3 ms·

I think checking if people donates to a project is a better indicator to the value of the project than the stars. I never paid attention to stars.

by jmclnx 4y ago

debarshri 4y ago
But there are OSS projects that are VC backed. They don't take donations.
- _cenw 4y ago
  That's already a very different deal then, no need to gauge repository health, you know there's a good chance of work suddenly ceasing.
  - debarshri 4y ago
    You have a point. I have often seen OSS projects being funded on the basis of github stars with no revenue whereas all the parameters show that the project health is not that great.
boxed 4y ago
Donating to yourself would be pretty cheap...
- jmclnx 4y ago
  Maybe not as cheap as you may think. I think github takes a small cut plus you may need to declare the donation as Income on your taxes. Also if you get "smart" and donate on multiple cards, I would think it is a trivial task for github to determine is is a scam. The CC address would match you Address for the funds your receive. Probably way too much work for this :)
  - Kelamir 4y ago
    They don't take a fee from what I read about it. > https://docs.github.com/en/sponsors/sponsoring-open-source-contributors/sponsoring-an-open-source-contributor https://docs.github.com/en/sponsors/sponsoring-open-source-c... > GitHub Sponsors does not charge any fees for sponsorships from personal accounts, so 100% of these sponsorships go to the sponsored developer or organization. The 10% fee for sponsorships from organizations is waived during the beta. For more information, see "About billing for GitHub Sponsors."
    - doodlesdev 4y ago
      GitHub sponsors has been out of beta for a long time, they take 10% of the donations if the code is under an organization which is very common for OSS projects. Of course one of the ways to get around it is to sponsor the lead developer, which is sometimes available as an option. Or just sponsor the developer some other way which doesn't go through Microsoft such as Liberapay or Opencollective.
debarshri 4y ago
I don't you can externally measure how much money is being donated for an OSS project can you?

I think checking if people donates to a project is a better indicator to the value of the project than the stars. I never paid attention to stars.

by jmclnx 4y ago

I think checking if people donates to a project is a better indicator to the value of the project than the stars. I never paid attention to stars.

debarshri 4y ago

But there are OSS projects that are VC backed. They don't take donations.

_cenw 4y ago
That's already a very different deal then, no need to gauge repository health, you know there's a good chance of work suddenly ceasing.
- debarshri 4y ago
  You have a point. I have often seen OSS projects being funded on the basis of github stars with no revenue whereas all the parameters show that the project health is not that great.

boxed 4y ago

Donating to yourself would be pretty cheap...

jmclnx 4y ago
Maybe not as cheap as you may think. I think github takes a small cut plus you may need to declare the donation as Income on your taxes. Also if you get "smart" and donate on multiple cards, I would think it is a trivial task for github to determine is is a scam. The CC address would match you Address for the funds your receive. Probably way too much work for this :)
- Kelamir 4y ago
  They don't take a fee from what I read about it. > https://docs.github.com/en/sponsors/sponsoring-open-source-contributors/sponsoring-an-open-source-contributor https://docs.github.com/en/sponsors/sponsoring-open-source-c... > GitHub Sponsors does not charge any fees for sponsorships from personal accounts, so 100% of these sponsorships go to the sponsored developer or organization. The 10% fee for sponsorships from organizations is waived during the beta. For more information, see "About billing for GitHub Sponsors."
  - doodlesdev 4y ago
    GitHub sponsors has been out of beta for a long time, they take 10% of the donations if the code is under an organization which is very common for OSS projects. Of course one of the ways to get around it is to sponsor the lead developer, which is sometimes available as an option. Or just sponsor the developer some other way which doesn't go through Microsoft such as Liberapay or Opencollective.

debarshri 4y ago

I don't you can externally measure how much money is being donated for an OSS project can you?