4 ms·
> David Mullet, a member of the Old Order Amish Church and the owner of E-bikes of Holmes County, a popular bicycle shop in a heavily Amish-populated area of Oh
by loeg 4y ago
> David Mullet, a member of the Old Order Amish Church and the owner of E-bikes of Holmes County, a popular bicycle shop in a heavily Amish-populated area of Ohio, explained that e-bikes are simply faster and easier than horses.
Well, certainly, but so are other vehicles you shun. I don’t get it, but I don’t really need to, either.
- kiba 4y agoThe Amish has a more intentional approach to technology than a lot of us. They don't consider just the benefit but the downside.
- gptgpp 4y ago[flagged]
- red-iron-pine 4y agoThere is an awful lot of debates as to the downsides of technology -- you're on HN, killer, it's what we do all day. The Chinese government restricted video games; the US gov may punt on TikTok. It comes up a lot, it's just that Capitalism is trying pretty damn hard to shove this tech down your throat. By comparison, the Amish are pretty much disconnected from the modern capitalist world, except when they have to be.
- paulcole 4y agoIt’s the same as any other religion or hobby. Follow the rules you like and either ignore, bend, or change the ones you don’t. Like kicking your ball out of a buried lie in a sand trap when you’re a 32-handicap.
- vkou 4y agoWhen you can't get gas for your car, it's a large, heavy, utterly useless pile of metal. When you can't get electricity for your e-bike, it's a large, heavy, but still functional bicycle. If you build your society around automobiles as a form of transportation, you become critically dependent on enormous supply chains beyond your control. Collapse those supply chains, and modern America would be uninhabitable without the automobile. If you build your society around e-bikes as a form of transportation, you'll be... Mildly inconvenienced if those supply chains break down. One of the factors that many Amish groups use when deciding to adopt novel technology is determining how reliant that would make them on the outside world. Automobiles generally have a very hard time passing this test. Bicycles, and electric bicycles have a much easier time. I've also never heard of having no choice but buying into a predatory 20% APR loan to buy a bicycle.
- alexvoda 4y agoIgnoring of course the very many ways they are reliant on the outside world for their lifestyle to be possible.
- vkou 4y agoNo man, or village is an island. That doesn't mean that you should blindly enslave yourself to reliance on things beyond your control, when you can help it. You tell me, how well has, say, reliance on foreign fossil fuels worked out for Germany last year? What if the winter were a few degrees colder? Or in the US, during the oil shocks? How well is Russia's reliance on trade with the rest of the world, and the decline of its industrial base working out for it?
- swatcoder 4y agoIs there a community free from someone’s claim of contradiction and inconsistency? Is there a point to this kind of snark? If you have concerns about the Amish community, tradition, or lifestyle, I’m sure they’re more interesting than the philosophical gotcha games that one could target at anyone.
- 4y ago
- xwdv 4y agoAmish have self driving vehicles, while we still struggle to develop anything close to that kind of tech.
- m463 4y agoNot only do they have FSD, but also FSR (replicating)