4 ms·
A group of psychologists, two from Northwestern University and the third from the University of Oregon, has found via online testing that IQ scores in the U.S.
by paulpauper 4y ago
A group of psychologists, two from Northwestern University and the third from the University of Oregon, has found via online testing that IQ scores in the U.S. may be dropping for the first time in nearly a century. In their paper published in the journal Intelligence, Elizabeth Dworak, William Revelle and David Condon describe analyzing the results of online IQ tests taken by volunteers over the years 2006 to 2018.
This is not that surprising. The people who took online tests in 2006 may have been earlier adopters, and and thus slightly smarter than later test takers. Second, it's impossible to make an extrapolation about online tests ad being applicable to IQs a century ago.
As it's said in the paper:
As the annual sample sizes have increased in more recent years and the SAPA Project has discussed in more public outlets such social media (mistressredditor, 2013; Murray, 2017; SAPAPsych, 2014a, SAPAPsych, 2014b) or online articles (Guarino, 2018), it's plausible that newer annual samples are more “average” or normal representation than those recruited during the SAPA Project's former years.
I don't think it's supposable to conclude that flynn effect is reversing
- krona 4y ago> I don't think it's supposable to conclude that flynn effect is reversing Lol, it's reversing all across western Europe and has been since birth cohorts starting around 1970. The Norwegian studies are the most cited AFAIK.
- impossiblefork 4y agoThe researchers behind one of the Norwegian studies have made some very weird arguments in public statements that aren't part of their research. They said that the drops in IQ are not explainable by immigration, but this is something that is only the case in their own study in Norway where the IQ drop was something like 1-1.2 points per decade, while the countries with big drops-- France and the UK have drops that are about 3.2-4.3 times higher.
- tgv 4y agoHere's an article about it, for those interested: https://www.sciencealert.com/iq-scores-falling-in-worrying-reversal-20th-century-intelligence-boom-flynn-effect-intelligence https://www.sciencealert.com/iq-scores-falling-in-worrying-r... They try to end the article with some feel-good hand-waiving, but so many things have changed since the mid 1970s, that it feels ridiculous to use lack of formal reasoning as an excuse. Since there's no data on it, nor on "fluid intelligence", there's no reason to assume later generations have more or less of either. If they do lack "crystallized intelligence", they did indeed become dumber.
- yeahsure22 4y agoYou will do well to remember the racist history of IW tests. Maybe we should be celebrating that scores are going down on what is essentially a racist test.
- tehjoker 4y agoThey even cite "The Bell Curve" a famously racist text in this article.
- hdhuegau6hfhd 4y agoBell curve a classic for a reason and even though I heard some complaints before, I don't recall complaints that disproved its core points. Would you care to elaborate on the famously racist parts ( and ideally what is racist about them ? )
- influx 4y agoCan you expand on this a bit? How exactly are they racist?
- DoctorOW 4y agoThere's a lot of analysis on this that is really easy to Google, so this is just the gist. Essentially, intelligence is an abstract and subjective quality. IQ correlates with what the big names in academia agreed were "smart people", back when such institutions were largely racially segregated. In particular a numeric/"empirical" standard was pushed for to give more credibility to eugenics.
- kaetemi 4y agoThat's fair. So the internet has really been getting dumber.