8 ms·
Virgin Orbit pauses all operations
- LatteLazy 4y agoThat's sad, but this space is likely ready for consolidation...
- eagerpace 4y agoYes, but the odds of them finding a buyer are astronomical. Full reusability is the future. Even ULA is reportedly up for sale after backing away from plans for their new rocket to be reusable. The new space race will be SpaceX and Blue Origin.
- stametseater 4y agoBlue Origin failing to deliver on time is a big part of the reason ULA is floundering. ULA bet on Blue Origin being able to provide engines for the Vulcan Centaur in a timely manner, but what they got were years of delays. And now that Bezos had his little joyride, he seems to have checked space off his bucket list and turned his attention towards yachting with his new wife, so I don't expect we'll see productive management reform in Blue Origin anytime soon. The real space race is between SpaceX and China.
- ben_w 4y agoFor the moment it's SpaceX vs everyone else combined, given how far ahead they are. I won't rule out China rising to the challenge, but I also wouldn't want to rule out Relativity Space and their 3D printing, nor some as-yet unannounced group saying they've made a breakthrough with superconducting levitation or active support structures or skyhooks or fusion-powered second stages that let them go directly (from a high altitude but suborbital first stage so you don't have to worry about backscattered radiation from the air) to Δv = 0.1c.
- panick21_ 4y agoYeah but here is the reality of the situation. The AR-15, the alternative engine, was years behind the BE-4 in development and likely would have been delayed just as much and also costs more for worse performance and a with a company behind it that has no independent interest in the engine. Also, ULA is not floundering. In fact the opposite. Amazon bought all Ariane 5s and given the increasingly constrained launch market, if you have a heavy lifter that can launch, you likely get some contracts. Bezos might be yachting, but he is currently spending 2-3 billion a year on a company that doesn't have revenue. So he is serious and they will just push threw.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AtlasBarfed 4y ago... in the USA. Japan, China, Russia, and the EU will all insist on their own rocket launch capability, won't they? At a minimum SpaceX shows the path to Starship-level reductions in launch payload costs, then the other state actors will follow the formula. If this just represents flawed approaches being trimmed from the marketplace, well ok. ... Blue Origin needs to get to "real" orbit, right? Last I heard they were resorting to troll-lawsuits against SpaceX because they weren't getting government launch contracts. Yeah, because... you ... can't yet?
- kown7 4y agoEurope will have to develop a fully reusable launcher to be competitive. Let's call it Ariane 7 and expect it to fly around 2035. They first have to get Ariane 6 off the ground and that's, from what I've heard, a horribly slow process.
- stametseater 4y agoThe ESA/ArianeGroup was blindsided by the economic feasibility of rocket reuse. They have only recently come to terms with this and begun developing their own semi-reusable equivalent to Falcon 9. Ariane 6 (no reuse) hasn't even flown yet but is already obsolete. A European Falcon 9 equivalent is many years away. I expect the EU to continue building their own rockets anyway, so they don't have to rely on the US and/or Russia. They do want their own launch capability as you mention. But will they produce anything that can compete with SpaceX for the sort of contracts that could go to an American company? Not anytime soon; they're already years behind and if Starship flies soon the gap will be huge.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoBut once starship gets into service, come on, that might be the most targeted piece of intellectual property in the history of corporate espionage. Why develop your own? If you are china/russia/india, you simply steal it. If you are the EU/Japan, you "cross-license". What does foreign patent law mean when national security is on the line? Starship is going to be an INSANE strategic and tactical weapon for the US government, if only for the rapid deployment ability. Starship is a private company. It will be so easy to steal. You simply bribe employees, or plant them.
- palebluedot 4y agoRocket Lab will likely be a contender in there, as well
- DennisP 4y agoAnd Stoke Space, which is going for full reusability with an aerospike on the second stage. Everyday Astronaut got a visit and it seemed pretty impressive. https://everydayastronaut.com/stoke-space/ https://everydayastronaut.com/stoke-space/
- benj111 4y ago>astronomical So does that mean it's likely in this context?
- stirlo 4y agoRichard Branson’s last 3 investments ($25, $20 & $10 million) have all been secured against the company’s assets. I don’t see anyone paying $55 million for it as a going concern so it looks like he’ll inherit it. Will be interesting to see if he chooses to continue or shut it down once it’s back in his hands.
- tempsy 4y agoBetween Virgin Galactic and now this hard to see him as much more than a pump and dump SPAC grifter.
- ta1243 4y agoI struggle to think of a successful Branson venture in the last 20 years, possible even longer. Other than selling the "Virgin" branding of course.
- panick21_ 4y agoVirgin Galactic was the most disgusting pump-and-dump ever. They literally SPAC telling a story about intercontinental hypersonic flight. Fucking absurd, the company can't make low power hybrid engine burn a short time readability and have constant issue with their air-frame. And beyond have a terrible safety culture. Yeah that company is gone build an intercontinental hypersonic airliner that about 100x more difficult problem. When will the get it working, in 2150? It was literally a pure lie and grift for money, and soon after Branson and all the leadership of VG dropped stocks like crazy. Branson also invested in this idiotic Hyperloop company. Another pure investor drift nonsense, but at least it didn't SPAC.
- stametseater 4y agoStill a more successful launch provider than Blue Origin.
- greesil 4y agoFor now
- stametseater 4y agoBlue Origin has been in business for more than two decades and still hasn't put anything in orbit. Two more decades maybe?
- miniman1337 4y agoExcept the engines they built are finally launching in about 2 months.
- ravenstine 4y ago"Business" is a generous descriptor when no viable product has ever been sold.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trollerator23 4y agoNot really
- stametseater 4y agoVirgin Orbital has actually succeeded in putting things into orbit, so yes really.
- starik36 4y agoThat is sad. I thought the idea of using a 747 as a glorified first stage (or stage 0) was sound as it saved a ton of money. I wonder why they couldn't make it work. And why does a single failure doom a company after 4 successful launches.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 4y agoElon said somewhere that using a carrier aircraft to replace the first stage doesn’t scale. I think Virgins space ventures are all pretty much dead in the water, similar the space plane it’s just outdated and outmatched by the competition.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stametseater 4y agoOrbital Sciences, now Northrop Grumman, has successfully used plane launches for the Pegasus a few dozen times since the 90s. They use a Lockheed TriStar instead of a 747, but the principle is the same. It definitely works. Their launch volume has been trending down though. I don't think they're able to effectively compete for most contracts.
- ianburrell 4y agoThere are other small-sat rocket which are cheaper. The Rocket Lab Electron is $7.5 million for 250kg while Pegasus is $40 million for 450kg. Plus, SpaceX has piggyback program for small sats that is cheaper but longer wait.
- jojosbuddy 4y agoYes, launch stage was pretty bulletproof, 2nd upto the liquid stage were the problems (should be fixed by now that the tech exists). The systems are likely the same as 2005 that new VC funded launch companies can undercut price with updated designs/tech (R&D expenses absorbed by VCs). I think the telemetry live stream/OpenGl viz of the last minotaur launch looked like a slightly revised UIX of the original live stream tool I built back in the 90s (I worked on Pegasus), aka old tech, not shiny. Edit: Really it's a potential energy to cost problem. 5% more efficiency is [actually] big when leaving this planet, but yes, cost of air launch is still stuck in 1990 times. From the outside I didn't see any innovation from the VO team aside from electronics. As for VG, I used to work with their new CEO and Eng VP: they know ops, but I thought the systems/tech hadn't been flush out 100%, so may have the similar fate if a few customers start canceling. I have some ideas to 'fix' air launch requiring big R&D, but knee deep in fixing autonomous drones! Peg was not financially successful cause prior 2002, the space race was maybe 15 launches a year: not profitable. Stuff like Iridium failed, shutting down ideas of having thousands of sats in LEO, mind that the only markets were communications (cellular/fiber won), science experiments, and imaging (imaging/remote sensing? Drone tech will eventually win). Luckily LEO payloads are a cool idea again-- tech is better + moore's law, thus demand is HOT. Heck Orbcomm is up there today, but old tech no one really wants. Today, Elon played the long game (2002) and kept innovating where SpaceX has found the cost-benefit balance via reusability, and [with timing] being the only system post Shuttle it's a duopoly with ULA--charge as much to stay in the black. BUT the markets are still the 3 above, nothing new (Elon's Mars thing == passion project) though every country now wants their 'own constellation' cause of the NRO, hehe. Trivia Edit: Peg's GNC computer was an 80386SX :)
- localplume 4y agoWhat will happen to Spaceport Cornwall then, if Virgin Orbit shuts down? Seems like a massive waste of investment then since I don't think any launch provider will take its place. Pretty grim for the UK space launch industry as a whole.
- ac29 4y ago"Spaceport" Cornwall is just Cornwall Airport. There are no traditional (vertical) launch facilities there.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> the UK space launch industry as a whole Was the UK ever a good place for space launches in the first place? It's too far from the equator.
- peoplearepeople 4y agoCountries often want independent capabilities even if it costs more. And plenty of of launch types don't care about distance to the equator, for example polar orbits. Lots of launch sites are very north, for example Baikonur, Plesetsk, and Vostochny.
- basementcat 4y agoSome satellites have polar or higher inclination orbits.
- ta1243 4y agoUK is perfect for launches to about 55 degree retrograde inclination You wouldn't want to launch into a sun-syncrhonous orbit from the Equator. Or from Florida or Cape Canaveral for that matter. The delta-V you start with which is great for an equatorial launch has to be shed to get into a polar or near-polar orbit. From Scotland though, there's far less Delta V than Florida, or from French Guiana.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoThe UK's only orbital rocket launched from Australia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Arrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Arrow
- peoplearepeople 4y agoI wonder if a country without an orbital rocket program would consider buying them out.
- wongarsu 4y agoMaybe a country with inconvenient geography. You really want to launch rockets close to the equator to save fuel, and ideally you want to launch on a path that doesn't drop debris (from spent stages or potential failures) on inhabited areas or foreign nations. Few such sites exist, but if you launch from an airplane you can just fly to a convenient location somewhere in international waters
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWhy wouldn't they just ship their payload to one of the existing launch providers? And save the money?
- bleuarff 4y agoGeostrategic considerations might make it impossible to use a foreign launch site.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoNo country that I know of is currently, or has ever been, on bad terms with all launching countries simultaneously. Do you have any examples?
- bleuarff 4y agoWhen you have business in space, having independent launch capabilities is a strategic matter, whatever your relationships with your partner countries are. E.g. Europe wants to keep access to space without having to rely solely on the United States.
- 4y ago
- nothingneko 4y agoIt's sad that Virgin Orbit isn't able to survive it was a really novel idea
- SonicScrub 4y agoIt really was not all that novel. Pegasus had been around for over 20 years before it was founded, and had already proven air launch more or less economically unviable compared with ground based launchers.
- jimnotgym 4y ago> and furlough almost all its staff, although the company did not officially confirm the furloughs to BBC News It is a fun point that I live in the UK and have headed up finance at SMEs. Until the pandemic I had never even heard the term 'furlough'. What does it mean now? If they are UK staff I doubt you can do anything other than make them redundant.
- CydeWeys 4y agoIt's been used in the US much longer than that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Furlough https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Furlough
- jimnotgym 4y agoI'm aware of that. I, like everyone else in the UK, googled it at the start of the pandemic. My point was more that the linked article was from the BBC, and this is a phrase that is basically legally meaningless in the UK.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Symmetry 4y agoThere are real advantages to launching from higher up, not just in terms of reducing drag losses but in using larger engine bells with higher ISPs, saving on structural mass due to lower aerodynamic forces, and maybe launching from over the sea if otherwise you'd have a hard time finding a safe launch corridor. But rockets are usually launched from the middle of large, empty pads for a reason since there's always the danger of an explosion. Unmanned planes could help but planes are expensive pieces of capital to have sitting around if you don't have a fast launch cadence. I'd tend to favor balloon style designs, though that makes getting to remote launch locations more awkward.
- SonicScrub 4y agoBalloon launch is a god-awful concept. Not only do you have the logistical challenges of air-launch (compounded by carrying a bomb with a minimally controllable vehicle), you also don't have the horizontal velocity of an aircraft to provide additional dynamic pressure at the critical pitch-up first turn phase of flight, AND you have the absymal lifting capabilities of a balloon. Balloon launch is all the downsides of air launch with a few extra thrown in for good measure, with almost zero advantages over traditional air-launch (let alone ground launch)
- schiffern 4y ago> you also don't have the horizontal velocity of an aircraft to provide additional dynamic pressure at the critical pitch-up first turn phase of flight Isn't one of the (few) advantages of balloon launch that this critical pitch-up maneuver is far less dramatic? At launch the rocket can already be oriented mostly vertical instead of mostly horizontal. Of course this has the attendant disadvantage that your rocket starts with less kinetic energy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- immmmmm 4y agoi've been fascinated about rockets since im 3, was drawing engines with turbopumps by 5, but since i read about ecology at 35 i am now convinced we need exactly two types of satellites: 1) earth observation and weather one, to monitor a very dangerous warming on this planet 2) icbm early warning systems, to avoid cooling it very fast. what argument do you have for more orbital stuff and which type?
- oh_sigh 4y agoCommunications and astronomy seem like very reasonable uses of space. Comms because how much of the planet can be seen/covered be a single device, and astronomy to bypass information loss from the atmosphere.
- immmmmm 4y agoagreed! it's important to communicate, and studying distant worlds makes us human (but as a physicist im biased). maybe an international mission to mars could be useful. dunno.
- mkl 4y agoGPS etc. are pretty important.
- throwaway67743 4y agoI'd like to remind everyone this is the same guy that took tax breaks and grants and has failed at pretty much everything, including trains, somehow, it's pretty much given on a silver platter - this is not unexpected