3 ms·
Everywhere has problems, it’s less about perfection than simply being a better option. I’ve generally considered Canada the best option for a while. English sp
by Retric 4y ago
Everywhere has problems, it’s less about perfection than simply being a better option. I’ve generally considered Canada the best option for a while. English speaking, low crime, same time zone with family, etc.
New Zealand, or one of the Nordic countries aren’t that far behind. Australia, England, and Western Europe etc are much lower, but still have plenty going for them.
The biggest thing America has going for it is my friends and family happen to live here.
- nradov 4y agoCrime rates are a city by city and neighborhood by neighborhood issue. Most of the USA is very safe; my city has zero murders most years. The statistics are thrown off by a few neighborhoods in a few cities like Chicago that have degenerated into third-world war zones. While that's a terrible situation and we need to fix it, most HN users can easily avoid those places.
- Retric 4y agoEven the “safe” parts of the US aren’t all that safe. Ontario which includes Canada’s largest city and 38% of the population had a lower average murder rate between 2016 and 2020 than every single US state but New Hampshire. Quebec population 8.5 million is significantly lower. These statistics aren’t completely equivalent due to various factors, but it’s close enough for reasonable comparisons.
- refurb 4y agoYou’re comparing a rate - murders over population, of a province with a vast rural population with few murders to US cities where murders are concentrated. Edit: I'm an idiot and can't read.
- Retric 4y agoI am comparing states with provinces. The most populous “city” in Wyoming is Cheyenne with 63,957 people. Ontario meanwhile includes Toronto population City:2,794,356, Metro Area: 6,202,225. Yet, your more likely to be murdered in Wyoming.
- reducesuffering 4y agoIf you want to talk cities, Toronto has a 2x - 3x higher per capita murder rate than my city in the US, so like GP said, it depends where you are. Sure you can generalize over a whole country, but ultimately what will matter is a city by city comparison where you actually are. And I'm safer here than Toronto.
- Retric 4y agoI can’t find any independent US city with crime rates that low. If by city you mean some wealthier part of a larger metropolitan area then compare it to a similar portion of Toronto.
- reducesuffering 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_crime_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... A lot of those still seem to have lower violent crime rates than Toronto, Brampton, Mississuaga, and probably every other >200k population place around Toronto. So it's like I said, best to refrain from huge generalizations like Canada / USA when it doesn't matter for our specific circumstances. Or, keep saying 'Even the “safe” parts of the US aren’t all that safe.' from an area that is more violent than mine in the US...
- Retric 4y agoBoise Idaho is the only independent city (not part of a larger metro area) on that page listed with a lower murder rate than Toronto. However, it’s not consistent year to year going from a vastly higher 5 per 100k in 2007 then dropping to 0.5 in 2008, then back to 2.9 in 2009 etc. Looking at the most recent years it’s roughly comparable with Toronto, but the long term average is higher. Suggesting it’s a more dangerous city with higher annual variance in rates. https://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Boise-City-Idaho.html https://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Boise-City-Idaho.html Violent crime statistics are based on different standards in different areas and are therefore much harder to actually compare than dead bodies. Even with dead bodies there’s some ambiguity for people who died after the fact from injuries and when murder is more ambiguous etc. Violent crime rates between states let alone countries face different definitions, levels of reporting, etc so you really need to closely examine both raw data and methodology to do a solid assessment. Simply looking at official data from a Wikipedia table etc is very misleading.
- HWR_14 4y agoChicago's homicide rate isn't that high once you use per-capita numbers.
- mikewarot 4y agoOne day, on my way to work, there was a two hour backup, because the Eisenhower was closed for a murder investigation. One day at work, making gears, I heard what sounded like fire-crackers... turns out there was a shooting in front of the gear factory. I had to drive through a murder crime scene to exit the parking lot. Per capita numbers don't erase that from my memory.
- Retric 4y agoChicago and Toronto are roughly the same size, but per-capta Chicago has ~10x as many murders. That’s fucked up.
- HWR_14 4y agoIf they are per-capita then you don't need similarly sized cities. I was comparing Chicago's per capita numbers to the US's
- Retric 4y agoChicago’s per capita murder rate is much higher than the US. In 2021 Chicago had 29.6 per 100k people where the US averaged 6.5 per 100k in 2020. The 4 least dangerous districts in Chicago are actually slightly below to the US’s average murder rate. https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Ander%20testimony.pdf https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Ander%20testi... The point of roughly equivalent sized cities is small entities can be much larger statistical outliers. A small city can go from a higher rate than Chicago one year to 0 the next year. Meanwhile Chicago’s numbers don’t really change with a single mass shooting etc.
- rayiner 4y agoI'm not talking about what's perfect or not perfect. I'm talking about why OP thinks "the wealthy and powerful" are the reason for whatever shortcomings they perceive about the U.S. Canada, for example, has basically the same corporate tax rates as the U.S. Canada's capital gains tax rate is effectively about the same as the U.S. for high income earners, because of only half of it is included in income. The social services are paid for by higher middle class taxes, including an 18% total VAT in Ontario.
- Retric 4y agoUS nominal tax rates are meaningless. Canada's companies pay twice the share of taxes as US companies.