4 ms·

I don’t think Elon understands open source. It’s very difficult to build a community and the only reason you’re going to get outside contributors is if they too

I don’t think Elon understands open source. It’s very difficult to build a community and the only reason you’re going to get outside contributors is if they too have a need for the project. I’m sure the current implementation is very Twitter focused. Maybe a generic recommendation framework could be useful?

cbeach 4y ago
What makes you think he wants to "build a community" or attract outside contributors? Elon spotted the rot and bias within Twitter. From day 1 he's been exposing and expunging it. Same with the recommendation algorithm. This is about transparency and trust. It's not a traditional OSS play.
- SpikeDad 4y ago
  Hahahahahahahahahahahaha. He's an evil megalomaniac. His every action has only one goal - attempting to demonstrate he's the most brilliant person on Earth. Psst. He's not succeeding.
- lillecarl 4y ago
  Is this how people who don't follow Elon got notifications about his tweets?
- starkd 4y ago
  Exactly right. It is about transparency. After exposing all the censorship games in the Twitter Files releases, he knows he needs to gain trust in the product. A better idea of how the feeds are generated would go a long way. The only way he can turn it into an open source project is if he rewrites the entire project. He has hinted at possibly doing this, since the code is very fragile and breaks whenever they try to add features. It would be great if he could turn the whole enterprise into a non-profit like wikileaks, but that is probably too optimistic.
roflyear 4y ago
Not true. Plenty of people will contribute because they like Elon. I know small private communities of commercial product that put in countless hours of free work to a software that is only ever to be used for that product. I'm sure people will contribute
starkd 4y ago
Not sure if a community of open source dev's is what he's after here. It is more about transparency, so that people can have an idea on how they are being recommended tweets.
asalahli 4y ago
Open source =/= community, though, nor contributions. It just means releasing the source code with an open license
- squeaky-clean 4y ago
  To non technical people Open Source often doesn't even mean what it means in FOSS circles. I wouldn't be surprised at all if he releases it under a license most of us on HN would consider "Source Available"
solarkraft 4y ago
That's probably not the point. His goal is likely auditability, not getting outside contributions. However: > I don’t think Elon understands open source Absolutely. Like most popular tech-wannabes he uses the term to mean something like "freely licensed". I fact he called his opening up of Tesla's patents "open sourcing" them. As somebody who knows what "open source" actually means, I cringe at this over-use. On the other hand I appreciate that the term and the concept are gaining popularity.

cbeach 4y ago

What makes you think he wants to "build a community" or attract outside contributors? Elon spotted the rot and bias within Twitter. From day 1 he's been exposing and expunging it. Same with the recommendation algorithm. This is about transparency and trust. It's not a traditional OSS play.

SpikeDad 4y ago
Hahahahahahahahahahahaha. He's an evil megalomaniac. His every action has only one goal - attempting to demonstrate he's the most brilliant person on Earth. Psst. He's not succeeding.
lillecarl 4y ago
Is this how people who don't follow Elon got notifications about his tweets?
starkd 4y ago
Exactly right. It is about transparency. After exposing all the censorship games in the Twitter Files releases, he knows he needs to gain trust in the product. A better idea of how the feeds are generated would go a long way. The only way he can turn it into an open source project is if he rewrites the entire project. He has hinted at possibly doing this, since the code is very fragile and breaks whenever they try to add features. It would be great if he could turn the whole enterprise into a non-profit like wikileaks, but that is probably too optimistic.

roflyear 4y ago

Not true. Plenty of people will contribute because they like Elon. I know small private communities of commercial product that put in countless hours of free work to a software that is only ever to be used for that product. I'm sure people will contribute

starkd 4y ago

Not sure if a community of open source dev's is what he's after here. It is more about transparency, so that people can have an idea on how they are being recommended tweets.

asalahli 4y ago

Open source =/= community, though, nor contributions. It just means releasing the source code with an open license

squeaky-clean 4y ago
To non technical people Open Source often doesn't even mean what it means in FOSS circles. I wouldn't be surprised at all if he releases it under a license most of us on HN would consider "Source Available"

solarkraft 4y ago

That's probably not the point. His goal is likely auditability, not getting outside contributions. However: > I don’t think Elon understands open source Absolutely. Like most popular tech-wannabes he uses the term to mean something like "freely licensed". I fact he called his opening up of Tesla's patents "open sourcing" them. As somebody who knows what "open source" actually means, I cringe at this over-use. On the other hand I appreciate that the term and the concept are gaining popularity.