7 ms·
Mercury Vault: money market fund and up to $3M in FDIC insurance
- berkle4455 4y agoFDIC insures to 100% by default now
- colinmorelli 4y agoThis is a bad take on what FDIC did with SVB, and certainly not an assumption that is safe to rely on. Please do not spread this, as people who believe it carry a real risk of financial harm. There are multiple threads trying to go into detail about the nuance of what happened, so I'll spare from rehashing it here. But it certainly was not promising FDIC coverage on all deposited funds.
- qeternity 4y ago> and certainly not an assumption that is safe to rely on. What scenario can you imagine where this does not hold true? SVB is almost the perfect scenario in which to haircut depositors, and yet here we are.
- colinmorelli 4y agoThe Failed Bank List on the FDIC has quite a few examples. You can see dividend payouts from failed banks here: https://closedbanks.fdic.gov/dividends/ https://closedbanks.fdic.gov/dividends/ There are many examples of cases in which depositors take a 4-10% haircut, and receive it months or years after the failure (meaning the haircut is quite a bit larger when factoring for time).
- Scoundreller 4y agoThanks for that. Looks like the IndyMac uninsured did only get 50% on the uninsured portion. Was always wondering if they got more, but nope. (They did get lucky in that fdic limit was $100k and I think they retroactively upped it to $250k on this failure, but that probably hurt rather than helped anyone with over $500k or so). Many other examples of >10% losses, would be cool if someone did an analysis.
- generj 4y agoRight if you bank at a regional bank that isn’t connected to influential VC your deposits might still lose value.
- berkle4455 4y agoHow much would you like to bet that FDIC will formally announce 100% protection for depositors and the cost of that will be borne by FDIC member banks along with dramatically increasing banking scrunity for banks of all sizes. Bank stocks will crash more, and consumers will ultimately feel the pinch as banks use the only tools then available to create margins: dramatically increased fees and cost of borrowing.
- colinmorelli 4y agoAnd if they do, then that's the right time to begin claiming that 100% of deposits are FDIC insured. That time is not now.
- berkle4455 4y agoIt’s already the time. The decision was made literally yesterday with SVB and Signature.
- colinmorelli 4y agoThere was absolutely zero announcement yesterday that 100% of all deposits in all banks are guaranteed by FDIC. There was a commitment to cover 100% of SVB and Signature Bank deposits under the systemic risk exception. You can take issue with this, or suggest that they will offer protection for 100% of deposits in the future, and that's fine. I'm not going to argue that point, since I don't know what will happen next. But to say that the FDIC came out and announced 100% protection of all deposits is no more true today than it was when banks were bailed out in the '08 crisis, and there have been many, many examples of depositors losing money since those bailouts happened.
- berkle4455 4y agoI’m not talking about failures since 08. Just since Thursday. It’s a new policy. You can debate the nuances all you want, I’m sticking with the simple proof and reality. FDIC member banks offer 100% depositor protection now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MaxGabriel 4y agoHey all, I'm the CTO/a co-founder at Mercury. Here's background on this and where we are now: - We currently work with two partner banks, Evolve Bank and Trust and Choice Financial - Both our partner banks operate or are part of a sweep network (https://mercury.com/blog/company-news/understanding-bank-sweep-network https://mercury.com/blog/company-news/understanding-bank-swe...), where they can move funds into other banks. Each bank your money is in increases FDIC coverage by 250K. - For customers on our partner bank Evolve, this was bumped from 1mm to 3mm as of this morning. You get this automatically if you have accepted the T&Cs for the sweep program already; if you haven't you can do so at: https://mercury.com/settings/vault https://mercury.com/settings/vault - For customers on our partner bank Choice, you're still at 1mm FDIC insurance. We are working on getting you an Evolve savings account (or getting increased coverage from Choice) by tomorrow morning, or you can keep excess funds in Treasury (see below) # treasury - We also have a product called Mercury Treasury. This allows you to invest in mutual funds, the safest of which is a Vanguard Treasury Money Market fund (VUSXX), which invests primarily in short-term U.S. Treasury bills https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-funds/profile/vusxx#overview https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-fun... - These securities are held in your name at Apex Clearing, which is https://www.apexclearing.com/ https://www.apexclearing.com/ - They're not part of any fractional reserve system like with banks; every share of a mutual fund you hold is in your name and Apex can't lend against it (unless you give them permission which would be weird) - You can automatically sweep any funds between our treasury product and your savings account. Liquidity is about 3 to 4 days. - All treasury funds are visible on your Mercury dashboard, so you don't have to manually manage fund movements or keep track of your total balance across websites - You also earn interest on these AMA if you'd like, though caveat I'm jumping between a lot of Slack messages right now (edit: probably bowing eat to eat lunch)
- MartinMond 4y agoHey Max, I think your offering is amazing but it might be built for the world of yesterday: Since starting this weekend apparently all deposits are 100% insured, why would I go to Mercury to take advantage of sweeps or a money market fund, when my bank offers me slightly higher rates for uninsured-but-insured-in-practice deposits?
- jacobriis 4y agoGuys can we keep quite about this please. Yesterday the party line was it was outrageous to suggest a company could keep money in more than one bank and or in treasuries. Have you no empathy?
- chernevik 4y agoIt sounds like a useful and important product (if perhaps duplicative of extant offerings) but I'm afraid the government has blown up your market. All one has to do now is bank somewhere that "everyone thinks safe". So long as the community sharing this belief is sufficiently large and politically connected, the government will underwrite their belief. Questioning the groupthink is for risk nerds.
- chernevik 4y ago"Don't talk about downvotes" but I'm sorry, the obvious suppression of inconvenient opinion on this thread is HILARIOUS. The HN community is all for free-thinking except when its own conventions are contradicted. And those conventions are quite self-interested. I know this sort of meta-discourse is off-limits, but the effect is real and does deserve notice.
- p_j_w 4y agoThere was an article this morning about Silicon Valley VCs throwing a temper tantrum over the whole SVB debacle that was flagged, locked, and hidden with incredible speed (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35138024 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35138024). I'm sure the fact that it ran counter to YC's interests had nothing at all to do with it.
- chernevik 4y agoThere has always been a lot of groupthink in the downvoting and flagging here and they don't want to do anything about it. Oh well.
- mritchie712 4y agoThey were already at $1M FDIC insurance. I was in process of transferring money out when I got the email about this. Still going to transfer a little out, but less then I was going to before.
- fillskills 4y agoCame in to say that we have had a very positive experience with Mercury’s UX, features and support after using Mercury for almost 2 years. Lots of simple details and decisions that make a big impact on our day to day usage. The only bank site where I look forward to logging in No experience with this actual Money Market Fund account announcement
- ics 4y agoRecently opened a Mercury account and the first impression is great. But to add, their support was very quick to reach out with a human when I had a minor issue and some questions during the signup process.
- rkagerer 4y agoHere's the key bit: Through our partner banks, customers get access to a sweep network that provides up to $3M in FDIC insurance by spreading your deposits across up to 12 different banks, including Goldman Sachs & Capital One, without requiring you to open or manage separate accounts.
- cryptonector 4y agoMany banks offer this. It's a bit silly in that it's like not having any insurance limits, ah, but only for those in the know.
- mquirion 4y agoHow is this different from an insured cash sweep that practically every other bank offers?
- zamnos 4y agoMost of SVB's accounts apparently weren't sweep accounts.
- chernevik 4y agoYeah, why was that? Oops, sorry, not supposed to ask such questions.
- mcculley 4y agoMove fast, break things.
- p_j_w 4y agoI can't believe you would dare to imply that these companies and VCs actually bear some responsibility and that their incessant whining that it's not actually their fault at all isn't entirely true.
- mquirion 4y agoExactly. It's an abject failure of journalism if a dozen national journalists aren't currently sorting out why this was the case.
- HoyaSaxa 4y agoJust remember that if Mercury abruptly goes bankrupt, it is likely going to take days if not weeks or months for you to get access to those underlying funds from an operational perspective. Fintechs that rely upon Banking-as-a-Service (BaaS) arrangement like this are woefully under-regulated.
- riskneutral 4y agoImagine a convenient, Single Point of access for all your Redundancy-as-a-Service needs!
- hartator 4y agoIsn’t this kind of product not relavant anymore if the fed gonna to pick the tab anyway?
- Brajeshwar 4y agoI know I'm the one who submitted the one linking directly to mercury.com/vault but shouldn't that be the link here? It has all the information outlined in the current twitter thread. Here - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35137232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35137232
- altairprime 4y agoEmail the mods a link to this comment and ask them to consider merging the dupes.
- gneray 4y agoHappy Mercury customer for 4+ years
- vasco 4y agoIn an alternative timeline this has been the most aggressive guerrilla marketing tactic ever, induce a bank run to hype up your new Vault product.
- idiotsecant 4y agoIf products like this become widespread isn't it equivalent to 'tricking' FDIC into covering a higher % of your deposits? It appears this is more or less a service that takes your money and opens a lot of smaller accounts spread throughout all the different banks. Imagine that everyone did this. Now in the event of a medium scale bank default FDIC needs to cover not only the first 250k of a lot of people's money, but some multiple of that depending on how many banks that customer also had money in. Doesn't this stress FDIC insurance as a system? It seems to me it's counter to the intention of FDIC insurance in the first place (keep the small guy's money safe, assume the rich guy has plans to keep himself safe)
- chernevik 4y agoNo. - The FDIC's risk is distributed across many bank balance sheets - The FDIC is collecting insurance premium on these deposits Structures like this have existed for decades. [ETA: I've just seen a good bit in the WSJ that such structures do abuse deposit insurance, since they allow large depositors to avoid inspection of bank liquidity. So maybe I'm wrong.]
- vineyardmike 4y agoThis would only apply stress in the case of widespread failure. One bad bank means only using $250k in insurance. On the flip side, why would you engage in a bank run when you’re fully insured? It seems it would slow the incentives to be part of a bank run, which is the systemically damaging part.
- azinman2 4y agoWouldn’t it need to just cover the failed bank?
- mikedouglas 4y agoNo, because the FDIC would collect higher fees commensurate with the increase in insured deposits. It would reduce profits for banks like SVB which have a large number of uninsured deposits and were able to take advantage of a "fed put".
- 4y ago
- blobbers 4y agoThese guys have bumped up their ads like crazy. They were showing them through ESPN last night.
- dboreham 4y agoHA proxy deployed in front of retail banks.
- neilv 4y agohttps://mercury.com/about https://mercury.com/about looks like an affluent Bay Area lifestyle company for 20 year-olds? Does this resonate with their target customer, as what they're looking for, to hold their money and provide misc. banking services? (Personally, I love their decor and lifestyle aesthetic, but... I'd prefer to entrust my money to a place that seemed interested in providing good customer service for rock-solid banking services to small-fry me, yet was also a time-tested battleship of a trusted institution, where the head of it could get POTUS on the phone if ever needed.)