8 ms·
Stripe missing the 2018-2021 tech IPO window is going to be seen as a historic business decision making failure. Everything was in their favor. They could have
by paxys 4y ago
Stripe missing the 2018-2021 tech IPO window is going to be seen as a historic business decision making failure. Everything was in their favor. They could have sleepwalked into a $120B+ market cap. All employees and investors could have had as much liquidity as they desired. But for whatever reason the founders stuck to their "we will stay private forever" stance, and the entire company is suffering because of it.
- htrp 4y agoprobably not as bad as the wework botched ipo.... but your point remains
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWework had indefensible problems with their business model, hence sinking even in the frothiest of times. Stripes would have surely fared much better.
- paxys 4y agoWework's problem wasn't timing. They actually chose to go public under perfect market conditions, just that their underlying business was so out of touch with reality that not even the most optimistic institutional investors or bankers could digest it.
- TheNewsIsHere 4y agoI have been reading Billion Dollar Loser by Reeves Wiedeman. That out of touch quality that seemed to permeate WeWork was seemingly there from the beginning, courtesy of Adam Neumann. To say that he comes off looking delusional is being kind.
- fnimick 4y agoAnd yet somehow whenever he sneezes he finds investors willing to throw millions upon millions of dollars at him. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/15/business/dealbook/adam-neumann-wework-startup.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/15/business/dealbook/adam-ne...
- paxys 4y agoThere is always a greater fool...
- csomar 4y agoHe is not delusional. He just started a Carbon business and raised money for it.
- TheNewsIsHere 4y agoI don’t submit he’s delusional because of the business he started. My position is that he comes off as delusional because of some of the things he says in the context of business. To read and listen to some of the things he has said, he does come off as a bit of a cultist. I do however think it’s delusional to slap a “tech” label on a real estate firm, treat it like it’s a tech company, and expect any different outcome.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- efields 4y ago> Stripe does not need this capital to run its business. Suffering? Raising $6.5b when you don’t need to, but because it helps your longest running employees, is suffering?
- paxys 4y agoTheir last raise was at a $95B valuation, so this is a massive down round. It isn't a case of raising extra unneeded money just because market conditions are favorable. Quite the opposite in fact. If they didn't critically need this money they wouldn't have taken the hit at all.
- rubiquity 4y agoAn IPO during that time would certainly help stock holders get liquid but it wouldn't help the business given that Banks/Firms were making a killing on the IPOs of that era by disastrously mispricing the businesses. There's a lot of business that still needs to happen after an IPO and an IPO in and of itself is not the goal. If you're running a solid business like Stripe during turbulent times keeping your options open is a good idea. We haven't seen how the IPO fest of 2020-2021 is going to work out for some of those companies if they get cash strapped.
- hgsgm 4y agoThe IPOs were overpriced, which is great for sellers.
- rubiquity 4y agoWhich won't be the employees for 180 days.
- satvikpendem 4y agoEven counting the lock up, prices were still higher then than now.
- ergocoder 4y agoStripe likely would have gone direct listing which would have no lock up.
- peanuty1 4y agoIf Stripe went public via IPO between Sep 2020 and March 2021 (like so many other pre-IPO tech companies of a similar maturity as Stripe such as Snowflake, DoorDash, Airbnb, Unity, Roblox, Palantir, etc), their employees would still presumably be able to sell their RSUs at a $100B+ market cap after the 180-day lockup period as tech companies in the payments space like Adyen and Square only started to see their shares plummet from their peak in November 2021. And if Stripe went public via direct listing like Slack and Coinbase, their employees wouldn't have a lockup period.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThis isn't right. Whether they give up ~5% or ~10% of the company for the capital raise is a rounding error in the grand scheme. For context, many stocks went down 5% today because some dude in europe said they won't put more money into credit suisse. Tomorrow they might go up 5% because Elon farts in a certain direction.
- hesparrow 4y agoThe article states they raised billions to allow employees to sell their (otherwise soon to expire) RSUs to investors to cover their tax bill. Stripe itself isn’t using the money.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoYes. But what is your point?
- jmillikin 4y agoTheir point is that this isn't a capital raise and Stripe isn't issuing new shares. Also, if it were to be a capital raise: issuing new shares comprising 5% of a company is not the same as having the price of existing shares reduce by 5% (in many ways). Your post is completely off-track.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIt is a capital raise. It's right there in the announcement. They are raising new capital, issuing shares, then buying back different shares. The net result will be about the same share count. But the series I investors are getting a little over 10% of the company for their 6.5B, instead of about 5% for their 6.5B (if the valuation was 120B as suggested). For the company as a whole, it's just not a big deal. And if you happen to be a RSU holder/employee, don't sell at this price if you don't want to (and you were going to lose about a 1/3 of it no matter what, so no the tax withholding doesn't change it materially). Correct, it isn't the same thing - it's an analogy - the point was that in both cases it's a rounding error. The existing equity holders as a group are in a position which is about 5% different economically than it could have been if they'd snatched the very top and raised at that level. When you buy or sell shares, you are almost always off 5% v if you'd sold at some other slightly better time. Following?
- varispeed 4y ago> All employees and investors could have had as much liquidity as they desired. Not necessarily. Investors see employees as a cost, necessary evil, nuisance. There would be a strong push for layoffs and maximisation of profit. Some investors could even try for asset stripping and extract as much value as possible in the short term to fund their other investments. It is very much universal, once company does IPO it basically turns into cr*p.
- gkoberger 4y agoThey could have hit $120B market cap at one point, but all public tech stocks are significantly down since then. For example, their closest competitor Adyen hit $31, but is now at $14. So with this logic, Stripe's valuation would be almost exactly where it currently is. Yes, a lot of former employees could have become liquid. But a lot also would have had money tied up exactly the same way it is now, except on a much more volatile public market where their every move would be much more scrutinized. They're now providing liquidity to employees via this fundraise, too, which solves the only major drawback I can see with not going public earlier.
- sangnoir 4y ago> They could have hit $120B market cap at one point, but all public tech stocks are significantly down since then I think that's parent's point: investors and current stock holders could have transferred $120B from retail investors before the adjustment. Now they have to hold onto their own devalued stock like a bunch of rubes. /s
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThat isn't how it works. Going public at $120 bill valuation doesn't mean you raise $120 billion. They'd have raised something like they have here.
- hgsgm 4y agoIt is how it works, selling at inflated valuation, but a fraction of the $120B, not all of it.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThe "fraction" part is key....
- nimbuscoder 4y agoDing ding ding
- neximo64 4y agoExactly right. If it was an IPO, the $6.5B would go into Stripe's bank account to grow the business instead of buying out shares from employees who have to sell. And sure maybe they didn't need that money, but it could have helped acquire companies and grow more. This deal is basically the preamble to a direct listing. Which again would not help Stripe raise funds but instead merry go round shareholders.
- rvz 4y agoThis is all down to greediness. Instead of IPO'ing in 2019 (Which was the optimal time to IPO and head to the exit as mentioned before [0]), not even $95BN is somehow enough? A direct listing is probably a better option since it will be even more difficult for them to raise again for an IPO this year, given the current market turbulence. To Downvoters: I will triple down. It is certainly greed. Here's why: As far back as 2017 [1] and since then Stripe's founders just wanted more and missed the opportunity to IPO in 2019 and just almost forgot about it's own employees stock options expiring and becoming worthless. They are now forced to delay plans for an IPO due to the market downturn and have to deal with a significant 50% down-round. They know they cannot raise anymore money this time otherwise it is another hit to their valuation. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20993919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20993919 [1] https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/07/stripes-patrick-collison-says-no-to-an-ipo-any-time-soon/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/07/stripes-patrick-collison-s...
- cptcobalt 4y agoThis is not a clear-cut "hindsight is 20/20" case — what you are proposing is merely a hazy probability and not a "they could have done this to print money—it's equally likely if they IPO'ed that a downward trend and less value could have been the result.
- camhart 4y ago> the entire company is suffering because of it. What are you proposing? That the company should have instead made a "predict the future" decisions optimized for short term gains?
- paxys 4y agoWhat I'm suggesting didn't require some crazy foresight. It was the obvious move. Stripe was fully capable of going public at any point in that period, and analysts, investors, insiders were all calling for it to happen. Every other tech "unicorn" in its cohort – Uber, Lyft, Airbnb, Pinterest, Slack, Snowflake, Zoom, Palantir and like a hundred more – did just that. Stripe choosing to stay public was a deliberate decision by the founders, one that did not work out.
- camhart 4y agoVery few people were confident enough to make a financial bet that tech valuations would tank by 50%. I'm not arguing whether it did or didn't work. I'm trying to point out that anyone who could have predicted this change in tech valuations stood to make a crap ton of money regardless of what Stripe did. You make it sound obvious--that's hindsight bias. It wasn't obvious.
- elAhmo 4y agoIs there more available on the actual reasons why they didn't go public earlier?
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Uber, Lyft, Airbnb, Pinterest, Slack, Snowflake, Zoom, Palantir and like a hundred more – did just that. Stripe choosing to stay public was a deliberate decision by the founders, one that did not work out. I guess that depends on what you mean by "worked out". For Stripe employees, maybe it didn't. For the public at large, many of whom are underwater owning shares in the companies you mentioned, maybe it did?
- paxys 4y ago
- mathattack 4y agoI think it’s more nuanced. The issue bigger than market cap is just being able to IPO at all and give your folks liquidity.
- tempsy 4y agouh 2018-2020 was not a good window it was pretty much very end of 2020 and early to mid 2021.
- armatav 4y agoWas a great decision - should stay private forever. You think the IPO window was “missed”, they aren’t short sighted about their company.
- myhrvold 4y agoYeah I think the question is "great for who". I think it could be great for the founders (who can achieve liquidity in a variety of ways at any point really, that regular employees don't have access to. I'm not critical of this -- makes sense to me -- just pointing that out.) It wasn't so good for employees who would've wanted to sell and diversify when the valuation was, conservatively, about 2x what it is now. And maybe even 2.5x plus if you extrapolate what Stripe could've been worth at the height of the market. For the long term company, it still could be a good, because if they can raise capital privately like they were just able to do, then they get the upside of access to money without the downside of share price fluctuations, scrutiny, more bureaucracy etcetera.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>It wasn't so good for employees who would've wanted to sell and diversify when the valuation was, conservatively, about 2x what it is now. Again I will point out that the "good" argument is one-sided. Had the employees sold at 2x the valuation, then some person (or pension) bought at 2x the valuation and lost a lot of money. What is that "good"? Because the SV crew "got theirs"?
- armatav 4y agoYeah, but it’s like; 1) Sacrifice the entire companies long term existence to let a small number of people sell at 2.5X the share price one time during a macroeconomic peak 2) Allow almost everyone, including new employees, a longer-term path to wealth, by ignoring that bubble peak and focusing on long term value generation outside of the public markets (which notoriously destroy companies) IMO, it’s such a base layer of internet businesses, they should keep it private forever; otherwise it’ll be PayPal in 10 years.
- cloudking 4y agoOr they dodged a bullet by not having their valuation artificially inflated by money printing?
- ergocoder 4y agoAnd that is bad for employees, how?
- mushbino 4y agoWhy is the entire company suffering? Do they need to raise funds?
- jasmer 4y agoI don't agree at all. The only 'suffering' going on here is issues with employee liquidity. As long as the company can raise the money it needs on good terms, there's absolutely no reason otherwise to be a public company.
- al_be_back 4y ago> They could have sleepwalked into a $120B+ market cap payments market dramatically shifted with emergence of Device Pay (Google/Apple Pay), I think an IPO would've distracted them - staying private for now makes sense, they can focus on differentiating factors.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIn fairness, who can time a market?
- zouhair 4y agoValve and Ikea are doing great and I know of a bunch of companies that had successful IPOs that are now defunct. Your comment is quite silly. No one can predict the future with certainty.