8 ms·
The biggest problem with mass-transit is that most often riders do not want to pay what it actually costs, so they vote for some form of tax-supported subsidy.
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
The biggest problem with mass-transit is that most often riders do not want to pay what it actually costs, so they vote for some form of tax-supported subsidy. And that almost inevitably hobbles it, because acquiring new passengers will affect total revenue only a little, whereas conforming to the whims of the public and the local government will affect its revenue a lot.
Aside from that, these sorts of analyses ignore the many benefits that cars provide and the many downsides of public transit. You aren't going to get people to switch just by pointing out how much more efficient something is, you have to make it actually better.
When I have to commute I prefer to do so by bus, but there are still a ton of use cases for local travel where I would only consider mass transit as an absolute last resort due to the intrinsic advantages/disadvantages.
- ajju 15y ago>Aside from that, these sorts of analyses ignore the many benefits that cars provide and the many downsides of public transit. Actually, the post doesn't ignore the benefits of cars. It says for example that an SUV is a great option for a family of 6 going to the suburbs. Perhaps you had some other benefits in mind?
- dangrossman 15y ago> Perhaps you had some other benefits in mind? How many days can you feed your family on 2 bags of groceries? Gonna carry the new TV you just bought on the bus with you? I can't imagine doing normal shopping without a car.
- ajju 15y ago>How many days can you feed your family on 2 bags of groceries? 4 of us actually live 2 blocks from the grocery store and I think someone gets a couple of bags every other day. The "10 bags of groceries" shopping trip is actually an effect of cars (and suburbanization). When cities are walkable, grocery stores are nearby too. I think it's obvious that just like a family of 6 can't fit on a bicycle and would need a SUV to go to Florida, you'd need a big vehicle to get a TV home. Presumably, you don't buy a TV every week.
- bdunbar 15y agoWhen cities are walkable, grocery stores are nearby too. I live in a small town in the American midwest, considered very walkable, lots of bike lanes, etc. We don't have smaller retail stores within walking distance. Instead we have big-box grocery stores like everywhere else. We _used_ to have those but in the late 50s they were zoned out of existence.
- perokreco 15y agoThe TV and all the bulkier things get delivered. Even if you have a car its not like you buy a fridge and drive it home.
- derekp7 15y agoUm, that is exactly what I did with my last fridge. I went to the appliance store, and got a $30 discount for cash & carry. Backed my F150 up to their warehouse, loaded it up, and drove it home. Now I don't buy a fridge everyday, but I've had to get enough large items over the last 10 years for the house to make the pickup truck worth it (when I first got the truck I was picking up some 2x4s, couple sheets of drywall, etc, about every couple weeks -- finished the basement, built a shed, etc, buy buying a couple pieces at a time).
- paganel 15y ago> Gonna carry the new TV you just bought on the bus with you? I can't imagine doing normal shopping without a car. I'm doing that just fine by using a tramway. And I'm not dead yet :) The good thing is that the hypermarket is only 3 tram stations away, and yes, there's a tram that goes by the hypermarket. Not to mention the 8AM-to-10PM grocery story that is open just outside my building, in case I need something very quick. That's what urbanization is all about. American suburbs don't fall into that category, they're more like Roman rural villas that will find a quick and painful death once the Barbarians "invade" (a stupid metaphor for when gasoline prices in the US will finally reach their normal levels). And I carried my 43' plasma using a taxi, I agree. I paid the taxi driver 15 bucks (in my country's money), and he even helped me carry it to my building's front-door.
- LaGrange 15y agoI get my bulky shopping delivered, I mean sticking a 42" TV into a sedan doesn't feel really safe anyway. I do my groceries in small portions, in a shop that's very close by. What's your problem?
- dangrossman 15y ago> I do my groceries in small portions, in a shop that's very close by. What's your problem? Last time I lived in a city, there were no reasonably priced grocery stores within walking distance, just tons of pizza shops and fast food. I live in the suburbs now. I buy more groceries per trip and eat healthier now -- I'm not tempted to eat out instead of revisit a grocery store when I'm out of food every few days. I moved my 42" TV in my sedan because it was safer there than in the moving truck.
- catch23 15y agoI live about 2 miles from the nearest grocery store, and still cook at home at least 70% of the time. One backpack and a bicycle buys enough food for 2 weeks. Even when I lived in the suburbs, there were grocery stores at that distance. It just never occurred to me that one could bike to the store and buy stuff, I always drove until I tried using the bike. I think the problem is more psychological than reasoned.
- icebraining 15y agoI moved my 42" TV in my sedan because it was safer there than in the moving truck. That doesn't make much sense. The shop is responsible for whatever happens to the stuff they deliver. If they damaged it, they'd have to repair it at no extra cost. Using your own car, on the other hand, puts the liability on you.
- barrkel 15y agoI live in London; but I very rarely take public transport unless I'll be drinking. There's a middle way: scooters. In most of London, parking is free, cheap in Westminster, and fairly plentiful outside of the City. The nearest big supermarket is about 30 minutes walk away, or about 5 minutes by scooter, somewhat longer by bicycle (owing to a road that bicycles aren't allowed on). There's a bus that goes directly to it every 15 minutes, but it doesn't really save time, only effort. I can't imagine only visiting a grocery store every few days, not least because I like my food fresh, particularly for baked items. Having to plan ahead for meals also kills some spontaneity. Knowing that you're 5 minutes away from buying anything you need, for a trivial transport cost, and having no concern for traffic (owing to scooter agility and filtering), is liberating.
- FJim 15y agoWhen you live in a city, most merchants deliver.
- toyg 15y agoThis approach assumes that you, the consumer, are supposed to take on the price (and problem) of delivering goods from a central "market" to your own home. This is an evolution of the old ox-and-cart system, and it's extremely inefficient. It's much, much better for you to pick the items you need on the internet, or in a showroom, and have them delivered; the delivery round will be much more energy-efficient, serving multiple customers in one go with one vehicle. We are slowly getting there, one item at a time (first books/cds, then electronics, then nappies, then then then...). The main stumbling block (people who want to check the horse's mouth before buying it) is really not a problem in the age of precise mechanization, food standards and cheap shipping. I do my grocery shopping online, most of the time.
- dagw 15y agoHow many days can you feed your family on 2 bags of groceries? 1-3 depending on what I buy. Fortunately both my girlfriend and I walk past a couple of different grocery stores, fish mongers and vegetable stands, on our way home from work, so it's never a problem to drop in and pick up anything we happen to need. Gonna carry the new TV you just bought on the bus with you? Nope. Most likely I'll get it delivered to my front door (same with furniture and other similarly sized purchases). If for some reason that isn't an option, I'll call a taxi. Fortunately I buy TVs very rarely. I can't imagine doing normal shopping without a car. Are TV's regularly part of your "normal shopping"?
- huherto 15y agoI agree that the TV example is rather silly. But it is one the first things that pops in my mind when I think about living without a car. We are so used to it, that we don't know how to function without it.
- ginko 15y agoOver here in Vienna, you do normal shopping by stepping out of your house, walking 5 minutes and entering one of several local super markets. Why would you need a car for shopping in a city?
- saalweachter 15y ago"Intermingled commercial and residential" was the phrase Jane Jacobs threw around. If you visit a city like New York, you'll notice that everything is zoned a bit differently; heck, it looks like it hasn't been zoned at all. Most residential buildings have a store of some kind in the first floor. Consequently, in a city with intermingled commercial and residential buildings, you're never more than a block or three from a grocery or a drug store, and generally never more than a block from a coffee shop or a deli. Doing your grocery shopping via mass transit is insane. That's why in a city where 75% of the population uses mass transit as their primary form of transportation, you don't. You just walk across the the street.
- pwthornton 15y agoMixed-use zoning is making a comeback, and it really fosters walkability. You can have a dense area that isn't that easy to get to things because its zoned too rigidly. Zoning originally came about for a few reasons. One was that industrial pollution was a serious issue and people wanted that away from other types of land use. The other was the rise of the car. Zoning has allowed places to require minimum lot sizes or state that mixed-use isn't allowed. One of the reasons we have so few walkable communities in the U.S. (even small ones like old towns used to be) is that zoning doesn't permit it. Because of this, areas that are walkable and are mixed-use are extremely expensive to live in.
- saalweachter 15y agoI feel like zoning away industrial pollution is a bit of a band-aid. "That factory is generating a lot of pollution. Let's ... put it somewhere we won't see it." Zoning a required minimum number of parking spots is indeed a terrible thing. Back where I went to college, that was a major headache for every business around campus. A bar was blocked from expanding because it couldn't acquire enough parking spots (and you want people driving to a bar why?), and the public library was required to put in a three story car park across the street when it renovated, demolishing a half a block of shops and apartments. This despite being a block and a half from a seven story car park which was never fully filled. New York, on the other hand, doesn't seem to give a flying fig about parking. You drive, it's your own problem.
- pwthornton 15y agoPeople own collapsable shopping carts that they walk to and from the grocery store with. A lot of times a grocery store or market may be on your way home from work, making it not a big deal to stop in and get some fresh food. How often would you say you buy a new TV? Making transportation decisions based on a once-in-a-10-year purchase isn't that rational. Plus, you could just have the TV delivered.
- chipsy 15y agoReal-life situation(my own family): 1 adult, 2 seniors. In an apartment on a steep hill in the city. No car since 2008 - a rental is done maybe once or twice per year. There are definitely drawbacks, however, most of the large items, and the bulk of the groceries, can be done with an online order today. Smaller items can be picked up while out. (No regular jobs here - all independent business, contracting, etc.) It would be harder if this were a two adults-two children situation and the parents both worked 9-5 jobs. The kids would be more dependent, and it would be tough for everyone to hit the work/school schedule exactly. However, it wouldn't be impossible.
- paganel 15y ago> Actually, the post doesn't ignore the benefits of cars. It says for example that an SUV is a great option for a family of 6 going to the suburbs. Perhaps you had some other benefits in mind? Those benefits will go the way of the dodo once all the externalities will finally go into gasoline prices, at least in the US. Right now the EU I think does it better, it tries to inhibit owning a car by taxing gasoline prices extensively, while the US has chosen to start and fight apparently useless wars just to keep those gasoline prices under control. And before I get accused of being a conspiracy freak just for stating the obvious, just remember that Japan's forays into SE Asia and Germany's desperate try to put its hands on Caspian Sea oil reserves during WW2 were made because of the exact same reasons: control of natural resources.
- toyg 15y agoahhahahaha, "it tries to inhibit"... It tries not; almost every EU country will have a number of subsidies for car ownership and a number of processes that, under the guise of promoting "environmental" and "safety" standards, really just force people to periodically upgrade their cars for the benefit of the car industry. What it originally tried to inhibit was the depletion of oil; most EU members introduced it 30 or 40 years ago, during the oil-shock period. Nowadays gasoline taxation is just that, a tax, and a profitable one: it's grown to be one of the largest income items for most states. (and if you think the various Middle-East wars were fought to keep oil prices under control, you're sorely mistaken; they were fought to maintain oil availability for corporations to exploit. Big difference.)
- JonnieCache 15y ago>almost every EU country will have a number of subsidies for car ownership and a number of processes that, under the guise of promoting "environmental" and "safety" standards, really just force people to periodically upgrade their cars for the benefit of the car industry. Could you elaborate?
- toyg 15y agoFor example, UK Road Tax is now heavier on "polluting" cars, which mostly means "old". After two years, all cars have to be officially checked every year, forcing old vehicles off the road when the cost of mostly-optional maintenance becomes higher than the actual car value. Several cities block access to certain areas depending again on the "environmental impact" (i.e. age) of the vehicle; the European Emission Standards have been changed on average every three years, so anything linked to that standard changed accordingly. Most countries run, or have run in the past 10 years, "scrapping" schemes where people trading in their old car would get a direct government subsidy when buying a new one. This is all fairly useless, considering how study after study demonstrated that the largest threats to air quality in cities are old heating systems and industrial activity, and 90% of accidents are not due to mechanical breakdowns; but it does push people to get newer cars. I'm not saying this is a negative thing (in theory it's quite nice), but in practice it's just another way to help car-makers. Most countries also dish out subsidies directly to struggling car-makers; companies like Renault and FIAT are seen as "national champions" and treated accordingly -- although this is now illegal under EU competition law, nobody complains because every manufacturer based in Europe will have enjoyed some "public love" at some point. After all, car manufacturing still employs, directly or indirectly, a lot of people.
- steve-howard 15y agoI totally agree about the downsides. Even when a bus goes from exactly where I am to exactly where I want to go with no transfers or half-mile walks in the middle (which, incidentally, is almost never), I still have to conform my schedule to the bus's. If it runs every ten minutes, that's no big deal, but if they run every 40 minutes (like my school's shuttles) or every 20-60 minutes (like the CTA is wont to do), that's just not going to work. My most frequent use of my car is a trip that takes 40 minutes through the city by car, and 2+ hours by bus/train. I would love it if the CTA managed to increase frequencies and fix all the slow zones on their track. It's just never going to happen.
- morsch 15y agoThose aren't inherent downsides of public transportation, those are downsides of a non-functioning system of public transportation. Of course it's a chicken and egg scenario: it's difficult to argue for buses every 10 minutes if the current buses aren't anywhere near being used to capacity. And no one is going to start using the buses as long as they're on such a useless schedule.
- steve-howard 15y agoI think it's inherent once a system gets large enough. As the size of a transit system grows by a factor of n, there will be O(n2) different kinds of trips that people need to take.
- ido 15y agoMorsch is right IMO. I live in Vienna and there are few I can't reach within the city within about half an hour (buses/trams/subways often come in 3-5 minutes intervals too). Within 45 minutes practically the whole city is covered.
- catch23 15y agoI think it's only true up to a certain value of n. Once the mass transit system has a subway system that has a train every 5 minutes and stops at most a block from any given location, it makes very little sense to drive. When I visited Hong Kong, it felt like this -- massively convenient and efficient. No time wasted looking for parking under $20/hr.
- megablast 15y agoPeople will not pay attention to making it better or easier. Even in some Australian cities, where it is so much easier to cycle, people still drive. My sister who works a 5 min ride from work, takes longer to drive there, and she has to pay for parking, will never cycle.
- gavinballard 15y agoWhere does she live? As a Melbournite living in London, I can imagine a sharp uptake in public transport use back home if we had half of the infrastructure London has. The problem is that cities like Melbourne are serviced so badly at the moment that as you indicated driving is the default option even when it's slower. Also, let's not forget brilliant strategies like implementing a city bike-sharing system without a corresponding change in bicycle helmet laws.
- megablast 15y agoAdelaide, which has nice wide roads, lots of bike paths, and the traffic is nowhere near as bad as Melbourne or Sydney. On top of that, most of the year the weather is great.
- adaml_623 15y agoWith regards to subsidies of public transport my opinion is that you are facing a tragedy of the commons situation but with two different categories of stake holder. You have the public who use the transport and you have the businesses that need it to operate. An example is that the City of London has a night time population of the vicinity of 11000 and a 330000 who come in to work every weekday. The businesses that operate in the City rely on the network effect of working close to other companies in this area but my impression is that that they don't pay sufficient infrastructure tax to support the city and hence the public transport costs are born by the 'end user'. Some of those end users are paid commensurately but some are minimum wage cleaners who are just as essential to the city but are the losers in this situation.
- morsch 15y agoCar operators usually don't pay what it costs, either, both literally in the sense that's it's directly subsidised by public infrastructure and the free use of a huge amount of very valuable public property, as well as more indirectly through externalities such as air and noise pollution and the massive toll they take on public health and the quality of life in cities.
- dereg 15y agoActually drivers do pay for roads in the form of gasoline taxes. Moreover, the gas tax incidence lies purely on a driver whereas funding for mass-transit comes from the entire populace (including those who will never use it).
- davekinkead 15y agoActually, registration and gas taxes don't even cover the damage cars do to tax payer subsidized roads. The real taxpayer funded contribution to transport is almost identical for public and private transport. The key difference is that cars have the roads, public space and pollution subsidized where as transit have the marginal ticket price subsidized. Here is an example from Australia (heavily car dependent) http://blogs.crikey.com.au/theurbanist/2010/11/24/what-costs-society-more-%E2%80%93-cars-or-public-transport/ http://blogs.crikey.com.au/theurbanist/2010/11/24/what-costs...
- natrius 15y agoHere's another example: The Texas Department of Transportation's 2010 budget was $8 billion. Its 2009 revenue from gas taxes (after diversions) was about $1.5 billion. http://www.texastribune.org/texas-transportation/transportation/texas-mulls-alternatives-gas-tax/ http://www.texastribune.org/texas-transportation/transportat...
- anamax 15y ago> Its 2009 revenue from gas taxes (after diversions) was about $1.5 billion. Not so fast - you dont get to ignore diversions. Also, you're ignoring other car-taxes, from registration, to sales tax (I don't know if Texas has both sales and gas taxes, but CA does), to sales tax on car stuff. (No cars, no sales tax on car stuff.) Also, car use is pretty much universal, so there can't be a significant amount of money going from non-car users to car subsidies. It's car uses paying, even when it isn't labelled a "car tax". "Mass transit" subsidies are mostly money from "not users". Two "mistakes", both in the same direction....
- agilecaveman 15y agoThe biggest problem with mass-transit is that it's "public", i.e. state owned. Back in Kyrgyzstan (my home country), there are plenty of cheap private shuttles ("marshrutkas") which ferry people on pre-set routes. They are only slightly slower than cabs. Legalizing private mass-transit would be a good way to make it better.
- Piskvorrr 15y agoThat very much depends on the country's laws - here in Prague, there are no fewer than seven different transport companies providing public transit. The traveller doesn't need to know or care that the bus line 292 is run by one company, line 165 by another, yet another runs 314, yet another runs the light rail and another runs the normal trains - the fare is integrated, so tickets are valid for all of these. The integrating organization (which IIRC holds auctions for licenses on each of the lines) is city-sponsored, so you could call that a government influence. It should be noted that this is a system that's been taking hold for some ten years now, and that the majority of public transit is still provided by the city's public transit company.