16 ms·
Google Reader shut down announced ten years ago today
- deafpolygon 4y agoJeez. Google really tarnished the hearts and minds of people everywhere when they shut this down. 10 years on, and people are still talking about it. I used it daily, too, and nothing really came close except maybe Feedly. I use Feedly now.
- genericacct 4y agoAs other have said it was the moment we realised goog was now run by suits and not techies and therefore lost its cool.
- zimmund 4y agoStill hurts.
- drewda 4y agoThen I guess that also means I've now been using newsblur.com and its Android app for 10 years. NewsBlur (and a handful of other RSS feed aggregators/reader apps) have continued to survive and offer some really useful functionality. None have really caught on in terms of discovering, sharing, commenting, and the other "social" functions of Google Reader. But they're still useful tools for those of us who like to read widely for both professional and personal reasons.
- goldenchrome 4y agoTen years on and these threads still get hundreds of comments. This must be the world’s biggest salt mine. Ten years ago, millions of nerds suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly compelled to moan about the loss of their favorite RSS reader for eternity. The volume of the protests are out of alignment with the value that any RSS reader could possibly give, so I assume the nerds are all crying out for the loss of their innocence.
- MattDemers 4y agoIt's funny how I'm STILL looking for an RSS solution that feels the same. I've settled on TTRSS, but it's not 100% there.
- lucabs 4y ago[dead]
- Glench 4y agoIn these threads I see a lot of RSS reader recommendations, but never the one I use, which is in fact the only personal software I pay for: https://bazqux.com https://bazqux.com It started around when Google Reader shut down and had all the exact features Google Reader had. I migrated around 10 years and have been using it ever since. It's blazing fast, always available, and never changes. I just bought a lifetime subscription a few minutes ago because I plan to use it for another 10 years.
- pers0n 4y agoIt was the death of web 2.0 for sure
- vipull 4y agoI remember it being a brilliant product I loved back then. Killing it was a foolhardy move on GOOG's part. In part, due to the loyal fanbase it had, but just to keep something running that doesn't cost as much, and gets you a lot of goodwill was a false move. RestIn PC.
- pjmlp 4y agoI still don't get it, as I always used native clients for RSS. As such its existence never mattered to me.
- consultSKI 4y agoThe ONLY reason I cared was it allowed others to think the RSS approach was somehow how "over" and no longer worthy. #sad P.S. I still use RSS Feeds and have a reader as a Chrome extension.
- Jmetz1 4y agoRIP Google Reader
- rippercushions 4y agoPour one out for Google Voice App for Blackberry. #neverforget
- dmix 4y agoHacker New's 9/11
- jamiek88 4y agoHahaha it really was. I’m still pissed off about it.
- tpreetham 4y agoDon't mean to be a snob, but you mean "hackernews' 9/11" :)
- dariusj18 4y agoStill blows my mind that news is just plural for new. I hate it so much, perhaps irrationally.
- mkl 4y agoI'd say "Hacker News's".
- dredmorbius 4y agoBobby says "Hacker News'); DROP TABLE Users;--"
- thiagocmoraes 4y agoAnd I'm still salty about it.
- wmf 4y agoI still don't understand why people couldn't switch to a different RSS reader. The Google Reader narrative seems like it was just as helpful as the bank run we just had.
- omoikane 4y agoI remember trying the alternatives back then (feedly, newsblur, etc) and they were just not as smooth, possibly because they were struggling to cope with the influx of Google Reader refugees.
- readthenotes1 4y agoi use feedly. works well.
- twelve40 4y agoI switched to different readers since then, but I'm still disappointed because 1. GR was in many ways just better and simpler (before they starting shoving sharing down the users throats), and 2. kind of sad the whole RSS feed subscription thing remained niche, seems like after that most large social networks/blogs started dragging users into their proprietary feeds, and then a lot if that got crushed by ads and dumbass "suggested for you" content which by now got so annoying I don't even want to use most services anymore. We've gone a long way from simple RSS/readers and not in a good direction : (
- JohnBooty 4y agoMany did, but: 1. The retirement of Google Reader sort of signaled the death knell for RSS. No, every RSS feed didn't shut down immediately. Yes, there are still zillions of RSS feeds live today in 2023. But it was a sign that any RSS feed you cared about wasn't likely to be around forever. 2. Many did switch, but Google Reader had some basic (but nice) social features. I think about 99% of my friends never made the switch to something else. So I miss seeing what my friends starred.
- rtpg 4y ago
- ramraj07 4y agoI literally stopped reading literature the same way after that. With GReader I used to consume the ToC of 15-30 journals without missing a single abstract. I just gave up on reading that way after that, no other tool came close.
- dewey 4y agoWhich part of Google Reader was the one that no other tools came close to? There's almost as many good and different RSS reader clients as Todo list apps, so this somehow seems like seen through rose-tinted glasses.
- ramraj07 4y agoI gave the entire gamut a chance back then, none was the same. They either cost a lot, didn’t offer the same UX or both. The fact that we are celebrating its anniversary today shows how irreplaceable it was so not sure if I’m the one wearing rose tinted glasses or if it’s the other way around where folks can’t acknowledge the magic some products capture that’s not easy to put in words.
- lopis 4y agoGoogle Reader had an "outdated" UI, in the sense that it was really bare-bones and feature-less, and focused on its main function. If it survived to today, it would probably have been redesigned 7 times like gmail and become increasingly complex and slow. So while you're not exactly wearing rose tinted glasses, you're yearning for a time when the web was simpler and gave birth to Google Reader.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoIt had an information dense UI and was super fast and snappy to load. It was basically like Gmail--always there, dependable, easy to scan and quickly digest information. All of the competition at the time of its demise was complete and utter garbage (sorry Feedly, I loved ya but you were slow and super unstable in the early days). Nowadays there are some worthy alternatives but the damage is done and RSS is just getting more and more obscure and blogging outside closed platforms like Twitter is basically dead.
- chunkyks 4y agoI switched to feedly. No biggie, in retrospect. But, that was the first Google product where it really hit home, to me, how even if a product is fantastic and useful, Google will kill it without a second thought. It fundamentally changed my attitude toward Google and made me far more deliberate about what services I choose to rely on, especially from the big G. Obligatory link to https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/
- daveslash 4y agoThis. I also switched to Feedly, no biggie. But it made me take a hard look at what else I was dependent on Google for. About 5 years ago I excised Google from my life as much as I good, including sunsetting my gmail account. I still use my Android phone, and use maps for navigation and browse youtube online, but I use as little 'account' features as is necessary. If I wanted to switch to iPhone tomorrow, there'd be next to zero migration headaches.
- Breza 4y agoI also moved to Feedly, but the shuttering of Reader meant that many websites stopped posting RSS links, and some big sites stopped supporting it altogether.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoAt Google too many people have the power to launch products to keep all of the products around forever.
- dmix 4y agoI'm curious if Clayton Christensen's would add some exceptions to his follow up book to "The Innovator's Dilemma" [1] ("The Innovators Solution") where the solution to BigCo failing to innovate is because they can never comprehend/tolerate any business which might cannibalize their core business even in the slightest (like a niche RSS reader taking away views from Google News and Google SERPs) is to do "intrapeanuership". Which is where your side plays are isolated/insulated from the downward pressure of established powerful internal teams controlling the current pet business model. I doubt Reader was ever going to be a serious business but maybe there should be a much more explicit execption for the side products your customers love that also don't fit perfectly into the parent companies main business/product dev strategy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator's_Dilemma?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator's_Dilemma?wprov=...
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoI feel like killing Reader was the point at which I switched from viewing Google mostly positively to more skeptically. Which doesn't seem terribly rational, really; it wasn't the first product to be axed, it was perfectly possible to replace... Maybe it was just the first product axing that really affected me? The moment Google went from "provider of great free stuff" to "sometimes provider of free stuff, sometimes kills stuff" is the moment it became unreliable, the moment I had to stop and consider whether their interests really aligned with mine rather than just assuming so. Or maybe I'm just bitter over nothing:) Edit: Perhaps a better phrasing: Before, if you asked "will this useful Google product be here in a year", I would answer "yes". After, I could only say "maybe". And that made all the difference.
- JohnFen 4y agoOddly enough, this was a watershed thing for me as well. It was when I finally had it driven into my head that it's mistake to rely too much on anything Google offers. I say "oddly enough" because I never really used Google Reader. I did (and still do) use RSS heavily, but I use a different reader for it. But Google's actions struck me because RSS was such a fundamental aspect of the way things worked that axing Reader without offering a replacement seem to me like them axing search itself without offering a replacement. If Reader can suffer such a fate, anything Google does can as well.
- 98codes 4y agoIt was the moment "embrace, extend, extinguish" was no longer the purview of only Microsoft.
- hintymad 4y agoThe service feed.ly, even its free version, seemed have implemented most of GReader's functionality. That said, somehow the vibe offered by GReader is gone, and I started to visit feed.ly less and less often.
- 6510 4y ago> it was perfectly possible to replace 2013 They delete everyone's subscriptions AND everyone's subscribers. Blogs come and go every day in large numbers. No more subscribers means it is time to let it go and go do something else. After years building an audience google moved in to embrace, extend, and extinguish. At the time I had many thousands of RSS subscriptions (in my own aggregator), I could see the post frequency decline and the comments dry up by the thousands. 2011 They killed blog search. 2007-2009 They hired Kevin Marks, Technorati's lead architect. And in 2014 Technorati died. 2005, Google, MSN Search and Yahoo created an initiative to help kill the eco system of organic links in comment. They chose to promote the Nofollow attribute to portray everyone and their references as spam. Spam is defined here as not obeying their webdesign orders. We might have gone a bit over the top with etiquette and "rules of civility" say 200 years ago but instruction to treat your guests as spammers??? Punishment if you don't comply! You may link to a limited number of things from your article/blog post but it must be approved materials following their instructions. Sometimes one needs to point out others are wrong on the internet. It is arguably what we do online? I write down my thoughts, you tell me I'm wrong? The idea one should not link to the "wrong" publication is not constructive to the dialog. But you can still post your articles to google wave and knol and to your google pages (joking) How about under that amateurish cookie banner defacing blogspot or google groups? usenet? They are endlessly tinkering with the search algorithm trying to find worthy results, dictating how we should shoot web (or else!), but everyone and their mum already gave up making websites for fun. Even developers who could put something together in a few hours at best have websites with just their resume on it. Its like.. Google talk > google hangout > google chat. Ahh, they finally stopped talking.
- paradox460 4y agoWhile this was a pretty monumental moment in how most of us viewed Google, and was probably bad for things like RSS adoption (it's fallen a lot since), I can't but help think that Google moving out of this field opened it up for some actual improvements I use inoreader, and it's got features Reader never had, and probably never would have grown. If Google was still king of the castle, it probably wouldn't exist today
- js4ever 4y agoThis is probably the inflection point in history where I lost all trust I had in Google. I don't know how much they saved by shutting it down (probably nearly nothing) but I know that for me and people around me it was a such terrible signal that I never trusted again Google for anything serious/business. Well done guys
- thr717272 4y agoIronically, for me it was probably when they shut down Google+ that I finally changed my views on Google. For me Google+ was a lot like HN: Peaceful, quiet and beautiful and lots Open Source content and smart people. I still look once or twice a year but it seems everyone who are into building social media wants to copy not only the very limited functionality of Twitter, down to its dumb limitations, but also its UX and aestheti. The exceptions I am aware of are Hubzilla (which lools seriously interesting but just confuses me and has no obvious way to enter - and yes, I can create my own instance but I cannot find anyone else), Diaspora (which I think copies Facebook and which is also confusing) and MeWe (which superficially look like Google+ but insist on repeating Googles mistake WRT real name policy).
- jemmyw 4y agoI also liked Google+ it was where I could manage my tech social stuff without participating in the madness that Facebook was becoming.
- modo_mario 4y agoThe trickle in invitation system with which they made it public was such a glaringly obvious mistake it still makes me mad. So many people I knew had accounts there but stopped using it because their friends weren't there or by the time they could join their friends had already left because in turn their friends weren't there.
- thr717272 4y agoThat, on top of branding it with the same name as the hated login system that[1] hamfistedly joined peoples accounts across vwry different contexts. [1]: or so I heard, I wasn't affected, I postponed that part again and again until that part ended up being very smooth for me
- easeout 4y agoNetNewsWire is keeping the dream alive. Its remake is one of my very favorite apps. https://netnewswire.com https://netnewswire.com
- jaimex2 4y agoKill all the chat apps Google... and stop starting new ones.
- saran945 4y agoI think they made a mistake, It was also supporting google ranking. they had a chance to build a social network on top of the feeds.
- AlbertCory 4y ago> These changes are never easy (ten years ago) "But we've had a lot more practice now, so it IS getting pretty easy." (now)
- Euphorbium 4y agoAlthough inoreader is better now, I have never forgiven google.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chupchap 4y agoWhat angers me even more is that this was done in a push to get more people to use Google Plus to share news. Even though people shifted to other readers the network effect was killed. We are seeing this happen all over again with Twitter.
- anotherhue 4y agoTo echo many others, killing reader is when Google jumped the shark for its technical fans. The love was so high, and the cost of maintaining it so (presumably) low, that it was nothing but a slap in the face. I've been de-googling myself ever since.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MrBra 4y agoDoes anyone here use the free Feedbro extension? I'm asking because it's working really good for me and I've never seen it mentioned here when it comes to RSS feed clients.
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoI think now it's better for us, because we discovered self-hosting RSS platforms, and other ways to use the RSS, but Google has missed a business opportunity to make some money, for example offer only 100 feeds to free plans and illimitate feeds to who bought Google One, or a cheap illimitated plan like $2-3/month. Indeed I'm paying Feedbin for the (great) service ($4,5/month)
- leemailll 4y agoGoogle killed reader is the wake-up call for me to begin self-hosting.
- nirui 4y ago> While the product has a loyal following, over the years usage has declined. So, on July 1, 2013, we will retire Google Reader. Back when Google was an underdog company in the market, they were desperately capturing the market share, and their strategy was basically throwing a lot of things at the wall and see what sticks (in a calculated way). I'd say Google Reader was one if the lucky coincidence they hit. Sadly, after Google stabilized at it's market position, they no longer need these loss leader products, so they just removed it. A completely normal business decision, if you give it a look today. I often use this as a reminder when I found myself developed a fan-altitude towards a company, so I can convert my altitude to "Nice product, I hope it make money" then proceed to use their product with an understanding that maybe one day I'll jump to another ship.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoNo the real reason Google Reader was shut down was because it was competing with Google Plus, their failed social network/Facebook compete. Vic Gundotra was the head of Google Plus product and was not shy or hiding that Google Reader had to go--at the time Reader had its own social features like the ability to subscribe to your friend's starred RSS feeds/stories and share them, comment on them, etc. It was purely a calculated move to kill Reader so people had to use Google Plus for sharing stories and commenting on them. This would goose the number of active Google Plus users and ensure Vic hit his targets for getting fat bonus payments. This absolutely was not a case of "the product was finished and did all it needed to do"... people were pissed at what was happening and didn't want to move over to Google Plus (which completely lacked the core feature of reading RSS feeds, despite Gundotra claiming they would eventually implement it (shocker! they never did)). The story of Google Reader's demise is purely a power grab by a mad exec/product leader that ran his product to failure and eventually was forced out of the company under allegations of being a sex pest to employees. Google Reader died for no good reason other than getting that piece of garbage some bonuses.
- 6510 4y agoDo they still have the code? What would it take?
- paxys 4y agoThere's so much "that was the day Google died" sentiment in this thread, while in the same ten years the share price of GOOG has gone up from $19.87 to $90.63 (adjusting for splits), wildly outperforming the rest of the market. Goes to show that the company considers a much wider audience than just the tech crowd when making key product decisions.
- slyall 4y agoYou are confusing "the day Google died" with "the day the old Google died". For a long time there Google was a cool company that was more than just something to make money. It was doing all this other stuff that didn't make money but made the world better. These days it does about the same amount of "good" as any other company in the Fortune 100.
- izacus 4y agoI don't know if you noticed, but the economic system you've built outright punishes companies and their CEOs if they don't extract maximum value and follow the herd.
- argiopetech 4y agoWe have noticed, 10 years ago today.
- Kwpolska 4y agoThe stock market is not a good indicator of anything. You don't need a random number from Wall Street to figure out that google.com is still alive.
- rtpg 4y agoWill take this opportunity to point out the following: - Almost all sites worth reading where an RSS feed makes sense... has an RSS feed - The Old Reader is basically Google Reader. No weird design stuff going on. on iOS Reeder is a good app to hook it up to. If you missed RSS, it's not cuz it went away. It's there waiting for you
- puzzlingcaptcha 4y agoI've been self-hosting tt-rss for the past nine years. Can't recall a single issue.
- vander_elst 4y agoReading that post you can really see how little Google cares about the end users. They are closing products and removing features without providing a replacement and providing ridiculously short timelines for changing.
- moomin 4y agoGoogle really did do “embrace, extend, extinguish” on a lot of internet technology, didn’t it?
- triggercut 4y agoWas notified about this via the Feedly widget on my Google Pixel phone. huh, how time flies
- MattPalmer1086 4y agoHaha, same!
- senectus1 4y agoI've fairly recently switched to self hosting and I'm pretty happy with the result. I still miss reader. but I'm happy with what i have. (FreshRSS)
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoThis always seemed like one of Google's worst decisions to me, and given that I remember the time they tried to spend $6 billion to buy Groupon, that's saying something. It was a plain unforced error. Google Reader was a product that was crazy cheap to maintain (no way it had more than a dozen engineers working on it), and it was used primarily by the extremely online, especially journalists, bloggers, and other sorts of influencers. If they had viewed Reader as a marketing expense, keeping it online would've been a no-brainer. But instead, they instead viewed it as a consumer tool that didn't have a path to profitability, and they were 100% right, but then over the next few years, it became clear how many later Google efforts would've benefited from Reader existing. Google+ would've meshed well with it. That little Google "stuff you maybe want to see" panel on Android phones that would frequently make little notices like "hey, we think you like this site, there's a new article," and that was probably really involved to build, and also it absolutely sucked compared to just having Reader. Ultimately I have to assume that it's a business org problem. No engineer was going to get a promotion keeping Reader alive. No manager was going to be able to grow Reader's audience 10x. No director would want to give up a half dozen of their engineers to keep Reader running just because it would significantly hurt Google to turn it off. And no executive cared about a product that small. The org structure didn't lead to someone incentivized to want to keep Reader going, despite its popularity inside and outside the company.
- scarface74 4y ago> Google Reader was a product that was crazy cheap to maintain (no way it had more than a dozen engineers working on it), It’s hard to show “scope” and “impact” by maintaining a product with declining usage. No one who cared about their career would want to work on something that was in maintenance mode.
- raizer88 4y agoI never understood why Google doesn't hire B teams to do the maintenance work, or outsource it. It's normal that if you hire only top players that no one wants to be stuck doing tickets.
- Hamuko 4y agoIf you have a server and are in the market for a new RSS reader service, try FreshRSS. The killer feature: ability to scrape the full article content with CSS selectors when only a truncated feed is offered.
- BMorearty 4y agoIt took me ten years to get back into using an RSS reader. Over that time, I found individual blog posts to read via links from Twitter. And there were a few that I subscribed to over email. But now with the whole Twitter debacle, a month ago I looked around to find a good RSS reader and installed NetNewsWire. It's nice to be back.
- kkarpkkarp 4y agoafter ten years I would say it turned out to be a good decision, at leats for me. Google Reader was "just a reader" and nothing more. They did not invest in it, it was stagnated but as it was working ok, I didn't have motivation to look for alternatives. When Google Reader was announced to be shut down, it gave a great motivation to other reader's authors to develop their products. I would never replace current Inoreader with its insanse features with Google Reader again.
- simonw 4y agoI imagine there's a small but significant overlap between the people who are still annoyed about the Google Reader Shutdown a full decade later and the people who are today making large scale cloud computing purchasing decisions. I doubt Google took into account how damaging for their reputation is would be to shut down a product that had an audience that was small but extremely online and influential, both at the time and into the future.
- 7to2 4y agoSo much this. I was lied to and strung along for weeks by Huawei support about a missing feature that should have been in their personal 4G dongles. Guess who blacklisted all Huawei gear in the last company I worked at. Guess who's now working in government IT procurement. Not everything is numbers and loss centers. Don't lie and do the right thing. Treat people with honesty and respect. It's not that difficult.
- megaman821 4y agoI am not in charge of the biggest buys in the world, but that describes me. I have chosen AWS or Azure everytime over Google Cloud mostly because Google Reader shutdown.
- eloop 4y agoI often wonder how much data they would have accumulated with Google Reader and Google Code that would now be a gold mine for training AI. Short sighted management!
- Breza 4y agoNo kidding, being able to know the exact type of content that interests you would make Google Assistant much more powerful, not to mention their other projects.
- rcarmo 4y agoIronically, I am reading this through RSS. It’s still alive and well.
- nanna 4y agoI finally managed to create a habit out of RSS after years of trying. What worked was,I know this may sound obvious, using a phone based reader instead of a desktop. It's like a categorizable, algorithmless social media feed now, full of content that people spent more than a few minutes writing, and it's great. Aside from regular feeds I feed in HN through hnrss.org, YouTube directly, and the odd twitter account through nitter.net. For an RSS client i use the excellent Feeder https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nononsenseapps.feeder.play https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nononsense...
- vort3 4y agoThe only thing I would recommend is using openrss youtube feeds instead of using youtube directly: https://openrss.org/blog/youtube-feeds https://openrss.org/blog/youtube-feeds
- pwpw 4y agoHow did you procure a list of feeds worth following? I really enjoy RSS, but I have had trouble finding enough content to fill a feed I can regularly check. An example of the perfect feed for me is https://ciechanow.ski/atom.xml https://ciechanow.ski/atom.xml.
- nanna 4y agoI realised that I was already browsing the web in a repetetive way, so RSS basically let me automate that. The daily loop would be something like... - theguardian.com for UK news - democracynow.org for US and world news - various blogs for Emacs things (irreal, planetemacs, sachachua) - ianvisits and londonist for London curios - a few youtube accounts that I care about - a friend's flickr - websites of some NGOs I care about - HN front page and replies to my comments (like yours!) Better to start small and add to it bit by bit than drown yourself in feeds that you don't find you care about. Good suggestion about Bartosz Ciechanowski's excellent site - will add it now. Edit: looking at your post history, to add that I too have ADHD and this has helped me focus and keep ontop of web updates way better than I have done before. News websites like the guardian feel like they're designed to obliterate your concentration.
- izacus 4y agoSo how many of you actually pay for and fund a sustainable alternative like Feedly or Old Reader?
- MapleWalnut 4y agoI pay for Feedly even though I had access to a very generous free plan. Their product is reliable and I use it every day, so it only seems fair to pay.
- thinkingemote 4y agoIt was the social graph that made Google Reader great not the basic RSS functionality. That was really the game changer. It tapped into your friends feeds, what they liked and read. You could follow other peoples recommendations, and the user belonged to a network of other users. It also made finding widely shared news items stand out and interesting blogs to follow easier and strengthened the network by doing so. All the replacements afterwards didn't have this social aspect (or if they did they lacked the network needed for it) so they were like a graveyard socially.
- dariusj18 4y agoWhat they should have done is used Google Reader to farm data from power users to then feed other products
- ElCapitanMarkla 4y agoCan't believe that has been 10 years. I had loads of interesting RSS feeds that I flicked through each morning, I think I exported them all to some other service but for whatever reason it just didn't work as well for me and I've never bothered with RSS since. I've seen a few people mention FreshRSS so I might give that a go
- smusamashah 4y agoGoogle reader died because Chrome to this date don't have a native RSS support. When Chrome was taking over the world, other major browsers (I only remember Firefox and opera) had native RSS support. As people moved to Chrome, they started to forget and use RSS less and therefore the decline and the death of reader.
- rswskg 4y agoDamm, I've been paying for feedbin for a while then. Worth it if I'm honest.
- m_st 4y agoReplaced it with Fever (feedafever.com) on my own server and Reeder on my iPhone and couldn't be happier since. The main issue is that less and less RSS feeds are available.
- BonoboIO 4y agoAfter 10 years im still puzzled how they could kill this product. Absolutely minimal costs to run, free data for their search business and even the possibility to monetize their tool with ads. They could have incorporated news and build a whole platform on it. And what did Google do ... they replaced it with NOTHING. Google Reader was THE original Newsfeed.
- ramijames 4y agoI'm still angry about this.
- iguana_lawyer 4y agoA terrible business decision. It killed blogging and concentrated content into a handful of silos. They probably thought Google+ would be one of those but that failed miserably. Now search is something you do inside an app or website, not on google.com.
- jamifsud 4y agoI remember when they shut it down and I haven't found one that I've loved like Reader. Reader was beloved to the level of apps like Notion and Figma and nothing has come along to replace it in a way that works for today's content content landscape. A lot has changed in ten years, content has exploded in volume and decreased in average quality and every app started to feel as noisy as my social feeds. Our users at Upnext (https://www.getupnext.com https://www.getupnext.com) are saying the same, so we're moving into the space with our next major release. Upnext 2.0 will allow you to follow anything on the web (Newsletters, sites, podcasts, YouTube channels, etc). If you're interested in trying out the beta you can sign up here: https://upnexthq.typeform.com/to/MYfd4pcK https://upnexthq.typeform.com/to/MYfd4pcK In the meantime, I'd love to hear what folks are using today and why they miss Google Reader.
- leokennis 4y agoI can recommend https://feedbin.com/ https://feedbin.com/ as a great replacement. It's $50 a year, but in return you get a service that is rock solid with an owner who is luckily very good in >> not << implementing features: no feature creep, no breaking changes, dead simple interface, no BS.
- tony2016 4y agoGoogle Reader was an RSS reader. There are many other RSS readers. I don't get the big fuss about it. I never used it.
- 8organicbits 4y agoIt was the top post of the day: https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2013-03-13 https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2013-03-13
- martythemaniak 4y agoThere was a very common character in many '90s movies, a sad old man who kept going on and on and on about 'Nam. Everything they said was about 'Nam, everything that happened reminded them about 'Nam, they kept telling the same story over and over again. Think Walter from The big Lebowski, Ned from South park, etc. The thing is it was only about 20 years between the end of the war and when these characters were created, ie not that long. It's been 10 years folks, it's time to Let it Go. If you don't, sometime over the next 10 years you're going to become that character. I've already seen it happen too friends of mine with the Iraq war (not participating, protesting) it's not a good look. It's time to let Google Reader rest in peace.
- compsciphd 4y agoGoogle Reader's shutdown made it realize that google didn't understand communities and platforms. OK, you want to push Google+? Isn't google+ supposed to be a platform (and not simply an application). Let google reader be an application on top of the Google+ platform. i.e. facebook is valuable because people share things on it. Why would you kill an app that is causing people to share things with each other. Leverage that user base. Reader should have simply been one app built on top of the Google+ platform. Yes, this would involve rewriting it to some extent, but better to do things that maintain your user base, than do things that give people reason to leave. Google has repeated this error over and over again since then, especially with their chat/messaging strategies. Don't give people reasons to jump ship. If you force them to migrate to something new, they can just as easily migrate away from you.
- ilikepi 4y ago> OK, you want to push Google+? Isn't google+ supposed to be a platform (and not simply an application). Let google reader be an application on top of the Google+ platform. They actually did start to integrate them. Google Reader had native sharing functionality for several years. Then in 2011 they suddenly removed it and replaced[1] it with sharing through Google+. My small network of Reader-using friends were split over wanting to join Google+, so that mostly killed our practice of regularly sharing links with each other. [1]: https://googlereader.blogspot.com/2011/10/new-in-reader-fresh-design-and-google.html https://googlereader.blogspot.com/2011/10/new-in-reader-fres...
- dontlaugh 4y agoThat's what killed Reader sharing & comments, yes. They should have done the opposite, growing Google+ out of Reader: keep the Reader sharing, but also automatically share to Google+.
- compsciphd 4y agosort of "Integrating with Google+ also helps us streamline Reader overall. So starting today we'll be turning off friending, following, shared items and comments in favor of similar Google+ functionality." i.e. reader could be used to add content to google+ but not to use google+ I could share a link on google+ but couldn't see any of the interactions unless I went to google+. If google+ was meant to be a platform, I should have been able to see the comments or other peoples shared items from within the google reader app. It should just have been one way to interact with google+ amongst many.
- Exendroinients 4y ago[flagged]
- ortusdux 4y agoI still have Reader bookmarked next to Gmail as a reminder.
- nntwozz 4y agoRSS is only dead to those who don't know how to use it or lack imagination, what a weird thing to say really. Personally I've been using it for a myriad of things ever since 2007, just recently I discovered you can add .atom to GitHub releases e.g. https://github.com/BLeeEZ/amperfy/releases.atom https://github.com/BLeeEZ/amperfy/releases.atom for a nice list of updates. I like how neatly I can keep track of everything in one place without having to run around the web and deal with all the madness. If the feed is full of crap I can filter it out with www.feedrinse.com RSS brings order to chaos, it keeps the signal-to-noise ratio under my control in a world bent on exploiting my web usage
- djha-skin 4y agoI self host a yarr[1] instance. I love it, and it's pretty cheap to do so. RSS is still ubiquitous, if underground. Sometimes the feed links are hard to find but they're usually there. 1: https://github.com/nkanaev/yarr https://github.com/nkanaev/yarr
- sylens 4y agoIt is wild to me how many people view this event as the divider of two eras of Google. And the same is true for me. Before this, I loved Google products - I was a fan of everything they did, I had an Android phone, things were working great. After they shuttered Reader, I never trusted anything they built the same way again. It's wild to think that something that was not really used for me for work or education had such an impact on my perception of a company. But I'm not exaggerating when I say this had a bigger impact on me than Microsoft's three red lights issue on my XBox 360 or their PlaysForSure debacle.
- lenocinor 4y agoStill mad about this too, like so many others here. I’ve been using Feedly since then, and it works for the RSS part. But I really miss the small community of people I discussed things articles with in Google Reader. Most of those people I no longer talk to. It was a unique form of sharing and commenting that just worked for us in a way no other products did.
- karpierz 4y agoCan anyone explain exactly what made Google Reader so amazing? I never used it, but from what I can tell it was basically an RSS reader?
- garrickvanburen 4y agoFast. $0. Straight-forward UI. As mass-market as any RSS Reader got. Arguably it was The RSS Reader. Killing Google Reader effectively killed RSS, shifting the gravity of the big tech companies from a fundamentally open & interoperable consumer web to a fundamentally closed silo.
- pornel 4y agoSome people just liked the UI and features, but I think major reason why people are so butthurt about Reader, is that its existence was a very important symbol: it was a mainstream product from a well-respected company that elevated RSS to being a normal feature of websites, not just a niche protocol of open-web-loving bloggers. And conversely, shutdown of the Reader was a wakeup call that big corporations exist to make money, and things that don't monetize well are not going to survive. That was just past the peak of "Web 2.0" frenzy that used free public APIs for all kinds of "mashups". The APIs didn't even require developer keys and didn't have stringent rate limiting. Everyone was giving away their data for free! It's hard to believe now. Around the time of Reader shutdown, Twitter locked down their API, significantly curbed 3rd party clients. Facebook and Google abandoned XMPP. Later Google Maps became serious about monetizing their API, and all those mashups and RSS feeds started dying down. So in short, shutdown of Google Reader was the beginning of the end of Web 2.0.
- miguelbemartin 4y agoGoogle Reader was killing Google Ads, so they decided to shutdown this service. RSS readers don't show ads in the same way of navigating in their websites.
- surajrmal 4y agoGoogle Reader only existed for 8 years. The fact that we are still talking about it 10 years after it was discontinued is quite amazing.
- wslh 4y agoMy concern with this shutdown goes more with the data than the web app: in Google Reader you can go back in the feed even when the RSS doesn't contain all the articles.
- kareemm 4y agoFunny, I was at the O'Reilly conference in 2005 (Etech) when Google Reader was *launched*, and wrote a blog post about it[1]. Here was my take on the launch: > At first I wondered if this would be the product that pushes RSS aggregators to the mainstream, but I'm beginning to think that a full-featured RSS reader won't ever cross the chasm from early adopters to the mainstream. A product like My Yahoo suits the purposes of a huge percentage of the mainstream audience, so unless their needs change significantly, there's no incentive to change to another aggregator. Sadly this seems to be true: My Yahoo didn't make it, but the FB/Twitter/Insta/TikTok/Google News algos serve as curated feeds where non-nerds prefer to get their news. There was a lot of anger amongst the digerati when Google Reader shut down, but in retrospect it seems to have been the right move. 1 - https://www.reemer.com/archive/v1/2005/10/07/web_20_google_announces_google_reader.html https://www.reemer.com/archive/v1/2005/10/07/web_20_google_a...
- markstos 4y agoI probably gave up on using a feed reader about then. Instead, I subscribe a few things I care about by email, and hear about some things passively through social media. The idea is that I can't keep with via email, I don't have time for it. For a while, I used "feed to email" for the services that didn't offer an email subscription, but I've since let that go. Now I feel like I don't have time for "one more place for news" to add back a feed reader into the mix. But I'm open to being convinced I should give Feedly or something else a try!
- zimmund 4y agoI tried several alternatives (including one which tried to be exactly like Reader), but I didn't get used to them. Up until then I always knew what was happening in tech and global news. Since Reader was killed I ended up relying on news websites and I find features by accident, not because I read updates on blogs/media. I feel I got disconnected from the bleeding edge of the web that day.
- ink_13 4y agoIt's interesting you should say that, because I was up and running on an alternative platform pretty quick. RSS was and is so core to how I gather and consume information from the web that I'd be considerably unhappier without it.
- notqanon 4y agoI wonder what Dave Winer would say about this, the guy who invested RSS.
- obeliskora 4y agoSwitched to newsblur when it was shut down, but I'm still salty about this.