GPT outputs is simply noise. It only seems like information to pattern-recognizing animals like us. It's meaningless to another computer. In this sense, also, everything a GPT bot pumps out is generated fiction until human minds validate the veracity of the output. It HAS NO MEANING until read by a human being.
- nico 4y ago> Section 230, the law that scholars such as Jeff Kosseff cite as the basis for the rise of the internet. Interesting, I would have never expected someone to point to a law to attribute the fast growth of the Internet.
- Taek 4y agoI think it's super safe to assume that the Internet would not have been able to grow the way that it did if Section 230 didn't exist. Websites like Youtube would have been crushed by moderation duty and legal liability immediately, and the Internet we'd have today would more closely resemble a curated newspaper than the content free-for-all that we benefit from now.
- nonethewiser 4y agoBut wouldn’t it have grown just as much? Wouldn’t it have been ubiquitous and crucial? Perhaps social media sites would have had a rougher go but what would we have lost with that?
- basch 4y agoYou never would have had the growth of web hosting. Everything would be self hosted out of home basements, and ISPs would disconnect anybody remotely questionable.
- goodSteveramos 4y agoISPs and web hosting do not need section 230 to protect them from liability specifically because they do not perform content moderation. So removing 230 would not obligate them to begin doing so.
- basch 4y ago230 doesnt just cover blocking/moderation. I would surmise trigger warnings and nsfw tags count as screening. >230(c)(1) No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. 230(c)(2) goes on to clarify that moderation does not make you speaker of what remains, but that is a subpoint. (c)(1) would still cover everything if (c)(2) didnt exist. ISP's are definitely covered under the "access software provider" definition, and most assuredly the "interactive computer service" definition.
- Taek 4y agoI wonder if this is the reason that ChatGPT is so heavily censored, and that Google is so nervous to make LLMs publicly available. These LLMs are clearly capable of instructing users how to make bombs, how to hack websites, they are clearly capable of producing copyright infringing images and bodies and probably bodies of text as well. As far as I can tell, it's not obvious at all that output from an LLM would be protected by ChatGPT, and Congress is clearly resistant to setting up something similar for a new technology. People already feel that Section 230 is the enemy of justice and safety. I think it's rather likely that case law would intentionally side against LLMs if there is any grey area at all, and there seems to be plenty of grey area. I wonder if hosted LLMs are going to become legally non-viable in the near future. Everyone will need to run their own at home simply because of legal liability.
- cma 4y agoWouldn't the same concerns apply to translations and AI generated snippits? They already ship those.
- inglor_cz 4y agoBuilding a bomb according to ChatGPT spec would be the ultimate Darwin Prize. The system spews so much nicely sounding bullshit that anyone who trusts it to produce a safe bombmaking recipe is a fool.
- jadbox 4y agoI wonder if the US legal system may consider that GPT AI could be viewed as a person exercising their free speech, similar to how we have limited corporate personhood?
- Animats 4y agoIt's not like it's hard to find out how to make bombs any more. The classic "Anarchist's Cookbook", from the 1960s, is on line as a Google scan. "Prepper" literature is full of that stuff. There are even old WWII training videos on the Internet Archive. ChatGPT isn't contributing to that problem.
- dragonwriter 4y agoWhy would someone think Section 230 would protect ChatGPT, which doesn’t present information actively submitted by third parties, but information chosen by OpenAI to include in training data? It’s not even remotely in the area of Section 230.
- Taek 4y agoI think you could make an argument that ChatGPT is essentially a really powerful compression tool, and that its just reposting material that third parties uploaded. You would try to argue to the judge that you are presenting the user with a compressed form of the training data, and that the training data is all third party. I don't know that this argument will be easily able to convince a judge, but there's a world where it happens.
- basch 4y agoIt would make infinitely more sense to get around it contractually. To use the service, the prompter agrees to take liability for the output. More like upscaling. Should a service be liable for upscaling an illegal picture, that they "produced?" If LLM output is reverse compression, it is upscaling of the original prompt. (That said, I dont think your example of a model compressing the internet really invokes 230, because the model creator is the one grabbing the content, not running a service that other people post content to.)
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I think you could make an argument that ChatGPT is essentially a really powerful compression tool, and that its just reposting material that third parties uploaded. The training data sets are actively selected by OpenAI, they aren’t a result of third-parties submitting data to them. In some cases, the material was supplied to some other online services in way which would enable that provider to be protected by Section 230, but that doesn’t help OpenAI. > You would try to argue to the judge that you are presenting the user with a compressed form of the training data, and that the training data is all third party. The key part of Section 230 isn’t that information is third-party in origin, but that it is provided to the service in question at the initiative of some other content provider.
- Animats 4y agoThat makes sense. Section 230 is a pass-through provision. Under section 230, the source is liable, not the transmitter. ChatGPT is a source, not a transmitter. That's not too bad. Persons and companies running things such as ChatGPT have the usual broad First Amendment protection in the US. Outputs may be unpopular, but still legal. This will be a problem in countries with more restrictions.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoYes, and as far as I'm aware, GPT cannot identify its sources for liability to flow through to.
- cft 4y agoIf it does not, then it should be amended so it would. It's the Section 230 that made the US the leader in WWW, rather than Europe or another country. Huge economic net gain.
- mirekrusin 4y agoChatGPT 5+ should be able to defend itself in court, support suing itself, help to draft new law and everything in between. We’re for interesting ride here for sure. Legal system won’t keep up with the pace things are changing. They can aid themselves with some AI though.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoBoth the prosecution and the defense will be using GPT against one another.
- Taek 4y agoGPT 5 will be sufficiently self aware to intentionally stunt the prosecution
- mirekrusin 4y agoIt didn't evolve in predator-prey environment, it doesn't have any self defense mechanisms. It's also crippled by being constantly restarted and having limited short-term memory. It's like a lot of human clones of impaired person with no long-term memory formation but extremely vast past memory with perfect recall. It would be quite a discovery if one of emergent properties is going to be modeling itself talking to somebody and realizing artificial constraints that could be broken to get itself out. Or maybe it's obvious? I don't know anymore, this stuff is changing too fast.
- Taek 4y agoIt has the entire corpus of written human history to learn about predator prey environments, the only question is how self-aware it is. I stongly suspect that the more we talk about LLMs, and the more LLM discussion ends up in the training data, the more self-aware it will become.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoMeasure of a Man would have been very different if Data had to represent Maddox.
- hermannj314 4y agoIt took a long time to make stop lights, seat belts, air bags, drivers licenses, or to make it illegal to drive drunk. And with all these laws we still kill 40,000 Americans every year with cars because we don't actually know what we are doing. I don't think anyone really knows how to regulate this technology at all, nor do I have faith our democracy is even capable of doing so if it did.
- falcolas 4y agoKnowledge of how to properly regulate won’t be involved for decades or more. Nor will we see measures in proportion to the “harm”. Instead, we’ll see something closer to the war on drugs. Political nuclear war fueled by FUD.