4 ms·
I mostly agree with this, but I feel like the past 25 years or so, ever since "the Greenspan put", has just gone more and more in the direction of telling peopl
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I mostly agree with this, but I feel like the past 25 years or so, ever since "the Greenspan put", has just gone more and more in the direction of telling people that they don't need to worry about doing adequate risk assessments, because if you have powerful people that yell loud enough, and you can cause enough damage, that Washington will come to the rescue. Eventually, I just don't see this ending well.
As someone who is naturally risk averse, I feel like a sucker. I was having a conversation in a separate thread where someone remarked "How can you expect startup companies to spread their deposits across multiple banks?" Besides the fact that there are tons of account structures specifically set up to do that, as an individual, I know what these insurance limits are and have moved assets around accordingly (for me, FDIC limits weren't relevant but SIPC limits were).
How much time I wasted. I should have just gone with a powerful enough institution that I knew would get bailed out if they ever failed. I certainly won't waste my time doing this again, which is probably not the follow-on effect that the feds want.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoThe decisions about "is this bank adequately capitalized to serve its depositors" should be made by the regulators, not by the market. We know what it takes to run a bank safely, and its really easy to both quantify and test. This is how the "too big to fail" banks are run today. No one talks about the moral hazard of elevators (make sure you inspect it before you get on) or airplanes (make sure you do your own pre flight check) we trust that the regulators have set up processes that make this infrastructure safe for the public to use. Even with a deposit guarantee, a poorly run bank can still be closed by regulators, a bank run doesn't need to happen for a bank to be shut down, just like an elevator accident doesn't need to happen to decertify an elevator in a building.
- zupreme 4y agoConsider: “Reserve requirements are a tool used by the central bank to increase or decrease the money supply in the economy and influence interest rates. Reserve requirements are currently set at ZERO as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic.” ref: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/requiredreserves.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/requiredreserves.asp
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoA mean reserve requirements are stupid and have no place in real risk assessment so that's a good thing.
- 8note 4y agoHow so?
- hellojesus 4y agoI don't think it necessarily is adjusted for risk that specific banks take on as operators. It's likely set at some requirement to help the fed achieve its goal while also adjusting for median or 2 std dev risk.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoIt doesn't take a CPA to know that depositing above 250k comes with increased risk. And I think you're kind of conflating types of consumers here. People depositing above that limit are generally not working from the same limitations and lack of information that regular people are.
- poof131 4y agoExactly. Circle and USDC are essentially a bank themselves, and those deposits were just guaranteed. Risk free return.
- eric_cc 4y ago> People depositing above that limit are generally not working from the same limitations and lack of information that regular people are. 250k is not that much money. What a weird statement.
- TimTheTinker 4y agoFeels like a lot to me. That's more than a year's wages.
- eric_cc 4y agoConsider financially responsible people in their 50’s and 60’s that have had decades to save. There are plenty of “regular”, middle class people with this type of savings in their account.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoIf you have that much in liquid cash, you meet virtually no definition of the term "middle class". You are upper middle class at leadt and you probably have a financial advisor who is telling you that you shouldn't locate all your money in one account unless it is yielding in a way that justifies such a risk. At least I hope you do.
- chernevik 4y agoAnd so the regulators are empowered to make a whole bunch of other decisions, such as asset and lending strategy. I prefer to minimize regulators' control over decisions. Perhaps you have noticed that regulators are at bottom politicians?
- kazen44 4y agoat the end of the day, everything in life is political. Did you also consider that the political incentive for a regulator are at odds with the ones running the bussiness. (mainly, not getting people killed).
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoI prefer to minimise banking's influence over everything, because banking is itself a form of political regulation - but not a democratically accountable one.
- lmm 4y agoAt this point we should just nationalize the whole banking system. Currently we have the worst of both worlds: privatised profits and socialised losses; strict regulations but limited oversight or appeal; no real market competition but no real voter influence either.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agowe don't have "socialized losses". Tax payers aren't paying for anything here. The FDIC is run an funded by an interbank consortium. Its essential a union of banks that run a collective risk pool and decide the rules of the risk pool. It works and has worked for nearly 100 years.
- lmm 4y ago> we don't have "socialized losses". Tax payers aren't paying for anything here. The FDIC is run an funded by an interbank consortium. Its essential a union of banks that run a collective risk pool and decide the rules of the risk pool. What meaningful distinction are you drawing here? It's not practical to opt out of banking, and FDIC has no real competition (the NCUA offers exactly the same terms, and in the credit union thread fans were at pains to emphasise how equivalent to the FDIC it is). Not all taxes are collected by governments from individuals.
- lostmsu 4y agoCryptos?
- hellojesus 4y agoPeople will be taxed for this through inflation. Where else does the money come from during a QT cycle? I haven't looked into the details for how this will be paid, but that would be my initial guess.
- AYBABTME 4y agoWhy isn't it. Pragmatically it's pretty silly to insure the first 250k and then expect people to go through the trouble of spreading their cash over a multitude of accounts. Punishing people for not having accounted for black swan events in their risk assessment is also not scalable. Do we want people to do useful stuff, or to spend their time digging the rule book to ensure they've accounted for every eventuality? Also it's not like once you have 250k in the bank, you're suddenly a finance wizz, omniscient of all the tricks and tips with regard to treasury management. Even as you get into the low millions of net worth, it's not like you suddenly became a HBS graduate. A lot of regular hard working people end up hitting those limits and wouldn't reasonably be expected to learn about treasury-foo. A lot of young or small businesses are in the same lot. Being somewhat wealthy doesn't turn you into a fine financier. And even if you think those folks should hire advisors, it's not like they can afford to hire the right ones with this relatively small amount of wealth. I think resentment of having gone through the pain of spreading your cash, in vein, isn't a good reason to screw up hundreds of thousands of salaried employees, and a bunch of regional banks.
- wyre 4y agoIf you have more than 250k in the bank you should be smart enough to split it into multiple accounts or hire someone to do treasury management.
- conradkay 4y agoI've never run a large company but I feel like it wouldn't be feasible when you have transactions routinely over 250k, like how I'd imagine most of these companies would be with their payroll.
- hellojesus 4y agoI think the solution to that is placing predence on the bank selection mechanism. You could audit banks' lending positions and make risk adjusted based decisions.
- sshumaker 4y ago
- rftyuikdjhgvcf 4y agoyou should have just went to a private elite school instead of working hard your while life too. /s
- throwaway12245 4y ago>How can you expect startup companies to spread their deposits across multiple banks? Buy one year CDs from many banks and T-bills.
- bink 4y agoI've been a student of housing bubbles for a long time. I remember back in 2003 I was participating in an online forum covering the bubble. The conventional wisdom back then was that when the bubble popped not even the Fed or Alan Greenspan and his helicopters could cover the losses. The hundreds of billions if not trillions of dollars that would be needed would cause runaway inflation. Then, they did it. The bastards managed to somehow buy tens of billions of mortgage backed securities every month for years. They bailed out automakers and banks with backdoor 0% loans while claiming the "investments" were profitable for the average citizen. Zombie Fannie and Freddie are still out there gobbling up mortgages. It's insane.
- User23 4y agoMoney printer go brrrrrrrr. None of this is surprising to people who know how bank money actually works. The US congress literally has unlimited nominal credit and practically unlimited useful credit, and it can grant same to any of its creatures.
- naasking 4y agoOf course they could, money is a fiction after all. As long as we all keep walking around believing that fiction, there's no real problem with just inventing more money out of thin air. The fiction has certain properties when it encounters the real world though, so there are sometimes downstream consequences, but none that could ever totally dissolve the fiction. Only enough people starting to disbelieve in the fiction itself could do that, and people mostly won't do that because money is too useful.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoSorry you had to spend like an hour opening a second account. But yes, not wasting people's time (not requiring small and medium businesses to hire CPAs to evaluate banks' books) is exactly the outcome the feds want.
- tolmasky 4y agoI think you are wrong to not keep doing this (and I also don’t believe you’ll stop doing it unless it’s actually hard to continue doing, vs. the initial setup being difficult). I can tell you that after this I will start doing it. I don’t see these events as proving anything for the future. I have no idea what the political climate will be next time around, or any other factors. It’s like being down 9-0 in a soccer game and saying “hey, remember that one epic game we were also down 9-0 but then came back 9-10? Everything is fine.” What? No way. I don’t want my team down 9-0 at the half, ever. BTW, in my experience many many people are risk averse in specific things they see that others don’t. It’s super hard to be an expert on everything. Talk to someone that knows about construction and they’ll have similar laments about home maintenance. Is it bad to “bail out” people that have their homes washed away in a hurricane? I honestly don’t know. But what I do know is that I’m definitely not jealous of them for making a silly location choice and “not paying the price”. That experience is not fun. I promise this episode was fairly disruptive even with this outcome. It is much better to look on from the outside than wonder whether a bunch of people you don’t know will save you. You’ll feel really bad if the next one isn’t bailed out because something is different and it gets you because you stopped doing something that aligned with your values just because of this thing this time.
- freddie_mercury 4y agoThe Greenspan Put was 37 years ago.