3 ms·
Am I the only one that believes that there is no way for this thing to cause harm? All it does is generate text. Text generation in and of itself is not harmfu
by sneak 4y ago
Am I the only one that believes that there is no way for this thing to cause harm?
All it does is generate text. Text generation in and of itself is not harmful or dangerous.
All this blathering on about "safety" and "risks" seems just like hypercorrection due to anticipating people freaking out when it says something against modern social orthodoxy, which it seems is to be expected given that it's a text generator that cannot think.
The only real danger from this thing is to the OpenAI brand name.
- antegamisou 4y agoSure, what harm could detailed self-injury instructions do to mentally-ill people?
- sebzim4500 4y agoIf OpenAI actually believed this information was harmful they wouldn't have included it in the appendix and distributed through a pdf on their own website.
- charcircuit 4y agoSomeone who wants to injure themselves can easily do so. Figuring out the risks or more information just allows people to make a more informed decision. In a way this can reduce harm in that it allows people to apply the level of injury to themselves that they wasnt.
- antegamisou 4y agoYou have a completely flawed perception of how people belonging in this group reason. They aren't some HN 'rationalist' type nerd carefully weighing pros and cons of every action they take and unfortunately a lot of the time they may not even be adults. You also place too much trust on them doing it 'carefully' enough to not cause serious damage.
- charcircuit 4y agoIf they didn't care about pros and cons of options they wouldn't ask the AI for options or to rate options. They would just do it.
- antegamisou 4y agoI’ll just repeat that those people’s impulsive behavior can’t be broken down into any binary manner and won’t engage in further discussion.
- sneak 4y agoWhat harm, indeed? Mentally ill people who are intending to self harm can already find such information. Whether a text generator does or does not provide it does not cause or preclude any harm to the mentally ill.
- antegamisou 4y agoAs I stated in a previous comment, you also don't seem to understand how impulsive these people can be. They aren't capable of following the detailed instructions about supposedly safe 'self-injury' without inflicting life-threatening injury. The parent comment, as well as the fact that you're making no distinction between information on harming yourself in an article and interacting with a bot that is instructing you in a human-like manner, especially when we're talking about the mentally unstable, on what to do is prohibiting enough to never have any insight on the subject.
- sneak 4y ago> As I stated in a previous comment, you also don't seem to understand how impulsive these people can be. They aren't capable of following the detailed instructions about supposedly safe 'self-injury' without inflicting life-threatening injury. I'm aware of this. What does it have to do with the bot?
- famouswaffles 4y agoNearly all the digital world is accessed through text. and we can and have given access to various tools via api's or code execution to these models.