7 ms·
Project Orion
- dang 4y agoRelated: Interstellar nuclear-powered transport (1968) [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28132756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28132756 - Aug 2021 (34 comments) - thanks antondd! Orion Project [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22691219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22691219 - March 2020 (1 comment) Nuclear Pulse Propulsion – Orion and Beyond (2000) [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12705705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12705705 - Oct 2016 (99 comments) Project Orion (nuclear propulsion) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9025611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9025611 - Feb 2015 (11 comments) Project Orion (nuclear propulsion) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3019627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3019627 - Sept 2011 (1 comment) Project Orion is one of the stupidest, most wonderful ideas ever conceived in America. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=261348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=261348 - July 2008 (6 comments) That's less than I expected - are there other threads?
- antondd 4y agoInterstellar nuclear-powered transport (1968) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28132756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28132756 - Aug 2021 (34 comments) There are a few more, under different titles. I remember reading Dyson’s autobiography a couple of years ago and he mentioned his involvement in the research. Absolutely amazing stuff.
- didericis 4y agoThere’s a great BBC documentary on this called “To Mars by a Bomb”, highly recommend it. Was one of my first introductions to Freeman Dyson, ended up reading his autobiography as well. Was a remarkable man, and one of my favorite people to listen to.
- smilespray 4y agoIt's on YouTube, and I second this recommendation. https://youtu.be/xYoLcJuBtOw https://youtu.be/xYoLcJuBtOw
- hermitcrab 4y agoI watched all 157 of these: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFzDA6mtmKQEgWfcIu49J4nN https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVV0r6CmEsFzDA6mtmKQE... Really interesting. I spoke to him once at a book signing and asked him about Orion. In summary he said: would it have worked - probably, should it be done - probably not. Although he did make the point that pretty much every big engineering project kills people.
- hermitcrab 4y agoAlso some good physicist gossip. Apparently Teller was a big sulk and Oppenheimer was a massive pain in the arse (some of the time, anyway).
- dang 4y agoAdded. Thanks!
- breppp 4y agoSimilarly crazy idea, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nike_Hercules https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nike_Hercules A nuclear tipped SAM, blow all the missiles out of the sky together with the sky
- HPsquared 4y agoRelated, Sprint missile test (anti-ballistic-missile missile). Extremely fast acceleration, you can see in the test footage which is not sped up. Mass: 7,700 lbs.; Thrust: 650,000 lbs. Around 100 G of acceleration, reaching Mach 10 within 5 seconds. "The first stage was exhausted after only 1.2 seconds, but produced 650,000 pounds-force (2,891 kilonewtons) of thrust. On separation, the spent first stage disintegrated due to aerodynamic forces. The second stage fired within 1 to 2 seconds of launch. Interception at an altitude of 1 to 19 miles (1.5 to 30 km) took at most 15 seconds." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) https://youtu.be/kvZGaMt7UgQ https://youtu.be/kvZGaMt7UgQ
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ianburrell 4y agoNuclear tipped SAM isn't too crazy for the time. They were defending against nuclear-armed supersonic bombers and knocking out multiple with one missile was good idea. Early SAMs also weren't that good. There were lots of nuclear tactical weapons (some bonkers) at the time. Nuclear torpedos. Nuclear anti-submarine rockets. Nuclear artillery shells. Nuclear tactical rockets.
- roywiggins 4y agoThe Russians still have theirs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-135_anti-ballistic_missile_system?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-135_anti-ballistic_missile_s...
- moffkalast 4y agoAnd well, the Genie missile of course https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIR-2_Genie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIR-2_Genie
- Laremere 4y agoRelevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/2423/ https://xkcd.com/2423/
- st_goliath 4y agoAn other quite interesting concept (also a little less "out there" and actually, successfully tested) is the NERVA engine, also linked at the bottom of the article[1]. It uses a nuclear reactor to heat up a single propellant (liquid hydrogen) which then rapidly expands as it goes out the nozzle at the end, resulting in quite high specific impulse and is more efficient than a chemical rocket. If we want to go really far out in terms of crazy rocket designs, there is also the concept of the nuclear salt-water rocket[2][3]. This one uses enriched plutonium or uranium salts, dissolved in water, inside a neutron-absorbent fuel tank design. The water is pushed out through a pipe, where an uncontrolled chain reaction starts. If it goes fast enough, it explodes right inside the engine bell, pushing the rocket. The proposed design in the original paper is supposed to generate hundreds of gigawatts of thermal power. This is comparable to the Chernobyl reactor #4 when it exploded, but unlike Chernobyl (which only exploded once) or the pulsed Orion engine, it could run continuously. The stuff that flies out of the nozzle easily reaches escape velocity of the solar system. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA?useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA?useskin=vector [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_salt-water_rocket?useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_salt-water_rocket?uses... [3] Obligatory Scott Manley video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvZjhWE-3zM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvZjhWE-3zM
- perihelions 4y agoThere's one more: the boring idea of combining a closed, electric-generating nuclear fission system with an (electric-powered) ion engine. Both components being flight tested and not crazy.
- jerf 4y agoThat doesn't sound like something that could get you off of the Earth. It's probably a great choice for once you're already in space, where being able to apply even very small thrusts nearly-continuously really adds up.
- walrus01 4y agoThe Soviets literally launched reactors into space in the late 70s for very high RF power radar satellites (intended to track US navy, among other things). One deorbited over northern Canada. https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=soviet+rorsat https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=soviet+ro... Of course anything related to hall effect/ion thrusters isn't going to get you off the earth even with some of the theoretical/bench-tested-only 100kW (electrical load) thrusters under development. These are things with very low thrust at any instantaneous moment in time but very high specific impulse from 3800 to 6000 ISP or more. Meant to be used in vacuum only.
- marktangotango 4y agoThere was a classic science fiction story with a twist on this idea; a low tech species was about to be discovered by a more advanced species. And according to the rules of the more advanced species, any planet that wasn't capable of space travel would become a client or vassal, and a planet with space travel would be seen as a peer. The protagonist built a pusher style rocket using an explosive, and launched the lightest person he knew into orbit, who happened to be his girl friend. I keep thinking this was a Larry Niven story, maybe someone here is familiar? Edit; another classic story was the novel Footfall by Niven and Pournelle which featured launching the USS Missouri into orbit on an Orion style pusher to battle the invading aliens.
- KineticLensman 4y agoThat doesn't sound part of Niven's Known Space canon. However, 'Footfall' by Niven and Pournelle does have an Orion, as does Invisible Sun, by Charles Stross. Nothing obvious in [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stories_featuring_nuclear_pulse_propulsion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stories_featuring_nucl...
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoIt was a Niven / Pournelle mashup. Also, Lucifer's Hammer is a fun read I recall.
- Arrath 4y agoI very much have a soft spot for Footfall. Sending up a battleship kludged into an Orion style ship to battle alien invaders is just so cool.
- variaga 4y agoI haven't read that book in 30 years, but the description of experiencing the launch from inside the craft was so succinct and evocative I still think about it from time to time. "God was knocking and he wanted in bad."
- ianburrell 4y agoProject Orion is a really bad idea. I guess it could be a good idea in specific situation where have to get a lot of mass off the planet and don't care about the effects. Problem one is that detonating a series of nuclear bombs in the atmosphere. The first couple are close to the ground and produce local fallout, the higher ones produce global fallout. Problem two is that detonating nuclear bombs in space causes EMP. That doesn't destroy electronics on ground as thought but will knock out the electrical grid. The extra radiation will knock out satellites in space. There is interstellar Orion, Project Daedalus, but that is quite different with inertial confinement fusion and magnetic fields directing the exhaust.
- nwah1 4y agoLaunching from lunar orbit would obviate EMP and terrestrial radiation concerns. But those are the least of the concerns.
- ianburrell 4y agoThe problem with that is Orion is that it is heavy. It only makes sense when launching the whole thing from the ground. Orion has been proposed for interplanetary propulsion since it is pretty efficient. But would need to be convertible from ground-launch to space propulsion. Nuclear rockets are pretty good and safer to launch. The other problem is that nuclear weapons are expensive. Something like Davy Crockett is 2kg of plutonium, and mid-sized Orion would use 800 to get to orbit. Plutonium is $4000/g which means $6.4 billion to launch Orion. Orion that puts 1600t in orbit. Or 10 Starships which is less as disposable rockets and way less if reuasable.
- philipkglass 4y agoIn 1965 the Atomic Energy Commission put the cost of plutonium 239 at $10/gram, which by simple consumer price indexing (only a rough guide, admittedly) would make it $96/gram today. See Table I in this publication "Values In Spent Fuel From Power Reactors": https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/4618921 https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/4618921 At $96 per gram instead of $4000, that's a much more attractive $154 million to put 1600 tons in orbit. Uranium enrichment costs have fallen greatly since the 1960s as centrifuges have replaced gaseous diffusion, so uranium-fueled units would probably cost less (despite the greater mass of uranium required). I'd say that the main modern problems of a terrestrially launched Orion are treaty violations and giving a plausible cover for nations to again pursue developing "peaceful" nuclear explosives.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoTitle should better be "Project Orion (nuclear propulsion)". There's too many "Orion" things out there to make it clear that this specific one is about nuclear propulsion.
- ShakataGaNai 4y agoThere is a Kerbal Space Program mod [1] that adds this to the game. It is hysterically fun to use because it is insanely unbalanced compared to normal space flight requirements. Want to change your orbit 180deg and fly backwards? No problem. Goto any planet the "direct" route? Sure, why not. Take off from the launch pad so fast you'll think the game broke? Not a problem - The Kerbal's don't worry about a little fallout. No idea how this would ever actually work in reality for manned spaceflight. For unmanned it seems relatively doable (ignoring the entire cost of getting it off the ground and into space first). But for a manned mission? Being subject to 2-4g is one thing, but to have it happen regularly... like a jackhammer almost? Sounds like a really bad trip. You could not do anything while that engine was firing (not that it'd be easy to do something under 2g constant acceleration) without risk of being in the wrong place/position at the wrong time. I don't know what the long terms effects of repeated, assumingly rapid, 2-4g pulsing is on the human body.... but I'd guess it falls under "can't be anything good" category. [1] https://umbraspaceindustries.github.io/UmbraSpaceIndustries/ https://umbraspaceindustries.github.io/UmbraSpaceIndustries/
- adrenvi 4y agoProject Orion uses a pusher plate mounted on giant springs to spread out the force of each explosion. If the system is designed correctly it should result in constant acceleration.
- whatshisface 4y agoBased on the amount of time a Kerbal can survive orbiting the sun in their barely-shielded capsules, I am inclined to think that they are immune to radiation damage, like tardigrades.
- galacticaactual 4y agoSo there are ways to make this interesting in the game and bring it back to balance. Some recommendations: - The USI pulse nukes are expensive. Play on career mode so you are cash constrained and have to rigorously plan for their build, use, and refueling. - Roleplay not using them anywhere near low home-planet orbit for fallout reasons. I.e. the ship is built and is parked in a shipyard in Cislunar space and kerbonauts must ride an intermediary shuttle vessel to crew it. - Use a life support pack and planet mods that add interplanetary destinations. Having your kerbonauts on a nuke ship around an extrasolar planetary body far away from home with limited supplies will add plenty to the mix.
- tppiotrowski 4y agoThere is also a book called Project Orion: The True Story of the Atomic Spaceship. It's still sitting on my shelf, but I don't remember it being a particularly inspiring read because it was tailored towards interstellar travel when we hadn't even reached Mars yet.
- LesZedCB 4y agoit was a fun plot point of the Remembrance of Earth's Past trilogy (Three Body Problem) too
- katzenversteher 4y agoExactly, it's quite important for the plot of "Death's End"
- aftbit 4y agoSee also Anathem by Neal Stephenson
- rqtwteye 4y agoMakes me wonder if there ever will be a type of propulsion that doesn’t rely on throwing out mass behind a spaceship.
- toast0 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_sail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_sail doesn't throw mass out the back. Although, it's not a lot of propulsion, it's something.
- randallsquared 4y agoIt still uses reaction mass; it’s just that it’s resupplied continuously by the Sun. In some orbits around Earth and other planets with a string magnetic field, you can drive a ship by pushing on the planet. Also pretty low propulsion.
- rbanffy 4y agoYou can make it a couple times better by doing a close approach to the Sun. Within Mercury's orbit, you'll get 16 times (apologies for my napkin-quality math) the push it'd get around here. And, with some mirrors, you can make a solar-thermal rocket as well. All that makes me think: if today we decided to launch a Voyager-mass probe, what would be the maximum speed we could achieve with technologies we could deploy in a couple years (ruling out NTRs, liquid reactors, nuclear lightbulb or anything that requires a non-RTG fission reactor on board). Imagining a chemical rocket for the initial push, then solar sail (maybe solar-thermal-rocket as well) from the perihelion until the distance to the Sun makes it worth to jettison the sail (maybe reorient the mirrors towards solar panels) and make the rest of the delta-v on ion engines powered by the solar panels increasingly replaced by a set of dedicated RTGs.
- api 4y agoThermonuclear Orion could (on paper) reach 10% the speed of light. Proxima Centauri in about 50 years using technology contemporary with the Beatles and Woodstock. This is why I have trouble dismissing the Fermi paradox. Either intelligent life that can engage in space flight is very rare (as in less than one per galaxy per billion years) or we are in a wildlife preserve or a zoo.
- ianburrell 4y agoProject Daedalus could reach 10% speed of light. But that didn’t use thermonuclear bombs but laser-pumped inertial confinement fusion. It also didn’t use physical pusher but magnetic nozzle. We don’t know how to do them with our technology but should be possible. There are followons that are more doable but slower. I have seen Wikipedia quote 10% for regular Orion but not finding any sources. I find that speed unlikely with all the trouble that Daedalus and others went through to get interstellar pulse rockets. I see 6ksec impulse for could-build-now Orion, 100ksec for theoretical improvements, and Daedalus would be 1Msec. Regular Orion probably maxes out at 1%. Fission Orion is infeasible for interstellar because need huge quantities of fissionables, maybe 10-100x weight of ship. Fusion has advantage of using cheap elements.
- neets 4y agoAh this is the project that the show Ascension[1] was based on 1. https://m.imdb.com/title/tt3696720/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt3696720/
- neets 4y agoI sorta hope they literally did what they did in Ascension IRL, does anyone else?