15 ms·
Learning the ropes: why Germany is building risk into its playgrounds (2021)
- yazzku 4y agoConsidering our species used to send children into dark caves as a rite of passage and the way things are now, this is probably for the best. "Parents can try to keep up with their young mountaineers as they ascend through the rope spiderweb, but they might get left behind in the tightly woven mesh." Like Instagram and TikTok, but with real safety guarantees.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Considering our species used to send children into dark caves as a rite of passage Is this a reference to Victorians sending kids into coal mines to die of back lung, or something else? As a bonus, the tunnels didn't need to be so large.
- yazzku 4y agoI was talking about prehistoric ages.
- mpweiher 4y ago"... it’s the strict policing of standards that enables a risk-accepting culture in the first place." Doesn't just apply to playgrounds.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoWhere what and how much risk matters. A kid falling off of a playground -- kids are small, falls don't hurt them as much -- has a lot less risk than changing a traffic pattern and having an F-150 slam into another vehicle. Or having banks get greedy and collapse the economy. Risks also require safety nets. Otherwise you're just screwing your people over.
- mpweiher 4y ago> Risks also require safety nets. Which is exactly what the piece said.
- moron4hire 4y agoWe've had a couple of playgrounds like this near where I live here in Virginia for a number of years. They're not very old, but certainly older than 2021.
- zabzonk 4y agoI don't know, kids these days. You should have seen what we had to contend with in the 60s - huge lumps of flesh mangling metal, swinging at terrifying angles, throwing small children off in all directions. And no wimpy rubber mats to catch them. Sometimes, I wonder that I survived.
- 123pie123 4y agoreminds me of when I was a kid in the UK, there was these places that was called 'funhouses' where kids was supposed to play, I was seriously terrified of dying. I'm unsure if it's my memory and/or if I was just too young
- swimfar 4y agoI've heard stories from relatives about a funhouse like that on Coney Island. Supposedly there was a dark maze section with clowns that would walk around and shock you. As I got older I assumed some of it had to be made up. But at least part of the story is corroborated in this article about the Steeplechase Park: https://www.westland.net/coneyisland/articles/steeplechase2.htm https://www.westland.net/coneyisland/articles/steeplechase2....
- 123pie123 4y agothanks - I wonder how many unrecorded near deaths or injuries there where - I'm assuming back then if you complained you was classed as a coward - different world!
- zabzonk 4y agodon't know about funhouse, but playgrounds were very scary. the most scary one, which would intimadate a brave man (amongst whom i was living - RAF pilots) was called "the boat" (if i remember correctly) which was a steel plank (which you sat on), supported by 4 steel struts, attached, swiveling, to a steel frame. it took some effort to get this monster swinging (like sitting on a normal swing and doing the stuff you do) but once it got going the momentum was tremendous. there was limiting mechanism to stop it going over the top. most kids too terrified to ride it to that point (humiliating admission: i was too scared). the other scary thing you could do with it was to grab hold of the plank on the up-swing, which would boost you high in the air. you had to have a nice touch of judgement on where you let go, if you didn't want multiple broken bones.
- hirundo 4y agoThey are lowering the long term risk of too little short term risk, an unsafe excess of safety. This is a kind of behavioral hormesis. The dose/response curve of a potential toxin is seldom linear, including for jungle gyms.
- _Microft 4y agoThere were some comments in a 2021 submission, among them one with links to a manufacturer’s website that has good pictures of playground structures. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28978056 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28978056
- janmarsal 4y agoI remember when I was a teen I started noticing how the nanny state had managed to remove all the old swings I used to play with and replaced them with some tiny and safe swings that no one even uses anymore. Children even started wearing yellow safety vests to school all of a sudden. I'm glad there's at least some backlash to this nonsense.
- themitigating 4y agoWhat state manages playground equipment?
- leipert 4y agoMany, if not most, public playgrounds are maintained by the city or municipality in Germany. Here in a larger city they are checked and cleaned weekly.
- themitigating 4y agoSo not the state?
- leipert 4y agoDepends on your definition of state. If you really want to dig into it: The country, Germany, or a federal state like Bavaria, likely not directly but indirectly, due to how our tax system works. Different entities collect different taxes, but the cities and municipalities get a certain percentage of wage and sales tax for example. Often those taxes are not bound to be used for a certain purpose. But also we have city-states liked Berlin or Hamburg, and those directly fund and maintain their playgrounds.
- sircastor 4y ago“The state” is a generic term that refers to the government, local, provincial, or larger.
- themitigating 4y agoChildren don't know better and getting hurt isn't always the best way to learn because their could be permanent consequences
- leipert 4y agoI don’t know. Our kid frequents these playgrounds and it’s interesting to see how the usage changes over time. The kid quite frequently signals when it thinks something is too high or a slide to steep or whatever. And most kids seem to be rather cautious.
- mpsprd 4y agoA friend of mine, PhD in early childhood education, told me the contrary: Toddlers instinctively know their limits and will not "bite more than they can chew", at least with gross motor skills. My personal experience confirms this: for example, when teaching my young kid of 18mo to climb down stairs standing, I would stop holding his hands and observe his behavior. He would initially try to go down a step on his feet while holding the side rail, then hesitate and ask for my hand. If I told him to do it himself, he would instead sit down and slide down gently.
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- Fricken 4y agoThere could be permanent consequences either way. Children of overprotective parents tend to live less: https://neurosciencenews.com/overprotective-parents-child-longevity-22453/ https://neurosciencenews.com/overprotective-parents-child-lo...
- swimfar 4y agoIt doesn't look like they are building risk into the playgrounds, as much as they are building the feeling of risk. which isn't necessarily a bad thing. This seems like a compromise that should be seen as better, or at least acceptable to both extremes of parents. "The maximum fall height in the Triitopia structure’s spiderweb is 1.8 metres." That's not a risky fall, if you're falling onto a rope net. Also, "The Triitopia tower is encased with boards and netting to ensure no child can take a tumble from a height above three metres." Kids used to climb on the outside and on top of tall playground structures like that. But they're making sure this much more difficult to attempt. This is not a criticism, just my observations.
- fsckboy 4y agoi wonder if it will be discovered as fun to "base-jump" into the net
- mschuster91 4y agoNot really, as you will notice and learn that the ropes are damn stiff and have metal ties to form the grid.
- germinalphrase 4y agoIn the US, my experience with this style of rope structure is that the ropes are actually steep cables encases in fiber or nylon rope sheathing. There is no stretch, so landings are immediate (unlike falling onto an actual rope net).
- schoen 4y agoI think I've seen that too; why are they made this way? Durability? Supporting more people's weight at once?
- mschuster91 4y agoSame shit as some commercial residential developments here in Germany have: wrong metrics. Like, when the builders' metric is "must last for 20 years at minimal maintenance effort and legal risk", you get radically different results (barely fulfilling the legal definition of playground, no one uses it) than if the metric is "out of the X potential users in the 200m surrounding the playground, Y% use it frequently". The latter costs more money in construction and upkeep.
- chmod775 4y agoThese things are ubiquitous in Berlin: https://stage.berliner-seilfabrik.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/BSF-Viersen_0KB2524-1-1440x1080.jpg https://stage.berliner-seilfabrik.com/wp-content/uploads/201... They're not actually that high to an adult, but I have childhood memories of these seeming somewhat tall and scary. On an average one, a young child can fall 4-6 times their own height (but not straight, you'll get buffered by the structure as you go down).
- LeanderK 4y agoI think common in whole germany, but maybe not ubiquitous. I certainly remember them well and in my imagination they were giant!
- moonchrome 4y ago> They're not actually that high to an adult Not the ones we have here in Croatia : https://fastly.4sqi.net/img/general/width960/57918118_91NXEEss2dW6sct-CwdV88KoTG2DPdt6ft4gdMwWHks.jpg https://fastly.4sqi.net/img/general/width960/57918118_91NXEE...
- rollcat 4y agoIs this Bundek? I love the place
- Aulig 4y agoLooks very similar to one we have in Karlsruhe, Germany :) https://mein.toubiz.de/api/v1/media/6d3f180e-13b0-4346-b142-2861ea12745a/preview?format=image/jpeg&width=1900 https://mein.toubiz.de/api/v1/media/6d3f180e-13b0-4346-b142-...
- nixass 4y agoThen there's this in Zagreb (Maksimir), which wasn't intended for climbing ever, but we as kids certainly did it https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/61/Park_Maksimir_pozornica_Zagreb.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/61/Park_Mak...
- PoignardAzur 4y ago
- mschuster91 4y agoTo add to the submission: I think there is one huge part why this is possible in the first place compared to the US, and the article just barely scrapes onto it: insurance. Like, when a kid gets injured here in Germany, mandatory healthcare insurance picks up the cost, and even if the maintainer can be held liable it's a few thousand euros in damages ("Schmerzensgeld") at most. In contrast, in the US healthcare insurances try to avoid paying up however possible, including shit such as forcing people to sue their family for healthcare cost. A paranoidly risk-averse society is the only thing that this can end up.
- fnomnom 4y ago>and even if the maintainer can be held liable and thats a big IF. i dont think i ever heard of something like this happening in my circle
- chopin 4y ago>Like, when a kid gets injured here in Germany, mandatory healthcare insurance picks up the cost, and even if the maintainer can be held liable it's a few thousand euros in damages ("Schmerzensgeld") at most. I am not so sure about this. It's true that the health insurers come up for the cost. But at least in cases where injury is due to a fight, they come after you for the money ("Durchgriffshaftung"). I would assume that if the maintainer failed its duties in a negligent manner, they (indirectly) would be held liable.
- andrewfromx 4y agoThis makes me think of this article https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/04/hey-parents-leave-those-kids-alone/358631/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/04/hey-par... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14241813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14241813
- ndsipa_pomu 4y ago>A sign urges parents to take off their children’s cycle helmets in order to eliminate a strangulation risk. That's ironic - PPE that becomes dangerous in a different environment.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoAnother example: there's a reason the security briefing on airplanes tells you to not inflate the vest while still inside the cabin.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoAlso helicopters. There used to be a gentleman who gave the mandatory safety briefing before taking guests from Lundy Island by helicopter (the only travel option in winter months) who would make the point that if one person inflates their vest, the other passengers would lemming-like inflate their vests and then you suddenly find the cabin is filled with 5 or 6 inflated people that have no chance of getting out of the door. He always used to joke that the whistle was to amuse yourself until the coastguard arrived.
- paleogizmo 4y agoAnother common example: don't wear safety gloves when working with rotating equipment, as they can catch and drag one's hand in
- ip26 4y agoHelmets in particular have tremendous specificity, which is fascinating. Bicycle, ski, and motorcycle helmets have MIPS. Motorcycle helmets have chin guards. Bicycle helmets have side impact protection. Climbing helmets have puncture resistance and top impact protection. Ski helmets have puncture resistance and coverage close to a motorcycle helmet, but less cushion. I’m sure the list is long for hard hats as well. Kids helmets have started to show up with breakaway neck straps- the strap only need be so strong to prevent the helmet from slipping off in a crash.
- texec 4y agoFor workplace protection helmets there are two European norms: EN 12492 for climbers and mountaineers requires >50kg holding force on the chin strap, to not come loose in case of a fall. EN 397 for industrial hard hats (on the ground) require chin straps to open on <25kg, to protect the wearer from strangulation in case of a fall.
- magicalhippo 4y agoSomeone I know designed playgrounds. One of his core concepts was that there's two aspects to safety. One is subjective. Like when you're high up and you see the ground beneath you, you know it'll hurt if you fall down, so you're more careful moving around. Then there's all the hidden dangers that kids don't think about or see[1], like a small gap where a cord from the clothing can get attached potentially leading to suffocation. The point being, the first aspect is something the kids should be able to expose themselves to. It teaches them about risk, but also can give them a goal and a sense of achievement when they finally dare to do something and succeed. His point was that this is an important part of their development, which could have knock-on effects later. However the playground should be designed such that any accident should not lead to permanent injury or death. Sure they might get a bit banged up if they misjudge, lesson hopefully learned, but nothing permanent. He was often in Germany to study their playgrounds for inspiration, and this article illustrates nicely why. [1]: https://www.utdanningsnytt.no/barnehage-grunnskole-leker/her-er-de-seks-alvorligste-feilene-pa-norske-lekeplasser/186250 https://www.utdanningsnytt.no/barnehage-grunnskole-leker/her...
- tunnuz 4y agoVery interesting, I never thought of safety that way. Thanks for sharing this.
- jl6 4y agoThere’s a broader lesson here about finding ways to teach kids to handle minor failures in a consequence-capped environment.
- youainti 4y agoYep. I like to think of the statement "A controlled failure is often a success".
- ccppurcell 4y agoWhen teaching kids to juggle, it is useful to say: a touch is as good as a catch
- lynx23 4y agoIt is hard to explain, but this headline makes me sad, very sad. Not because german children are supposedly put at risk, not at all... It is the tone of finger pointing. Risk is what eventually makes us grow. A totally risk free world/life would be utterly worthless living, and perhaps a reason to attempt suicide.
- nonethewiser 4y agoGood point. Makes me think of the complete lack of suicide in more primitive cultures.
- WJW 4y agoThat's simply untrue. Suicide among the Greeks and Romans was at least prevalent enough to have laws written about it (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_suicide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_suicide) and suicide among samurai was also certainly non-zero. If those examples are not "primitive" enough, already in 1894 Steinmetz collated an extensive list of at least forty-two documented cases of suicide amongst what he terms "savage peoples" like the "Polar peoples, North American Indians, Bedouins, Polynesians and native races of British India". Many of the terms he uses would be frowned upon today, but the article is available for free at https://www.jstor.org/stable/658295 https://www.jstor.org/stable/658295 and clearly documents many cases of suicide even in societies untouched by Western ideas. It's quite the list, from women killing themselves for "unrequited love" to adulterers committing suicide out of fear of repercussions. In fact he concludes that suicide may even be more prevalent in primitive cultures, relative to the size of the population, because some of those societies did not seem to have a stigma or taboo against suicide (unlike western civilizations where it is/was a sin).
- t344344 4y agoPlaygrounds in Germany (and EU) are pretty safe. Child may fall, but there are no sharp corners, and ground is covered with grovel or rubber.
- tanekloc 4y agoBuilding risk into playgrounds so that no adult German ever takes risks and has insurance for every case :)
- fs111 4y agohow do you think Allianz got so big? ;)
- wnevets 4y agoIs anyone else like me and just sick & tired of the boomerification of the public discourse? There isn't anything more wrong with kids these days compared to previous generations. Participation trophies didn't matter, foam playgrounds didn't create "soft" kids. Its all non-sense. "What is happening to our young people? They disrespect their elders, they disobey their parents. They ignore the law. They riot in the streets, inflamed with wild notions. Their morals are decaying. What is to become of them?" - Plato
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoWould you dismiss any evidence of generational changes in the way children are raised, in the aggregate? Or that changes in the way children are raised don’t affect the child?
- wnevets 4y agoI would love to see evidence that showed a measurable difference of an adult's behavior or personality based on the playground (or trophy policy) they grew up with.
- magicalhippo 4y agoFrom what I know there's a fair bit of research linking improved motor skills and social skills with later academic performance. Here are some quotes from a review article[1]: Research presented in this section indicates that removing play from early childhood classrooms may actually undermine intended achievement-oriented outcomes. Play enhances attention, memory, self-regulation, and overall academic achievement throughout childhood. In short, physical play is necessary for learning. Young children’s motor development has been found to be a powerful predictor of cognitive abilities in the elementary years. A good playground will be exciting and thus promote spontaneous play, a creative process, and it will be challenging which help kids develop their motor skills. A bad playground will be dull and lack challenges, thus not making kids develop those skills in the same way. Thus it seems quite likely that the quality of the playgrounds available at their kindergarten, school and local area can have an effect into adulthood. [1]: https://www.easternct.edu/center-for-early-childhood-education/about-us/publications-documents/benefits-of-play-lit-review.pdf https://www.easternct.edu/center-for-early-childhood-educati...
- auggierose 4y agoThis is nothing new. These exist in Germany since at least 1985, and can be pretty high. Source: Climbed on them. Never fell.
- dang 4y agoRelated: Germany is building risk into its playgrounds - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28978056 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28978056 - Oct 2021 (6 comments)
- daverol 4y agoThese people are amateurs: The USA lead the way: https://clickamericana.com/topics/family-parenting/life-for-kids/dangerous-old-playgrounds-our-great-grandparents-somehow-survived https://clickamericana.com/topics/family-parenting/life-for-...
- dllthomas 4y agoI remember playing on this as a child: https://playgroundology.wordpress.com/2018/06/29/whats-in-a-name-or-the-spinny-thing-of-death/ https://playgroundology.wordpress.com/2018/06/29/whats-in-a-... Mixed feelings about it being unavailable to my children.
- tda 4y agoI remember when my kids were younger they always had difficulty climbing onto the cooler play structures. Somehow the first few steps of the entrance are the most difficult. So I just had to help them get on and they would be fine. At first this annoyed me a bit, but later I realized that this must be intentional; if the kid manages to get in/on the play structure in the first place, they'll probably be fine. If they fall when trying to get on it, they fall in the sand so also no problem. Only the kids with some physical ability are able to reach some height, the smallest have to stay on the ground
- groestl 4y agoCame here to post this. I noticed as well, the first step is always adjusted to the target age group. So when he was smaller, my kid couldn't get into the structures that were not meant for him, but year after year more stuff became accessible. There were also structures with multiple difficulty levels at once, and different entrance obstacles tuned to them. Pretty neat I must say.
- Moru 4y agoI always expected this to be the case, everything designed with some sort of safety aspect for kid playgrounds. Until I was in one of those indoor playground companies where you pay an entrance fee. I was climbing around with my three year old daughter when we ended up at the top of the structure. There was a big sign with lots of text that a three year old can't read. It said something about four meter vertical drop slide. There were no hard places where I had to help her up to get up to this point. Luckily I'm not a very trusting parent. This place was later shut down because of lots of safety issues. Their defence was that they are a Café, not a kids playground. Weird even for swedish standards.
- sdwr 4y agoNever noticed this, that's fantastic design!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- globalise83 4y agoAll well and good, but the children in our local playground in Germany climb the nearby trees overlooking the risk-engineered playground, reaching heights of around 5 metres while standing on branches less than 1cm thick!
- gammarator 4y agoI saw some of this German company’s equipment in Memphis, Tennessee—very cool, and quite different from most U.S. playgrounds: https://www.richter-spielgeraete.de/en/playground-equipment/products/ https://www.richter-spielgeraete.de/en/playground-equipment/...
- qwertox 4y agoCrazy, this is one of their main playgrounds they are responsible for: https://www.garten-landschaft.de/guenter-beltzig-nachruf/ https://www.garten-landschaft.de/guenter-beltzig-nachruf/ The page is an obituary because the designer died in December. The video is in English.
- marton78 4y agoReally interesting. However, the Black Forest is not in the Bavarian Alps.
- 6_6_6 4y agotoo little too late
- dayjaby 4y agoMe as a 31 year old I climbed exactly this one with my young nephews. Berlin Frohnau is a very rich part of Berlin, so finding this quality of playgrounds is not that typical in Germany.
- paganel 4y agoUntil recently we still had a concrete-made children slide [1] here in Romania, built in pure brutalist style back in the '60s. There was also one built in my home-town, and I guess in other towns throughout Eastern Europe. There's no way anything like that could ever get built again, and yet, we managed to don't kill ourselves as kids when we were sliding on them. [1] https://www.cotidianul.ro/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/19/tobogan-copii-loc-joaca.ky9oxc617j-1000x600.jpg https://www.cotidianul.ro/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/19/tobo...
- EGreg 4y agoCompare to USA in the early 1900s: https://www.vintag.es/2017/02/how-we-came-to-play-pictures-of-kids.html https://www.vintag.es/2017/02/how-we-came-to-play-pictures-o...
- tomaskafka 4y agoPrague here, happy to have this: https://maps.app.goo.gl/eEcKTe5rfNxr7he77 https://maps.app.goo.gl/eEcKTe5rfNxr7he77 Was I scared a bit climbing this with my kids? Yes. Was it an awesome day? Hell, yeah, and returning there soon!
- barathr 4y agoMy favorite example of a classic super dangerous and fun park: Dennis the Menace park in Monterey, CA: https://playgroundology.wordpress.com/category/dennis-the-menace-playground/ https://playgroundology.wordpress.com/category/dennis-the-me... There was a full size real steam locomotive that kids could climb inside, under, and through, and strange spinning things made of steel that were far off the ground that you could old get on by jumping off a concrete wall onto it.
- pavelstoev 4y agoWe have these in Florida, USA and I have seen these types in Ontario, Canada where I am from originally.
- tony-allan 4y agoA great example in Australia — "Rocks on Wheels" https://theconversation.com/this-new-risky-playground-is-a-work-of-art-and-a-place-for-kids-to-escape-their-mollycoddling-parents-193218 https://theconversation.com/this-new-risky-playground-is-a-w... https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-11-07/risk-play-playground-city-of-melbourne-not-dangerous-safe/101622592 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-11-07/risk-play-playground-...
- dmn322 4y ago“We are not trying to avoid every broken leg possible.” Spoken like someone in s country with an affordable healthcare system.
- im3w1l 4y agoPeople speak as if risk is a positive. It isn't. It's intrinsically bad. The issue isn't risk avoidance, but excessive risk-avoidance. The issue is paying too high of a price to avoid risks. A top level comment mentioned climbing trees. This is an example of a somewhat risky activity that is well worth continuing. Why is that? The big benefit as I see it is that it is natural free-form play. That's freedom. It's also a play as old as time, letting them connect with our ancestors. It teaches them to interact with an environment that doesn't care about them one way or another, it isn't designed to be safe, it isn't designed to be fun or engaging. Trees are just out there for their own reasons. Exploring that, playing with that and respecting that, it seems like it should be very healthy and teach the right lessons and intuitions and prepare them for the rest of the world.
- amai 4y agoEspecially in Berlin people add dog shit, cigarette butts and broken glass bottles to the playground to increase the risks for kids. I‘m usually against video surveillance, but I believe it is unfortunately necessary to have video cameras on playgrounds, because without punishment some idiots simply don’t stop their destructive behavior.