3 ms·
Are you even familiar with the Turing test? Passing doesn't require the subject to demonstrate any particular level of knowledge or expertise. The subject only
by nradov 4y ago
Are you even familiar with the Turing test? Passing doesn't require the subject to demonstrate any particular level of knowledge or expertise. The subject only has to convince the evaluators that it is roughly as intelligent as an average human. Average humans are expected to pass such a Turing test.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoWhy should a panel exist in the first place if you are not testing knowledge? Intelligence is independent of one's knowledge. Plenty of intelligent but uneducated people, and plenty of educated people - or even people with perfect recall - that are not particularly intelligent. If you are testing intelligence you should be able to distill it to particular tests independent of domain expertise. Any intelligent agent should be capable of in-context learning. So how would you go about doing that? If you do find such a test, do you expect that only the average human and above will pass? Does that not imply that the remaining 4Bn people are not generally intelligent?
- nradov 4y agoThe (notional) panel exists to evaluate intelligence, not test knowledge or educational achievement. While some basic level of general knowledge would be necessary to even start a test the main focus would be on ability to learn and reason, including metacognition.