6 ms·
The Chinese Room argument is fundamentally flawed - it depends on the unfounded and frankly unlikely assumption that machines cannot be sentient.
by IshKebab 4y ago
The Chinese Room argument is fundamentally flawed - it depends on the unfounded and frankly unlikely assumption that machines cannot be sentient.
- ronjobber 4y agoCan you define sentience in this context?
- IshKebab 4y agoIt doesn't have a precise definition (which is part of the reason why the people saying programs fundamentally cannot be sentient are so stupid). But basically it means being conscious / self-aware. Technically it means having some kind of senses that make you aware of the external environment too but that's a minor difference from consciousness - I only said "sentience" because it's what most other people talking about this say. They really mean consciousness. (And also text based IO can be a sense.)
- rtkwe 4y agoFor me it's not an argument for or against sentience but a lot more about the difficulty of defining it and potentially measuring it in non-human systems along with the fuzziness of the concept of knowledge. My use of it was about my belief I guess that it's just pushing symbols around algorithmically without anything we'd call understanding.
- nullc 4y agoIt's an intuitive but false argument that a sentient thing can't be made from a non-sentient part. The room argument has a pointless human in it which is clearly clueless about the dialog in order to 'prove' that the room as a whole is clueless. But imagine applying that to a single person: pick a single neuron -- does it 'understand' our conversation? no. So why would any singular component of a chinese speaking room-system understand? It also fails at the opposite extreme, since we're willing to tolerate unreasonably large rooms -- what about one running a full molecular dynamics simulation of a human. As best as we understand physics that simulation would behave just as the human would and must be sentient. You cannot deny the abstract possibility of machine intelligence without rejecting physics for mysticism, only the practicality/plausibility of it.
- Reimersholme 4y ago[dead]
- epups 4y agoSorry but I think you got the first part wrong. It is not at all arguing that sentience cannot emerge from non-sentient parts: Searle is a materialist. Some of your arguments, such as the fact that single neurons are also not sentient, are addressed by him. The point of this thought experiment is to illustrate that merely replicating a behavior - in that case translation - does not say anything about sentience. The Chinese Room may produce intelligent output, but it does not reason as a human does. I find it remarkably prescient. ChatGPT can produce remarkably intelligent output, should we consider it human? If not, then you implicitly agree with Searle, at least in some level.
- nullc 4y agoI've never spoken directly with Searle, but I have with several of his students and all have been emphatic that the Chinese Room Argument is demonstrates that a computer program can't have intelligence. Quoting Searle himself, "The point of the argument is this: if the man in the room does not understand Chinese on the basis of implementing the appropriate program for understanding Chinese then neither does any other digital computer solely on that basis because no computer, qua computer, has anything the man does not have." I think the most succinct description of his error is substituting the (lack of) understanding of a part of the system (the man) for the understanding of the entire system (the rules and file cabinets, etc.). But I'm interested in learning that I'm mistaken. You could turn his position around and say it's not the computer itself that's intelligent when a Chinese room system exhibits intelligence but the program -- and I suppose I'd agree with that, but it's also just semantics, uninteresting, and I don't believe he's ever taken that position. I do agree that "merely replicating a behavior" doesn't prove much, but I don't think the Chinese room speaks to that substantially. It might if it demanded that the room implement only a very simple input to output map, but it doesn't: it allows the room to implement anything a computer program can implement. (A fact I use in my post to point out that the room could (in our land of hypotheticals) implement the molecular dynamics of an entire human being) GPT has structural properties that make it very easy to classify it as an entirely different thing than a human mind. GPT is frozen in time, it cannot have an internal existence due to how its structured. It doesn't even have memory. It cannot learn (unless you include the whole company training it as part of 'it') except in the sense that it can immediately adapt to the output right in front of it, but can't preserve the knowledge. Theoretically if you made it arbitrarily large you could say it was close enough to having memory by always evaluating its complete history, but because its size grows quadratically with its window that isn't practicaly (and might not be possible to train-- it's totally credible that beyond some size these models will lose performance we just haven't gotten there yet). Figuring out how to train these models make good use of 'memory' is an ongoing challenge, since efficient memory isn't differentiable just ordinarily training with memory as part of the process doesn't work. Except by 'thinking out loud' in its output GPT also has a fixed upper bound on the time it can spend thinking any thought which is seemingly unlike a human mind.
- epups 4y agoI don't think it depends on that assumption. It merely asserts that replicating behavior that indicates sentience does not equate sentience, and today we can see that this is correct.
- zamadatix 4y agoIn general I’d agree but in regards to ChatGPT there is nothing about the way it works that suggests it is conscious or has a mind. If you asked an AI researcher to implement something akin to the way the program mentioned in the Chinese room argument works you’d pretty much get ChatGPT style solution.