7 ms·
> So exact in fact that they will need to specify a program in a click and drag interface, or in human language. This. I started programming in Machine Code, w
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
> So exact in fact that they will need to specify a program in a click and drag interface, or in human language.
This. I started programming in Machine Code, where the "editor" was a pad of graph paper.
I've watched management- and business-focused people sneer at us geeks for my entire career, and watched them drool over the thought of finally getting rid of us.
Hasn't happened yet.
> I'd be surprised if the next step is "Hi, I'm an ideas guy, please give me an app that does Uber, for bicycles, but better."
I get that, from "idea people," on a regular basis. They have nothing but contempt for us "Make It Happen" folks. They treat us as if we grow on trees, and are suckers, to boot.
Inevitably, the above, is followed by something that translates to "Of course, you will do all the work, but I'll get all the money, because the idea is what's really valuable."
If I follow up on it at all, I'll be asked to sign an NDA, and meet in some clandestine place, so they can whisper to me about their AI-powered cheese straightener.
- whearyou 4y agoThis is the most amazing comment I’ve read in a while.
- jackmott 4y ago[dead]
- chiefalchemist 4y agore: idea people True. And once their product hits the market, if it ever gets there, they don't thrive. Prior to launch they are sooooo in love with their idea that they are meticulous about features all the while thinking they're smarter than the market. They don't understand and appreciate the value of execution. Ideas are easy. Execution - because it involves people as well as adapting to change - is 10x harder. Yes, those people exist. Unfortunately, that bias will ultimately undermine them, but they'll never admit it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoOne of the things that I'm fairly good at, is walking people from "Crazy Idea That Will Never Work," through to "Finished Product That People Want." It tends to be a very long process, and often involves a lot of "trial balloons." I just went through that, in the last couple of years. The project we're realizing, looks absolutely nothing at all like what the CEO originally dreamed up, but everyone that has seen it, loves it. The trick is to not start off by saying "It'll never work." That slams doors shut, right away. It's more like, "OK, so let's walk through what we'll need to do, to make it work." That will often result in changes being made, by the "idea person," as the plans are laid. We will also try to create test harnesses and prototypes. These often end up, with the idea person going "Hmm...it seemed like a good idea, but it doesn't work the way I wanted." It's slow and painful, but works.
- A_Venom_Roll 4y agoI love this approach. What is your current role that allows you to do that?
- spydum 4y agoQuite a few companies have innovation incubators/teams, and this is inline with how I have seen them work.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIn the project I’m on, I’m basically the CTO (sort of meaningless, as I’m the only front end programmer, and also do most of the backend). I could be a lot more of a pain in the butt than I am, as I have a lot of leverage, but one of my goals is to help others on the team (including a young CEO) to learn how to make ship software. If I were working on my own, I probably would have shipped, eighteen months ago. No one is making a dime. It’s a nonprofit effort.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoYes. They have a want. The key is to nail down the need. But they have to be willing.
- 4y ago
- belter 4y agoIt's the usual: "I have a great idea for a Startup, now I just need the money to hire some Developers to implement it...". The Winklevoss twins for example come to mind...
- j7ake 4y agoThis hits deep and resonates beyond tech. This “ideas” versus “make things happen” divide is also prevalent in science and art.
- ilyt 4y agoYe, often the "creator", the "head" gets credited with everything a whole team come up with. Sure, picking the good and directing it to consistent whole is important but they would be nothing without people that produced that in the first place.
- j7ake 4y agoYeah it seems natural to divide the credit evenly, just as midfielders and strikers and coaches get equal credit for winning a game.
- admissionsguy 4y agoPhD students and postdocs are mostly fungible, though. PIs are not, if only by the virtue of their position in the system. The same reason why menial workers earn so little relative to how hard they work. It would appear that both credit and money flow to those who enable things to happen rather than those who execute.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoInterestingly, that's probably another area where a language model could be put into service. Consider, every workman with access to say GPT-6 now has an expert lawyer, MBA, secretary, manager, etc. at his beck and call. What happens when every individual can navigate the system as well as an entire team of professionals? I'm imagining headless corporations where the only humans involved are those engaged in physical interface with the world.
- grugagag 4y agoThat sounds like a playfield leveller but most likely won’t happen. But it surely would be nice
- brianwawok 4y agoAnd the way to get back at PHB is to form a tech lead software company and hire 0 people with MBAs.
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoIs that truly fair though. I have no exposure to MBAs and it may be all the negative talk about them is based on the conspicuously bad ones. I'm speaking as an IT person with very little experience of running a business, and it may be that a good MBA could be a great asset. I genuinely don't know. I'm reminded of reading about a Lisp machine company that ran into the ground because it was managed by techies. Their tech may have been great but their marketing and business skills were very arguably what killed the company.
- _glass 4y agoI don't have an MBA, but I studied intercultural management as my Masters, and I am writing my PhD right now in management. To be honest it is quite zen like, with the degree you can understand how you can manage engineers by not trying to manage them. Other type of people mostly need closer alignment. I know a lot of stuff of how to make a company more profitable, and generally a nicer place to work. Management is actually quite like engineering, more of a craft than an exact science. The science helps you to have names for things, and a lot of times I really know how to fix people stuff.
- ryandrake 4y agoMBAs are HN’s favorite punching bags. They are the only stereotype that it’s still ok to blanket-generalize about and dunk on here. Some MBAs are dumbasses. Some are brilliant business people. Some of them actually have tech skills and have been writing software longer than you’ve been alive. This is true for many degrees. I don’t know how some of the anti-MBA commenters think it works: A smart software engineer goes off to business school, gets an MBA in addition to his undergrad technical degree/experience, and now… what? He’s somehow dumber? How does that work? Only on HN.
- 4y ago
- chadash 4y agoI agree with your characterization in general. If all someone has is an idea and no relevant experience to back it up, run. I can’t stand people like that. But there’s one type of ideas person I’m thrilled to work with. Someone with deep and successful experience in sales. The head of sales at my company is also relatively product oriented and boy, he just has a knack for what customers want. In general, I think many engineers can do some product management. We can figure out basic accounting and finance. But the idea of making a cold call to sell dental software, or chasing down school principals at an education conference is almost as foreign to most software engineers as CS is to most sales folks. Salesperson + engineer = superpowers
- moneywoes 4y agoBesides opening your own company does a role exist where you can do both?
- andric 4y agoDevRel or Sales Engineering roles, maybe?
- newaccount2023 4y ago[flagged]
- Keegs 4y agoThere’s a role called sales engineer that typically exists in the sales organization but requires a technical background. From the engineering org’s perspective, your SEs are there to make sure sales doesn’t oversell or undersell. At my company your pay is commission-based but with a higher base than sales proper.
- ghaff 4y agoSolution Architect is another common title. As someone else mentioned, Developer Relations is at least adjacent though that tends to be less salesy and, depending on the role/company, may be more focused on community aspects than building demos and the like. In any case, at software companies, there are definitely customer-facing roles that are more technical though they may not involve a lot of direct coding. For non-field roles, product management qualifies as well.
- Simran-B 4y agoWait until managers realize that their jobs are a lot easier to automate away with AI than the jobs of software developers.
- josephg 4y agoWhat makes you think that’s true?
- thuuuomas 4y agoHuman managers (who are good at their jobs) bring a little Bedside Manner, a modicum of compassion to Human Resource Allocation that will soon be seen as a luxury compared to low-cost, fully-automated Human Resource Monitoring & Reinforcement Systems
- ghaff 4y agoGood managers shield their reports from a lot of the crap that is inevitable at scale in a large organization. A large company can't just have individuals and small self-managed teams go off and do whatever they feel like. And, yes, if you just cut out all the intermediate layers, the VP with 150 direct reports will simply have to resort to automation based on simplistic metrics. "You didn't produce enough lines of code last week. If that happens again, you will be placed on a performance plan and then terminated if the situation doesn't improve in 2 months."
- 6510 4y ago> A large company can't just have individuals and small self-managed teams go off and do whatever they feel like. Right but how much of that is because humans don't scale? With the AI, if it can do a thing well enough it can do it 100 000 times per day.
- josephg 4y agoI think its simply because upper management doesn't trust the people they've hired. In my mind, having individuals and small self managed teams go off and do whatever they feel drawn to do is exactly how a good company is run. - So long as those teams and individuals talk to (& seek advice) from the rest of the company when their work has impacts outside the team. The book Reinventing Organizations by Laloux talks about this a lot, and how it works in some companies today. The reason it doesn't happen more is that upper management doesn't trust their employees and they don't feel in control when people just do things.
- brookst 4y agoTell me more about this cheese straightener… that sounds amazing. Where do I prepay?
- doubled112 4y agoI wonder what straightening it provides. Like when the brick of cheese comes out of the freezer with an obvious bend? Or like when I don’t make a nice square cut and my sandwich is cheesier in some spots than others?
- bee_rider 4y agoWhen you grate the cheese, it often curls a bit. My patent-application-indefinitely-pending cheese straightener uncurls it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIt was a George Carlin joke. Don't remember exactly which monologue, but he was talking about how you can generate a need with advertising.
- irrational 4y ago> If your managers could specify what they need in a manner that no-code tools, or now AI, can generate the code they want, they will have to be extremely exact in their language. So exact in fact that they will need to specify a program in a click and drag interface, or in human language. This is also one of the main reasons why all programming jobs were not outsourced to India.
- windexh8er 4y agoCouldn't agree more with this sentiment. And to expand on it - the great outsourcing events we saw in the mid-2000s didn't work out for many of the things outside of programming: IT consulting in general, support and operations, call centers and things like design and architecture. The barrier was not always technical, but often a misunderstanding of how BaU works in the <parent_country> vs offshore and/or what the ask/expectations were. There's a lot of waste that happens when needing to be overly explicit and still having the message misinterpreted, interpreted too literally or simply failure to understand.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> This is also one of the main reasons why all programming jobs were not outsourced to India. There's a whole industry here in America that re-shores programming contracts. They know they can't underbid Indian/foreign body shops so they just wait a few months and call back the companies who went with cheaper programmers. If the company is still around it's generally a complete re-write.
- ravagat 4y agoGreat point. A lot of folks forget that not all programming jobs can/should be outsourced. There's value in outsourcing but specifications and contexts change that.
- ozim 4y agoTo some level I agree - but at some point there is also much on the "business side" that cannot be easily dealt with. Like having connection or some kind of relation with people who will buy the stuff or would have people who would be interested in buying stuff you make. Yes there are these "idea people" who don't have any clue about business side and don't have any clue about technical side and in the end don't even have the right connections or business network. But they think they can make it because they have an idea(TM). These could basically play lottery and outcome would be the same they might make it but chances are 1:1000000 at best. Then there are these business people who have the right connections and have understanding of niche/business they are in .. that need technical help to execute their idea and these are worth their weight in gold.
- pg_1234 4y ago> I get that, from "idea people," on a regular basis. They have nothing but contempt for us "Make It Happen" folks. They treat us as if we grow on trees, and are suckers, to boot. Ideas are like assholes ... everybody has one and they're usually full of shit.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> I've watched management- and business-focused people sneer at us geeks for my entire career, and watched them drool over the thought of finally getting rid of us. [...] They have nothing but contempt for us "Make It Happen" folks. They treat us as if we grow on trees, and are suckers, to boot. I've met my fair share as well. Jobs copycats too! The trick is always to ask them how much they can raise, and do so assuming they raised successfully in the past and that they know VCs. Either the conversation gets really interesting, or they clam up real quick!
- lelanthran 4y ago> The trick is always to ask them how much they can raise, and do so assuming they raised successfully in the past and that they know VCs. They don't need to have the ability to raise anything in a B2B setting, if they can answer the alternative question: "How many customers have you personally signed up for previous software sales". I'll happily partner with someone who has profitably sold B2B software - having a list of existing contacts in existing companies as well as solid experience going through the entire sales channel is, to me, just as valuable as extracting money from VCs, because I'd rather have the money from customers than money from VCs.
- bitwize 4y ago> I get that, from "idea people," on a regular basis. They have nothing but contempt for us "Make It Happen" folks. I met a pair of such idea guys once, they ran their own idea company. Their specialty was brand consulting and online marketing, but if that involved something as menial as web development they'd help with that too. The thing that made me bristle was whenever they talked about the feasibility of software solutions for their ideas, they said "Oh, we'll run that through the machine." You know, as if their software team was just a big machine that ingested ideas and spit out code. Their idea company is no longer around. One of them decided that he'd rather design hiking boots than anything computer related; the other is a head of UI design at Apple.