8 ms·
Since half the comments haven't read the article and are making knee-jerk responses: "Bank of America, Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo announced toda
by pjc50 4y ago
Since half the comments haven't read the article and are making knee-jerk responses:
"Bank of America, Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo announced today they are each making a $5 billion uninsured deposit into First Republic Bank. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are each making an uninsured deposit of $2.5 billion, and BNY-Mellon, PNC Bank, State Street, Truist and U.S. Bank are each making an uninsured deposit of $1 billion, for a total deposit from the eleven banks of $30 billion. This action by America’s largest banks reflects their confidence in First Republic and in banks of all sizes, and it demonstrates their overall commitment to helping banks serve their customers and communities. Regional, midsize and small banks are critical to the health and functioning of our financial system."
Big highlighter on "deposit". No government or even FDIC money is involved in this.
It's significant that this is a private action. It's basically the exact opposite of the VCs telling each other to get their money out of SVB; it's a bunch of banks putting their own money into FRB. A "hold the line" move.
"We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" is a rather powerful statement.
- scotty79 4y agoI wonder what if First Republic collapses anyways? Will they be made whole anyways even though deposits are uninsured because they are deposits?
- javajosh 4y agoIn the event of a collapse of course the depositors will be made whole, especially after they've showed such courage.
- dymk 4y agoYellen says otherwise
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoAnd there is the government bail out...
- candiodari 4y agoSo it's about as risky as bungee jumping 5cm high using a VR headset with 5 medics around you? I agree. Either this will work, or the FED will step in and protect their member banks. Risk: zero.
- qwytw 4y agoWell it's non zero. If the banking system actually start collapsing the stock prices of these banks will also crash. I doubt their executives and other want that...
- pjc50 4y agoI wouldn't rule it out. But you can see how this works: because the FDIC intervened and gave 100% on SVB where perhaps it might only have been 95% otherwise, the banks are now able to privately assemble an intervention into First Direct, which is even cheaper because now FDIC don't have to intervene!
- twoodfin 4y agoSomehow I doubt this was planned entirely privately. For one thing, absent a government nod, this kind of coordination raises serious antitrust concerns.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> For one thing, absent a government nod, this kind of coordination raises serious antitrust concerns What concern, exactly?
- twoodfin 4y agoSuppose that (and this is not that wild a hypothetical under the circumstances) First Republic had been contemplating, barring significant new deposits, selling to an up-and-coming midsized bank, and the larger banks did not collectively desire that outcome. Their CEOs can’t sit around a table and discuss joint billion-dollar strategic action. It’s the definition of a “conspiracy in constraint of trade”.
- credit_guy 4y agoThe upside should be (and hopefully is) a good interest rate on that deposit. Let's say Fed Funds plus 5%.
- pjc50 4y ago.. does anyone have any evidence for this? It's not in the press release.
- chii 4y agoThese banks that would've gotten a run could accept a loss here, as long as it's in the future and can be funded. It's better than a run.
- eloff 4y agoI read in one news article that they got the same terms as all the other depositors at FRC, so the interest rate is negligible. Obviously the real benefit to them is calming the panic in the banking sector, which is harmful to all of them.
- MPSimmons 4y ago>"We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" is a rather powerful statement. It seems to me that there is a considerable amount of risk to the participating banks if FRB fails. "Hold the line" is right - if more banks fail, these participating banks will lose a lot more than their $1B each. I do wonder if there's something specific to FRB that made them pick this - is it the most likely to go next? Did it have published liquidity issues?
- throwanem 4y agoIt's been all over the news all week as the likeliest next failure, yes.
- uCano1 4y ago> It seems to me that there is a considerable amount of risk to the participating banks if FRB fails. "Hold the line" is right - if more banks fail, these participating banks will lose a lot more than their $1B each. $5 billion each.
- pjc50 4y agoUp to $5bn. The actual likely value at risk is a lot smaller; would need a First Direct balance sheet to estimate it. (Some are subscribed at $1bn and some at $5bn. That must have been an interesting meeting.)
- lxgr 4y agoA 100% haircut would mean that their assets are effectively worthless. I highly doubt that the depositing banks would have done this if that were the case.
- bumby 4y agoEven if their assets are things like Treasury notes? I'm assuming JPM would get first dibs on those types of assets if First Republic went under, no?
- Aaronontheweb 4y ago> Big highlighter on "deposit". No government or even FDIC money is involved in this. > > It's significant that this is a private action. No evidence on my part of back this up, but assuming that the government _isn't_ implicitly involved in de-risking this for banks seems naïve. I don't think these organizations, not exactly known for their civic-mindedness or charity, would risk any of their own precious liquidity without assurances or incentives from the government.
- aorloff 4y agoThe banks have concluded that the public statement may be worth more than those government assurances anyway. And yes these banks are TBTF
- jacquesm 4y agoOn the contrary, they have a very strong incentive to do so: it shows the market that they not only trust their own long term position but that they are able to act in concert to take care of a competitor in trouble exactly without the government forcing them to do so, in effect doing an end run around those that are now asking for more regulation. And that is all the incentive they need.
- brisdak 4y agoisn't this almost like a cartel move
- ceejayoz 4y agoLaws against cartels in the US say things like "in restraint of trade or commerce" and "monopolize any part of the trade or commerce". Propping a competitor up in this nature is fairly hard to argue as "restraint of trade".
- icegreentea2 4y agoYes-ish. Let's be real, banking is a public-private partnership. While it IS significant that the banks themselves are doing this, and not the Fed/FDIC, it would also seem quite possible (likely?) to be some nudging from the Fed/Treasury. Some form of "hey, we did our part (the new emergency backstop), you guys need to show you're worth this effort". While the top-tier of banking is obviously in competition with each other, they're also bound together by their shared interest in the status quo, and then doubling bound together by the Fed/USG also being very interested in the status quo. So it's cartel-like, but it would be a mistake to only include the banks as members of the cartel.
- u801e 4y ago> Big highlighter on "deposit". No government or even FDIC money is involved in this. I have deposit accounts in several of the banks listed. So my money is involved in a potentially bad investment. At least the balances I have do not exceed the FDIC insurance limit per bank.
- donavanm 4y agoOnce deposited it’s no longer your money. The bank has a liability to you equal to the deposited amount, but you have no more control of those (virtual) dollars. That’s an asset for you, but this action is not your “investment.”
- rswail 4y ago> At least the balances I have do not exceed the FDIC insurance limit per bank. That's is both the cure and the problem. All of your money is protected by the FDIC. So it's not "At least". Your deposits are protected. But SME companies have just realized that they are not protected and are busy rearranging their finances, which is seeing a lot of outflows from smaller banks, both to distribute money under the $250K limit as well as a "run to quality" to the big banks. All small banks with a mix of customers leaning towards SME will be impacted.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoIf JPM fails you probably will have bigger issues...
- slv77 4y agoTraditionally banks which needed cash to balance their books worked through the interbank market. Interbank lending was unsecured but short term so the risks were manageable. If a bank was known to be insolvent however lending would quickly dry up and banks would need to go hat-in-hand to the Federal Reserves discount window. That came with a high cost and invited regulatory scrutiny. Now the FDIC has indicated that it will insure deposits in unlimited amounts doing a direct deposit maybe a more attractive option to banks? That $30B previously was sitting around at the Fed earning a risk free return at prevailing interest rates. I have to assume that there is special treatment here and the banks are earning above market returns and the banks didn’t put cash-at-risk sitting in zero interest accounts out of the goodness of their hearts. If that is the case the Fed, FDIC and Yellen have effectively nerfed the interbank market.
- bumby 4y ago>Now the FDIC has indicated that it will insure deposits in unlimited amounts My understanding is that the FDIC does not have cash on hand to cover "unlimited" amounts. My (somewhat dated reference, 2010) said they have about $0.70 for every $100 insured, based on the idea that the number of depositors they would have to cover at any single time is relatively small. Similar to the idea that banks don't have to have enough reserves because depositors won't all request to pull their funds at the same time. Until they do.
- bombcar 4y agoFDIC has government guarantees for the $250k portion, and implicit guarantees beyond that. And with the SVB bailout of depositors it’s now signaled that FDIC is effectively insuring the full balance backed by the Treasury.
- bumby 4y agoRight, but the issue is they may not have $250k on hand for everyone who is insured. (Essentially no different than the banks needing enough reserves to cover withdrawal amounts.) The "implicit" part essentially means Congress will act on their behalf if needed. Which means the mechanism is to sell Treasuries to the Fed, who pays for it by printing money. I don't know if that's great option in the context of the highest inflationary period in 40 years. Or am I wrong on that understanding?
- Dalewyn 4y ago>It's basically the exact opposite of the VCs telling each other to get their money out of SVB; it's a bunch of banks putting their own money into FRB. A "hold the line" move. It's interesting to remember that banking, at least from the perspective of the commons (depositors), is an issue of trust. The more the commons say to withdraw their deposits, the more deposits will be withdrawn and the more banks will collapse; and the more banks will collapse the more the commons will say to withdraw their deposits, the more deposits will be withdrawn and the more banks will collapse. The opposite also holding true. Objectively, there is simply no value in giving one's money to a bank other than the ostensible claim that they will keep your money safer than if you just stash it under your bed. Given that, the FRB, FDIC, and banks et al. pulling out all the stops to reinforce depositor confidence is not surprising. It's a natural response to fear making the rounds in the commons.
- mihaaly 4y ago> "We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" Same sentences read to me completely differently: "First Republic is in so deep shit that we must intervene immediately with funds we will miss dearly - we are troubled too - so it would not drag all of us down later. We also need to push pompous text in the attempt of covering how big our troubles are." Sounds more believeable than "betting" for fun or being philantrophic all of the sudden.
- banannaise 4y agoIt's a liquidity injection. If there's a bank run, say, tomorrow, suddenly they have $30 billion of cash on hand to cover it.
- fairity 4y ago> "We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" is a rather powerful statement. Is it though? Although there's no upside, there's also little downside since deposits are at the top of the liquidation stack in the case of bankruptcy. The further up the liquidation stack your capital goes, the least risk you're taking. So, the biggest vote of confidence would be if big banks purchased First Republic equity. I would categorize offering FRC debt as a strong signal also (like JPM did). Offering FRC uninsured deposits is perhaps the weakest vote of confidence when it comes to transferring cash to FRC.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> "We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" is a rather powerful statement. It is. But perhaps less so than it appears. First, there may be downside to JPMorgan if First Republic fails, and especially if dominoes continue to fall after that. So JPMorgan has the upside of avoiding the downside, at least. Second, JPMorgan is officially recognized as a systemically-important bank. They will not be allowed to fail. So their risk from this move is the risk of some loss, but not the risk of collapse/destruction. Still a bold move, and one that, as you said, talks quite loudly.
- lebed2045 4y ago“ it's a bunch of banks putting their own money into FRB” - aren’t these their clients money? If so, isn’t the same situation when clients make “deposit” and expect their money held by bank, but bank start treating them as bank creditors?
- ozymandias12 4y agoBro this is residual investment for these banks, wake up. This money is NADA, is part of a fund every bank saves for things like this, they are literally just burning cash with this movement because 30 billion alone isn't enough to cover for any of them, even them "small" ones like First Republic. This is a political movement, in a time where these banks should be investing said "actual" money (another misnomer) in literally unfucking federal government gridlocks on systemic reforms. Banks make hundreds of billions every year, for them to take 2.5 or 1b to fund whatever is literally part of the business, not even computed as loss since it can be classified as net cost avoidance if this money actually ends up helping systemic chaos because these things are way pricier than 30bn. LOL, your analysis is literally made for children books, I'm not even scratching the surface here.
- sifar 4y ago>> "We, JPMorgan, are willing to bet $5bn that First Direct does not fail, with no upside to us if they do not" is a rather powerful statement. The upside is the contagion doesn't spread to them.
- webinvest 4y agoWhy are the big banks doing this?
- shagie 4y agoThey believe the books are sound, but people (depositors and investors) are a bit jumpy / skittish currently. No bank - and that is no bank - can survive a majority of its depositors all withdrawing their funds rapidly. Even the big banks can't survive that. The $250k backstop for the FDIC should prevent the regular depositors from doing a bank run, but when the depositors are more single sector business oriented then that is a more real fear. By putting in $30B into the bank it provides a few things. First, it is $30B of money that the big banks aren't going to be moving out soon. It is liquid money that can be used so that First Federal doesn't have to sell securities at a loss to close out depositors accounts (this is what got SVB). Secondly, it is a statement from the banks that they trust (with their money where their mouth is) that the bank will not fail - because if it does, they're way about that $250k FDIC insurance number. Those deposits are very much like yours and mine - just with a few more zeros on the end. They are deposits - not bond sales or other financial instruments, but rather cash in the bank. From yesterday: https://www.marketplace.org/2023/03/16/first-republic-bank-30-billion-rescue-plan/ https://www.marketplace.org/2023/03/16/first-republic-bank-3... From this morning: https://www.marketplace.org/shows/marketplace-morning-report/banks-are-leaning-on-each-other-for-cash-amid-turbulence/ https://www.marketplace.org/shows/marketplace-morning-report...