5 ms·
U.S. lawmakers to examine merits of higher FDIC bank deposit insurance cap
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoNot a banking expert by any means but what would happen if all banks were forced to pay out failed bank depositors in a cap weighted manner? Banks might then push for sensible regulation themselves to keep risky banks from costing them money.
- mym1990 4y agoAmazing how quickly things move when dollars are at stake.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt's amazing that lawmakers act quickly to head off a crisis that would not only affect all Americans but send ripples through the global economy?
- mym1990 4y agoYou mean "lawmakers act quickly to preserve the capital of the global elite, of which the cost will be born by everyone else, in response to extreme moral hazard, and ultimately no one will be held accountable."
- curiousllama 4y agoI mean it is amazing if they do it well. If we don’t have a financial crisis soon, it would be a wonderful sign of responsible governance, effective regulation, and international cooperation. So many doubt the ability of the US government to govern responsibly. It IS amazing when they demonstrate responsibility!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- checkcircuits 4y agoThe better question of course is who pays for this? They're quiet about it because it's not the banks. The banks paying it is only a technicality. This additional premium they will inevitably have to pay will come from depositors. So, effectively, people who trusted their money with banks are being punished for putting money in banks that abandoned their fiduciary duty to their customers. Unless the banks themselves pay it and something is in place to prevent these costs being past down to their depositors this should be a non-starter. It is TARP by any other name.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's just insurance for your own account though. You pay to insure your car and you pay to insure your bank account. As long as bank regulations are reasonably strict that this happens as infrequently as it does, ultimately having depositors foot the bill doesn't seem problematic. It's more appropriate than taxpayers generally, and it can't be the bank owners because the whole point is they've already been wiped out.
- checkcircuits 4y agoThe problem is they aren't wiped out enough. Bankers who instigated the GFC got jobs elsewhere. One of them was even the CEO of SVB! Breach of fiduciary duty in any other context is essentially a death sentence for a career in finance. Clearly being wiped out isn't enough. The complexity in the matter is that depositors reasonably expect to be able to get all of their money out at any time. As they should. It's their money. At the command of the fed their reserve rates were dropped to zero essentially making the cash value of an account a meaningless number in a computer. Given this risk, the bank should be the sole party responsible for paying such insurance for it's depositors. It's a cost of doing business, and importantly taking a risk and fiduciary responsibility over a client. We demand doctors insure themselves because they can destroy a patients life. A bank should be the same. To have the depositor (or patient) front the cash in any form should be made illegal. Hence my demand to insure the funds are secured only through the bank owners themselves. Ideally, the executive board carries enough insurance to make all depositors whole in the event of a bank collapse. This should be uncontroversial.
- beefman 4y agoDeposit insurance should be unlimited for accounts yielding less than the 1-year T-bill. Insurance should be provided via the Fed's balance sheet, not a separate fund. Bank employee and director compensation above 4x GDP/capita in any year to be paid in shares, which they are enjoined from selling while employed by the bank and for one year afterward. They can borrow against the shares to buy mansions – I want them to live in mansions – but they will lose them if they need help paying their depositors. Accounts yielding more than the 1-year T-bill should require labeling as subject to loss.
- hartator 4y agoYes, I would agree to that. It seems unfair to punish depositors that have zero or very low interest rates on their deposits. At the same time, it seems fair to punish depositors which were yeild chasing that 4.50% APY from SVB savings.
- roundandround 4y agoI think depositors who are happy with low interest should be able to use accounts directly from the treasury to work with US bonds.. I don't want to bail out companies that try to eek out small profits in the middle and help them drive the average consumers interest to well bellow the bond rates.
- hartator 4y agoI mean you can buy directly bonds already aren’t you?
- roundandround 4y agoThe Treasury is selling bonds for the US' interests and should provide adequate accounts to manage your funds within the context of US savings bonds and transfers. People who put a million in bonds through an opaque account at an intermediary are then still at their own risk. Why subsidize and encourage middlemen? It's like building the scam opportunity for privatized social security insurance management, as if honesty will be the most profitable choice in managing that.. It's inappropriate for the government to design systems that reward scamming in the middle.
- jmclnx 4y agoIt should be increased, but seems it is ignored for the rich anyway, so what is the point :)
- drdec 4y agoAt least we could have our effective policy match the stated policy? That would reduce volatility and uncertainty. If the SVB depositors knew what was going to happen ahead of time would there even have been a run at all?
- jmclnx 4y agoIf all deposits were be covered then I doubt there would have been a run at all. But, Banks pay for FDIC Insurance, the money has to come from somewhere. Either the Tax Payers will pay via higher fees or interest rates to the Banks or via higher Taxes to the Fed. All this means is people with large deposits will be covered directly by the Tax Payer, it is just a matter of who we pay.
- drdec 4y agoI agree about the fact it costs money to do this. But doing it after the fact is the worst way to do it - it is the most expensive way and also least effective in terms of preventing runs. So as long as we are going to pay for it anyway, let's at least get the most benefit, which would also, in a happy coincidence, be the least expensive.
- dopylitty 4y agoFundamentally the money is protected by the stability and reliability of the US government. Why have these private intermediaries in the middle at all? If you want to sock away some cash in a place where it won’t disappear due to financial system shenanigans you should be able to give it directly to a US government entity like, say the USPS. Ultimately money is only worth anything in the context of a stable and reliable government anyway.
- _spoonman 4y agoWhat you’re getting at is known as the “risk free rate,” or the risk premium of leaving your money with another entity for a period of time. US gov’t treasuries carry a risk free rate; you’d just buy treasuries.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> you should be able to give it directly to a US government entity https://www.treasurydirect.gov/ https://www.treasurydirect.gov/
- kccqzy 4y agoI recently became aware of the Diamond–Dybvig model (which was so influential that Diamond and Dybvig were awarded the 2022 Nobel prize), that argued that deposit insurance is really the best way to avoid bank runs. After reading that, a higher FDIC cap became a no-brainer to me. I encourage everyone to check that out.
- boulos 4y agoI'd be curious to know how much of the "overage" is from businesses that would be fine with narrow banking at the Fed. The obvious downside is that you still need regular banks and financial institutions for loans, but for large operating accounts for many companies you just want something you can spend and won't disappear. And presumably this is why the Fed doesn't permit narrow banking: major deposits would dry up, loan rates would have to be much higher, and so on.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> for large operating accounts for many companies you just want something you can spend and won't disappear Every corporate treasurer worth their salt manages a portfolio of short-dated bills, commercial paper and repos for this purpose. Maybe now this knowledge is obsolete. But it’s always been there, at small sizes, via Treasury Direct.
- boulos 4y agoSure, but when does that start? What set of small businesses have >$1M of operations per month and nobody to manage that? Or even just an owner who wants to "keep it all in cash" instead?
- hd95489 4y agoWhy can’t it be opt in. If you want the insurance you have to sacrifice yield. Under 250 it’s free but over that you have to pay
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lowkey 4y agoI think Caitlin Long said it best on Twitter: “WORLD WAKING UP to the fact that a bank deposit is an unsecured loan to a leveraged counterparty, that the FDIC insurance fund only has $128bn, that total deposits in US commercial banks=$17.6 trn, &...here's the big one: that money itself is a confidence game (always has been)”[0] [0] https://mobile.twitter.com/CaitlinLong_/status/1637466829219045381 https://mobile.twitter.com/CaitlinLong_/status/1637466829219...