6 ms·
Twitter isn't Censoring You. Your Government is.
- joebadmo 15y agoI think this is more a problem with centralized services than with Twitter or any particular government. I'm with Dave Winer on this one: http://scripting.com/stories/2012/01/27/onTwittersNewFiltering.html http://scripting.com/stories/2012/01/27/onTwittersNewFilteri...
- pasbesoin 15y agoBut, as I've pleaded previously, if we force them to shut down the Internet to control the flow of information, everyone will know. If there is an ability to shut off communities selectively, that would be hard to detect. Although Twitter says they will provide removal requests to the Chilling Effects site, I remain skeptical. If nothing else, this seems akin to the increasingly mandated "protest areas" in the U.S. and elsewhere that are well, or thoroughly, removed from the events being protested.
- davewiner 15y agoI'm sure there are requests that governments can make that Twitter will not be able to report to Chilling Effects.
- stfu 15y agoDave: The EC2 tutorial is nicely done. But the problem of setting up an individual communication island seems that "they" will come for those people "personally". While using an existing platform people can "hide" behind proxies, open wlans and so on the required money trail for bringing a personal system online makes the "rule breaker" much more identifiable.
- biafra 15y agoOnly if those request come from the US-Government.
- thetrendycyborg 15y agoBut Twitter is too.
- drcube 15y agoTwitter is censoring users at the behest of their governments. They don't have to. How long do you think it would continue to be illegal to mention Naziism in Germany if Twitter, Facebook, Google, et al, decided to boycott the entire country? If Hollywood can play governments like evil marionettes, the vastly richer internet giants ought to be able to pull off a simple boycott for good. That they aren't says a lot to me. Their priorities are revenue, regardless of their stated abhorrence of censorship.
- spindritf 15y ago> How long do you think it would continue to be illegal to mention Naziism in Germany if Twitter, Facebook, Google, et al, decided to boycott the entire country? Probably longer than it would take to develop local clones of those services. As a side note, I do not think it would be appropriate for a foreign corporation to try to influence national politics of a free and democratic country like Germany. While it's not entirely rational, especially an American corporation. IMVHO Twitter, Google et al. should conform to the law, it's up to German citizens to change the rules accordingly to their will and values.
- drcube 15y agoYou can only take this so far. What if your company were required to kill innocent people in order to operate legally in another country? Would you do it, lest you be seen as meddling in local affairs? Saying "I won't be part of your censorship regime" is not the same thing as trying to influence another country's democratic politics. They can take what I have to offer or leave it, but I'll be damned if I'll sacrifice my integrity for a dollar. This is probably the reason I haven't ever run a company. Yet...
- spindritf 15y agoYou can also only take it so far in the other direction -- does every corporation have to be a supporter of completely unrestricted free speech? Is it wrong to provide Germans with your service on the terms set largely by the Germans themselves? Do you think foreign companies should also try to circumvent privacy laws they find unreasonable for example? Of course I would not run a business in a country where innocent people are being intentionally killed by the government. Not even on principle, thought that too, but simply because of the risk to me personally, my employees and general uncertainty.
- nextparadigms 15y agoSomeone was raising the question if there's a coincidence between them doing this now, a month after that Arabian prince invested $300 million in Twitter. It's probably not a coincidence, but I bet the US Government wanting to censor tweets from certain groups in the Middle East for "spreading propaganda" has a lot to do with it, too. And I'm a lot more worried about that than about a certain country wanting to censor their own people's tweets, because at least then that country's citizens can protest against it. Not much another country can do about US censoring their tweets.
- draggnar 15y agoDoes anyone believe that the nature of censorship on the internet actually makes a situation worse? Maybe during tv days censorship worked because a story was blacked out completely, but on the internet the fact that a story is blacked out can become a story. It may be argued that this is an attempt to make more gradual the shift to a more free and open society but isn't it a step backwards?
- throwaway64 15y agoWhy is people being actively aware of censorship a step backwards?
- Someone 15y agoWhat if one started playing with terms close to forbidden ones? For example, will Twitter hide tweets denying that people got killed in Mousewitz or Duckau (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/letters/3595693/Mousewitz-and-Duckau.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/letters/3595693/Mousewitz...)? If so, an enterprising group of people will probably be able to make Twitter hide terms that, currently, are utterly unrelated to forbidden terms.
- bbwharris 15y agoSlowly but surely, the internet will receive the same censorship apparent in public broadcasting. The fun's over. We've been discovered.
- bbwharris 15y agoHere's a thought though. Information spreads faster today than at any other period in Human history. Pandora's box is already open. Other ways to release this censored information will appear.
- coopdog 15y agoAs long as there's anonimity there's no way they can censor Once every single packet in the entire network requires authentication to move, and they outlaw any kind of network that doesn't require this authentication, then Pandora's box will be shut again Was pretty happy with the outrage at SOPA, I just wish it was 'stop censorship' instead of stop SOPA because the buzz seems to have died off even with ACTA gettting signed left right and center
- RatOrigami 15y agoTwitter is a tool.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoTwitter taking action to remove/block tweets due to individual court orders would fall under "governments are censoring twitter". Twitter complying with requests to pre-emptively filter tweets would fall under "twitter is censoring itself".
- rooshdi 15y agoI don't buy this. Twitter is in a powerful position to protest for free speech and they are choosing not to. They have the attention of the mainstream public and have a precious opportunity to make a stand for human rights similar to the SOPA protests. By censoring their very own beliefs, they enable the government censors to continue to silence everyone else. How can you have a tool for free expression, when you yourself don't fight for it?
- stevefeinstein 15y agoThe Government is us, isn't it? How did these jokers who "represent" us get into the positions they're in? We elected them. We need to get rid of the bad ones, and put in some good ones. And we need those new ones to undo the rules the bad ones place to keep things in their favor.